1/198
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Do goods on display in a shop constitute an offer?
No - It is an invitation to treat. Offer is made at checkout which cashier can either accept or deny.
Do advertisements for goods/services constitute an offer? Are there any exceptions?
General rule = No. Invitation to treat.
Exception = If an intention to be bound can be shown, can constitute an offer and thus unilateral contract
What is a 'reserve price' in an auction sale?
A set price hidden from buyers which allows auctioneer to withdraw the asset if bidding does not reach the set price.
Is a tender an offer? Are there any exceptions?
No - a tender is generally an invitation to treat.
Exception = where company promises to accept lowest tender OR impliedly promises to consider all conforming tenders, this will constitute an offer for a unilateral contract.
What are the two limbs of acceptance?
(a) An expression of assent
(b) Which is unqualified
How is acceptance generally communicated in unilateral contracts?
By conduct.
When can silence amount to acceptance?
When coupled with conduct which a reasonable person would take to mean 'yes'. Mere silence cannot bind a party
Is a conditional response acceptance? What about a question?
A conditional response constitute a counter-offer. A question does not negate acceptance.
Where businesses contract on standard terms, which will constitute an offer?
The last offer to be accepted in the back and forward.
What is the postal rule? What are its 3 limbs?
A letter of acceptance will be effective when posted even if the letter gets lost.
It must be
(a) reasonable to use post,
(b) letter properly addressed/stamped/posted,
(c) postal rule has not been excluded by offer (expressly/impliedly).
When will the postal rule not apply?
Where an offeror stipulates or implies they need to be notified in writing or "told" of acceptance. In this scenario, acceptance only happens when letter is received.
What are the 4 methods of terminating an offer?
1. Counter-offer
2. Lapse of time
3. Revocation
4. Express rejection
If an offeror promises to keep offer open for a certain time period, can he still revoke the offer before said date?
Yes.
Exception = If offeree gives something in return for a promise to keep offer open (e.g., £1 to keep open for a week)
In unilateral contracts, when can revocation occur?
At any time before the specified act is completed
What is the rule for revocations when sent via electronic communications to a business?
Revocation will be effective when the e-message should reasonably have been read (i.e, within business hours).
Who can give notice of revocation?
Offeror or a reliable third party (objectively judged)
Does the postal rule apply to notices of revocation?
No.
How can the presumption in favour of an intention to create legal relations in commercial agreements be rebutted?
By express statement of a desire to not be legally bound (e.g., 'binding in honour only').
What facts might rebut the presumption against an intention to create legal relations in domestic agreements?
Arm's length dealing of parties, amount of money at stake, express agreement by parties to be bound, value of asset under consideration.
What is executed consideration? When is it used.
An act. It is used in unilateral contracts
What is the rule on consideration being adequate?
It need not be adequate (i.e, amount/value of the thing need not correspond to value of promise). Must simply have some value.
What type of consideration would not be sufficient?
'In consideration of natural love and affection'
Will performance of a public duty be sufficient consideration?
No. But EXCEEDING public duty can be.
What is the exception to the past consideration rule?
(a) Past act/promise is done at promisors request
(b) Mutual understanding between parties that act/promise would be compensated for
(c) Had promise been made in advance, it would have been legally enforceable (i.e, there is intention to create legal relations).
What is the common issue in enforcing contractual variations?
Consideration.
Is performance of an existing contractual duty good consideration for a promise to pay more money?
No.
Exception = Where a party EXCEEDS an existing contractual obligation, this is good consideration.
What constitutes good consideration for variation?
Conferral of a practical benefit (so long as not procured under duress)
What is the rule in Pinnels Case?
An agreement to accept part-payment as full settlement of a debt is not binding on the creditor.
What is the exception to the rule in Pinnels Case?
Where a debtor gives something to the creditor (other than just part payment) in return for promise to forgo balance of debt, this is good consideration and agreement will be enforceable.
Can a creditor be stopped from going back on a promise to accept part payment?
Yes. The doctrine of promissory estoppel.
(a) Promise is made that party will not enforce legal rights
(b) Other party relies on it
(c) Party is estopped from enforcing said legal rights at common law.
In cases of promissory estoppel, can a party claim arrears in part-payment disputes?
No. Creditor can only resume right to full payment moving forward by giving reasonable notice.
What is the doctrine of privity of contract?
Only the parties to a contract are bound by it. Third-parties can neither sue nor be sued.
Per the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999, how can a third-party acquire contractual rights?
1. If contract expressly provides that they may acquire a benefit
2. If term purports to confer a benefit on them
What is required for a third-party to enforce a term of a contract?
They must be expressly identified in contract by name or as member of a defined class
When can an agent bind someone to a deal?
If they have express or implied authority to do so (actual or apparent).
What is the rule for actual authority in agency relationships?
Calculated by working out what parties have said/done. Can be express/implied
What is apparent authority in agency relationships?
Where an agent dosen't have actual authority from a principal via contract but a form which has been made 'apparent' by the principal
What is the 3-stage test for establishing if apparent authority exists?
1. Principal must represent via words/conduct that the agent had authority
2. Third-party must rely on said representation, believing agent has authority
3. Third-party must alter their position (e.g., entering into the contract)
What will happen to the principal/ agent in scenarios where apparent authority existed?
Principal = will be estopped from going back on contract.
Agent = Can be liable only to the principal for breach of agency agreement.
Can a minor be bound by a contract they enter into?
No.
Exception = If contract is for 'necessaries'
What is a contract for 'necessaries' in relation to a minor?
A supply of necessary goods/services or contracts of service for a minors benefit.
What is the rule on contracts of service viz minors?
If on balance the contract is more favourable than not to the minor, then it will be binding (e.g., an apprenticeship or training/experience type roles).
What is the rule for contracts made by individuals of mental impairment/drunkenness
It will be voidable if a party is incapable of understanding nature of transaction + the other party knows this.
What is the s.39 CA 2006 rule for registered companies?
Where a company contracts with an outsider, it cannot be challenged if it is beyond the powers granted in the company's constitution. Both parties will be bound.
In what 3 ways can an express term be incorporated into a contract?
1. Signature
2. Reasonable notice before/at time of contracting
3. Previous course of dealing
What factors will the court take into account when deciding whether reasonable notice has been given?
1. Nature of document
- E.g., Is document one which a reasonable person would expect their to be terms?
2. Timing
- Notice must come before or at time of contracting (not afterwards)
3. Onerous terms
- More onerous a term, the more a party must do to bring it to other party's attention
4. Exemption clause must be legible
5. If terms on back of document, are there words on front drawing attention to them (e.g., 'see back')
What is the rule about previous consistent court of dealing and express terms?
If parties had regular dealings in past, on exactly same terms and conditions, certain default conditions can be expressly incorporated into the contract.
What are the 2 types of classification of contractual terms?
1. Conditions
2. Warranties
What can a party do on breach of a condition?
Prima facie, innocent party can terminate contract AND claim damages
What can a party do on breach of a warranty?
Potentially claim damages (but not terminate contract).
What is an example of a clause the court has determined will be 'conditions'?
'Expected ready to load' clauses in charter parties.
What are 'innominate' terms?
Terms where the remedy will depend on the ultimate effect of breach.
I.e., Only if the breach was really serious and deprived innocent party of substantially whole benefit under contract may they be able to terminate.
What are the 4 main types of implied contractual terms?
1. Implied by custom
2. Implied by fact
3. Implied by law
4. Implied by statute
When will a term NOT be implied by custom?
If it would contradict an express term in the contract
What is a term implied by fact?
A term which contract would be unworkable without
What is a term implied by law?
E.g., In employment contract, implied duty on employer to provide healthy/safe environment.
What is the implied term in s.12(1) Sale of Goods Act?
Seller has right to sell the goods
What is the implied term in s.13(1) sale of goods act?
In a contract for sale of goods by description, the goods will correspond with said description
What is the implied term in s.14(2) SGA?
Goods supplied are of satisfactory quality
What is the implied term in s.14(2A) SGA?
Goods meet standard a reasonable person would regard as satisfactory
What is the implied term in s.14(3) SGA?
Goods supplied are reasonably fit for purpose
What are ss.12/13/14 SGA all classified as? Effect?
Conditions.
Prima facie allow an innocent party to terminate contract and claim damages.
What are the bars to rejecting the goods/terminating a contract?
1. Buyer has accepted goods
2. Breach is so slight it would be unreasonable to reject goods (s.13/14)
What is the implied term in Supply of Goods Services Act s.13
Where work/service is done in course of business, it will be carried out with reasonable care and skill
What is the implied term in Supply of Goods Services Act s.14
Where work/service is done and no time for performance is agreed, implied that work will be done within a reasonable time.
What is the implied term in Supply of Goods Services Act s.15
If a price for work/service has not been fixed, implied term that reasonable sum will be charged.
Under the Consumer Rights Act, if goods do not conform to contract, what rights does the consumer have?
1. Short-term right to reject and get full refund
2. Right to repair/replacement (if appropriate)
3. Right to price reduction or final right to reject and get a partial refund to reflect consumers' use of goods.
Unless parties have expressly agreed otherwise, what is the time limit for short-term right to reject non-perishable goods? Perishable goods?
30 days after they have been bought, delivered and installed.
No longer than the goods could reasonably be expected to last
What right does a consumer have under s.54 CRA in relation to enforcing terms about services/work?
If service/work does not conform to contract due to breach of express/implied term, consumer has right to require repeat performance OR a price reduction.
In relation to a breach of implied term as to performance within a reasonable time, what dos the consumer have a right to under s.52 CRA?
Price reduction.
What is the 2-stage test relating to exemption clauses?
1. Incorporation
2. Construction
What is the construction test?
Whether the clause was intended to exclude or limit liability for the particular breach and loss which occurred
If there is an ambiguity as to construction of an exemption clause, how will the courts interpret it?
Contra preferentum (i.e., construed AS AGAINST the person seeking to rely on it)
What are the 2 main statutes which cover exemption clauses and limitation clauses?
Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 (business-to-business)
Consumer Rights Act 2015 (business-to-consumer)
What are the 3 results which can emerge from applying the UCTA?
1. Defendant cannot rely on term
2. Defendant can rely on term
3. Defendant can rely on term with added requirement of 'reasonableness'
When can a defendant not restrict their liability?
In relation to death/personal injury caused by negligence
What type of exemption clause does the requirement of reasonableness commonly apply to?
1. Loss or damage caused by negligence
2. Breach of statutory implied terms relating to goods
3. Breach of express term in standard written terms
What is the 'reasonableness test'
Clause must be fair and reasonable to have been included in the contract.
What type of factors will the courts take into account in terms of reasonableness?
1. Was risk insurable?
2. Nature of parties dealings/negotiations
3. Bargaining position of parties
4. Did customer receive inducement to enter into clause?
5. Nature/dangerousness of task being undertaken
What does s.31 CRA say about exemption clauses for s.9/10/11?
These provisions cannot be excluded or restricted.
What does s.57 CRA say about exemption clauses for s.49 (duty to take reasonable care and skill)?
It cannot be excluded.
What is the general rule about exemption clauses and third-parties?
An exemption clause in a contract cannot protect a third-party (privity)
What is the exception to the rule above?
If a third-party is NAMED in an exemption clause or identified as a member of a class entitled to benefit from it, they can rely on the clause.
What is the general principle used to assess damages?
What position would the claimant have been in had the contract been performed?
What other type of loss might a claimant claim for, other than loss of bargain/profits?
Reliance loss.
E.g., Where profits they hope will materialise from contract are too speculative.
What are non-pecuniary losses?
E.g., 'Pain and suffering'
What type of contracts night a non-pecuniary claim be successful on?
Holiday contracts and weddings
- E.g., 'Disappointment' or 'loss of enjoyment' caused by breach of contract.
What is the rule on remoteness in damages?
Is the particular loss likely to have been in the reasonable contemplation of the parties at the time of the contract as a likely consequence of breach?
What factors will be taken into account when considering remoteness?
Did defendant know of special circumstances which meant particular loss would be a likely consequence of breach?
What is the rule about the extent of loss and remoteness?
As long as the particular type of loss is not too remote, the extent of the loss is irrelevant.
What is the principle of mitigation?
The claimant must take reasonable steps to mitigate loss caused by breach.
Who is the burden of proof on to prove a failure to mitigate?
Defendant.
When might the full cost of cure not be awarded in a contract (Forsyth)
If the real loss is actually amenity/ consumer surplus, as opposed to a defect.
What is a specified damage clause in a contract?
A clause which attempts to pre-estimate the loss likely to be caused by breach, represented by a fixed sum payable.
Do the rules of mitigation, measuring damages, remoteness etc apply to a specified damages clause?
No.
The pre-agreed figure is binding.
What is a penalty clause in a contract and are they enforceable?
A clause designed to put pressure on a party to perform contract, due to sum being disproportionately high and excessive.
A penalty clause is unenforceable.
Court will instead assess damages in the usual way.
What is 'action for an agreed sum'?
Suing directly for a fixed amount owed.
What is 'specific performance'. When is it available?
Equitable remedy, where claimant asks court for an order requiring actual performance.
Generally available if damages are not an adequate remedy (e.g., purchases of land).