1/34
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Sengupta – Reimagining Rice, From the Mekong to the Mississippi
3 billion people rely on rice as staple grain
Hundreds of millions of farmers depend on rice for livelihood
With climate change, rice is in trouble
Extreme heat, erratic rainfall, rising sea levels
Flooded rice paddies release methane = pollutant
Intensive rice production save world from hunger BUT also reduce genetic diversity, encourage chemical fertilizers, drain underground aquifers
Yet, sense of optimism (local people will come up with more solutions)
Turning to shrimp, sorghum, millets = all have drawbacks
Oriental Despotism – The Problem with Modernization Theory
Modernization theory → Eu develop something to dominate rest of world
Oriental despotism → certain climates/culture prone to despotism
Ex. means of production in Orient need strong central government (focus on water management – hydraulic societies)
Talhelm – The Rice Theory of Culture
Rice-wheat split in China, India
North China = more independent
South China = more concerned about preserving harmony (collectivist)
Rice growing region
Requires collaboration for irrigation, labor
Implicit self-inflation, thought style
Giordano – Water Security
Two definitions:
Securitization of water → conflict between countries leading to water wars, water becomes threat to national security
Strategic securitization → internationally shared waters and environmental, economic, political interdependencies they create
Tactical securitization → connection of low politics aspects with high politics issues
Spillover impacts of intranational water outcomes on the relations between states
Human security → water scarcity affect basic needs, food security, ecosystem maintenance
Usages
Water insecurity becomes synonymous with water scarcity
Water security as a new agenda (?)
Water = instrument to raise public awareness/profile of water
Definitions
Derived from human security rather than securitization perspectives of water security
Substantial variation
Meehan et al. – Exposing the myths of household water insecurity in the global north: A critical review
Household water insecurity → lack of safe, reliable, sufficient, affordable water for a thriving life
Not just in Global South, also in high-income countries
Product of structural and institutionalized power; manifests unevenly through space and time; reproduced in places we tend to assume are the most affluent and water-secure in the world
US = water rates unaffordable for low-income households
Canada = First Nation communities on boil water advisory
Modern water → set of ideas, discourses, and practices associated with scientific and Western models of water management
Notion that household water is universal and secure in high-income countries
Imagined as uniform in access/delivery
Myths:
Water access is universal
Insecure water access through:
Geography and scale of drinking water systems
Racialized wealth gaps expressed through unequal geographies of housing
Linked to status of citizenship and belonging
Institutionalized structures of marginalization
Water is clean
Water is affordable
Water delivery is trustworthy
Water is uniformly governed
Modern water is the best water
Biswas and Tortajada – Water Crisis and Water Wars: Myths and Realities
Erroneous assumption: quantity of water available in world for human use is limited
Population, urbanization, industrial activities all steadily increasing
Result: prediction that world faces water crisis and water wars
Wrong:
Water is renewable resource
Most important = planning and management of water resources
Agricultural water (largest user) becoming more efficient
More countries forced improve water management practices
In human history, no countries gone to war over water
Price of water low
Countries know that they must manage water better
Issue = management of transboundary rivers
DuBois King – Weaponization of Water in Syria and Iraq
Correlation between water stress and violence during conflict in Syria and Iraq between 2012 and 2015
Water scarcity create conditions leading to political unrest and violent insurrection in Syria/Iraq
Drought, food insecurity, formed migration, policy failures
Lack of water contribute to political instability and violent conflict
Weaponization of water → offensive capability, used to gain strategic/material/mental advantage
Often seen in Fertile Cresent
Types of water weapons:
Strategic weaponization → use of water to control land areas to fulfill vision of sovereignty OR use of water as assent for funding (collect taxes)
Tactical weaponization → weapon on battlefield
Psychological terrorism → fear among non-combatants of denial of access/contamination of water supply
Instrument of extortion or incentivization → establish credibility as governing authority or reward support
Unintentional weaponiztion → causes collateral damage of civilians or ecological environment
Islamic State use water as weapon
Enable stategic campaign of territorial acquisition
Win hearts and minds of people
Unprecedented in history of modern conflict
US recommendations:
Military - do not harm
Development – post-conflict stabilization/reconstruction assistance
Leverage international law
Kramer – The US needs a real plan to defend its water systems
Iranian cyberattacks on water systems in 12 U.S. states
Could have caused public health crisis that impacts entire population
Vulnerable:
Technical – U.S. water systems lack basic cyber hygiene
Legal – EPA lacks clear statutory authority to impose cybersecurity requirements on water systems
Practical – U.S. water systems small = lack resources
Struggles:
Cost/complexity of stronger technical defenses
Highly fragmented nature of water sector
Recommendations:
Stronger technical capabilities (zero-trust architecture)
Large water systems
Assist midsize water systems
Create safe operations posture for small water systems
Build AI-capable cybersecurity cohort
Garrick et al. - Rethinking the economics of water: an assessment
Water shortages = global risk of great concern
Policy approaches:
Public water supply projects
Water as economic good (supply and demand)
Water challenges multifaceted (politics/governance crucial)
Trends:
Increasing dependence on groundwater
Piped water supplies failing to reach rural regions in Global South
Economic roots of water scarcity (diff value/measure)
Supply
Mobility = difficult bound/measure
Variability = diff measure/allocate rights
Heaviness = capital intensive to store/transport
Demand
Multiple uses = difficult compare value
Non-rival uses
Priorities for econ policy
Financing/managing water infrastructure
Pricing water
Reforming property rights
Future
Tech innovation for decentralized solutions and desalination
Blended finance to bridge infrastructure finance gap
Smart markets for sustainable water use
Central lessons
Institutions for coordination are necessary
Blended solutions require blended governancequantity signals as important as price signals
Economic policy levers outside of water important
Never waste crisis but don’t wait for one
The Economist – Investors start to pay attention to water risk
Portfolio managers realize that water risk could hurt investments/price for water increase
Disclosures of water risk = opaque
Third-party data providers estimate company’s water risk
The Economist – For business, water scarcity is where climate change hits home
Mexico’s brewery’s struggle with drought
Water shortages affect hydro-dependent industries (food production, mining, power generation, apparel, electronics)
Scarcity exacerbated by climate change, population growth, greater water use
Affect producers throughout world
Problem = unequal distribution of freshwater (also w/ waste, pollution, underpricing)
Best outcome = use less, treat what is used better
For most shareholders, water behind carbon emissions as ESG concern
Duvick – Biotechnology in the 1930s
Biotechnology → branch of molecular biology that uses recombinant DNA tech to study, categorize, manipulate genetic materials
Ex. genetic transformation
New breeding methods
Improved varieties = increase yields
Inbred-hybrid method = increase hybrid vigor
1920s: primary source = public-sector maize breeders at agricultural colleges and USDA
Hybrid maize = interest/demand increased in 1930s
1950s: also synthetic nitrogen fertilizers, chemical weed killers, efficient planting/harvesting machinery
Yield improvements from genetic improvements in tolerance to stresses (disease, insects, dense planting, drought, low soil fertility)
Not from heterosis (difference in yield between single cross hybrid and mean of its two inbred parents)
1960s: focus on inbreds (single cross hybrids rather than double cross hybrids)
Private sector of seed breeding emerged to cater to farmers
Exchange of inbreds one-way (from public to private)
Consequences
Acceptance
Farmers give up status as independent seed savers to make greater profit
Hybrids of 1930s made through natural methods of gene transfer, now use laboratory manipulation
Today’s focus = convince non-farming public of safety of new creations of genetic engineering
Farmer’s opinion = secondary
Biotech now controversial in scientific community
Effects
Decreased genetic diversity of maize on farm
Hybrids more tolerant to stress
Farmers use more fertilizer = greater groundwater pollution
Mechanization of maize growing
Future prospects: cannot imagine future in which biotech not beneficially applied to maize breeding
However, with more delay/difficulty than imagined two decades ago
Cullather – Miracles of Modernization: The Green Revolution and the Apotheosis of Technology
Green Revolution → agricultural revolution
India, Pakistan, Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia declare self-sufficiency in food with improved agricultural technology
Rice (IR-8) = division between traditional and modern agriculture
Fruits of modernity = weapon against communism
Visiual representation of modernization
Est IRRI to train professionals of Asian countries
Ideal plant type = short, dark green, rigid, grow in tropical Asia, resistant to pests/diseases
Mission from reforming institutions/attitudes to averting famine
After 1967, Green Rev = instrument of U.S. policy in Asia
Miracle seeds create moment of possibility in which govs could be converted and wars won
Ex. try sell IR-8 to Vietnamese farmers
Parayil – The Green Revolution in India
Green Revolution → increase in cereal productivity experienced in some Third World countries as a result of change in agricultural tech during 1960/70s
Use of high-yielding varieties (HYV) and improved agricultural practices
In place of traditional agricultural practices
With seeds whose genetic makeup goes back thousands of years, wooden plows/carts, dependent on monsoon rains
Punjab = most successful state in terms of exploiting benefits of tech change in agriculture
Result = India self-sufficient in food grain production
Subsistence farming characterized by exclusion effect → peasant farmers resist change
No more land to plant = must increase productivity
Green Rev replace one way of life with another in two decades
Background
No change in agricultural practices/tech in India for ks years
HYV → early maturing semidwarf types that under intensive agricultural practices (chemical fertilizers, irrigation, pumps, etc) provide significantly higher yield compared to traditional types
Suitable to Asia dev in 1960s at IRRI
Fit ecological/economic/culinary conditions
Green Rev in India w/: gov of India, multilat/bilat donor agencies, internat agri research institutions, Indian farmers/peasants
New research system
Institutional/bureaucratic reform/tech transfer
Diffusion and adoption of new tech
Parayil – Mapping technological trajectories of the Green Revolution and the Gene Revolution from modernization to globalization
Biotechnology → human endeavors to alter living things to produce food, fodder, fiber
***Green Rev + Gene Rev = two different socio-tech systems
Gene Rev NOT follower of Green Rev
Diff global/nat innov systems
Tech trajectory of:
Green Rev = shaped by exigencies of modernization in post-colonial societies
Project of internat tech transfer
Supp by internat public domain
Seeds of HYV
Gene Rev = shaped by imperatives of neo-liberal economic globalization
Knowledge intensive innovation
Supp by internat priv domain
Advances in cell/molecular bio
Temple – How a Breakthrough Gene-Editing Tool will Help the World Cope with Climate Change
CRISPR-edited plants/animals survive in conditions fueled by climate change
Ability precisely remove specific parts of DNA within existing genomes of plants/animals
Not labeled as bioengineered because won’t carry DNA from other organisms
But need more research to target right part of genome, evaluate if changes bring benefits, ensure edits don’t come at cost of overall plant health/food safety
Reduce climate change by limiting stomata, reducing methane emissions from cattle
However, CRISPR patents controlled by few entities = slow agricultural products from hitting market
Wang et al. – Revolutionizing Agriculture With CRISPR Technology: Applications, Challenges, and Future Perspectives
CRISPR = flexible genome editing tool across organisms
Unprecedented precision and efficiency compared to conventional breeding methods
Applications:
Plants: enhance stress tolerance, increase yields, improve nutritional quality
Animals: improve productivity, disease resistance, animal welfare
Aquaculture: address disease outbreaks, feed efficiency, environmental stress
Microbes and synthetic biology: degrade pesticides/crop residues, enhance soil health/nutrient cycling
Support food security by:
Improving food availability
Enhancing access
Boosting food utilization
Advanced CRISPR tech = expand what gene editing can achieve in agriculture
***depends on fair regulation, public trust, equitable access
Hakimdavar – Water is the New Oil in the Gulf
4/6 most water scarce countries in the Gulf
Exacerbated with climate change
Problem = low water supply + rapid population growth
Led Gulf countries to rely heavily on food imports from countries facing water/climate uncertainties and increase national agricultural production
Exploit groundwater = lower groundwater levels
Turn to seawater desalination
Energy intensive = greenhouse gas emissions
Byproducts of desalination (brine) = dumped back into sea + make water saltier
Suffocate marine life
Threat of desalination plant attacks, fluctuations in global oil market, changing energy distribution policies
Recommendations:
Reduce water demand through smart policies/conservation awareness campaigns
Increase and diversify watersupply
Invest in research/dev to decarbonize desalination and reduce environmental costs of brine
Greater collaboration among Gulf nations
Weise – AI, the Electricians and the Boom Towns of Central Washington
Building AI needs computing/electrical power
Electricians move around country to regions with power to spare
Ex. Central Washington state
Give energy to data centers
WA tax break for data centers to encourage construction
Use power, land, and labor
Host of centers along Columbia River
Provide money for the community (schools, increase property value)
Data centers provide many jobs during construction, only employ a few workers once running
Worry about whether job bubble will burst
The Misconceptions of AI Water Use: Why Everybody Is Wrong … & Right?
What kind of water is used
Withdrawal vs. consumption
Direct (used at data center) vs. indirect (used upstream in electricity system that powers facility)
National totals (allow comparison between data centers and other large water using sectors) vs. local materiality (impact of water in a munincipality)
How water is used
Moving and rejecting heat
Cool broader system that keeps hardware at safe operation conditions
Tradeoff between energy use and direct water use
Evaporative cooling, air-based cooling, liquid cooling, zoer-water designs
Allow for humidity control
Level of analysis should not be one-query
Should focus on workload, processing, cooling, boundary conditions
AI’s water use = range
Real risk = local materiality
Bloom: No Such Thing As Waste, Only Wasted Resources
Bloom = recycled product of Blue Plains wastewater treatment facility
Solids collected in plant, turned into fertilizer
Sold to public, reduces use of chemical fertilizers
NewBrew
Used water in Singapore undergoes treatment and gets turned into beer
Fits into government’s goal of reclaiming used water
Giordano and Wahal – Hydro-diplomacy on the Brahmaputra
Water wars rationale predicts that countries will wage war to safeguard access to water resources
Applies to Brahmaputra River with China and India
Both countries water-stressed and water demand continues to grow
China builds dams upstream which affects India’s downstream water
Conclusions:
Violent conflict about territorial control rather than water
Water infrastructure serves as means of territorial posturing and control
River used as tool to meet political objectives related to Bangladesh
Bandalesh faces greatest threats as China/India infrastructure reduces sediment deposit
***Risk for water war is relatively low
China contributes smaller proportion of Brahmaputra’s flow than commonly perceived
Chinese dams designed for hydropower, not consumption
Brahmaputra flows through most humid region of India
Conflict for water through diplomatic/political means rather than military conflict
Winner – Do Artifacts Have Politics?
Technical systems interwoven in conditions of modern politics
What matters is not technology, but social or economic systems in which it is embedded
Approaches:
Invention, design, arrangement of specific technical device becomes way of settling an issue in particular community
Ex. New York highways have low overpasses to prevent buses + Black residents from traveling to certain areas
Technology = ways of building order in our world
Man-made systems require particular kinds of political relationships
Ex. operating conditions of ships at sea requires subordination of workers
Attempt to justify strong authority on basis of necessary conditions of technical practice
With nuclear power
Requires authoritarian government for management
Didion – Holy Water
Obsession with movement of water
So crucial to life in Western United States
Only natural force they have any control over (recent)
Rizvi – Colonial Infrastructure and the Politics of Partition of Punjab
Role of colonial infrastructure and technological change in shaping climate for mass violence in Punjab during Partition
Sikhs, Hindus, Muslims scramble cross India-Pakistan border in 1947
Accretion of instrastructural violence inherent in making rule of property in central Punjab
Infrastructure shaped landownership and economic relations
Agricultural land transferred from peasant farmers to creditors/merchant castes
Canal colonies exacerbate communal divisions
Rigid administration of revenue based on private property
Bhakra Nangal Dam
People in deserts of India seek water
Nearby, Sutlej River was available
Plan dam to generate electricity and divert water
Town of Nangal flourish nearby
Represented hopes and wishes of country
Things to think about:
The river is a tributary of the Indus and Pakistan never mentioned
The dam is referred to as a "temple"
The home states and languages spoken at the end by the workers (hard to know what is going on with the languages if you aren't familiar with South Asian languages)
The Chief Engineer was Harvey Slocum (also built Grand Coulee Dam in United States)
Hardin – The Tragedy of the Commons
On national security in a nuclear world, no technical solution exists
Need change in human values/idea of morality
Finite world can support finite population, population growth must eventually equal zero
Tragedy of the commons
Tragedy = remorseless working of things
Freedom in a commons brings ruin to all
Individual denies truth even though society as a whole suffers
Ex. with National Parks, pollution
Morality of an act is function of state of system at the time it is performed
Ex. pollution does not harm general public under frontier conditions, same behavior in metropolis is unbearable
Legislate temperance through mediation of administrative law
Criticize UNDHR for saying decisions of family reside within family itself
Should control population
Cannot rely on conscience
Mutually agreed upon coercion to prevent something from becoming a commons
***commons only justifiable under conditions of low population density
As population increases, commons abandoned
Education must reveal necessity of abandoning freedom to breed
End this aspect of tragedy of commons
Ostrom – Revisiting the Commons: Local Lessons, Global Challenges
Common-pool resource problems → systems where exclusion of beneficiaries through physical/institutional means is costly, exploitation by one user reduces resource availability for others
Solutions:
Restrict access
Creating incentives for users to invest in resource instead of overexploiting
Challenges of global commons
Scaling-up problem
Cultural diversity challenge
Complications of interlinked CPRs
Accelerating rates of change
Requirement of unanimous agreement as a collective-choice rule
Only one globe with which to experiment
Zenner – Just Water
9) Women, Wells and Living Water
Story of Samaritan woman at the well creates interpretations about mater/spirit, well/living water, Samaritan woman/Jesus
Water for living and living waters depend on one another
Standing water (wells, pond, dam) = disease
For most of us, water is largely invisible
For most people, water is neither invisible nor neutral
Gathering water = predominantly women’s task (life-defining)
Burden of water = gendered
Physically burdensome
Fresh water scarcity = burden
Burden of sex
Ingram et al. – The Importance of Equity and the Limits of Efficiency in Water Resources
Importance of Water
Water will dominate natural resource politics
Permeates social, political, economic, religious conflicts
Largest portion located in wrong places (misallocated, wasted, degraded by pollution)
Water regarded as basic human right
Impediments in agreement for water management = failure recognize value pluralism
Conclusion
Equity equal to efficiency among criteria to evaluate water-related actions/policies
Social interaction related to water
Normative studies = how and by whom water will be used
Main point = context
Leopold – Thinking Like a Mountain
All strive for safety, prosperity, comfort, etc
Too much safety = danger in long run
Killing all wolves = overpopulation of deer
Thoreau’s dictum: in wildness = salvation of world
Known among mountains, seldom perceived among men
Rittel and Webber – Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning
Challenges in:
Goal formulation
Problem definition
Planning problems = wicked (nearly all public policy issues)
No definite formulation
No stopping rule
Solutions not true/false, but good/bad
No immediate/ultimate test of solution
Each solution = one-shot operation
No opportunity to learn by trial-and-error
No enumerable set of potential solutions/permissible operations
Essentially unique
Each can be considered symptom of another problem
Discrepancy representing wicked problem explaine in numerous ways, chocie of explanation determine nature of solution
Planner has no right to be wrong
Meadows – Leverage Points
Leverage points → places within complex system where small shift in one thing produces big changes in everything
Points of power
Everyone strives to know
Able to intuitively figure out BUT push in wrong direction
Complex systems + leverage points = counterintuitive
Places to intervene in a system (increasing order of effectiveness)
Constants, parameters, numbers (subsidies, taxes, standards)
Sizes of buffers and other stabilizing stocks, relative to their flows
Structure of material stocks/flows (transport networks, pop age structures)
Length of delays, relative to rate of system change
Strength of negative feedback loops, relative to impacts they are trying to correct against
Gain around driving positive feedback loops
Structure of information flows (who does/doesn’t have access)
Rules of system (incentives, punishments, constraints)
Power to add, change, evolve, self-organize system structure
Goals of system
Mindset out of which system arises
Power to transcend paradigms
Biscoe – Fluid Prejudice
Managing the Mississippi
Beware of hydrocentrism
Water is only one of dozens of priority issues for governments
Initiate reforms only when powerful need and demonstrated demand for chance
Professional concerns are never primary mover
Water reform = dialectic not mechanical process
No straight line from bad to good management
Values dependent on income and change over time
Beware of moral hazards
Beware of concepts which have not encountered practice
Avoid rigidities which come from formalization
Financing matters
Instruments matter more than organizations
Implementation matters