1/14
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Impressions and Ideas
Hume says we can distinguish between things in the mind that have ‘force and vivacity’ compared to those ideas that are duller. He argues;
Those that have force and vivacity are impressions;
Internal/inward impressions are feelings, emotions, desires etc.
External /outward impressions are our direct sense experiences (sight, smell, touch etc.)
Those that are duller are ideas;
These are thoughts, beliefs, memories that we can recall and contemplate
Note: impressions are the same as what Locke calls ‘sensations’
The Copy Principle
Hume says that all ideas can be traced back to impressions – those that we gain from the external world. This explains why ideas are ‘less vivid’ – they are simply imitations of the real thing (impressions). So without the impressions, we cannot have the ideas.
Imagination and Complex Ideas
Hume gave four ways that our imagination changes simple ideas, making them complex:
Compound – an idea made from multiple other simple ideas joined together
Transpose – an idea made by swapping parts with other ideas
Augment – Adding to an idea
Diminish – Taking away from an idea
Hume’s argument 1
When you look at any complex idea you have, you can break it down and trace it back to the original impressions that it is copied from (Hume’s e.g. God made up of augmented human attributes).
Hume’s argument 2
If someone is unable to perceive certain impressions – they are unable to obtain any associated ideas that come from them (Hume’s e.g. blind man cannot have ideas of colours).
Analytic:
Something that is true by definition – we know it is true because of the meaning of the words.
Synthetic:
Not true by definition; true because of the way the world is.
Hume believes knowledge is either
“All the objects of human reason or enquiry may naturally be divided into two kinds, to wit, Relations of Ideas and Matters of Fact”.
Differences between matters of fact and relations of ideas
Example: John is a bachelor
The statement can be contradicted and still make sense
Need to look to the world to know if it is true
These are contingent and so we only know if it is true a posteriori
Being that they must be checked for truth, these are synthetic
Relations of ideas:
Example: Bachelor is an unmarried man
These are a tautology and therefore cannot be contradicted
Know it is true without looking at the world
Both the statement and it’s opposite could not be true
Being true by definition, these are analytic and necessary
What do relations of ideas tell Hume?
relations of ideas do not tell us anything useful as they are tautologies – he calls them ‘trivial’.
What does matters of fact tell Hume
Only matters of facts contain new information from which we learn new things through experience.
How matters of fact and relations of ideas relates to Hume’s empiricism
It is matters of fact that are useful to us as they tell us about the way the world is and from this information we continue learning knew facts that we could not have known before
Matters of fact all come from our experience so this side of the fork has no problem with Hume’s empirical account
Relations of Ideas are as they sound –
ideas are copies of impressions and
relations of ideas are us connecting these copied impressions…
So RofI are just terms that we have learnt that via their meaning, we can connect up without further experience - therefore he has explained a priori knowledge through empiricism
But he argues they cannot lead us to new knowledge about the world and the way it is