Module 10 - Contracts Clause - Limiting State Power

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/35

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

36 Terms

1
New cards

Do states have absolute/plenary power?

No

2
New cards

How does the Constitution limit State’s powers?

  1. Explicit limits in Article I, Section 10 (e.g. coin money, impair contracts)

  2. Structural protections of federal institutions (e.g. Congress and choosing the President belongs to the whole nation)

  3. Federal preemption (Federal law overrides state law)


3
New cards

What does Article I, Section 10 expressly bar states from doing?

  1. Coining money

  2. Issuing bills of credit

  3. Making treaties or alliances

  4. Granting letters of marque (capture enemy ships during war)


4
New cards

What are states and federal government prohibited from doing?

  1. Bills of attainder: punishing a specific person or group without a trial.

  2. Ex post facto laws: criminalizing conduct after it was committed (wasn’t illegal when it was committed), or increasing the punishment for it afterward.

  3. Titles of nobility: granting anyone an official title like “Lord” or “Duke.”


5
New cards

What are the different versions of Government Power?

  1. Exclusive Federal Powers: The nation must speak with one voice. (e.g. coining money—can’t have 50 currencies).

  2. State Powers: Powers never given to the federal government stay with the states. (e.g. police powers, general police powers over health, safety, and welfare)

  3. Shared Powers: Both federal and state government have power. (e.g. taxing, regulating businesses, highway safety)


6
New cards

Contracts Clause (Article I, Section 10): Rule

No State shall…pass any Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts

7
New cards

In the 1780s, after the Revolution, the country fell into an economic depression. Many people, especially farmers, owed money they couldn’t repay, and creditors were foreclosing on their land.

Debtors made up a large share of voters, so state legislatures passed relief laws that changed existing loan agreements after the fact. States canceled debts and delayed foreclosures.

Result?

States cannot impair obligation of contracts.

Rationale: If a state could rewrite loans whenever borrowers struggled, no one could rely on a contract, lenders would stop lending, and commerce between states would suffer. So the Framers added: “No State shall…pass any Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts.”

8
New cards

The federal government is trying to impair the obligation of contracts.

  1. Can a Plaintiff use Article I, Section 10 (Contracts Clause) to stop the federal government from impairing the obligation of contracts?

  2. If not, what law can Plaintiff use?


  1. No. It only applies to states.

  2. The Fifth Amendment:

    Clause

    What it says

    How it applies to an economic law

    Due Process

    No person shall “be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law”

    The challenger argues the law is arbitrary or irrational in how it affects their contract rights

    Takings

    Private property shall not “be taken for public use, without just compensation”

    The challenger argues the law effectively takes their property (contract rights can count) and the government must pay for it


9
New cards

FACTS:

During the Great Depression, the economy was in freefall. John and Rosella Blaisdell fell behind on their mortgage, and their bank foreclosed on their house. Under normal circumstances, the bank would take the house immediately.

However, to prevent mass homelessness, the state of Minnesota passed an emergency law hitting "pause" on foreclosures.The law said families could stay in their homes longer, provided they paid a fair rent to the bank in the meantime.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?


  1. Home Building & Loan Ass’n v. Blaisdell

  2. Can a state temporarily violate the Contracts Clause to save its citizens during a national emergency?

  3. In times of severe crisis (like the Great Depression), a state can temporarily bend the rules to protect society from collapsing.
    Balance two ideas:

    1. The Contracts Clause: The federal rule that states can't mess with private contracts.

    2. State Police Power: A state's inherent right to protect the health, safety, and welfare of its citizens.


10
New cards

What factors CAN enable a contract to impair the Obligation of Contracts?

Blaidsdell factors:

  1. Genuine emergency or great public calamity? (economic causes count)

  2. Legitimate public purpose protecting the community’s interest?

  3. Is the proposed relief reasonable and tailored? (enough e.g. the adjustment gives the lender the equivalent of possession)

  4. Is the relief temporary?

  5. Is the underlying obligation preserved (debt/interest/lender’s title), while the remedy is adjusted?

AN EMERGENCY ALONE DOES NOT CREATE POWER.

11
New cards

Protection of Federal Institutions: Rule

The qualifications to become a Congressperson in Article I (age, citizenship, residency) are fixed and exclusive.

States may not add to these qualifications, directly or indirectly through controlling ballot access rules (who shows up on the ballot).

12
New cards

Under the Elections Clause, what can states do?

Only the procedural “Times, Places and Manner” of elections, not substantive qualifications. States CANNOT use these powers to penalize a candidate.

e.g. For California’s U.S. House and Senate elections, polls close on November 2 at 12 p.m., voters must vote at designated polling places in the state, and only paper ballots are allowed.

13
New cards

In Cook v. Gralike, the state placed a label saying “DON’T VOTE FOR THE CANDIDATE WHO REFUSE TO PLEDGE SUPPORT FOR TERM LIMITS.”

Can a state do this under their power to control the “manner” of an election?

No. States CANNOT use these powers to penalize a candidate.

14
New cards

States can’t establish qualifications for office, but can expel members of Congress. Why so?

These are two different powers.


Setting qualifications

Expelling a member

What it is

Entry requirements for who may serve (age, citizenship, residency)

Removing someone already elected and seated

Who controls it

The Constitution alone; states can’t add to it (Thornton)

Each House of Congress, over its own members

When it applies

Before someone takes office

After they’re serving

Basis

A general rule for every candidate

That member’s own misconduct


15
New cards

FACTS:

In 1992, voters in Arkansas were frustrated with career politicians. Arkansas passed a ballot measure called Amendment 73. It basically created a strict term limit: if a politician had already served three terms in the U.S. House or two terms in the U.S. Senate, their name was legally banned from appearing on the ballot again.

The State defended the law as an exercise of the State's reserved powers under the Tenth Amendment and its authority to regulate elections under the Elections Clause.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?


  1. U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton

  2. Can States add or alter the qualifications enumerated in the Constitution to become a Congressperson?

  3. No, the requirements to become a Congressperson are firmly locked into the Constitution. States do not have the power to add new rules to that list because we need 1) national uniformity and 2) states can only control procedure, not substance.


16
New cards

Presidential Electors (Article II of the U.S. Constitution): Rule

Context: When you vote for a presidential candidate, you are actually voting for a slate of "electors." These electors are real people who go to the Electoral College to cast the official, deciding votes for President.

These “electors” must cast their vote for whoever wins their state’s popular vote.

17
New cards

FACTS:

Following the 2016 presidential election, three presidential electors in Washington voted for candidates other than Hillary Clinton, who had won the state's popular vote. Under Washington law, electors are required to cast their votes for the candidates of the party they represent, and a violation of this pledge is subject to a civil fine of up to $1,000. The State imposed the $1,000 fine on the faithless electors, who challenged the penalty as a violation of the U.S. Constitution.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?


Chiafalo v. Washington

  1. Can states penalize electors who don’t vote in accordance with the state's popular vote?

  2. Yes, states can impose penalties on electors for failing to vote according to their pledged candidates as part of their authority to regulate the electoral process.

  3. Yes. Electors are NOT free agents. Words like “elector” and “vote” do not guarantee free choice.


18
New cards

What does Section 3 of the 14th Amendment say?

Bars people from holding office. States apply the below standard to their candidates. The federal government through Congress applies this standard to their candidates.

  • Who is covered: someone who took an oath, as an officer, to support the Constitution

  • who then engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the United States.

  • Effect: that person cannot hold civil or military office, federal or state.

  • Escape hatch: Congress can remove the disqualification by a two-thirds vote of each House.


19
New cards
  1. Can States disqualify candidates for state office?

  2. Can States disqualify candidates for federal office (prevent them from showing up on the ballot)?


  1. Yes. States can prescribe qualifications disqualifications for their own state officers.

  2. No. That power belongs to Congress.


20
New cards

FACTS:

Following the 2020 Presidential election, Donald Trump disputed the results, culminating in the events of January 6, 2021, when a crowd breached the U.S. Capitol during the certification of electoral votes. A group of Colorado voters brought a statutory challenge under the Colorado Election Code seeking to keep Trump off the 2024 presidential primary ballot, asserting that he took an oath as an officer of the United States and subsequently engaged in insurrection within the meaning of Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?


  1. Trump v. Anderson

  2. Can States disqualify federal candidates from appearing on state ballots? (particularly the Presidency)?

  3. No. Responsibility for enforcing Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment against federal officeholders and candidates rests exclusively with Congress (via appropriate legislation) and not with individual States.


21
New cards

Supremacy Clause and Preemption: Rule

The Constitution, federal laws made under it, and treaties are “the supreme Law of the Land,” binding state judges (Article VI, Clause 2).

22
New cards

What does EVERY preemption analysis start with?

Every preemption analysis starts with the presumption against preemption.

States have long regulated health, safety, and welfare (their police power): tort law, product safety, medical rules, and so on.

When Congress passes a law in one of these areas, courts assume Congress did not mean to wipe out the state laws already there. That assumption holds unless Congress made its intent to override them “clear and manifest.”

23
New cards

When is Federal Law supreme?

  1. Express: Federal law says it controls or excludes state law.

  2. Implied Conflict: Complying with both laws is impossible.

  3. Implied Obstacle: State law stands in the way of accomplishing federal objectives.

  4. Implied by Field: Congress occupies the entire field (shown by law’s structure or history).


24
New cards

Provide examples of the following:

  1. Express

  2. Implied Conflict

  3. Implied Obstacle

  4. Implied by Field


  1. Federal law requires 8-point font on drug labels. State law requires 6-point font.

  2. Federal law requires 8-point font. State law requires 6-point font.

  3. Federal law requires all drugs to carry an ingredients list in plain English so patients can understand what they’re taking. State law requires the ingredients list to be printed only in Latin chemical names.

  4. Immigration, foreign affairs.


25
New cards

FACTS:

Alexis Geier was seriously injured in 1987 while driving a 1987 Honda Accord equipped with manual lap and shoulder belts (which she was wearing) when her car collided with a tree.

She sued American Honda in tort, alleging negligence and defective design for failing to equip the vehicle with a driver's side airbag.

At the time the car was manufactured, Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) 208 required auto manufacturers to equip only a fraction of their new car fleets with passive restraints, deliberately providing a gradual phase-in and a mix of choices (such as automatic seatbelts or passive interiors alongside airbags) to lower costs, encourage technology development, and win consumer acceptance. Honda complied with the federal law.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?

  4. Reasoning?


  1. Geier v. American Honda Motor Company

  2. Does the federal law pre-empt a common law tort action claiming that Honda should’ve equipped a 1987 vehicle with an airbag?

  3. Federal motor vehicle safety standards override state common-law tort actions that conflict with federal regulatory objectives and phase-in requirements.

  4. The Act’s savings clause (compliance does not exempt manufacturers from common law liability) does not block implied conflict preemption.


26
New cards

FACTS:

  • For decades after World War II, Holocaust survivors and their families struggled to collect on life insurance policies that European companies refused to pay. To help them, the U.S. President negotiated direct agreements with European governments to set up special, fast-track compensation funds.

    However, the state of California decided the federal government wasn't doing enough. California passed its own strict law (HVIRA) to force these European insurance companies to hand over their World War II-era records, threatening to kick them out of the California market if they didn't comply.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?

  4. Reasoning?


  1. American Ins. Assoc. v. Garamendi

  2. Is California’s Act preempted because it interferes with foreign policy and executive agreements conducted by the U.S President?

  3. States cannot play a diplomat. California's Holocaust Victim Insurance Relief Act is unconstitutional because it conflicts with the foreign policy of the Executive Branch and is preempted.

  4. The Constitution gives the federal government—specifically the President—the exclusive power to conduct foreign affairs and negotiate with other countries. A single nation cannot have 50 different foreign policies.


27
New cards

Why did the court decide that states cannot act as diplomats in American Ins. Assoc. v. Garamendi?

The nation needs to speak with “one voice.”

28
New cards

Intergovernmental Immunity: Rule

States Can't Boss Around the Feds

The federal government is supreme. Because of this, a state cannot regulate or directly tax the federal government or its employees while they are doing their official jobs. (e.g. a state cannot force a U.S. Postal worker or a military pilot to get a state driver's license to operate a federal vehicle)

29
New cards

Anti-Commandeering: Rule

The Feds Can't Boss Around State Legislatures

The federal government cannot treat state governments like its own branch offices. Congress cannot order states to pass specific laws. Congress cannot force state police or state officials to enforce federal programs.

  • The Exception: If Congress passes a general law that applies to private businesses, it can apply that same law to state governments as employers. For example, if Congress passes a federal minimum wage or anti-discrimination law for all workplaces, the state government must obey it for its own employees, just like a private company would.


30
New cards

Conditional Spending: Rule

Because of the Anti-Commandeering rule, Congress cannot force states to pass laws (like raising the drinking age). Instead, Congress uses its spending power to legally bribe them. Congress can offer federal grant money to states with strings attached, provided the strings meet strict rules:

  • Express: The condition must be stated clearly upfront.

  • Related: The condition must be logically connected to the purpose of the money (e.g., tying highway repair funds to highway safety laws, like a 21-year-old drinking age).

  • Not Coercive: It cannot be a financial "gun to the head." In the famous drinking age case, states only lost 5% of their federal highway funds if they refused, which the Court said was a fair choice.

  • Not Otherwise Unconstitutional: If Congress threatened to pull 100% of a state's federal healthcare funding, it would cross the line from a "choice" to unconstitutional coercion.


31
New cards

FACTS:

In 1952, the United States was in the middle of the Korean War, and the military desperately needed steel for weapons and equipment. At the same time, a major labor dispute broke out between U.S. steel companies and their workers. The workers planned a nationwide strike, which would have completely shut down steel production.

Fearing this would cripple the war effort, President Harry Truman took drastic action. Just hours before the strike, he issued an Executive Order commanding the Secretary of Commerce (Charles Sawyer) to seize the steel mills and force them to keep running under government control.

Truman didn't ask Congress for permission to do this. The steel companies sued, arguing the President had overstepped his authority.

  1. What is this case’s name?

  2. What is the Issue?

  3. What is the Holding?


  1. Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer

  2. Does the President have the constitutional or statutory authority without congressional authorization to issue an executive order seizing and operating private steel mills to avert a national crisis during a wartime emergency?

  3. No, the President does not have the constitutional or statutory authority to seize private property without authorization from Congress or the Constitution.


32
New cards

What did the Supreme Court decide in Trump v. Anderson about a State's ability to disqualify a presidential candidate under Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment? 

A. The President is not covered by Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment.

B. Section 3 can only be enforced through impeachment.

C. Congress has exclusive authority to enforce Section 3 for federal offices, including the Presidency.

D. States may disqualify any federal officeholder, including presidential candidates, under Section 3.

C.

The Court held that enforcement of Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment against federal candidates—including the presidency—is assigned by the Constitution to Congress, not the States.

“Responsibility for enforcing Section 3 against federal officeholders and candidates rests with Congress and not the States.”

33
New cards

The U.S. economy continues to grow, but not everyone is doing well. Recent university graduates have complained about the burden of repaying their student loans because they feel that satisfactory jobs are too scarce. Minnesota has responded by passing a law allowing any graduate within the state to postpone making loan payments to a lender in the state until the graduate’s annual income exceeds 50% of the graduate’s total student loan debt. The law does not reduce the principal or interest owed on the student loans. Which of the following factors is a court least likely to consider in determining whether the law is constitutional?

A. The exigency of the circumstances that produced the need for the regulation.

B. The extent of the interference with the student loan contracts.

C. The weight of the governmental interest advanced by the regulation.

D. The bargaining power of the lenders and students at the time when the loans were made.

D.

The bargaining power of the parties when the contract was made is not a factor courts consider in determining whether a state law that affects the terms of existing contracts violates the Contract Clause.

34
New cards

Why did the Supreme Court strike down Arkansas’s attempt to impose term limits on its federal congressional candidates in U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton?

A. Because the Constitution explicitly prohibits term limits.

B. Because term limits violate the First Amendment rights of candidates.

C. Because allowing States to alter qualifications undermines the uniform national character of Congress.

D. Because the Arkansas law lacked proper legislative authorization.

C.

The Court emphasized that the Constitution sets fixed qualifications for federal office, and allowing each State to impose additional limits would fracture the national

character of the U.S. Congress. “The Framers intended the Constitution to be the exclusive source of qualifications for members of Congress… [and] that the qualifications be uniform throughout the Nation.”

35
New cards

What did the Supreme Court hold in Chiafalo v. Washington about states’ authority over presidential electors?

A. States may bind electors to vote for the candidate who won the State’s popular vote.

B. Electors must always vote according to their conscience, not party pledges.

C. Only Congress can regulate presidential electors.

D. The Constitution prohibits any restrictions on elector discretion.

A.

The Court upheld Washington’s law penalizing “faithless electors,” holding that a State may require electors to follow their pledge and vote for the state’s popular vote winner. “The Constitution’s text and the Nation’s history both support allowing a State to enforce an elector’s pledge…”

36
New cards

Congress has passed a law outlawing the use of marijuana. Although the Supreme Court has upheld the law as constitutional, the President has announced that the Justice Department will not enforce the law in states where state law does not prohibit the use of marijuana. Which of the following statements is correct?

A. State law has no bearing on whether the President’s actions are constitutional.

B. The President’s actions are constitutional because they fall within the first category of executive actions identified by Justice Jackson in his separate opinion in Youngstown Sheet & Tube v. Sawyer (1952).

C. Congress may respond to the President’s actions by creating an independent federal agency, over which the President has no control, and then giving that agency authority to prosecute marijuana offenses.

D. The President’s duty to ensure that the laws are faithfully executed affords no discretion in deciding whether or how to prosecute crimes.

A.

Correct. The President is responsible for faithfully executing federal law. Because federal law is supreme over state law under the Supremacy Clause, state law has no bearing on the President’s action.