1/46
KHÓ VL CÍU T
3 DIMENSIONS OF CRITICAL THINKING
awareness of a set of interrlated critical questions
desire to actively use the critical questions
ability to ask and answer critical questions in an appropriate manner
def of sponge approach
absorbing everything you learn
adva of sponge approach
the more information you absorb abt the world ==> the more capable you are of understanding its complexity
quick and easy
dis adva of sponge approach
no method for deciding which to believe and reject
def of panning for gold
involves active participation
ask frequent questions and reflect to the answers
key characteristic of panning for gold
most important: interactive involvement
question why authors make claims
ask urself sev ques to uncover the best avai beliefs or decisions
weak sense of CT
defending ur current beliefs
resist any ideas that different form yours
strong sense of CT
use same skills to evaluate all claims and beliefs
def of value
standards of conduct that we endorse and expect ppl to meet
key values of critical thinker
autonomy
curiosity
humility
respect for good reasoning
autonomy
making reasoned choices and acting on your own examined values rather than blind authority, peer pressure, or impulse
curiosity
really listen and read
ask questions abt hat you have encountered
humility
each of us is very limited in what we can do
what is an issue
question or controversy responsible for the conversation or duscussion - stimulus for what is being said
2 kinds of issues
descriptive
prescriptive
descriptive
what is/was or how things work
does…
what …
is …
==> describe the way the world was/is/is going to be
ATTENTION: RAISE QUESTIONS ABT THE ACCURACY OF DESCRIPTIONS OF THE PAST, PRESENT OR FUTURE
prescriptive
raise questions abt what we should do or what is wight/wrong, good or bad
should…
what ought to be done…
must…
==> recommendation
conclusion
message that the speaker or writer wishes you to accept
claims and judgements must be based on reasoning
every conclusion is an answer to an issue
how to find conclusion
ask urself: what question is being answered here? what is the writer trying to prove
avoid How questions, prefer what question
conclusions must be supported by other ideas
what a conclusion is not
eg
sta
def
back in4
evi
def of assumption
ideas and beliefs that you accept as true withour direct proof or complete evidence
belief (usually unstated), that is taken 4 granted and supports the xplicit reasoning
key aspects of assumptions
hidden or unstated
taken for granted
influential in determining the conclusion
potentially deceptive
believed true by the person making the argument
2 places to look for assumptions
assumptions needed for the reason to support the conclusion (bridge the gap - linkage assumptions)
assumptions needed for the reasons to be true
def of value assumptions
implict preference for 1 value over another in a particular context
very contextual
what the writer wants the world to be like - what goals he/she thinks are most imp
how the world should be
value preference
have major impact on conclusion and the way of defending it
finding value assumptions
reverse role-play (phan bien theo chieu nguoc lai)
def of des assumptions
beliefs abt the way the world was/is or will be
definitional assumptions
ask urself: ON WHAT BASIS CAN THAT CONCLUSION BE DRAWN FROM THAT REASON? IS THERE ANY BASIS FOR ACCEPTING ASSUMPTIONS
DEF OF FALLACY
A reasoning “trick” that sb might use while trying to persuade you to accept a conclusion
AD HOMINEM
an attack on the person, rather than directly addressing the person’s reasons
def + eg of narrative
def: The tendency to create a convincing story or explanation by connecting events into a meaningful narrative, even when there is insufficient evidence to establish that the events are actually related.
eg: She became successful because she always woke up at 5 a.m. and followed a strict morning routine. Therefore, waking up early is the secret to success.
def + eg of sloppery slope
def: Assuming that one relatively small action will inevitably lead to a series of increasingly serious consequences, without providing sufficient evidence for those connections.
eg: If universities allow students to submit assignments late, students will become irresponsible. Eventually, nobody will meet deadlines, and the entire education system will collapse
def + eg of searching 4 perf solu
def: Rejecting a reasonable solution because it is not perfect or does not solve every aspect of a problem.
eg: We shouldn't introduce public transport improvements because they won't completely eliminate traffic congestion
appeal to popularity
def: Claiming that something is true, correct or valuable simply because a large number of people believe it or support it.
eg: Millions of people use this language-learning application, so it must be the most effective application available
appeal to questionable authority
def: Using the opinion or statement of someone who lacks relevant expertise or credibility as sufficient evidence to support a claim.
EG: A famous actor says that this investment strategy is guaranteed to make money, so it must be reliable.
appeal to emotion
def: Attempting to persuade an audience by provoking emotions such as fear, pity, anger or guilt rather than providing relevant logical evidence.
eg: You should support this school policy because the students who proposed it have worked incredibly hard. Rejecting it would break their hearts.
straw person
def: Misrepresenting, exaggerating or oversimplifying someone's argument to make it easier to attack, instead of addressing their actual position
eg: Person A: "Universities should reduce unnecessary homework so students have more time for independent learning."
Person B: "So you think students shouldn't have to study or do any homework at all?
hasty generalization
def: Drawing a broad conclusion about an entire group or situation based on an insufficient or unrepresentative sample.
eg: I worked with two university students who were irresponsible. Therefore, university students are generally irresponsible
either-or (false dilemma)
def: Presenting only two possible choices when other reasonable alternatives actually exist.
eg: You either study abroad or you will never have a successful international career.
explain by naming
def: falsely assuming that because you have provided a name for some event or behaviour, you have also adequately explained the event
eg: He performs poorly in exams because he has test anxiety
the planning fallacy
def: The tendency to underestimate the time, resources or difficulties required to complete a task, even when previous experiences suggest that it will take longer.
eg: Our group can definitely finish the entire startup proposal in two days because we have already divided the work
glittering generality
def: Using emotionally appealing but vague and positive words to persuade people without providing clear explanations or supporting evidence.
eg: Our application will create a brighter future, empower young people and bring freedom to every learner
red herring
def: Introducing irrelevant information or shifting attention to an unrelated issue to distract the audience from the original argument or question.
eg: Person A: "Why hasn't the company improved its customer service despite repeated complaints?"
Person B: "Our company has created thousands of jobs and contributed significantly to the local economy
begging the question
def: Using the conclusion itself, either directly or indirectly, as a premise to support that same conclusion.
eg: This university is the best university because no other university is as good as it is
==> same conclusion with different wording 0 basically the same
common des assumptions
events happen to ppl - primarily the result of personal choices
the assumption is in the bacground. that sth should be true means that it will be true
because sth happened in the past, it will happen in the future
clues for locating assumptions
the gap btwn conclusion and reasons: ask urself: how do you get form the reason to the conclusion? if the reason is true, what else must be true the conclusion to follow
look 4 unstated id that sp reasons
id with the opposition: reverse role, ask urself: why anyone might disagree with the conclusion
what are the reasons
explanation + rationales for ehy we should believe a particular conclusion
characteristic of argument
basically consist of a single reason and a conclusion
they have intent==> convince us to sth
their quality varies
2 essential components - conclusion and reason