1/34
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Metaphysics
The nature of reality in a more “abstract” manner
Meta “over and beyond” and physics “the knowledge of nature”
The oldest school of philosophy.
Non-empirical and non-scientific subjects or topics.
Deals with concepts of reality such as being and identity, mind and matter, substance and existence, cause and effect, time and space- aspects of reality but not always tangible, concrete, empirical
Can be considered the pursuit of wisdom
Mind-Body Problem
Mind
Mental states
Consciousness
Thoughts
Body
Physical Brain
Body
Body with a Mind
A physical body that experiences thoughts and emotions as a result of biochemical interactions in the brain.
Mind with a Body
There’s some non-physical part of you that’s pulling the strings, but could live outside of your biological body.
Physical vs. Mental Properties
Physical properties include size, weight, shape, colour, motion through space and time, etc.
Mental properties involve consciousness (including perceptual and emotional experience), intentionality (including beliefs and desires) and they are possessed by a subject or a self.
Materialist vs. Idealis
Materialism
Mental states are physical states.
Reality is made of matter, physical processes, and natural laws.
Idealist
Physical reality is really mental.
Reality is based on ideas, thoughts, and consciousness.
Monism vs Dualism
Monism: the mind and the brain are the same thing
Types of Monism
Physicalist Monism: Mind is part of the physical world
Idealist Monism: Mind is all there is; body is perception
Neutral Monism: Mind & body are two aspects of a deeper reality
Dualism believes that the mind and the brain are separate
Mary’s Room
Mary knows every scientific fact about colour but has only lived in a black-and-white room.
When she sees colour for the first time, she learns what it feels like to experience colour.
This suggests that scientific facts alone cannot explain all conscious experiences.
Main argument: Experiencing something gives us knowledge that simply learning facts cannot.
Mysterianism
the idea that the human mind is just not capable of fully understanding itself.
The Ship of Theseus
A ship has all its parts gradually replaced over time.
Eventually, none of its original parts remain.
Is it still the same ship, or has it become a completely different ship?
If the original parts are put back together into another ship, which ship is the real Ship of Theseus?
Explores identity, change, and what makes something the same thing over time
Numerical vs Qualitative Identity
Numerical Identity
An object is the exact same object as itself.
Two numerically identical things are one object, not two.
Qualitative Identity
Two objects share the same properties or characteristics.
They are similar, but not necessarily the same object.
Persistent Identity
the idea that a person remains the same person over time, despite changes in their body, personality, memories, or experiences.
Asks what makes you “you” throughout your life.
Fungibility
refers to the property of an item where individual units are interchangeable and have equal value. Meaning that one unit of a fungible good can be substituted for another without affecting its overall value or function.
Essential vs Accidental Properties
Essential Properties
Properties an object must have to be what it is.
Without them, it would no longer be that thing.
Example: A triangle must have 3 sides. Without 3 sides, it is not a triangle.
Accidental Properties
Properties an object can change without changing what it is.
Example: A triangle can be red or blue and is still a triangle.
Body Theory
a person's identity across time is defined by the continuity of their physical body.
Meaning that a person remains the same as long as they possess the same body, regardless of any changes to their mind, memories, or personality and regardless of changes in the body's composition
Memory Theory
Personal identity is based on continuity of consciousness
You are the same person if you remember being that person.
The body is not what makes you the same person. If you can remember it, you maintain a memory link to that person
Bundle Theory
The self is not one permanent thing, but a collection of constantly changing thoughts, feelings, memories, and experiences that make us who we are.
Teletransporter Paradox
“Personhood”
Human
Biological term
Human dna
Person
Moral term
They deserve moral consideration.
What makes someone a person, and what qualities does someone need to deserve personhood?
Genetic Criterion
You become a person at conception because you have unique human DNA.
However, having human DNA doesn't automatically make something a person (e.g., skin cells, lab embryos, corpses).
Cognitive Criterion
You are a person if you can think, reason, communicate, make decisions, and recognize yourself.
Yet, Excludes young children and some people who cannot meet these requirements.
Social Criterion
You become a person through how society treats, recognizes, and interacts with you.
But, society can deny personhood to people through discrimination or exclusion (e.g., slavery). Does having no friends mean you're not a person?
Sentience Criterion
Personhood is based on the ability to feel pain, pleasure, and have preferences or desires
Some animals may qualify for greater moral consideration than some humans.
Gradient Theory
Personhood is not all-or-nothing; it exists on a scale depending on how many person-like traits you have (consciousness, memory, language, etc.).
Useful Because…
Helps explain moral intuitions we already have: people tend to feel more moral concern for a fetus at 8 months than 8 weeks.
Offers a middle path between extreme positions
Allows for flexibility in difficult ethical decisions (e.g., abortion, end-of-life care, animal rights).
Libertarian Free Will
People have the ability to make conscious choices that determine one’s future.
Some human actions are freely chosen.
Hard Determinism
All events and human actions are determined by causes external to
the will. Everything is caused.
The Principle of Alternate Possibilities vs Frankfurt Case
The Principle of Alternate Possibilities
An action is free only if the agent (person doing the thing) could have done otherwise! Truly free actions require options.
Frankfurt Case
Challenges the Principle of Alternate Possibilities(PoaP):
Say the Green Party put a chip in your brain forcing you to vote Green at the next election. However, you were already a Green Party supporter anyway, and you go to vote for them.
According to PoaP, your vote wasn’t a free choice bc you didn’t have another option (the chip would have stopped you).
Event vs Agent Causation
Event Causation
No physical event can occur without having been caused by a previous physical event
Agent Causation
An agent (propelled by a mind) can start a chain of causality that wasn’t caused by anything else.
Reductionism
is the idea that complex phenomena (like our actions) can be explained entirely by simpler, more basic components. Human behavior is nothing more than the outcome of biological, environmental, and psychological processes.
The difference between the causes of human action and physical events is that our actions have all sorts of invisible causes that happen in the brain. Just because we can’t pinpoint the exact factors that led to the action, we could in theory isolate them. Our decisions is a combination of various mental stuff combining in the right way.
Compatibilism
Free will and determinism are compatible. Freedom doesn’t mean uncaused; it means being able to act on your own desires without being forced by others.
Key Ideas:
You are free if you act because you want to, not because you are forced.
Responsibility is preserved as long as choices reflect the agent’s character or values.
Pascal’s Wager
Pascal’s Wager is the idea that believing in God is the safer choice because you have more to gain and less to lose.
Pascal says you should believe in God because:
If God exists + you believe: You receive an infinite reward (Heaven).
If God exists + you don't believe: You risk infinite punishment (Hell).
If God doesn't exist + you believe: You only lose some time, money, or freedom by following religion.
If God doesn't exist + you don't believe: You save your time and money and live however you want.
Existentialism
A philosophical movement that emphasizes individual existence, freedom, and choice. It explores the human struggle to create meaning in a meaningless universe and the importance of living an authentic life.
Kierkegaard + 3 Stages
Kierkegaard: Truth is subjective; important truths (love, faith, purpose) must be personally lived and experienced. Meaning comes through your choices.
3 Stages:
Aesthetic: Living for pleasure, novelty, and escape.
Ethical: Taking responsibility for your actions and seeking purpose.
Religious: A “leap of faith” — committing to God without certainty
Nietzsche + Ubermensch
Nietzsche: Since traditional values no longer give us meaning, we must create our own values.
Übermensch (Overman): A person who creates their own values and shapes their life through self-expression.
Creates their own values.
Accepts suffering and chaos.
Constantly overcomes and improves themselves.
Not about being superior or dominating others.
Sartre + Bad Faith
Sartre: “Existence precedes essence” — we are born without a predefined purpose and must define ourselves through our choices.
Bad Faith: Self-deception; pretending you aren't free or responsible for your choices by blaming outside factors.
Denying your freedom.
Avoiding responsibility.
Pretending you have no choice.
Example: A person says, “I can't change; that's just who I am,” to avoid making a choice.
De Beauvoir + Immanence
De Beauvoir: Social systems can limit people's freedom, especially through oppression and gender. Meaning should be created while respecting others' freedom.
Immanence: Being limited or defined by others.
Society can restrict people's freedom.
People can be pushed into roles defined by others.
A meaningful life includes helping others achieve freedom too.
Camus + Absurdism
Camus: The absurd is the clash between our desire for meaning and the indifferent, silent universe.
Life has no guaranteed or final meaning.
Don't escape the absurd with false hope.
Live passionately and authentically.
Find freedom and joy in the struggle itself.
His solution: Revolt — accept the absurd and continue living fully anyway.