1/77
Flashcards to comprehensively study for LPS 3101 - Political Analysis
Power
It is a central concept in Political Science
Terence Ball, 1992
Power is arguably the single most important organizing concept in social and political theory’
Political Analysis
Defined as the analysis of the nature, exercise and distribution of power (Dahl 1963; Duverger 1964/66; Lasswell 1936/50; M. Weber 1919/46; and, for a more recent view, Goodin and Klingemann 1996)
True, it is highly contested
True or False
The field of political analysis is, by the very political nature of its subject matter, profoundly contested, then within that field the concept of power is more profoundly contested than most.
Power Relations
What is often neglected in Political Analysis
Political Domain
_____ cannot and should not be held coextensive with that of power itself.
Tendency
Delineated definition of the political as the arena of government as distinct from the practice or exercise of power
Influence
This refers to the outcome of an attempt to change someone’s behavior or attitude
Power
This refers to the means by which the influence is accomplished (A capacity that A has to influence the behavior of B , so that B acts in accordance with A ’s wishes).
Politics
The pursuit of self- interest in an organization to protect or further either individual or organizational goals.
Position Power
Legitimate, Reward, Coercive
Legitimate
Position Power
Power derived from a person’s position of authority in an organization
Reward
Position Power
Power derived form the ability to provide positive outcomes
Coercive
Position Power
Power derived from the ability to administer punishments
Individual Power
Information, Expert, Referent
Information
Individual Power
Power derived access to information that is important to others in the organization
Expert
Individual Power
Power derived from an individual’s superior skills or abilities in an area values by the organization
Referent
Individual Power
Power derived from the extent to which an individual is well liked and admired by others.
Rational Persuasion, Emotional Appeals, Exchange, Norms
Influence Tactics in the Exercise of Power
Formal Power, Personal Power
Bases of Power
Coercive, Reward, Legitimate, Information
4 Kinds of Formal Power
Expert, Referent, Charismatic
3 Kinds of Personal Power
Power Tactics
Ways in which individuals translate power bases into specific actions:
1. Legitimacy
2. Rational persuasion
3. Inspirational appeals
4. Consultation
5. Exchange
6. Personal appeals
7. Ingratiation
8. Pressure
9. Coalitions
Political Tactics
● Controlling access to information
● Building a favorable impression
● Building a support base — Politics as the art of clout or gathering debts owed
● Blaming and attacking others
● Networking
Dependency
The key to power
"The greater B’s ______ on A, the greater the power A has over B"
Importance, scarcity, non-substituability
What creates dependency?
Coalitions, Alliance
What are the two Power in Groups?
Coalition
An informal group bound together by the active pursuit of a single issue
They seek to maximize their size = “strength” in numbers
Alliance
A formal agreement between two or more states for mutual support in case of war
Formed between two or more countries to counter a common adversary, i.e. strong states enter into this arrangement to counter other strong states i.e., they enter into this to maintain balance of power.
Scarce Resources, Conflicting Interests, Ambiguity
Political Action Occurs
Gain or Greed, Role Conflict, Competition, Organizational Culture
Causes of Unethical Choices
Positive Power (Induction)
Power as an ability to initiate activity
Negative Power (Resistance)
Power as an ability to stop some activity
Socrates
true power comes with the control and order of one's body and soul — the discipline to act justly,
Live virtuously, and not need anything.
Plato
He also argues that in a system in which everyone has a right to rule all sorts of selfish people who care nothing for the people but are only motivated by their own personal desires are able to attain power. He concludes that democracy risks bringing dictators, tyrants, and demagogues to power.
Aristotle
○ Power as a source for change and rest
○ Powers order the physical world insofar as it is a world of changing things subject to causation
Democracy, One-Man Tyranny, Aristocracy
What is the Never-ending cycle of Democracy?
Max Weber
that state power consisted in a ‘monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force’.
Thomas Hobbes
at its best and purest power would be exercised from the singular position of sovereignty. He ‘called it ‘The Leviathan’.
Robert Dahl
Defined power as: “A has power over B to the extent that he can get B to do something that B would not otherwise do.”
Steven Lukes
Provided a more satisfactory interpretation by constructing a "three- dimensional" account of power.
Decision-making Power (Issue), Non-decision making (Agenda Setting) , Ideological Power (Manipulation)
What are the three dimensions of power?
Issue (Decision-making Power)
'relation among people'
It is the ability of one person to achieve compliance by others who change how they behave as a result of the power being exerted. It can be seen in systems of ruling elites, where few people have significant power. As such, power is direct, with identification of an issue and a singular response to this.
In governmental power, this can be seen when the government makes a decision, typically through law- making, that requires obedience by the broader population.
Non-Decision Making Power (Agenda Setting)
decision is made within a complex system.
In this situation, power is not just about making decisions, but also about setting the agenda that leads to decisions. In other words, if you can control the context within which decisions are made, then you can influence those decisions.
In governmental power, this can be seen in decisions made 'behind closed doors' andin the 'corridors of power', where who is deciding and why is seldom clear.
This can be seen as a 'secretive face', where it is not clear who is making the decision.
Manipulation (Preference-Shaping)
This can be seen as similar to the Marxist view of ideological power, where the ability to control what people think of as being 'right' can lead to acceptance of biased decisions without question.
In governmental power, this appears in propaganda, spin and crafting of speeches that are deliberately designed to change minds before the decision is announced.
This can be seen as a 'deceptive face', where trickery and psychological methods are the primary tool in shifting values and changing what people consider to be important.
Jurgen Habermas on Power
Communicative Concepts of Power
Communication through language necessarily involves the raising of ‘validity- claims’ (distinguished as ‘truth’, ‘rightness’ and ‘sincerity’), the status of which, when contested, can ultimately only be resolved through discussion. Habermas further contends that speakers of a language possess an implicit knowledge of the conditions under which such discussion would produce an objectively correct result, and these he has spelled out in terms of the features of an egalitarian ‘ideal speech situation’.
Communicative Rationality
refers to the capacity to engage in argumentation under conditions approximating to this ideal situation (‘discourse’, in Habermas’ terminology), with the aim of achieving consensus.
Communicative Concepts of Power
relies on the concept of communicative rationality to argue that democratic forms of social organization express more than simply the preferences of a particular cultural and political tradition.
Michel Focault
Power is everywhere
Influential in shaping understandings of power, leading away from the analysis of actors who use power as an instrument of coercion, and even away from the discreet structures in which those actors operate, toward the idea that ‘power is everywhere’, diffused and embodied in discourse, knowledge and ‘regimes of truth’
Meta Power, Regimes of Truth
For Michel Focault, power is a kind of "___” or “___” that pervades society and which is in constant flux and negotiation
Focault-Habermas Debate
a dispute concerning whether Michel Foucault's ideas of "power analytics" and "genealogy" or Jurgen Habermas' ideas of "communicative rationality" and "discourse ethics" provide a better critique of the nature of power in society.
One-Face of Power
Power was transparent, expressed in an unambiguous and empirically demonstrable way in the decision- making process
Conflict
How to operationalize the concept of power
Decision Making, Agenda Setting, Preference Shaping
Faces of Power
Decision Making
● A has power over B to the extent that she can ‘get B to do something that B would not otherwise do’ (1957: 201) and, crucially, where there is an overt conflict of interests (here assumed synonymous with preferences) between the actors involved.
● Thus, by virtue of A’s power, B not only modifies her behavior, but does so in full knowledge that her modified behavior is contrary to her own genuine interests.
Decision Making Power
Conceptualizations:
1. Power is understood in terms of its effects – if Anna’s actions have no effect on Ben, there is no power relation
2. Power is an attribute of individuals, exercised in their relations with other individuals – it is behavioral
3. Power is associated with domination or power over – it is not so much a capacity to affect outcomes, but to dominate others in so doing
4. Consequently, power is unproductive or zero- sum – some gain only to the extent that others lose out. If Anna has power, Ben does not; the extent of Anna’s power is the extent of Ben’s lack of power
Agenda Setting
Power, they argued, is Janus- faced, its complex nature merely obscured by a narrow concentration on the decision- making process. For power is also exercised in what they, rather cryptically termed, ‘non- decision making’.
● Power is exerted in setting the agenda for the decision- making process.
Agenda Setting
Conceptualizations
1. The need to consider the largely informal process of agenda- setting within the corridors of power before examining the formal decision- making process itself
2. The need to weight issues in the decision- making process in terms of their ‘importance’ in assessing the real distribution of power.
Preference Shaping
To restrict the use of the term ‘power’ to situations in which actual and observable conflict is present, he argues, is arbitrary, unrealistic and myopic.
Preference Shaping
Conceptualizations
○ A framework capable of recognizing:
1. the strategies, struggles and practices that characterize the decision- making process;
2. the actions and inactions involved in shaping the agenda for the decision- making process; and
3. the actions and inactions similarly implicated in the shaping of perceived interests and political preferences.
Negative Conception of Power
Power over as opposed to power of
○ The essence of power is negative, the purpose of critique to expose power relations as a potential means to their elimination.
○ Lukes: analysis of power on the distinction between real and perceived interests, i.e. the notion of power as a subversion of real interests
True
True or False
To Identify a power relationship is to engage in critique
Utopianism
To engage in critique is not to apply a scientific principle or analytical technique but to compare real practices to an idealized alternative – in Lukes’ case, a world free from power relations. This requires (normative or value) judgements about the legitimacy of conduct which cannot be grounded in claims to neutrality or objectivity.
Microphysics of Power
“In human relations . . . power is always present . . . these relationships of power are changeable relations, i.e., they can modify themselves, they are not given once and for all . . . The thought that there could be a state of communication which would be such that the games of truth could circulate freely, without obstacles, without constraint and without coercive effects, seems to me to be utopian. It is being blind to the fact that relations of power are not something bad in themselves, from which one must free one’s self. I don’t believe there can be a society without relations of power.”