1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
A01-Agentic state
A mental state where we feel no personal responsibility for our behaviour,
This frees us from the demand of our consciousness and allows us to obey even destructive authority figures
A01-Autonomous state
person is free to behave according to their own principles and feels a sense of responsibility for their actions. This is our ‘default’ state.
A01-Agentic shift
The shift from autonomy to agency. Milgram (1974) suggested that this occurs when someone perceives someone else as an authority figure, because they have a higher position in a social hierarchy.
A01-Agentic shift
The shift from autonomy to agency. Milgram (1974) suggested that this occurs when someone perceives someone else as an authority figure, because they have a higher position in a social hierarchy.
A01-Legitimacy of Authority
Authority is agreed by society we allow certain people to exercise some social power over us in order for society to run smoothly
A01-Destructive Authority
History has shown that charismatic and powerful leaderscan use their legitimate powers for destructive purposes, ordering people to behave in ways that are cruel and dangerous.
Destructive authority was obvious in Milgram’s study, when the experimenter used prods to order participants to behave in ways that went against their consciences.
A03-Research Support(legitimacy of authority)
Point: One strength of the legitimacy of authority explanation for obedience is that there is supporting real-world research evidence.
Evidence: For example, Tarnow (2000) studied a US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) review of 37 serious aircraft incidents between 1978 and 1990 where flight crew actions contributed to the crash. He found excessive dependence on the captain's authority and expertise in 19 out of the 37 accidents investigated, such as a second officer saying nothing during a risky approach because he assumed "the captain must know what he's doing."
Explanation: This supports the legitimacy of authority explanation because it demonstrates how a strict hierarchy of authority operates in real-life, high-stakes situations, leading subordinates to defer to authority figures even when they recognise danger.
Link: This therefore increases the external validity of the theory, showing it is a credible and useful explanation of obedience to authority in everyday life (and highlights the practical need for policies like whistle-blowing to prevent destructive obedience
A03-Cultural Variationt(legitimacy of authority)
Point:
One limitation of social-psychological explanations for obedience, such as the agentic state and legitimacy of authority, is that they do not account for cultural variations in obedience.
Evidence:
Research shows that obedience levels vary significantly between different countries. For example, Kilham and Mann (1974) replicated Milgram’s study in Australia and found that only 16% of female participants went all the way to 450 volts. In contrast, Mantell (1971) found a much higher obedience rate of 85% among German participants.
Explain:
This suggests that different cultures have different norms and expectations regarding how authority figures are viewed and respected, meaning social-psychological factors alone do not dictate obedience in the same way globally.
Link:
Therefore, this limits the usefulness of social-psychological explanations as they lack population validity and cannot be generalised universally to explain obedience across all cultures
A03-research support
Point: One strength of the agentic state explanation of obedience is that it is supported by empirical research evidence.
Evidence: In Milgram’s original obedience study, most participants resisted giving shocks at some point and asked the experimenter questions about the procedure, such as "who is responsible if Mr Wallace is harmed?" Once the experimenter assured them that he would take full responsibility, participants often proceeded quickly with no further objections.
Explanation: This supports the theory because it demonstrates that participants were experiencing moral strain while acting autonomously, and only alleviated this discomfort by shifting into an agentic state through binding factors once responsibility was transferred to the authority figure.
Link: This therefore means that the agentic state is a credible explanation of obedience, as there is clear evidence from Milgram's observations to suggest its mechanisms are accurate (though critics note the laboratory setting may limit its ecological validity).
A03-Obedience Alibi
• Point: One limitation of the agentic state explanation of obedience is that it provides an "obedience alibi," suggesting that people may commit destructive acts for reasons other than simply following orders.
• Evidence: For example, David Mandel (1998) described an incident during the Second World War involving German Reserve Police Battalion 101. These men shot many civilians in a small town in Poland despite not having direct orders to do so—in fact, they were explicitly told they could be assigned to other duties if they preferred.
• Explain: This challenges Milgram's agentic state theory because the soldiers were clearly operating in an autonomous state rather than an agentic state, yet they still chose to execute others. Instead of blind obedience, their behaviour may be better explained by social identity theory, as they strongly identified with their group and role as soldiers.
• Link: Therefore, the agentic state is limited as a complete explanation of real-world atrocities like those in Nazi Germany, as it downplays personal responsibility and fails to account for harmful behaviour that occurs without direct authority pressure.