1/83
Intellectual Property
Intellectual Property
Intangible property
4 types of protections for intellectual property
Examples of intellectual property
inventions, literary and artistic works, designs, symbols, names, and confidential business processes—that are protected by law
Intellectual property: Justification
Article 1: Section 8
Article 1: Section 8
gives Congress the power "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.
not a “new” idea
protects patents and copywrites
protected for a limited amount of time
these protections eventually expire to the public domain
Intellectual Property: Importance
Very important in business
75% or more value of fortune 500 companies is made up of intellectual property
employee skills and talents
reports and manuals
customer lists
Intellectual Property: Competition
Companies spend lots of money on protecting their intellectual property which can be a monetary disadvantage for a period of time
once their intellectual property is protected they will have a payback and also be ahead of their competitors
Intellectual Property: Capturing
the systematic process a business uses to identify, record, and evaluate new ideas, technical innovations, and creative assets generated by employees, contractors, or everyday operations before they are lost or left unprotected
capture the information before it gets to the public, because once it is out you can’t recapture it
Trade Secrets
Knowledge or information that is kept secret and has economic value
reasonable measures must be taken to keep the information secret
characteristics of trade secrets
they don’t need to unique
it just needs to be company information that is kept secret
secrecy of information must be maintained so that it is not misappropriated
reasonable steps must be made to keep the trade secrets secret
trade secrets are long lived unlike patents
Uniform Trade Secrets Act
a model law drafted by the Uniform Law Commission in 1979 and amended in 1985 to create a uniform legal standard for protecting trade secrets across U.S. states
If a trade secret is misappropriated…
you must convince the court that you had a trade secret
then you must show that it was misappropriated
To establish the existence of trade secrets…
conduct a trade secret audit to identify confidential knowledge-based resources
preserve secrecy
lock written material
secure computer stored knowledge with firewalls and encryption
impose confidentiality restrictions
regulate visitors
ask employees, customers, and business partners to sign nondisclosure agreements
Demonstrating Misappropriations
misappropriation occurs when one improperly acquires or discloses secret information
Independent creation and reverse engineering are exempted
Employee Mobility and trade secrets
confidentiality contracts forbid employees from disclosing the knowledge obtained in the workplace
employers can enforce agreements not to compete only when there is a valid business purpose for the contract
Independent creation
If you develop a formula, process, or business method on your own through proper means, you do not commit misappropriation—even if another company already holds the exact same information as a trade secret
reverse engineering
Reverse engineering involves dismantling and analyzing a product to understand how it works or to discover its trade secrets.
examples of Misappropriations
burglary, espionage, and hacking
If you get information from some one who knows a trade secret…
If you knew that it was a secret when they told you, you are just as guilty as the perpetrator
if you didn’t know that it was a trade secret when you were told, then thats not considered misappropriation
Patent Law
A new invention that can create a legal monopoly
a specialized branch of intellectual property law that grants inventors exclusive legal rights to protect their new and useful inventions from being made, used, sold, or imported by others without permission
the constitution allows congress to create patent
PTO
exclusive right created by a statute for a limited time
3types
PTO (Patent and Trademarks Office)
a federal agency within the U.S. Department of Commerce that grants U.S. patents and registers trademarks
3 Types of Patents
utility
design
plant
Utility patents
protects the functional aspects, operational methods, and new or improved utility of a product, machine, process, or composition of matter
new, non-obvious, useful processes, machines, compositions of matter or improvement therof
can last up to 20 years
Design Patent
legal protection granted to the new, original, and ornamental appearance of an article of manufacture, separate from its functional utility
can last up to 15 years
covers the visual aspects of a product
Plant Patent
a special legal protection granted by the U.S. government to inventors or discoverers who create or find a new plant variety and successfully reproduce it asexually
can last for 20 years
Obtaining a Patent
File application
Filing fee
Explain invention
Show difference from prior art
Describe patentable aspects
Evaluation by the patent examiner
Patent
exclusive right to invention
can be challenged
The party seeking a patent must be…
an individual or individuals
not AI
Patent examiner
employee of the PTO
When trying to file for a patent it is a good idea to…
hire a patent agent or patent lawyer
both have to pass the US patent bar
both have to have taken a difficult science degree in undergrad
Characteristics of Patents
Novelty
something new and different from the prior art
Non-obviousness
ability of an invention to produce surprising or unexpected results
battle of the experts
Utility
must do something useful
doesn’t have to be useful for what its intended to be useful for
Once a patent is issued the patent owner can…
maintain the patents secrecy
have others pay to use it
What cannot be patented
natural phenomena
mere abstract ideas
math equations
Patent enforcement
patent owner can sue against infringement for injunction and damages
inventions can cover methods and articles that can overlap
overlapping rights provide an opportunity for firms to purchase patent rights and sue companies- patent trolls
courts may increase patent infringement damages up to three times the amount found or assessed
Patent trolls
person or company who purchases rights to multiple patents to earn money
University of Wisconsin v. Apple
decade-long patent dispute between the University of Wisconsin-Madison (represented by the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation, or WARF) and Apple concluded in August 2024 when a federal appeals court ruled against the university, denying them a new trial
UGARF
owns patents filed by uga students in the duration of their schooling
Al Minor & Associates, Inc. V. Martin, 881 N.E. 2d 850 (Ohio 2008)
trade secret case
The Supreme Court of Ohio held in Al Minor & Associates, Inc. v. Martin that a customer list can qualify as a trade secret under Ohio's Uniform Trade Secrets Act (UTSA) even if a former employee memorized the information rather than taking physical or written documents
even info that is just memorized & not physically taken can still be considered misappropriations of trade secrets
When dealing with trade secrets
Security Protocols
Identify Trade secrets
Limit access
Educate employees
Nondisclosure agreements
Talk carefully
Association for Molecular Pathology V. Myriad Genetics, Inc., 133 S.Ct. 2107 (2013)
In Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc. (133 S.Ct. 2107 / 569 U.S. 576, decided June 13, 2013), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously (9–0) that naturally occurring human DNA sequences are products of nature and are not patent-eligible under 35 U.S.C. § 101, simply because they have been isolated from the human genome
BRCA-1
BRCA-2
Sct. says that extensive effort is not enough to be patentable → they discovered something not invented it
rewards invention not investment
Alice Corporation Pty. Ltd. V. CLS Bank Int’l, 134 S.Ct. 2347 (2014)
The landmark Supreme Court decision Alice Corporation Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank International (573 U.S. 208, decided June 19, 2014) established that patent claims directed to abstract ideas implemented via generic computers are ineligible for protection under 35 U.S.C. § 101
challenged the validity of Alice’s already existing patents
section 101 of patent act
Alice 2 step
courts are to use a 2 step Alice framework
does the claim hold an inventive concept
Alice looses all of their patents
Trademarks
marks on what is produced to represent the origin of goods and services
recognizability or distinctiveness
protection against confusion
trademarks protect…
the maker of the mark
Trade marks can be registered with…
the PTO (Patent and Trademarks office)
but trademarks don’t HAVE to be registered
Being registered allows the trademark to receive protection from the
Lanham Act
The Lanham act of 1946
protects 5 different types of trademarks
the primary federal statute governing trademark law, unfair competition, and false advertising in the United States
5 types of trademarks protected by the Lanham act
Trademark
Service mark
Certification mark
Collective mark
Trade dress
Trademark characteristics
TM→ unregistered
R→ registered
Service Mark characteristics
SM→ unregistered
R→ registered
a word, phrase, symbol, design, or combination of them that identifies and distinguishes the source of services rather than physical goods
Certification Mark characteristics
used by people other than the owner of the mark
a special symbol, word, or design that shows a product or service meets certain set standards, quality levels, or safety rules
ex.) organic marking
Collective mark characteristics
used by members of an organization
a special type of trademark or service mark owned by an association, union, cooperative, or other group that its members use to identify their goods or services and distinguish them from those of non-members
ex.) the SEC
Trade dress characteristics
The look of a product
can go on indefinitely, unlike a patent
the total visual image recognizable to the consumer
the visual appearance, "look and feel," or total commercial image of a product or service that identifies its source and distinguishes it from competitors,
non traditional trademarks
color marks
sound marks
color marks
PTO is very persnickety about these
colors are too limited to let every business own one (color depletion)
ex.) tiffany blue, christian louboutin’s red soles
john deer can’t trademark the color green because green is a functional color in the agriculture industry
a non-traditional trademark where a specific color or combination of colors functions as a unique source identifier for a company's goods or services
Sound marks
The PTO is very persnickety about these
the customer must be able to recognize it
ex.) the opening netflix sound
a non-traditional trademark where a distinct sound, melody, jingle, or voice is used to identify and distinguish the commercial origin of a product or service
Trademark Registration
PTO can deny registration
usage of mark in interstate commerce is required for registration with the PTO
PTO places the mark in the Official Gazette
Registered on the Principal Register if the mark is acceptable
Landham Act protection
If listed in the Supplemental Register for 5 years and acquires a secondary meaning, a name or descriptive term can acquire full trademark status
Gains a secondary meaning in the minds of the consumer
ex.) honey baked ham, disney
what is required for trademark registration with the PTO
usage of the mark in interstate commerce
what kind of law would trademark infringement be?
can be either civil or criminal
trademark enforcement
the law protects the owner from unauthorized use of the mark
generic marks cannot be protected
manufacturing and trafficking counterfeit trademarked products is a criminal violation
the standard of proof → the likelyhood of confusion if the customer
Infringement
civil violation of a trademark
remedies include damages and injunctions and orders to destroy infringing products
fair use
a legal defense that allows someone to use another party's registered trademark without permission under specific, limited circumstances
Trademark dilution
Federal Trademark Dilution Act, 1995
Prohibits the usage of a mark same as or similar to another’s famous trademark due to its significance, reputation, and goodwill
has to be brought forth by a famous mark holder
Types:
Blurring
Tarnishment
Blurring
when usage of a mark blurs distinctiveness of a famous mark
Tarnishment
when usage of a mark creates a negative impression about the famous company
Copyright
monopoly
→copying and marketing
→limited period of time
→original expression
Protects creative original expression
art, music, and film
limited time determined by congress
intentional copyright→ criminal
No AI can hold a copyright
Copyright Ownership
copyright law grants property in certain creative expressions & prohibits others from reproducing it without permission
Criteria for Copyright protection
work must be original
must be fixed in a tangible medium of expression
must show creative expression
How long does an Individual’s copyright protection last for?
the authors life plus 70 years
how long do a company’s copyright protections last for?
95 years from publication or 120 years from the creation of the work, whichever expires first
Public domain day
January 1st of each year
as of Jan 1st 2026, works published in or before 1930 are in the public domain
this is done by operation of law
Copyright infringement
the owner has to establish that defendant violated his or her exclusive rights of:
Reproduction
Creation of derivative works
Distribution
Performance
Display
Piracy
large scale copyright infringement
what can you not do before getting a copyright registered
sue!
Copyright fair use
includes copying for
criticism
news reporting
teaching
scholarship
research
factors for fair use are considered on a case-by-case basis
The PTO will never let you ______ from fair use.
Profit
The law of the internet
copyright law
DMCA 1998
The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) is a United States federal law signed by President Bill Clinton on October 28, 1998, that updates copyright law for the internet age
Notice-and-Takedown System: Protects online service providers (OSPs) from copyright liability if they quickly remove or disable access to user-posted content when notified by a copyright owner
Internet service providers are protected if they are patrolling their sites
Reasons the PTO can deny registration
same or similar to another mark
prohibited or reserved names or design
name or likeness without permission
descriptive
generic
PTO used to be able to deny registration on these grounds
disparagement
Immoral/ scandalous names or symbols
Matal v. Tam, 582 U.S. ____, 137 S.Ct 1744 (2017)
is the disparagement clause in the Lanham act invalid under the 1st amendment?
ruled in Matal v. Tam that the disparagement clause of the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. § 1052(a)) violates the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment
Tam sought to register his dance-rock band’s name, "The Slants," to reclaim an ethnic slur. The USPTO refused registration, arguing the name was disparaging to Asian Americans under Section 2(a) of the Lanham Act
Laneu v. Brunetti, 588 U.S. ____, 139 S.Ct. 2294 (2019)
Laneu v. Brunetti), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 6–3 that Section 2(a) of the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. § 1052(a))—which prohibited the federal registration of trademarks consisting of "immoral, or scandalous matter"—violates the First Amendment
Erik Brunetti tried to register his streetwear clothing brand FUCT (pronounced as four individual letters, F-U-C-T). The USPTO refused registration, finding the mark to be "immoral or scandalous" because it sounds like a vulgar profanity
Jack Daniel’s Properties, Inc. v. VIP products LLC, 599 U.S. ____ 2023
The Supreme Court ruled unanimously in Jack Daniel’s Properties, Inc. v. VIP Products LLC (599 U.S. 140, 2023) that the Rogers test for expressive works does not apply when an alleged infringer uses a trademark as a designation of source for their own commercial goods
The Product: VIP Products created "Bad Spaniels," a humor-themed dog chew toy that parodied the shape, label, and trade dress of a Jack Daniel’s whiskey bottle (substituting phrases like "Old No. 7" with "Old No. 2 on your Tennessee Carpet").
The Dispute: Jack Daniel's sued for trademark infringement and dilution. VIP Products argued that the toy was an expressive parody protected by the First Amendment.
Procedural Path: The U.S. District Court initially ruled for Jack Daniel's, the Ninth Circuit reversed by applying the Rogers test and finding a noncommercial use exclusion for parody, and the Supreme Court granted certiorari.
Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC v. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. (No. 13-2559)
The Dispute: Kraft Foods has sold "Cracker Barrel" branded cheese in grocery stores since the 1950s. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store (CBOCS) entered a deal to sell its own line of branded food products (like hams and bacon) in traditional grocery stores.
The Lawsuit: Kraft sued CBOCS for trademark infringement and Lanham Act violations, arguing that consumers would be confused when seeing "Cracker Barrel" food products side-by-side in regular grocery store aisles.
The Ruling: The Seventh Circuit affirmed a preliminary injunction blocking CBOCS from selling its food products in standard grocery stores.
The Scope: The injunction was narrow; it applied only to grocery store sales. It did not stop Cracker Barrel from selling or serving food inside its own restaurants, its adjoining country gift stores, or via its own mail-order and online channels.
The Legal Basis: The court found a high likelihood of consumer confusion due to the identical brand name, similar visual style, and overlapping retail environment
Google LLC v. Oracle America Inc., 593 U.S. ____ (2021)
decided April 5th 2021
the “copyright lawsuit of the decade” pitted google against oracle in a titanic legal battle over smartphone software
In Google LLC v. Oracle America, Inc., the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 6–2 that Google's copying of 11,500 lines of Java Application Programming Interface (API) declaring code to build the Android operating system was a fair use as a matter of law