1/78
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Artificial Intelligence (AI)
The capability of a machine or computer to imitate human behavior. Also known as machine learning
Coding
Refers to the process of reviewing documents and summarizing key elements in a structured format.
Data Preservation Plan
A detailed plan made by the legal team outlining the course of action for how preservation of documents and other pieces of digital evidence relevant to the case will be preserved from destruction.
Electronic Discovery or eDiscovery
The process of identifying and delivering electronic information that can be used as evidence in legal cases.
Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM)
A community of eDiscovery and legal professionals who develop practical resources to improve eDiscovery and information governance processes.
Electronically Stored Information (ESI)
Information created, manipulated, communicated, stored, and best utilized in digital form, requiring use of computer hardware and software.
Information Goverance
A systematic business process for managing information: classifying, storing, and deleting electronic and paper-based information so that it is retained only while it has significant business value and can be deleted before it becomes an operational or legal liability.
Legal Hold
A communication requesting the preservation and the resulting preservation of information that is potentially relevant to current or a reasonably anticipated legal matter.
Review Stage
The document review phase of the EDRM is where the lawyers are able to view, tag, manage, download, and notate every document and other pieces of digital evidence related to the case.
Sampling
The process of testing a search query by searching a limited number of records against to total volume to determine an accurate search response.
Spoliation
The destruction or alteration of data that might be relevant to a legal matter.
Technology Assisted Review (TAR)
An approach within the document review phase of eDiscovery that leverages computer algorithms to identify and tag potentially responsive documents based on keywords and other metadata.
edrm
lays basic format to find and implement digital evidence into client’s defense
what is e-discoery
process of identifying/delivering electronic info
used as evidence in cases
obtained through electronic means of finding evidennce
e-discoery term
used to clarify legality of obtaining + using electronic docs in state + fed court
lawyers are obligated to obtain records + evidence that follows code
carry out respectfully
used in litigation + other processes that required evidence
usage of eDiscovery
range of info can be discoverd + used in case
document authentication + fact checking are necessary to make sure info = genuine + admissible
testimonies and recorded interrogations
most used forms of evidence in court
straight from witness’s mouth
esi
evidence found through ediscovery
primary method of discoveringn evidence + presenting case
the umbrella of esi
various forms of digital evidence fall under this
emails,
social media records,
cell phone data,
digital audio,
video recordings,
global databases,
apps,
global positioning data,
data stored in household appliance,
onboard computers in car,
any digital records
why use edisc
no eDiscovery = missing out on evidence that help case
challenges w/ edisc
cost of initial use + confusion w/ introduction
people must learn how to navigate from using physical to digital
learning curve for new users
edisc benefits
cost effective + simpler than antiquated methods of discovery
can be difficult to know what info needs to be brought in, sifted through, determined
more comfort; process = effective
treasure trove of digital info; help understand proccess w/ efficiency
exponential digital growth
esi changed the world
306.4 billion —→ 361 billion emails are seent; 500 million tweets made
44 zettabytes were stored in cloud; companies were digitized because of COVID
increase in cybercrime + ransomeware attacks
cyber + ransom attaks
REvil stole terabyte of data from NYC law firm
demanded $21 million for return of dta
released 2 gigs of contracts + other docs relating to celebrity client
stole emails related to Trump, doubled ransom to $41 million
How can you keep data secure?
what is EDRM
Electronic Disc Reference Model
outlines + explains various stages of eDic process
help lawyers practice what eDisc looks like in investgiation
hwo to collect + use ESI
George Socha + Tom Gelbmann
created in 2005
wanted to create method lawyers could follow
make process digestible, understood, followed by anyone
become second nature
reference for dicussion + analysis
EDRM is not strict
up to you and specific case how to use
complete steps of model in various order
iterative process
repeat stpes, go back, skip forward, customize model to fit case
various approaches to eDisc
9 stages of (grief) EDRM

EDRM MODEL
represents conceptual view of eDisc
may engage in some, not all steps
may elect to carry out steps in different order
steps of EDRM
Information Governance
Identification
Preservation
Collection
Processing
Review
Analysis
Production
Presentation
Step 1. Info Gov.
getting everything in order
safely approve storing client’s digital records + info + supporting evidence
help minimize risks you encounter; keeps you covered + expenses related to eDisc
gives protection over entire process from intitial creation of ESI —> final deposition
Info Governance is VITAL
managing info is done through understanding legal + security + rim risks, privacy
knowing potential for profit + efficiency of info tech in case
info management should be used throughout process;
come back as new data is added to case + new risks pop up
no info gov = problems
step 2. Identification
locate ESI + potential sources
determine scope, breadth, and depth of case + docs to obtain
case reviews, interview w/ people, docs, etc.
started w/ identification strategy
identification strategy
identify key quantitatiive data + key people who build case
build a team
build team that executes identification plan
compromised of
info tech specialists,
in-house legal counsel,
outside counsel,
records management personnel,
human resources personnel,
service providers,
etc.
identify relevant ESI sources
verify they are defensible and usable
what you need for caase
not collecting sources yet; seeing what is out there + how much we will need to discover + pull
determine scope + breadth of ESI sources
Preservation
litigation is initiated/reasonably anticipated
spoliation expanded
intentional destruction/inadvertent loss of evvidence
can occur if preservation is not executed properly
data preservation plan = made; legal hold notice is sent to ESI custoidians
legal hold notcie
informs relevant custodians to preserve ESI + cease destruction of docs
take place during normal course of business
important to procedures + programs to protect material
how preservtion ahppens
through docs collected + removed their current location/preserved and stored in place
allows data to be frozen + preserved; moment legal hold goes into effect
mitigate risks by ptection + isolation
process of preservation
involves developing strategy,
suspending destruction of files and evidence through legal holds,
preparing preservation plan,
selecting preservation method,
executing it
step 4. collection
gathering ESI
collect in authentic manner; recognized by court
develop collection strategy, prepare collection, selecting collection method, executing collection plan
follow step of collecting evidence
esi = legally defensible
efficient, auditable, proportionate, and targeted
make sure actions = clear, documentd, transparent
step 5. processing
narrows down what you want to include in case
reduce amount of ESI at this stage
convert anyy if necessary
ESI aligns + ready for later stpes of review + analysis
clean up files
delete irrelevant data
convert any incompatible files
gather evidence into single software platform
narrow ESI needed
eDisc + processing
use eDisc software platforms for this step
assess data + plan
prepare data + select + normalize data
validate output + handle exceptions
cumulate w/ exporting file of ESI; processed for production to opposing counsel/presentation
step 6. review
costliest stage; take the longest
go back over curated data + reviewing how piece relates to case
evaluate ESI in terms of relevance + privilege
review expanded
organize evidence into subgroups
develop review strategy, set up review training
perform data analysis + conduct
CONDUCT REVIEW + EVALUATE PLAN + WRAP UP STAGE
go about it smart and productive
step 7. analysis
evaluate ESI in terms of content + context
identify patterns in data, topic, perople, discussion found
consists of content analysis + process analysis
content analysis
look at ESI approved as fact
enhanced thorugh search + futher review
analyze whether ESI is at level
if not, go back to previous step; see what you may have omitted
check process is serving you
comfortable with position of process?
go back and take cre of intial stages
fix blunders, make final changes
step 8. production
consists of preparation for presentation
make sure everything is READY
production stage
esi = appropriate formats + through correct delivery mechanisms
asking yourself question of how you will present digital info you have gathered = authentic + defensible
confirm forms of production
data analysis
familiarize w/ each type; produce evidence accordingly
native data files are in native format
ESI is native; include load files, extractd metadata, searchable text
near-native files
same as native ones
extracted/converted into different format
done to make file more searchable
near-paper/image files
converted into images
PDF/TIF files
ESI can be in paper format
step of analyzing data piece goes into subgroup is important
data analysis = identifying production requirements for case
what form of file will be utilized for case?
prepare files; copy files to media
step 9. presentation
broken down into form of model; important for success of case
made up of various parts; make or break case
knowing display is important to keep in mind at depositions, hearings, trials, etc.
native + near-native
= best way to go to elicit further info,
validate existing facts,
persuade jury
ditigal presentations
show off client better + enhance case by keeping jury engage
show off ESI evidence, develop strong presentation strategy
select exhibits that will represent case
prepare exhibits, test them out
follow trial run, present sexhibits, move to storing
continue to keep daabse of cases after finish
Tech Assisted Review
take up unnecessary time and money
73% of costs involved in eDisc process from review stage alone
help gt through review stage w/ more ease
TAR benefits
reduces cost and time that is eaten up by review process
done by using AI to analyze data sets
identify ata sets
tag docs
safe from human error
social media searcher
documented thorugh what we post
relevant to growing number of lawsuits
challenges legal indsutrcy how to collect and review volumes of data we generate
started building software to address ever-increasing issue
transunion
offers search and report functionality for access to publicly facing social media to support + enhance investigations, research, due diligence
helps gather info from broad variety of social media sites
assess risk + gather info about clients, opposing party, witnesses
anything in social media that would make potential employer change his or her opinion of you?
benefits of TAR
enhance human effort; how well work is done + efficiently is is created
finds relevant docs you need and tags for you
great way to ensure docs are found in one review v. multiple
Anne Kershaw in 2005
looked at TAR system
identified 95% of relevant docs
great accomplishment, stacked up to group of humans
found 51% relevant docs available
programmed by humans; oeprates more efficiently through review stage
tar and sanctions and fines
avoid them
they’re bad for business + reputation
sanctions/fines are given when legal team fails to prouct electronic data in timely/appropriate manner
completed in timely and accurate manner
TAR increase access to courts
did not have time or money beforehand
allowed justice system to operate effectively
helped courts keep up w/ how they’re expected to function as system
early case resolution = frequent when review process is sped up
last benefit will include ability for TAR system to update
cons of TAR
faces inability to analyze + locate files not text based
can find PDFs/word docs
fall short w/ images, spreadsheets, other dos not rich in text
software is built to identify words alone
pagefreezer
works in conjunction w/ TAR
overcome precious limitations
best way to have TAR system work is by human review involved
AI programs bridge gaps tho
steps for TAR process
set goals
set protocol
educate reiewer
code documents
predict results
test results
evaluate results
achieve goals
set goals
set goals for TAR process
what you want from process + how to improve working day
goals to consider can help priortize docs first; reduce + discard nonrelevant docs
act to double-check quality
human empllyees can make evidence found is quality; AI can do thiis beforce humans can
set protocol
have human coding rules + same regultaions you had when AI was not involved
same protocals can combine w/ introduction of TAR
set up coding using metho that makes sense
happen early in TAR training; test out coding patterns + categories best w/ currect case issue
educate reviewer
take place alongside person heading the review stage
happen in conjunction
reviewer must be fully informed of how new TAR process will function
code docs
help TAR system understand what to look for
example docs that fit crtain category
will recognize docs that are alike and add them to review collection/remove them
predict results
take over and begin to collect/label docs basd on coding
knows what you want it to look out fot
test results
room for error
avoid error, test results
reviwerer look over results while using validation process
good way to validate accuracy is by using statistical sampling
evaluate results
know results are accurate to what you programmed
TAR performed as expected
go back to goals set; see if achieved
achieve goals
goals set at beginning were not achieved; go back and correct review process
goals of review process achieved; move on w/ rest of EDRM eDisc process