Prediction in Differential Psychology

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/18

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

19 Terms

1
New cards

What can be used for predictions?

Individual differences

2
New cards

What are some drawbacks of psychology being focused on objective, clean explanations?

  • Experiments in contrived settings

  • Models of the mind that strive for parsimony (few significant associations + variations)

  • Relevance for real-world goals not a huge priority


3
New cards

What is the alternative to making clear explanations?

Use individual differences as a predictive science (behaviour + outcomes)

  • Goal is for generalisable, out-of-sample prediction that aren’t based on particular samples or contrived experimental designs

  • Collect data from rep sample then collect outcome data


4
New cards

What can individual differences be used to predict?

  • Educational achievement + attainment

  • Job performance

  • Attained social class + socioeconomic status

  • Income + financial resources

  • Health + longevity


Snares: unemployment, divorce, out-of-wetlock birth, incarceration, public benefit receipt, school dropout


5
New cards

What is the typically effect size for predictive individual differences (personality coefficient)?

~0.2 - 0.3

6
New cards

Why is intelligence predictive?

  • Jobs are increasingly intellectually complex (automate simpler ones)

  • Society rewards educational achievement starting from young childhood

    • Both financially + socially

    • At least in higher-SES groups

    • Financial resources buy healthy lifestyles + cultural access (piano lessons, test preps etc)

  • Parents pass both genes + educational culture to children

  • Reinforced by SES-related access to health + cultural knowledge + social support


7
New cards

Why is personality predictive?

  • Individual differences as a science of any numbers → many predictors with small effects that aggregate up

  • We can use multiple variables from any level of trait nierarchy

    • Broad traits → broad outcomes

    • Narrow traits → narrow outcomes

  • Measure many psych variables → summarise a lot of psych stuff


8
New cards

What are some challenges within prediction?

  • Vulnerability to responder distortions (e.g. social desirability) → over-claimers of personality = over claim outcomes

  • Intelligence tests’ cultural loadings → may bias effects, especially for group differences

  • Omissions from the Big 5 (e.g. religiosity, libido) that predict important outcomes

  • Difficult to make simple, causal inferences

    • Reciprocal influences

    • Reverse causation

    • Education gene-environment correlations

  • Statistical confounding (e.g. IQ + socioeconomic status → education)

  • Multipotentiality + equifinality


9
New cards

When are personality and intelligence predictions used?

  • Psychometric testing → one of our greatest contributions outside of psych

    • Originated in selecting soldiers for WW1 + 2

  • Wide variety contexts

    • Workplace → who should we hire for this job?

    • Courts → is this person a danger to society?

    • Hospitals → what should we target for treatment?


10
New cards

What are personality disorders?

Problems in functioning of the self and/or interpersonal dysfunction that

  • Persist over an extended period of time

  • Manifest in patterns of cognition, emotions, behaviour

  • Aren’t developmentally appropriate or due to social/cultural factors

  • Are associated with substantial distress or significant impairment in personal, family, social, education or occupational areas of functioning

  • Not attributable to physio effects of a substance/medical condition


11
New cards

Describe the early history of personality disorders

  • Kraepelin → viewed them as natural disease entities

    • Same as simple-cause somatic diseases (e.g. infectious disease, stroke)

    • Each disease has its own unique etiology

  • Normal vs abnormal are qualitative distinct, flip from 1 state to another

    • Consistent with pharmacological treatment psych disorders

    • Fix the cause + symptoms will go

  • Sprawling taxonomy of diseases (dom model in 20th century)


12
New cards

What is a common classification system of personality disorders?

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders

  • Controlled + promoted by the American Psychiatric Association

  • 5th iteration (current)


Alt: International Classification of Disease


13
New cards

What are some weaknesses of common classification systems of personality disorders?

  • Clinical authority with negotiating, politics + vested interested

  • Overdiagnosis vs underdiagnosis

  • Cultural bias (e.g. homosexuality in early DSMs)

  • Categorical disorders BUT with overlapping phenytupes


14
New cards

What are some limitations of the categorical (discrete) approach to diagnoses?

  • Have extensive list of inclusion criteria (symptoms)

    • Polythetic (same diagnosis, different symptoms)

    • Many share endophenotypes (different diagnosis, same symptoms)

  • Very low inter-rater agreement common among mental health conditions

  • Co-morbidity means identifying distinct predictors + outcomes is hard

  • Arbitrary cut-offers (~15% of the population on Psychopathy Checklist)


15
New cards

How are symptoms of pathology continuous?

  • People vary in quantity + probability

  • Distribution may be normal or skewed

  • Clinical cases are at either ends (e.g. contentiousness) or at one end (e.g. suicide attempts)


<ul><li><p>People vary in quantity + probability</p></li><li><p>Distribution may be normal or skewed</p></li><li><p>Clinical cases are at either ends (e.g. contentiousness) or at one end (e.g. suicide attempts)</p></li></ul><p></p>
16
New cards

What is the alternative model for personality disorders?

Model of pathological personality traits that maps onto the Big 5

  • Criterion A: level of personality function (e.g. direction, identity)

  • Criterion B: elevated levels of pathological personality traits


High levels of both = diagnosis of eprsonality disorder


<p>Model of pathological personality traits that maps onto the Big 5</p><ul><li><p>Criterion A: level of personality function (e.g. direction, identity)</p></li><li><p>Criterion B: elevated levels of pathological personality traits</p></li></ul><p></p><p>High levels of both = diagnosis of eprsonality disorder</p><p></p>
17
New cards

How is the alternative model for personality disorders similar to the Big 5?

  • Themes overlap across the 2 models BUT specific content differs

  • Hard for normal trait measures to also provide adequate coverage of extreme end of the distribution

  • Pathological measure need to be more sensitive at those extreme ends (e.g. when does preference to be alone become withdrawal?)


18
New cards

What is the hierarchal taxonomy of pscyhopathology?

  • Developed by a research consortium, first major paper in 2017

  • Attempt to systematise all of psychopathology as a hierarchy of ABCD patterns

  • Framework descends from very general dysfunction to specific disorders + symptoms

  • Attempt to fix the existing approach of pages of isolated symptoms + diagnoses


<ul><li><p>Developed by a research consortium, first major paper in 2017</p></li><li><p>Attempt to systematise all of psychopathology as a hierarchy of ABCD patterns</p></li><li><p>Framework descends from very general dysfunction to specific disorders + symptoms</p></li><li><p>Attempt to fix the existing approach of pages of isolated symptoms + diagnoses</p></li></ul><p></p>
19
New cards

What is the dark triad (non-clinical model)?

  • Cluster of socially malevolent personality constructs

    • Psychopathy → recklessness, poor impulse control

    • Narcissism → grandiose attention-seeking, gregariousness, vulnerability + shame

    • Machiavellianism → self-control, strategic planning, cynicism

  • United by a common core of antagonism (callous, manipulative + exploitative style that causes harm to others)

  • Related constructs in ‘dark tent’: sadism, entitlement, greed, dependency, perfectionism

  • BUT extreme traits can be adaptive, given a suitable niche

    • Assumption of evolutionary psychology (wouldn’t exist in the population if they weren’t at some point adaptive)

  • BUT personality pathology has to to equal extreme traits + impaired functioning