1/57
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Positive Impacts of migration on originating country
- Reduces unemployment: When workers leave a country with a surplus of labor, fewer people compete for the jobs available. This reduces pressure on the domestic labor market.
- Raises wages: When the supply of labor decreases, employers may need to offer higher wages to attract or retain workers.
- Releases political pressure: High unemployment and limited economic opportunities can create public dissatisfaction. Migration may reduce some of that pressure by allowing people to seek employment elsewhere.
- Increases foreign currency reserves through remittances: Migrants send money to their families in their home countries. These transfers are called remittances. They provide income to households and bring foreign currency into the originating economy.
- Encourages the transfer of knowledge and technology: Migrants may return with new skills, professional experience, technology, cultural practices, and ideas that benefit their home communities.
Negative Impacts of migration on originating country
- Brain drain: The originating country can lose highly educated and skilled workers, such as doctors, engineers, scientists, and other professionals.
- Changes in family and community structures: When working-age adults leave, some communities may have a disproportionate number of children, women, and elderly residents.
- Loss of productive capacity: If workers with valuable skills leave permanently, their home country may lose some of the benefits of its investment in their education and training.
Positive Impact of migration on host country
- Fills labor shortages: Migrants can supply workers for jobs that employers have difficulty filling.
- Provides needed skills: Highly educated migrants may contribute specialized knowledge and professional expertise.
- Supports economic activity: Migrants work, consume goods and services, and contribute to production.
- Provides social and cultural benefits: Migrants bring different traditions, languages, experiences, and perspectives.
- Helps address population decline: Immigration can increase the working-age population in countries experiencing low birth rates or aging populations.
Negative Impact of migration on host country
- A mismatch between migrants' skills and the jobs available can limit their economic contribution.
- Immigration may create competition for particular jobs, especially in certain local labor markets.
- Failure to integrate can create social or political tensions.
- criminal activity as a possible negative effect when it occurs; this should not be interpreted as suggesting that immigrants generally engage in crime.
immigration does not necessarily have the same financial impact on every level of government:
Federal gov: Receives federal income and payroll tax revenue; Can benefit from workers contributing to Social Security; Benefits may be spread nationally
State/Local Gov: Pays for public schools, emergency services, and other local services; May experience concentrated service costs in particular communities; Costs may be concentrated in border states and immigrant-receiving cities
Neoclassical migration model
The neoclassical migration model explains migration primarily through differences in wages between countries.
- Individuals are assumed to make rational economic decisions by comparing the earnings available at home with the earnings they could obtain abroad, after accounting for migration costs.
- The neoclassical migration model states that individuals migrate when the foreign wage minus migration costs is greater than the wage they can earn at home. Migration is driven by wage differentials and the expectation of improving personal income.
- (Wf-t)-Wd>0
Migrate if the net foreign wage exceeds the domestic wage.
(Wf-t)-Wd
Neoclassical migration model Example
Suppose a worker earns $12,000 annually in Mexico and could earn $30,000 in the United States, with $4,000 in migration costs.
- (30,000-4,000)
-12,000= $14,000
--> Because the difference is positive, the model predicts that the worker will migrate.
If the difference were zero or negative, the worker would not migrate.
Neoclassical migration model Example #2
There is a person that is considering migrating to Atlantis. If he is using the classical economics model, should he migrate? Let WF (or Yf) $500, WD(Yh)=$200, t=$150, P1=0.8, P2=0.2.
Harris-Todaro model
- expands the neoclassical model by recognizing that a higher wage in another country does not guarantee that a migrant will find employment there.
Instead of looking only at the wage difference, individuals consider their expected income, which depends on the probability of obtaining a job.
- E(Ym)=Pemp x Yf
- Where:
E(Ym) = expected income from migration
Pemp = probability of finding employment in the destination
Yf = income earned if employed in the destination
Yh = income at home
t = migration cost
- Including migration costs, the decision can be expressed as:
(Pemp x Yf) - t > Yh
- states that migration depends on expected income rather than simply the difference in wages. Expected income is determined by the probability of obtaining employment multiplied by the wage available in the destination country. A person migrates when expected foreign income, after migration costs, exceeds income at home.
Harris-Todaro model Example
A worker earns $15,000 in Mexico. In the United States, a job pays $40,000, but the worker estimates only a 50% chance of obtaining employment.
E(Ym)=0.50 x 40,000
=$20,000
- If migration costs $3,000:
20,000-3,000=$17,000
Because $17,000 is greater than the $15,000 earned at home, the worker would choose to migrate under this simplified model.
- However, if the employment probability were only 30%:
0.30 x 40,000-3,000=$9,000
--> The worker would be better off remaining in Mexico.
Harris-Todaro model Example #2
There is a person that is considering migrating to Atlantis. If he is using the classical economics model, should he migrate? If he is using the Harris-Todaro model, should he migrate if the probability of employment in the foreign country is P1, should he
migrate? If the probability of employment in the foreign country is P2, should he
migrate? Let WF (or Yf) $500, WD(Yh)=$200, t=$150, P1=0.8, P2=0.2.
Stark & Taylor migration model
- emphasize relative income.
People may decide to migrate because they want to improve their economic position compared with other households in their community.
This is connected to the idea of relative deprivation: people assess their economic well-being partly by comparing themselves with others.
- Migrants are not necessarily the richest or poorest members of a community. The poorest may lack the money and connections needed to migrate, while the wealthiest may have less economic incentive to leave. Households in between may be especially motivated.
The model also recognizes that migration decisions may be made by households rather than isolated individuals.
- Stark and Taylor argue that migration is influenced by relative income and a household's economic position compared with others in its community. Families may send members abroad to improve their relative economic standing, meaning migrants are often neither the richest nor the poorest people in their communities.
Stark & Taylor migration model Example
Imagine three families in a Mexican village:
Family A earns $5,000 annually.
Family B earns $12,000 annually.
Family C earns $50,000 annually.
--> Family B may feel economically disadvantaged when comparing itself with Family C, even if its income is sufficient to meet basic needs. It may send a household member to the United States to improve its relative position.
- The assumption is that migration, usually by the middle class, is influenced by relative income. Even if wage differences between the original country and the other country are small, those might still migrate if it can improve their household economic position compared to other classes. Usually, one or a few people leave their country to work abroad, often the oldest son, to reduce risk and create income sources.
Explain what is meant by migration becomes part of a risk diversification package.
treats migration as a household strategy for managing economic uncertainty.
Instead of depending entirely on one local labor market, a household spreads its income sources across different locations.
- Migration becomes part of a risk diversification package when a household sends some members abroad while others remain at home, allowing the family to earn income in different labor markets. This reduces the risk of losing all household income if one economy experiences unemployment, recession, or another shock. Migration is therefore a family strategy for economic security, not simply an individual's attempt to earn higher wages.
Network migration theory
explains how relationships between previous migrants, current migrants, and people who have not yet migrated make future migration easier.
- states that migration is facilitated by social relationships connecting migrants and nonmigrants across countries. These networks reduce the costs and risks of migration by helping newcomers find employment, housing, and support. As networks grow, migration becomes easier and can continue even when wage differences or government policies change.
Network migration theory 3 major mechanism
1. Declining migration costs
The first migrants face high costs because they must arrange transportation, housing, employment, and other necessities without an established support system.
Later migrants may receive assistance from people already living in the destination country.
2. Declining migration risks
Knowing someone in the destination country reduces uncertainty.
For example, a relative might help a new migrant find housing, identify job opportunities, or understand the local environment.
3. Continued migration through established networks
Once a migration network develops, additional people may migrate even when the original economic conditions change.
This makes migration increasingly self-sustaining and can reduce the effectiveness of restrictive government policies.
Background of Mexican migration
- Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo: Ended the Mexican-American War and transferred large territories to the United States. Approximately 80,000 Mexicans remained in territories that became part of the United States.
- Chinese Exclusion Act:
Restricted Chinese immigration, contributing to demand for Mexican labor as an alternative source of workers.
- Gentlemen's Agreement with Japan: Further limited Japanese immigration and contributed to recruitment of Mexican workers, including for railroad construction.
- Expansion of Mexican labor recruitment: U.S. agriculture, railroads, and other industries increasingly employed Mexican laborers.
- Immigration legislation and national-origin quotas: Reflected a restrictive immigration system that favored certain European countries.
- Great Depression and Mexican repatriation: Economic hardship and government enforcement contributed to the removal or departure of large numbers of Mexican residents, including some U.S. citizens.
Background of Mexican migration P. 2
- Bracero Program: A bilateral labor agreement brought Mexican workers to the United States, especially for agricultural employment.
- McCarran-Walter Act: Maintained much of the existing immigration quota system while making other changes.
- Operation Wetback: A major federal campaign to apprehend and remove unauthorized Mexican migrants.
- Immigration and Nationality Act amendments: Reformed the national-origin quota system and introduced important changes affecting immigration from the Western Hemisphere.
- Changing migration patterns: Economic crises, labor demand, immigration reform, enforcement, and family networks shaped migration.
- Great Recession: Reduced employment opportunities in the United States, particularly in industries employing low-wage workers.
Mexican migration to the United States has a long history:
Mexican migration developed through a combination of territorial changes, U.S. labor demand, immigration restrictions, and economic conditions. The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in 1848 placed many Mexican residents within U.S. territory. Later, restrictions on Chinese and Japanese immigration increased demand for Mexican workers. Programs such as the Bracero Program encouraged legal labor migration, while the Great Depression, deportation campaigns, and later immigration legislation altered migration patterns. Although migration has predominantly moved northward, it has historically been bidirectional.
What is the earning suspension fund
- It contains reported earnings that the agency cannot properly match to an individual's Social Security earnings record.
This can happen because of:
1) Incorrect Social Security numbers. 2) Names and identifying information that do not match. 3) Reporting errors. 4) Workers using Social Security numbers that do not belong to them.
- some unauthorized immigrants work using invalid or mismatched Social Security information.
Employers may still withhold Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes from their wages. However, the earnings may not be credited to the correct individual's Social Security record.
- example of workplaces where numerous employees had used the same Social Security number.
He also described a conversation at the Mexican Embassy in Washington, D.C., where someone pointed out that unauthorized Mexican workers were contributing payroll taxes that helped support Social Security, even though those workers might not qualify to receive benefits based on the unmatched earnings.
10. In terms of the bidirectional migration between US and Mexico what are the issues
- a. Brain Drain: Brain drain is the migration of highly educated or skilled workers from one country to another. Mexico may lose doctors, engineers, scientists, and other professionals, including students whose education was financed by the Mexican government. The United States gains skilled labor, while Mexico loses human capital and some of the benefits of its educational investments.
- b. Bracero program: The Bracero Program was a U.S.-Mexico temporary labor agreement from 1942 to 1964 that allowed Mexican workers to enter the United States, primarily for agricultural employment. It addressed labor shortages during and after World War II but raised concerns about wages, working conditions, employer dependence on temporary labor, and competition with unauthorized workers.
- c. Retail tourism: Money spent by Mexican residents in U.S. stores represents a form of export revenue for the United States, even though the goods may be purchased in person rather than shipped internationally.
The professor emphasized that this spending can account for a substantial portion of retail businesses' revenue and profits in border communities.
- d. Retirees: Retirement migration involves people, particularly Americans, moving to Mexico after retirement to benefit from lower living costs and other lifestyle advantages. Their spending supports the Mexican economy, especially housing, healthcare, and local services, although growing demand may also raise prices for local residents.
10. In terms of the bidirectional migration between US and Mexico what are the issues P.2
- e. Medical Tourism: Medical tourism occurs when Americans travel to Mexico to receive healthcare or purchase medications at lower prices. It is particularly important along the border because travel costs are relatively low, allowing people to save money on medical treatment, prescriptions, and other healthcare services.
- f. Digital Nomads: Digital nomads are remote workers who live abroad while earning income through digital employment. Many Americans have moved temporarily to Mexico City because they can earn U.S. wages while benefiting from lower living costs. Their spending benefits Mexican businesses, but increased demand for apartments and long-term Airbnb rentals can cause gentrification, higher rents, and displacement of local residents.
- g. Impact of Migration offspring: Migration can improve opportunities for migrants' children through better education, higher household income, and greater economic mobility. However, it can also create challenges involving family separation, cultural adjustment, language barriers, and immigration status. The effects depend on whether children migrate with their parents or remain in the originating country.
- h. Mexico's policy to help students obtaining higher education abroad: Mexico has supported students pursuing graduate education abroad, particularly master's and doctoral degrees, to improve its supply of highly educated professionals. However, some students remain in the countries where they studied, creating brain drain because Mexico loses the benefits of the education it helped finance.
10a. Brain Drain
- occurs when highly educated or skilled workers leave their home country to work or live elsewhere.
- Consequences for Mexico:
{Loss of highly trained professionals;
Loss of potential productivity and innovation;
Reduced return on public investments in education;
Possible shortages of specialized workers;
Slower development in some industries or research fields.}
- Consequences for the United States:
{Gains skilled workers without necessarily paying for all their original education; Benefits from their expertise, productivity, and research; May gain access to specialized skills that are in short supply.
10b. Bracero Program
- a temporary labor agreement between Mexico and the United States that operated from 1942 to 1964.
It began during World War II when the United States needed agricultural workers because many Americans were serving in the military or working in wartime industries.
The agreement allowed Mexican laborers, known as braceros, to work temporarily in the United States, primarily in agriculture.
10c. Retail Tourism
- occurs when people cross an international border primarily to purchase goods and services.
Along the U.S.-Mexico border, Mexican consumers frequently cross into American cities to shop.
- Mexican shoppers may prefer U.S. stores because of: Lower or more attractive price, Greater product variety, Perceived product quality or safety, Better customer service, Opportunities to visit family while shopping.
10c. Retail Tourism: What is the location quotient (LQ)
- measures how concentrated retail sales are relative to personal income in a particular metropolitan area compared with the state.
- 1) Difference= sales as share of income in MSA/Sales as share of income in state 2) Implied Export= difference * retail sales in MSA
10c. Retail Tourism: What is the location quotient (LQ) example #2
Sales as share of income in state = .2
Sales as share of income in MSA =.5
Difference = .3
Implied Export = 0.3 * Retail Sales in MSA = 0.3 * 4.5 million = 1.35 million
10c. Retail Tourism: What is the location quotient (LQ) example
Retail sales as a share of income in Laredo = 50%.
Retail sales as a share of income in Texas = 20%.
--> This means Laredo has retail sales relative to income that are 2.5 times the statewide ratio.
10c. Retail Tourism: What is the comparison of LQ to 1 imply in terms of retail tourism
- LQ greater than 1: Retail sales are unusually high relative to local income, suggesting that outside shoppers, including Mexican consumers, may be contributing to sales.
- LQ equal to 1: Retail sales relative to income are approximately the same as the state average.
- LQ less than 1: Retail sales relative to income are below the state average, which may suggest that local consumers shop elsewhere or that the area attracts fewer outside retail customers.
10c. Retail Tourism: What do border retailers indicate about Mexican consumer preferences and the impact on their profits.
- Mexican consumers continued crossing the border even when comparable goods were available in Mexico.
- Shoppers cited attractive prices, more choices, perceived safety, customer service, and family visits.
- Some retailers depended heavily on Mexican customers for a meaningful portion of their profits.
--> Border retailers indicate that Mexican consumers often prefer shopping in the United States because of greater product variety, competitive prices, perceived safety, customer service, and opportunities to visit family. Mexican shoppers contribute significantly to retail revenue and profits in border communities, demonstrating that retail tourism remains economically important even when the same products are available in Mexico.
10d. Retirees
- Retirement migration occurs when people move to another country after leaving the workforce.
Your professor discussed Americans retiring in Mexico, often because their retirement income can support a more comfortable lifestyle there.
Reasons include lower housing costs, lower everyday expenses, climate, and lifestyle preferences.
- Economic effects on Mexico: Increased spending on housing, food, transportation, and services.
Greater demand for healthcare and other services used by older residents.
Job creation in communities attracting retirees.
Possible increases in local housing prices.
Economic effects on the United States:
- Retirees may spend some of their retirement income outside the United States rather than in American communities.
10e. Medical Tourism
- occurs when people travel to another country to receive medical treatment, purchase prescription medication, or obtain healthcare services.
Along the U.S.-Mexico border, many Americans cross into Mexico because medical services and prescription drugs may cost substantially less.
- Reasons for medical tourism:
Lower prices for medical procedures.
Less expensive prescription medications.
Affordable dental care.
Access to services that may be financially difficult to obtain in the United States.
10e. Medical Tourism: Impact of Mexican medical services in border towns on uninsured rations on the US border towns in Texas.
- proximity to inexpensive Mexican healthcare can influence whether some residents purchase health insurance in the United States.
- How the relationship works:
1) U.S. health insurance can be expensive.
2) Border residents may have access to lower-cost healthcare and medications in nearby Mexican cities.
3) Some individuals may decide that paying directly for services in Mexico is less expensive than purchasing U.S. insurance.
4) This can contribute to high uninsured rates in certain Texas border communities.
- Mexican medical services provide a relatively inexpensive healthcare alternative for residents of Texas border towns. Because people can cross into Mexico for medical treatment and prescription medications, some may choose not to purchase expensive U.S. health insurance. The professor argued that this helps explain part of the unusually high uninsured rates in areas such as the Rio Grande Valley.
10f. Digital Nomads
- individuals who work remotely using digital technology while living or traveling in locations outside their employer's usual location. Your professor discussed Americans living in Mexico, particularly Mexico City, while continuing to work remotely for U.S. employers or clients. They may earn salaries in U.S. dollars while paying Mexican living expenses.
- Benefits to Mexico:
Spending on restaurants, transportation, housing, and other services.
Additional revenue for property owners and local businesses.
Increased demand for certain professional and consumer services.
- Negative consequences: gentrification occurs when wealthier residents or newcomers increase demand for property and services in an area, contributing to rising housing costs and potentially displacing existing residents.
Your professor discussed how digital nomads renting apartments in Mexico City can increase housing prices beyond what many local residents can afford.
- The Airbnb connection
He emphasized an arrangement involving Mexico City's government and Airbnb that encouraged longer stays. Instead of properties being rented only for short vacations, some became available for months at a time. This increased the appeal of Mexico City to remote workers but also contributed to competition for housing.
10g. Impact of migration on offspring
Migration can affect migrants' children through changes in family structure, educational opportunities, cultural identity, and economic mobility.
- Potential benefits:
Children may gain access to better schools and employment opportunities in the destination country.
Remittances may improve the living standards of children who remain in the originating country.
Children may develop bilingual and cross-cultural skills.
Subsequent generations may experience greater economic mobility.
- Potential difficulties:
Separation from parents can create emotional and social challenges.
Children may face language barriers and difficulties integrating into schools.
Differences in immigration status within families can create insecurity.
Children may experience cultural differences between their parents' country of origin and their country of residence.
10h. Mexico's policy to help students obtaining higher education abroad.
- the Mexican government has supported students pursuing advanced education abroad, especially master's degrees and PhDs.
The purpose is to develop highly skilled workers who can contribute to Mexico's economic development, scientific research, and professional workforce.
- How the policy works:
1) Mexico provides financial support to eligible students.
2) Students attend universities abroad, including institutions in the United States.
3) They gain advanced education, research experience, and specialized skills.
4) Ideally, they return to Mexico and contribute to its development.
- The problem: brain drain
Some students choose to remain abroad after completing their degrees.
This means Mexico may finance their education without receiving the full benefit of their new expertise.
Graphically explain what how transportation cost affects the quantity and price equilibrium of trade between Mexico and the US.
Transportation costs affect trade because they increase the total cost of moving goods between countries.
The central economic relationship is that higher transportation costs reduce the quantity of trade and increase the delivered price of imported goods, all else equal.
When transportation costs decrease, international trade generally becomes more attractive because the difference between the price received by exporters and the price paid by importers becomes smaller.
- How to explain the graph on the exam:
The vertical axis represents price, and the horizontal axis represents quantity.
Demand slopes downward, showing that consumers purchase less at higher prices.
Supply slopes upward.
When transportation costs increase, delivering goods becomes more expensive, shifting the supply curve upward or leftward.
The new equilibrium has a higher price and lower quantity.
- Reverse effect: If transportation costs decrease, the supply curve shifts downward or rightward, resulting in a lower delivered price and a higher equilibrium quantity.
- Connection to the U.S.-Mexico border: Delays, inspections, trucking restrictions, and other border-related costs make trade more expensive. Reducing these costs can increase cross-border commerce.
- Higher transportation costs increase the delivered cost of traded goods, shifting the supply curve upward or leftward. This raises the equilibrium price and reduces the quantity traded. Lower transportation costs shift supply downward or rightward, reducing prices and increasing trade. Border delays and trucking restrictions therefore act as barriers to U.S.-Mexico trade.
What is the Drayage system.
- a system of short-distance transportation used to move trailers and freight across the U.S.-Mexico border.
- Why is it inefficient?
It creates additional labor and handling costs.
It requires more time and coordination.
It can cause delays and congestion.
It raises transportation costs for businesses.
It makes cross-border supply chains less efficient.
- The drayage system is the practice of using separate trucks to transport trailers to the border, across the border, and onward into the destination country. Mexican trucks may deliver trailers to a border facility, drayage trucks carry them across, and American trucks continue the journey. This creates additional transportation costs, delays, and inefficiencies, reducing the potential benefits of free trade.
What is the US-Mexico Border Human Development Index what are the main findings.
- (BHDI) measures and compares human development in border regions of the two countries.
- The index combines three components: 1/3 of income index, 1/3 of education index and 1/3 of health index all added up
- Main findings: Human development improved over time, The United States generally had higher income and education indicators, Mexican border regions were generally better off than Mexico's national average, U.S. border counties often performed worse than the broader United States, Health outcomes improved, and some gaps narrowed, Education gaps persisted
- The U.S.-Mexico Border Human Development Index compares income, education, and health in the two countries' border regions. Its main findings are that human development improved between 1990 and 2015, but substantial differences remained. Mexican border regions generally performed better than Mexico's national average, while American border counties often performed worse than the U.S. national average. The United States continued to have higher income and education indicators, although health outcomes improved on both side
What is the IBC (International Boundary Commission) and the IBWC (International Boundary and Water Commission) relating to water sharing between US and Mexico
IBC: was created to address boundary issues between the United States and Mexico, particularly those involving the Rio Grande.
Rivers can change their courses over time through erosion, flooding, and sediment deposits, which can create disputes over the location of the international boundary.
IBWC: The IBWC developed from the earlier boundary commission and gained broader responsibilities involving international water agreements.
--> the original institution dealt primarily with boundary questions, but the importance of sharing river water required expanding its responsibilities.
- Important water-sharing agreement: The 1944 Water Treaty established major arrangements governing shared water resources from the Colorado River and Rio Grande.
- The International Boundary Commission was established in 1889 to manage boundary disputes between the United States and Mexico. It later developed into the International Boundary and Water Commission, which manages international water agreements, including water allocation from the Rio Grande and Colorado River, as well as flood control, sanitation, and boundary issues
What is the NADBank (North American Development Bank) and what is its purpose.
- a binational financial institution established in connection with NAFTA to support environmental infrastructure projects along the U.S.-Mexico border. The bank was created because environmental problems in border communities often affect both countries.
- Why was it needed?
Pollution does not stop at an international boundary.
The professor gave the example of El Paso, Texas, and Ciudad Juárez, Mexico.
Dust from unpaved roads in Ciudad Juárez can become airborne and cross into El Paso. Pollution particles attach to dust, worsening air quality.
Even if El Paso adopts strict pollution controls, it cannot completely solve a problem originating across the border without cooperation from Mexico.
- The North American Development Bank is a binational institution created in connection with NAFTA to finance environmental infrastructure along the U.S.-Mexico border. Its purpose is to help both countries address shared environmental problems, such as air pollution, inadequate water systems, and wastewater treatment, that cannot be solved effectively by one country acting alone.
What type of projects does NADBank fund.
- NADBank supports environmental infrastructure projects, particularly those benefiting border communities.
- Major project categories include:
1) Water supply: Improving access to reliable and safe drinking water.
2) Wastewater treatment: Constructing or upgrading sewage collection and treatment systems.
3) Solid waste management: Improving garbage collection, landfills, and waste disposal.
4) Air quality: Reducing pollution through transportation and other environmental improvements.
5) Stormwater and drainage: Reducing flooding and improving drainage infrastructure.
6) Clean energy and energy efficiency: Supporting projects that reduce environmental impacts.
- NADBank funds environmental infrastructure projects such as drinking water systems, wastewater treatment facilities, solid waste management, air quality improvements, drainage projects, and clean energy infrastructure. These projects are intended to improve environmental conditions and public health in communities along both sides of the U.S.-Mexico border.
What had been the change in the Mexican Drug trafficking into the US.
- The major change has been a shift in the types of drugs trafficked and the organization of drug production and distribution.
Historically, Mexican trafficking organizations were strongly associated with marijuana and the transportation of cocaine.
Over time, trafficking increasingly included heroin, methamphetamine, and synthetic opioids such as fentanyl.
- Important changes:
1) From plant-based to synthetic drugs: Synthetic substances can be produced in laboratories rather than requiring large agricultural growing areas.
2) Greater importance of fentanyl and methamphetamine: These drugs have become major concerns in cross-border trafficking.
3) Changing trafficking methods: Smaller quantities of highly potent drugs can have substantial market value, changing the economics of smuggling.
4) Greater public health consequences: Fentanyl is extremely potent, and its spread has contributed to serious overdose problems.
- Mexican drug trafficking into the United States has shifted from a greater emphasis on marijuana and cocaine toward methamphetamine and synthetic opioids, particularly fentanyl. These substances can be highly profitable and, in the case of fentanyl, extremely potent in small quantities. This has changed trafficking strategies and increased the public health consequences of cross-border drug smuggling
What has been the impact of the change in its political control in Mexico from centralization to decentralization on the drug cartels.
- Under centralized political control, powerful national and regional political authorities had considerable influence over law enforcement and government institutions.
As Mexico's political system became more competitive and decentralized, power became more dispersed among different political parties and levels of government.
- How this affected drug cartels:
1. Weaker centralized control: A centralized political system could exercise greater coordination over local officials and law enforcement. Decentralization made such control more fragmented.
2. Competition among criminal organizations:
As established political arrangements changed, cartels competed for territories, trafficking routes, and influence.
3. Increased fragmentation:
Some larger organizations split into smaller competing groups.
4. Greater violence in contested territories:
Competition over profitable routes and local control contributed to violent conflicts between criminal organizations.
5. Different relationships with local authorities:
Cartels increasingly had to negotiate, intimidate, or corrupt different local and regional authorities rather than operating under a more centralized political structure.
- Mexico's transition from centralized to more decentralized political control weakened some of the established arrangements through which criminal organizations operated. As political power became more fragmented, drug cartels competed for territories, trafficking routes, and influence over local authorities. This contributed to cartel fragmentation, territorial competition, and increased violence.
19. The militarization of the US-Mexico border has been somewhat continuous with slow at times and intense in others
- border militarization did not begin with recent presidents or modern immigration debates.
The U.S.-Mexico border has experienced periods of military involvement, armed conflict, increased law enforcement, and immigration restrictions since the nineteenth century.
The intensity has varied according to political tensions, labor demand, armed conflicts, drug trafficking, and national security concerns.
- a. The Cortina's war.
- b. Plan De San Diego.
- c. Pancho Villa's raid near Columbus, New Mexico.
- d. What was the purpose of the US Border Patrol at its inception and how can
you determine it was so.
- e. Under what agencies has the US Border Patrol (and its different names) be
place and what has that implied about its purpose
19a. The Cortina's war
- conflicts along the Texas-Mexico border involving Juan Nepomuceno Cortina and American and Texan authorities.
- Following the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, many Mexican residents of Texas experienced disputes involving land ownership, political rights, and treatment by Anglo-American settlers and officials.
Juan Cortina argued that Mexican residents were being mistreated through land dispossession, intimidation, racism, and violence.
-> the conflict began after Cortina shot Brownsville marshal Robert Shears in the arm. Cortina and his followers subsequently clashed with Texas Rangers and American forces.
--> The conflict illustrates how the border became militarized in response to disputes over land, sovereignty, racial discrimination, and political authority.
It also shows that military involvement along the border began long before modern debates about unauthorized immigration.
- The Cortina Wars were armed conflicts beginning in 1859 involving Juan Cortina and U.S. and Texas authorities near Brownsville. Cortina opposed the mistreatment of Mexican residents, including land dispossession, racism, and violence. The conflicts led to military and Texas Ranger involvement and demonstrate the early militarization of the U.S.-Mexico border following the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo.
19b. Plan De San Diego
- a revolutionary plan associated with unrest along the Texas-Mexico border. It called for an uprising against American authority in parts of the southwestern United States. The plan was associated with violence and attacks along the border during a period of political instability connected to the Mexican Revolution.
- Major consequences:
1) Armed raids and clashes occurred in the Lower Rio Grande Valley.
2) U.S. military personnel and Texas Rangers were deployed.
3) Thousands of residents fled or were evacuated.
4) Violence and retaliatory actions caused substantial loss of life.
--> The Plan de San Diego intensified border militarization and contributed to a period of violence involving Mexican residents, American authorities, and armed groups
- The Plan de San Diego was a 1915 revolutionary plan associated with armed resistance to American control in parts of the Southwest. It contributed to raids, violence, and military mobilization along the Texas-Mexico border. The United States deployed troops and Texas Rangers, and the resulting conflict intensified border militarization and caused significant civilian displacement and deaths.
19c. Pancho Villa's raid near Columbus, New Mexico.
- Mexican revolutionary leader Pancho Villa led approximately 500 fighters in an attack on Columbus, New Mexico, and nearby U.S. military positions.
- Villa's forces crossed into the United States and attacked the town and military installation --> American response:
President Woodrow Wilson authorized a military expedition into Mexico led by General John J. Pershing.
The expedition attempted to capture Villa but was unsuccessful.
- The raid demonstrates how revolutionary violence in Mexico could lead to direct U.S. military operations across the international border.
- Pancho Villa led approximately 500 fighters in an attack on Columbus, New Mexico, killing American soldiers and civilians. The United States responded by sending General John J. Pershing and troops into Mexico to capture Villa, but the expedition failed. The incident intensified military activity along the border and illustrates how the Mexican Revolution affected U.S.-Mexico relations.
19d. What was the purpose of the US Border Patrol at its inception and how can you determine it was so.
- its original priorities differed from the issues commonly associated with the agency today.
Original purpose:
The Border Patrol was initially concerned with preventing unauthorized entry, including the entry of Asian and European immigrants traveling through Mexico to circumvent U.S. immigration restrictions.
It was not originally organized exclusively around stopping Mexican laborers. The types of people immigration officials were concerned about, the laws being enforced, and the agency's original organizational placement help reveal its priorities.
- The U.S. Border Patrol was established in 1924 primarily to enforce immigration restrictions and prevent unauthorized entry, including Asian and European immigrants entering through Mexico. Its original priorities can be identified through the immigration laws in effect at the time, the groups targeted by enforcement, and the agency's early structure and responsibilities. Its mission later expanded considerably.
19e. Under what agencies has the US Border Patrol (and its different names) be place and what has that implied about its purpose.
- Department of Labor:
Immigration was strongly connected to labor supply, employment, and regulation of workers.
- Department of Justice:
Immigration enforcement became increasingly connected to legal enforcement, public safety, and national security.
- Department of Homeland Security: Border enforcement became more closely connected to terrorism prevention, national security, and border protection.
- the transfer to the Department of Justice in 1940, when concerns about the approaching war and national security became more prominent.
Following September 11, 2001, the creation of the Department of Homeland Security represented another major shift toward viewing border control as a national security responsibility.
- The Border Patrol was established under the Department of Labor in 1924, reflecting immigration's relationship to employment and labor markets. It moved to the Department of Justice in 1940, reflecting growing emphasis on law enforcement and national security. In 2003, it became part of Customs and Border Protection within the Department of Homeland Security, demonstrating the increasing importance of border security and terrorism prevention.
What was the Merida Plan
was a U.S.-Mexico security cooperation program launched during the administration of President George W. Bush and continued under President Barack Obama.
Its purpose was to help Mexico combat drug trafficking organizations and organized crime.
- The Mérida Initiative illustrates how the United States increasingly treated drug trafficking as a shared security problem requiring cooperation with Mexican law enforcement and security institutions.
- The Mérida Initiative was a U.S.-Mexico security cooperation program launched under President George W. Bush and continued under President Obama. It provided assistance, equipment, and training to help Mexico combat drug cartels and organized crime. Its broader purpose was to improve security cooperation and reduce cross-border drug trafficking
How have tariffs and the militarization of the US-Mexico border being related during the two terms of the Trump administration
- First Trump administration: Trump threatened tariffs on Mexican imports to pressure Mexico to reduce migration toward the United States; proposed tariff schedule began at 5%, with increases that could reach 25% if Mexico did not take sufficient action; Mexico agreed to increase immigration enforcement, including deploying its National Guard and cooperating with U.S. migration policies. --> Tariffs were used as economic leverage to obtain greater immigration and border enforcement from Mexico.
- Second Trump administration: renewed use of economic pressure and an expanded role for military forces in border enforcement; again connected trade measures with demands involving migration, border security, and drug trafficking. The Posse Comitatus Act is relevant because it generally restricts the use of federal armed forces to execute domestic laws unless authorized by law.
- During Trump's first administration, tariffs were used as leverage to pressure Mexico into increasing immigration enforcement. In 2019, Trump threatened tariffs starting at 5% and rising to 25%, leading Mexico to strengthen border enforcement and cooperate with U.S. migration policies. During his second administration, tariffs again became connected to migration and drug-trafficking concerns, alongside expanded military involvement at the border. Both periods demonstrate the use of trade policy to advance border-security objectives.
What is the Lone Star Operation
- a Texas border-security initiative launched in March 2021 by Governor Greg Abbott. It involves the Texas Department of Public Safety and the Texas National Guard.
- Main objectives:
1) Increase enforcement along the Texas-Mexico border.
2) Respond to unauthorized border crossings.
3) Combat human smuggling and drug trafficking.
4) Increase surveillance, patrols, and physical barriers.
- Operation Lone Star demonstrates the growing involvement of state governments in border enforcement, an area traditionally dominated by the federal government.
It has also generated disputes about the respective authority of Texas and the federal government over immigration enforcement and access to the border.
- Operation Lone Star is a Texas border-security initiative launched by Governor Greg Abbott in 2021. It uses the Texas National Guard, state police, surveillance, and physical barriers to address unauthorized migration, human smuggling, and drug trafficking. It represents an expansion of state-level border militarization and has led to disputes between Texas and the federal government over immigration enforcement authority.
How do islands along the Rio Grand impact border militarization
- Islands along the Rio Grande create complications for border enforcement because the river forms part of the international boundary between the United States and Mexico.
- Why islands matter:
1) They complicate border geography 2) They can complicate enforcement jurisdiction 3) They affect the placement of barriers and patrols 4) They can create diplomatic and legal disputes 5) They can create diplomatic and legal disputes
- Islands along the Rio Grande complicate border militarization because the river serves as an international boundary, and islands or changes in river channels can create jurisdictional questions. Their location affects where military personnel, border agents, and physical barriers can legally operate. Enforcement activities involving these areas can also create disputes between the United States and Mexico over sovereignty, water agreements, and border control.
Visa 1: TN Visa — USMCA Professional
- The TN visa allows eligible Canadian and Mexican citizens to work temporarily in the United States in qualifying professional occupations under the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), which replaced NAFTA.
Applicants must generally have a qualifying profession, appropriate credentials, and a qualifying professional job.
- What I find interesting: The TN visa demonstrates how a trade agreement can affect not only the movement of goods but also the movement of skilled workers. It is interesting that economic cooperation between countries can create specific employment opportunities for professionals.
Visa 2: O-1 Visa — Extraordinary Ability or Achievement
- The O-1 visa is for individuals who demonstrate extraordinary ability in fields such as science, education, business, athletics, or the arts, or extraordinary achievement in certain entertainment fields.
Applicants must provide evidence of their qualifications and meet the relevant immigration requirements.
- What I find interesting: The O-1 visa shows how the United States seeks to attract individuals with exceptional skills and achievements. It connects directly to brain drain because countries may lose highly talented professionals when those individuals move abroad for better opportunities.
- A useful connection to the course: The TN and O-1 visas both illustrate the movement of skilled labor, but they have different eligibility requirements. They also show how immigration policy can influence brain drain and the international distribution of human capital.
Documentary bonus: Day laborers during the Great Recession
Important concepts to prepare:
1) Low-wage and low-skilled workers can experience reduced employment opportunities early in an economic downturn.
2) Day laborers often depend on temporary jobs and have uncertain daily earnings.
3) Reduced spending on services such as landscaping, hospitality, and household maintenance can reduce demand for their labor.
4) The professor discussed a day-labor hiring system in Plano, Texas, that used identification cards and eventually randomized job selection rather than relying entirely on arrival order.
5) The documentary considered the experiences of Hispanic and Black day laborers during the recession.
- Possible bonus response: The documentary illustrates how the Great Recession affected workers who depended on temporary, low-wage employment. When households and businesses reduced spending, demand for day labor declined, making it more difficult for workers to find jobs and maintain stable income. The experiences of Mexican and Black laborers demonstrate how economic downturns can affect different groups competing for limited employment opportunities.
comparison of the four migration theories
- Neoclassical:
Main reason people migrate=Higher net wages abroad; Main decision-maker=Individual
- Harris-Todaro: Main reason people migrate=Higher expected income, accounting for employment probability; Main decision-maker= Individual
- Stark & Taylor: Main reason people migrate= Improve relative income and economic standing; Main decision-maker = Individual within a household/community context
- New Economics / Risk Diversification: Main reason people migrate = Reduce household income risk; Main decision-maker = Household
- Network theory: Main reason people migrate = Existing relationships reduce migration costs and risks; Main decision-maker = Individuals supported by migrant networks
- A useful way to remember the distinctions: Neoclassical asks "Where can I earn more?" Harris-Todaro asks "What can I expect to earn after accounting for the chance of getting a job?" Stark and Taylor ask "How does my family's income compare with others?" Risk diversification asks "How can our family avoid losing all its income?" Network theory asks "Who can help me migrate?"