1/41
Looks like no tags are added yet.
economic growth & the local ecosystem
Significant societal and ecological costs undermine long-term sustainability
Accelerated resource consumption and widespread environmental pollution
International Transport Forum
Reported that CO2 emissions from transport are projected to increase 16 percent by 2050
These rising greenhouse gas emissions directly contribute to global pollution, climate change, and ocean acidification, which significantly impact biodiversity
A primary result of globalization
Finished products travel farther now than ever before replacing models where products were produced, sold, and consumed locally
increased transport of goods significantly impacting the environment
Land-based transportation habitat destruction
Requires extensive infrastructure like roads and bridges
development of such infrastructure leads to several issues including habitat loss, ecosystem fragmentation, and localized pollution
Massachusetts v. EPA (2007)
States and environmental groups sued the EPA to force regulation of greenhouse gases (CO2) from new motor vehicles under the Clean Air Act
Massachusetts argued that the EPA was required by the Clean Air Act to regulate “any air pollutant” which could “endanger public health or welfare.”
EPA claimed the Clean Air Act didn’t cover climate change and fuel economy was the only reasonable answer which was under the Department of Transportation
Additionally, the EPA questioned the standing of Massachusetts, questioning what they had to lose
Massachusetts v. EPA (2007) Outcome
5-4 decision, court decided:
Greenhouse gases fit the “capacious definition” of air pollutants under the Clean Air Act
Massachusetts had standing due to actual concrete harms like rising sea levels losing coastal land
EPA’s rationale for not regulating was not adequate and required the agency to develop a reasonable basis to decide whether an air pollutant “causes, or contributes to, air pollution may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare”
The Endangerment Finding (2009)
Following the Massachusetts v. EPA decision, the EPA determined that six greenhouse gases endangered public health and welfare
Carbon dioxide CO2
Methane (CH4)
Hydrofluorocarbons
Nitrous oxide (N2O)
Perfluorocarbons
Sulfur hexafluoride
This finding gave the EPA the basis to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from cars, trucks, and power plants
Repealing the Endangerment Finding
EPA’s repeal of the 2009 finding
Repealing it removes the scientific and legal basis used to require federal greenhouse gas regulation under this framework
Scientific evidence of greenhouse gas harm remains and that lawsuits are pending
D. Maritime freight and invasive species
International shipping can unintentionally transport invasive species
Ballast water
Water stored in ships to stabilize them during transportation
Ships take in water in one location and discharge it somewhere else
Organisms, larvae, microorganisms, and plant spores can travel in the water
These organisms can enter new ecosystems and become invasive species
They may reproduce rapidly without their normal predators or other natural population controls
Environmental DNA (eDNA)
Genetic material organisms shed into their environment, including water, soil, and air
Scientists can identify species without physically seeing or capturing them
Port authorities use eDNA testing to detect potentially invasive organisms
*remember, ballast water transports organisms; eDNA helps detect them
Economic specialization and environmental damage
Globalization allows countries to specialize in industries where they have economic advantages
benefits of globalization
greater productivity
increased efficiency
access to international markets
environmental disadvantages of globalization
Overspecialization can lead to deforestation and habitat loss
Dependence on cash crops can damage tropical ecosystems
Countries depend on oil, natural gas, and timber may resist transitioning to renewable energy because their economies depend on those industries
Global biodiversity loss
Environmental problems work together to reduce biodiversity
greenhouse gas emissions
ocean acidification
deforestation
climate change
invasive species
Latin America and Africa have experienced disproportionate biodiversity losses
Brazilian beef production and deforestation
International beef demand contributes to expansion of cattle ranching
Pasture expansion is a major driver of Amazon deforestation
Cattle production responsible for ~80% of the clearing discussed
Indirect suppliers make it difficult to trace cattle back to their original properties
Deforestation also threatens Indigenous communities and small farmers
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
Businesses voluntarily take steps to reduce their environmental and social impacts
switching to renewable energy
reducing energy consumption
sustainable packaging
shortening transportation chains
responsible land-use practice
limitation: companies may prioritize immediate profits over expensive environmental improvements
Fair trade
Connects small farmers with international buyers
Provides fair minimum prices to help cover sustainable production costs
Provides Fairtrade Premiums that producers can use for community infrastructure, education, healthcare, and farm improvements
Limitations of Fair Trade
Certification fees can be expensive for the poorest farmers
Retail markups may benefit intermediaries more than producers
Research findings on its overall impact are mixed
Mandatory environmental regulations
Know the difference between voluntary and mandatory approaches
Voluntary | Mandatory |
|---|---|
Companies choose to participate. | Companies must follow legal requirements. |
CSR commitments | Government reporting laws |
Sustainable packaging promises | Mandatory emissions disclosures |
Voluntary environmental improvements | Mandatory supply-chain traceability |
European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS)
Require large companies in the EU to disclose environmental, social, and governance information
EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR)
Requires importers to demonstrate that certain commodities did not originate from recently deforested land. Uses GPS coordinates and satellite monitoring
California Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act
Requires qualifying companies doing business in California with more than $1 billion in annual global revenue to report greenhouse gas emissions
Emission scope 1
Direct emissions from sources owned or controlled by the company
Emission scope 2
Indirect emissions from purchased energy
Emission scope 3
Other indirect emissions throughout the company’s value chain
Food system
The interconnected processes involved in getting food from production to consumption and disposal
Includes:
production
processing
distribution
sales
consumption
waste disposal
food system inputs
seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, energy, water, research, labor
food system outputs
food, contamination, greenhouse gases, and waste
Industrial agriculture
Large-scale food production that relies on fossil fuels, chemical fertilizers, pesticides, and machinery
main goal of industrial agriculture
produce the greatest possible yield at the lowest possible cost, mechanization allows fewer farmers to manage larger amounts of land
farms then vs now
1935: 6.8 million US farms and a population of 127 million
Today: 1.8 million farms and a population of 345 million
Agriculture depends on:
soil
water
biodiversity
pollination
decomposition
natural predators that control pests
a stable climate
US agriculture consumes 50% of U.S. land, 80% of consumptive freshwater, 16% of U.S. energy
Manufactured agricultural inputs
Input | Benefit | Environmental concern |
|---|---|---|
Pesticides | Control pests and allow monocultures | Pesticide resistance |
Fertilizers | Increase crop yields | Nutrient pollution and eutrophication |
Genetically engineered crops | Can provide herbicide tolerance and resistance to climate fluctuations | Can perpetuate herbicide use |
Monoculture
Growing one crop over a large area
Makes large-scale production more efficient
Reduces crop diversity
Makes crops more vulnerable to widespread pest outbreaks
Eutrophication
Excess nutrients, often from fertilizers, enter water systems and cause algal blooms. The algae eventually die and decompose consuming dissolved oxygen. This can create aquatic dead zones
Environmental consequences of industrial agriculture
Farming accounts for 70% of current U.S. water pollution
Industrial farming uses 7-10 calories of fossil fuel energy for every 1 calories of fossil fuel energy for every 1 calorie of edible food produced
Soil erosion and intensive plowing degrade topsoil faster than it can naturally form
Agriculture accounts for approximately 70% of global freshwater withdrawals
Large areas of U.S. cropland are dedicated to corn and soybean monocultures
Ogallala Aquifer
An important groundwater source used for irrigation, including approximately one-quarter of U.S. irrigated land
Why is soil degradation concerning?
Soil formation is extremely slow, so losing topsoil can threaten long-term food production
Industrial Food and Animal Production (IFAP)
Industrial Food and Animal Production. A system that raises large numbers of animals for meat, milk, and eggs using industrial methods
CAFO
Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation
A legally defined facility that confines animals above certain population thresholds
Animals are kept in confinement areas without grass or other vegetation
Most meat, milk, and eggs consumed in the U.S. come from industrial animal production systems
Animal feed
Primary corn and soybeans
Can contain antimicrobials
Can contain rendered animal products and animal waste