HRM

0.0(0)
Studied by 1 person
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/14

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

15 Terms

1
New cards

Explain your understanding of theory. What functions do theories have? Use the unitarist employment relationship model to explain these functions.

What is a theory?
A theory is a tool made of language that helps us organize a complex, real world (Bachrach, 1989). It's a set of general ideas connecting concepts together, within certain limits and assumptions. Theories decide what we see and include, and what we don't see and leave out.

Functions of theories, in general and applied to the Unitarist model:

Critical authority of agency: in general, a theory makes the conditions and consequences of actions, tools, and systems visible, so we can judge them critically. Applied to Unitarist: it shows how HRM can get rid of conflict between employer and employee and create competitive advantage, and helps improve HR policies to reach both organizational and individual goals.

Reduction of complexity / "Spotlight", "Framing": in general, a theory picks out the most important factors and gives us one specific angle to interpret a situation. Applied to Unitarist: it focuses on unifying interests, and on how HR policies can improve organizational performance while also reaching social goals at the same time.

New insights: in general, a theory can spark creative, new ways of looking at a problem. Applied to Unitarist: it reveals the psychological complexity of employees, shows that commitment and intrinsic motivation genuinely matter for performance, shows that HRM itself can create a real competitive advantage, and shows that the labor market does not fully determine HR practices.


2
New cards

Explain the five building blocks of the employment relationship: employer, employees, labor market, state, contracts. Please also relate to different theoretical concepts of these building blocks.

The five building blocks, in general:

  • Employer — the organization that hires people and pays them for their work

  • Employees — the people who sell their labor in exchange for pay

  • Labor market — the wider market where labor is bought and sold, shaping how much bargaining power each side has

  • State — the government, setting laws and rules around work (e.g. minimum wage, dismissal protection)

  • Contracts — the agreements defining the relationship, both the formal written contract and the unwritten, implicit ("psychological") expectations

Employer

  • Egoist: wants to maximize profit

  • Unitarist: aligns both sides' interests

  • Pluralist: one player, must bargain

  • Critical: acts within capitalism; tries to keep control

Employees

  • Egoist: only care about income/leisure; a commodity

  • Unitarist: psychological beings; performance/fairness matter

  • Pluralist: economic + psychological; entitled to equity and voice

  • Critical: relatively powerless, exploited

Labor market

  • Egoist: perfectly competitive; the main driver

  • Unitarist: imperfect, not deterministic

  • Pluralist: indeterminate, but still matters

  • Critical: imperfect, but favors capital

State

  • Egoist: only protect property/contracts

  • Unitarist: should not intervene

  • Pluralist: can play a genuinely productive role

  • Critical: could help, but mostly protects capital

Contracts

  • Egoist: employment-at-will (either side ends anytime)

  • Unitarist: long-term partnership, "beyond the contract"

  • Pluralist: a bargaining exchange (formal + psychological)

  • Critical: formal "equality" can mask real power imbalance


3
New cards

Compare systematically 'Taylorism' and the 'Human Relations approach'. What relevance do These theories have in modern, contemporary organizations?

Taylorism and Human Relations share the same goal, efficiency, but see organizations and people very differently. Human Relations emerged as a reaction to Taylorism's weaknesses.

Organization and people: Taylorism sees the organization as a machine and people as "economic man", motivated only by money. Human Relations, based on the Hawthorne studies, sees the organization as an organism and people as "social man", who need recognition and belonging.

Management and methods: Taylorist managers plan and control: they standardize tasks, find the "one best way" and pay by performance. Human Relations adds caring and counselling, focusing on job satisfaction and group dynamics, because satisfied workers are assumed to perform better.

Control: Taylorism controls the body through the system and work process. Human Relations controls the mind through supervisors and group norms, so the control is softer but still present.

Relevance today: Taylorism lives on in standardized, measured work such as call centers, warehouses, KPIs and algorithmic management. Human Relations shows up in engagement surveys, teamwork, feedback culture and wellbeing programs. Most organizations today combine both: efficient processes plus attention to people.

4
New cards

Provide a systematic comparison of the unitarist and the egoist model of the employment relationship

The unitarist and the egoist model both say that no state or union intervention is needed, but for very different reasons. The unitarist model relies on shared interests, the egoist model on the free market.

Main idea: The unitarist model assumes a unity of interests: employers and employees want the same thing, so conflict is a sign of poor management. The egoist model sees employment as a voluntary trade between self-interested parties in a market, like buying any other good.

Employer and employees: In the unitarist view, the employer's job is to align interests, and employees are seen psychologically, with needs for motivation, satisfaction and commitment. In the egoist view, the employer simply maximizes profit, and employees only care about income and leisure. Labor becomes a commodity that has to be monitored so people don't slack off.

Labor market: The unitarist model sees the market as imperfect: it leaves room for choice, so a company's own HR decisions matter. The egoist model assumes a perfectly competitive market that is the main driver of wages and conditions. If you're treated unfairly, you can just switch employers.

State and unions: For unitarists, state regulation is unnecessary, because good HR already creates fair outcomes. Unions are an outside disruptor and a signal that HR has failed. For egoists, the state should only protect property and contracts. Unions distort the market and restrict individual freedom.

HR policies: In the unitarist model, HR is the key mechanism for profit, since aligned, motivated employees perform better. In the egoist model, HR is dictated by the market and merely administrative.

Example – monitoring: A unitarist company monitors to collect data and give feedback that helps employees improve. An egoist company monitors to stop self-interested workers from shirking.

5
New cards

Explain briefly the following concepts : Neo-Institutionalism, resourceful humans, Taylorism, Fordism, economic rationality

Neo-Institutionalism: The idea that organizations need legitimacy — social acceptance — not just economic success (DiMaggio & Powell). This leads to "isomorphism," organizations becoming similar to each other because they face the same outside pressures. There are three types: normative (shared professional training), coercive (shared laws), and mimetic (copying others under uncertainty). This explains things like employer branding, and why HR practices across companies tend to look more and more alike over time.

Resourceful humans: Employees are seen as a valuable resource, not just a cost. People bring skills, creativity, and adaptability to their work. Unlike physical resources, this can actually grow over time through training. Because of this, it becomes a source of lasting advantage that's hard for competitors to copy.

Taylorism: Comes from Frederick Taylor's 1911 book on "Scientific Management." It separates planning (done by management) from doing (done by workers), using time-and-motion studies to find the most efficient way to work. The goal was efficiency and cost-effective labor. It's been criticized for treating workers too mechanically, leading to monotony and alienation.

Fordism: Named after Henry Ford's moving assembly line, which was actually inspired by Chicago slaughterhouses. Ford introduced the "Five-Dollar-Day" to fight high worker turnover caused by the exhausting, repetitive work. But Fordism went further than just production — it also included "moral education" of workers, checking on their private lives. It builds on Taylorism, but focuses more on connecting the whole production process into one smooth flow.

Economic rationality: The core assumption behind the Egoist model — that people act to maximize their own self-interest. Being "rational" means either reaching a goal using the fewest resources possible, or getting the most out of a fixed set of resources. It assumes people weigh costs and benefits for every decision. Critics say this view is too narrow, since it ignores emotions and social needs — "satisficing," choosing something good enough rather than optimal, is the proposed alternative.

6
New cards

Explain briefly the following concepts: Hawthorne effect, Human Relations, cognitive dissonance, psychological contract, HRM-P-formula

Hawthorne effect: Discovered during experiments testing how lighting affected worker output. Output went up no matter what changed — even when the light got worse. The real reason: just being watched by researchers made workers try harder. It's now used as a general research term.

Human Relations: Grew out of the Hawthorne experiments and challenged Taylorism. It shifted the focus from controlling the body to understanding the "soul" — people's feelings and social needs. Key ideas include the "social man," the importance of informal groups, and the belief that satisfaction leads to better performance. Critics say it still mainly serves employer efficiency, just through manipulation instead of direct control.

Cognitive dissonance: Festinger's 1956 theory about the discomfort people feel when holding two contradicting beliefs. His famous "When Prophecy Fails" study showed that a cult didn't abandon its belief when a prophecy failed — instead, they rationalized it. In HR, this helps explain why people stick with bad decisions or see failing HR tools positively. Being aware of this helps us find better, more constructive solutions.

Psychological contract: The unwritten expectations that exist alongside the formal, written contract, made up of three dimensions — economic, psychological, and social. When these unwritten expectations are met, it leads to positive work outcomes. It exists because a formal contract can never cover absolutely everything.

HRM-P-formula: Guest's idea that putting a coherent set of HR practices in place leads to better performance, because it increases employees' commitment, quality, and flexibility. For this to work, the practices need to form a real "package" — integrated into company strategy and genuinely backed by line managers. Critics say the approach is too focused on the individual, and that the link between HR practices and performance isn't fully proven.

7
New cards

What are the main elements of the employment relationship. How does the pluralist model conceptualize these elements?

There are five main elements: the employer, the employees, the labor market, the state, and contracts.

How does the pluralist model see each of these?

Employer: one player among several — not the dominant one, unlike in the unitarist model. The employer has to bargain, is shaped by the labor market and the state, and has a mix of common and conflicting interests with employees.

Employees: seen as complex economic and psychological agents, entitled to key rights as human beings — equity and voice.

Labor market: described as "indeterminate" — not fully fixed or determined, unlike the egoist model's view of a perfectly competitive market that sets everything.

State: can play a genuinely productive role, through legal regulation and setting norms, that complements HR practices rather than interfering with them.

Contracts: (not detailed for this model in your source material — worth checking your slides, but based on the pluralist logic, this would likely be: a bargaining exchange with both explicit, formal terms and informal, implicit expectations).

8
New cards

What are the main elements of the employment relationship. How does the critical model conceptualize these elements?

There are five main elements: the employer, the employees, the labor market, the state, and contracts.

How does the critical model see each of these?

Employer: acts within the capitalist system. Tries to undermine labor's power, blocks employees from unionizing, and aims for cultural control over employees.

Employees: shares the view that labor is "more than a commodity" with the unitarist and pluralist models, but sees employees as relatively powerless — usually exploited and controlled by the employer, or more precisely, by capitalism itself.

Labor market: also shares the "imperfectly competitive" view with the unitarist and pluralist models, but sees this imperfection as specifically tilted in favor of capital/employers.

State: could play a helpful role, but mostly ends up protecting capital and stabilizing the system instead. Cautious, conservative policies are seen as favoring elite (employer) interests.

Contracts: (not detailed for this model in your source material either — worth checking your slides, but based on the critical logic, this would likely be: a formal "equality" on paper that actually hides a real, unequal power relationship underneath).

9
New cards

Explain the difference between human resource management policies and politics. What are four main analytical dimensions of politics (in HRM)? Explain them briefly.

Policies are the established guidelines, rules, and procedures a company sets up — things like performance appraisals or incentive schemes — meant to help the organization run smoothly and reach its goals. With policies, the objectives themselves aren't really disputed; conflict and differing interests don't play a strong role.

Politics, on the other hand, refers to the small, everyday techniques individuals or groups use to gain power and influence others — to broaden their own freedom and avoid being controlled from outside. This is based on the fact that HR stakeholders have partly competing interests.

The analytical dimensions of politics

Actors and their interests: the people involved — HR managers, works councils, employees, line managers — all keep their own self-interest in view. This shows up as making deals, forming coalitions, or framing things as "win-win" while still pursuing your own goals.

Power: not something you simply "own" — it's an unequal relationship that depends on context. It shows up through things like confidence and assertiveness, controlling expert or tacit knowledge, and creating information monopolies.

Ambiguity of situations: almost nothing about a real situation is fully clear, objective, or undisputed. This shows up through controlling how information gets presented, making decisions look more "fact-based" than they really are, or even using emotion to distract from the actual facts.

10
New cards

Describe the goals of HRM according to Boxall & Purcell. What are critical aspects of their concept of HRM?

They split HRM's goals into two broad categories: economic goals and socio-political goals.

Economic goals:

  • Cost-effective labor — not just "cheap" labor, but a dual concept: having effective, motivated employees at a cost the company can actually afford

  • Organizational flexibility — being able to adjust staffing in the short term, and having the deeper, long-term ability to learn and adapt

  • Human resource advantage — a lasting (not just temporary) edge over competitors, built from having talented people (human capital) and knowing how to combine their talents well (social capital)

Socio-political goals:

  • Social legitimacy — being accepted by society as doing things the right way, not just being profitable (based on DiMaggio & Powell)

  • Managerial power — management's desire for the freedom to run things its own way, which can sometimes turn into serving its own interests rather than the organization's

Critical aspects of their concept

The basic definition of HRM's goal — "optimum utilization of human resources" — is actually pretty vague: whose goals exactly, and optimum for whom?

There's also a real, ongoing tension between staying cost-effective and staying legitimate, which companies manage through things like decoupling (looking good on paper while practice stays different) or genuinely win-win investments.

And managerial power can become its own separate problem — managers pursuing their own career interests at the expense of the owners, not just at the expense of employees.


11
New cards

Explain the HRM models of Harvard and Guest. What are the main differences between these models?

Harvard Model: Starts with what stakeholders want and the company's situation — this shapes the HR policies chosen. These policies lead to four outcomes (Commitment, Competence, Congruence, Cost-effectiveness), which lead to long-term effects on individuals, the organization, and society, with feedback loops back to the start. Mostly descriptive, connects to Theory Y (people are naturally motivated, capable of guiding themselves, and can genuinely find satisfaction in their work under the right conditions). Criticism: doesn't say what to actually DO, and doesn't explore the pluralist side deeply enough.

Guest Model: Compares old personnel management (compliance, collective, rigid) with modern HRM (commitment, individual, flexible, strategic). Core idea: a coherent set of HR practices leads to more commitment, quality, and flexibility, which leads to better performance. Criticism: too individualist, uncertain causal link.

Main difference: Harvard describes a whole system with feedback loops; Guest gives one clear, action-guiding hypothesis.

12
New cards

Explain the HRM models of Storey and Ulrich. What are the main differences between these models?

Storey: Storey treats "HRM" as a "Utopia" — an ideal type that doesn't actually exist in reality, but is useful as a benchmark to measure real practice against. Four elements: Beliefs (employees are an asset, not a cost, and employers should aim for commitment that goes beyond the formal contract), Strategic Aspects (HRM is seen as critical to corporate planning), Role of Line Managers (not just HR specialists, but line managers themselves are vital for actually delivering HR practices), and Key Levers (moving away from rules and procedures, toward managing organizational culture instead).

Ulrich: Ulrich says HR needs genuine business partnership — being actively involved in decisions, not just carrying them out. Four roles: HR Business Partner (aligns HR with business goals), Change Champion (drives change forward), Administration Expert (runs efficient processes), Employee Advocate (represents employee interests). Main criticism: HR professionals tend to find the first two roles more attractive, which pulls them away from employees — creating both a legitimacy problem AND a "tension of identity" (torn between representing employees and acting as management's agent).

Main difference: Storey is more theoretical (an unreachable ideal type, with culture as the lever). Ulrich is more practical (four concrete roles) — but gets sharper criticism about whether it really works as well in practice as it claims.

13
New cards

What are important stakeholders for HRM? Which expectations do these stakeholders have? How can HR managers/professionals try to meet these expectations and, thus, increase their legitimacy and credibility?

Important stakeholders & their expectations:

  • Top management — expects strategic value, cost-effectiveness

  • Middle management — expects practical, everyday support

  • Employees — expect fair treatment and a real voice

  • HR peers at other companies — expect professional standards upheld

  • HR department colleagues — expect collaboration

  • Works councils/unions — expect genuine consultation, not just being informed afterward

  • Consultants — expect a knowledgeable partner to work with

How HR managers can meet these expectations and build legitimacy:

  • Make the business case — show real, demonstrable value

  • Build genuine expertise — technical, social, AND conceptual skills

  • Stay broadly knowledgeable and credible

  • Build trustful networks, inside and outside the organization

  • Stay conceptually flexible, especially when working with other managers

  • Be personally trustworthy — this also lifts the whole HR profession's reputation

  • Don't neglect daily, "micro"-level communication

  • Quantify your actual impact through evaluations

  • Actively combine employee wellbeing with business goals, instead of treating them as separate tracks


14
New cards

Explain briefly the following concepts: Cost-effective labor, Human resource advantage, power, knowledgeability, identity

Cost-effective labor: Not the same as "cheap" labor — it's a dual concept, meaning you need both effective, motivated employees AND a cost the company can actually afford. What counts as cost-effective varies a lot by industry (discount retail needs lean staffing; knowledge-intensive work needs high investment in rare talent) — and it applies to public sector organizations too, not just private companies.

Human resource advantage: A LASTING competitive advantage — not a temporary one — built through people. It has two parts: human capital (having genuinely talented individuals) and social capital (knowing how to combine those talents well, through teamwork and communication). It's hard for competitors to copy, which is what makes it so valuable.

Power: An unequal relationship, not something you simply "own" — it depends on context. In the Pluralist model, it shows up in everyday things like monitoring and promotion decisions. In the Critical model, it's seen as structural, built right into the capitalist system itself. In practice, it shows up through things like assertiveness, confidence, and controlling access to information or expert knowledge.

Knowledgeability: Being broadly well-informed and seen as a credible source — not just technically skilled in one narrow area. It's one of the key ways HR managers build legitimacy, since understanding an organization's social and political dynamics (not just its technical HR needs) is necessary to actually get HR policies successfully implemented.

Identity: Made up of Personal Identity (your own unique mix of traits and self-evaluation) and Social Identity (your sense of self through group membership — nationality, profession, employer). Identity Work is the ongoing, active effort to build and adjust both of these, and to align your inner sense of self with what different situations expect of you. For HR managers specifically, this creates real tension — juggling multiple roles (like Business Partner and Employee Advocate) at once, each with different expectations.

15
New cards

Explain your understanding of theory. What functions do theories have? Use the pluralist employment relationship model to explain these functions.

What is a theory?
A theory is a tool made of language that helps us organize a complex, real world (Bachrach, 1989). It's a set of general ideas connecting concepts together, within certain limits and assumptions. Theories decide what we see and include, and what we don't see and leave out.

Functions of theories, in general and applied to the Pluralist model:

Critical authority of agency: in general, a theory makes the conditions and consequences of actions, tools, and systems visible, so we can judge them critically. Applied to Pluralist: it makes POLITICAL conditions and consequences visible — power relations, conflicts, how changes affect power, inequality between actors, discrimination against certain groups, and lack of voice.

Reduction of complexity / "Spotlight", "Framing": in general, a theory picks out the most important factors and gives us one specific angle to interpret a situation. Applied to Pluralist: it focuses on different interests, power structures and relations, conflict, negotiation, compromise, and how the structural order of an organization influences decision-making.

New insights: in general, a theory can spark creative, new ways of looking at a problem. Applied to Pluralist: understanding different interests and power dynamics lets us think about HR practices and tools differently; it shows the necessity of understanding an organization's social and political dynamics to successfully implement HR policies (= knowledgeability); and it shows that social acceptance matters just as much as the practical, instrumental side of HRM.