1/75
Looks like no tags are added yet.
crime control
Goal is to deter criminal conduct and protect society
Follows Herbert Packer
Emphasizes efficiency, speed, and the effective investigation and prosecution of the crime
Accused is presumed guilty, police and prosecutors should have the freedom to exercise their own judgement in the interest of controlling crime, legal loopholes should be eliminated, people who commit crimes should be punished swiftly
If the scenario emphasizes speed, efficiency, convictions, or crime prevention, think crime control
due process
fairness is the primary goal
Follows Herbert Packer
Criminal defendants should be presumed innocent before being guilty → the courts’ priority is protecting their constitutional rights of the accused, law enforcement officials should be held in check to preserve freedom and civil liberties
Crime is not a result of an individual’s moral failure but is driven by social influences → racial discrimination, unemployment, injustice
Courts that do not follow this philosophy are fundamentally unfair to their defendants
Emphasizes fairness, individual rights, procedural protections, and safeguard against government error or abuse
If the scenario emphasizes constitutional rights, fair procedures, or preventing wrongful convictions, think due process.
consensus
most citizens in society share similar values and beliefs
Based on the fact that even a diverse population holds the same morals or views concerning what should be labeled as “right” or “wrong” behavior → views are reflected by the law
Society comes together in order to protect itself from those who threaten the well-being of others by passing laws that prevent them from doing harmful behavior
Changes overtime based on society → EX: adultery used to be illegal
Members of society generally agree on certain fundamental values and laws
conflict
there will always be competing interests and viewpoints among members of society
Consensus is not possible
Laws reflect the interests of the most powerful people in society → not everyone has equal power to shape the laws
Characteristics of certain groups make them more or less likely to be subjected to laws and different criminal proceedings
mitigating circumstances
justify a less severe sentence
aggravating circumstances
justify a more severe sentence
discretion
Authority to choose among legally permitted options based on the circumstances of a situation
Officers can respond to specific parts of a case
Circumstances may differ so sentences can differ
More efficient since prosecutors can resolve minor cases
But can lead to inconsistency, bias, unequal treatment, and the abuse of power
substantive law
written law that defines criminal acts
Defines what is legal and illegal and what punishments may apply
procedural law
sets the procedures and mechanisms for processing criminal cases
Set from constitutional amendments
Describes the rules concerning legal jurisdiction, jury selection, appeal, evidence, etc.
civil law
disputes between individuals, businesses, or other parties → does not involve the government
Plaintiff → person bringing lawsuit
Defendant → defending against lawsuit
Punishment is usually compensation from the other party
criminal law
defines offenses against the public and details government prosecution and punishment
Represents what society has deemed criminal behavior
prosecutor/state has burden of proof
Punishment is usually jail or prison
stare decisis
Stare decisis is the…. “Let the decision stand”
Follow previously decided cases
Provides rules/guidance for future cases
actus reus
“guilty act”
The physical action that leads to a crime
mens rea
“guilty mind”
Criminal intent
Mental state required to commit a crime
purposeful mental state
person knows and has an objective to perform the action
knowing mental state
person is aware that their conduct will cause something to happen
reckless mental state
person consciously disregards a risk → recognizes it but doesn’t care
negligent mental state
person fails to perceive a substantial risk that they should have known about
murder
intentional homicide
reckless manslaughter
accidental homicide
“Involuntary manslaughter”
Reckless conduct
Someone ignores the risks and ends up killing another
Passion/provocation manslaughter
an intense emotional response causes someone to act in the moment
“Voluntary manslaughter”
Felony murder
unintentionally causing a death while committing a felony
Strict liability → held to the consequences of their actions despite their mens rea
Robbery
taking property from a person through force or threat
Burglary
unlawful entry of a place with the intent to commit a felony
Nothing has to be stolen
Theft
unlawful taking or controlling of one’s property
Arson
setting something on fire with malicious intent
Uniform Crime Reports (UCR)
|
|
National Incident Based Reporting System (NIBRS)
|
|
National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS)
|
|
Self-Report
|
|
crime rate
they help us measure, compare, and understand crime in different places and over time.

classical criminology
Classical criminology emphasizes…. Encouraged reform of the law to be more consistent and rational
Punishments can influence people not to commit crimes → people weight the benefits and costs → deterrence
Punishment should fit the crime rather than the offender
Laws and punishments must be known to the public
Cesare Beccaria
Classical school of criminology
Criminal laws and punishments should be fair, predictable, and proportionate to the offense and not the offender
Jeremy Bentham
Pleasure vs. pain
People tend to seek pleasure and avoid pain
Punishment should prevent more harm
Punishment can deter crime if its expected consequence outweighs the expected benefits
positivist criminology
Positivist theories examine how factors….. Beyond simple conscious choice may influence criminal behavior
Criminal rather than the criminal act
Seek to uncover the basic case of a crime
Cesare Lombroso → people were a product of their physical features → the way you look can influence how much crime you commit
a. These may include biological, psychological, social, and environmental influences.
Biological: Genetic influences, neurological differences, or other biological factors
Psychological: Impulsivity, personality, trauma, or difficulties with emotional regulation
Social: Family relationships, peer groups, poverty, or social inequality
Environmental: Neighborhood conditions, exposure to violence, or opportunities for offending.
positivist vs classical

criminology theories

code of silence (blue code)
officers protect their coworkers by keeping quiet and refusing to report misconduct
deontology
duties, rules, and moral principles
People commit actions because it is their duty to do so
If one does an action for self-gratification rather than to help the community, their action would be considered unethical
“Is it wrong because it violates a rule or duty”
Do the right thing because it’s your duty
Utilitarianism
consequences result in the greatest good for the greatest number of people
Which choice produces the best consequence
Greatest overall benefit
virtue ethics
focuses on character and integrity
Actions are evaluated in terms of virtue → honesty, courage, fairness, compassion, integrity
Whistleblowing
someone reporting another employee for misconduct
retaliation
response to someone reporting them
The Knapp Commission
investigated corruption in the NYPD 1970s; associated with 2 types of officers
a. Grass eaters: officers who accept small forms of gratitude or corruption
b. Meat eaters: officers who actively seek out opportunities for substantial corruption or personal gain
Noble cause corruption
someone in the CJ system commits an unethical/illegal act because they believe it will achieve a desirable outcome like convicting a dangerous offender → ends justify the means → double effect
dirty harry → an officer who believes extreme or unethical tactics are justified to achieve a good result
Prosecutorial ethics and Brady v. Maryland
SCOTUS held that prosecution violates due process when it suppresses evidence favorable to the accused that will make them guilty
disclosure
make previously hidden information open to the public
exculpatory evidence
evidence that can make a defendant innocent → evidence favorable to a defendant
sixth amendment
Right to a counsel
Speedy and public trial
Impartial jury
political era -→ 1840 - 1930s
1844 law in NY passed establishing a full time police force for NYC
Was placed under the control of city government and city politicians
Each ward in the city be a separate patrol district
Mayor would choose recruits from a list of names submitted by the aldermen and tax assessors of each ward → would then submit his choices to the city council for approval
Politics became a big issue as officers would use political backers to obtain promotions, desired assignments, and transfers
Police corruption also surfaced where they would work close to gamblers, saloonkeepers, madams, and pimps
Close personal relationships, corruption, politics played major role
reform era (prof era) 1930s - 1980s
Reformers wanted to get rid of political involvement by the police
Emphasized professional training and hiring based on merit
Used technology
Rapid responses
Distance between police and community
Career of August Vollmer was a major factor in the shaping and development of police professionalism
Increased deputies from 3 to 12 in order to form day and night patrols
First to order his men to patrol on bikes
System of red lights → served as an emergency notification system for officers
Came up with the idea of a formal police school which included courses of police methods and procedures, fingerprinting, first aid, criminal law, anthropometry, photography, and public health
Much of police work was driven by numbers → how many arrests, calls, response times, etc
The community Era → 1980s - present
Police were trained to work with the community to solve problems by looking at their underlying causes and developing tailored responses to them
Municipal police departments jurisdiction
serve cities, towns, local municipalities
Emergencies
Patrol neighborhoods
Local crimes
Traffic laws
County law enforcement agencies jurisdiction
Major investigation
Persecution support
state police jurisdiction
Specialized resources like forensic analysis
Highway patrol
Assist local agencies
Enforce laws without municipal departments
Special investigations
Federal law enforcement agencies jurisdiction
Specialized federal responsibilities → nationwide
Special state missions
federal enforcement agencies

de-escalation
Techniques used to reduce the intensity of a confrontation while minimizing the need for force
Used to reduce danger
force must be constitutional
Watchman style
maintain order in neighborhoods
Officers act as if order maintenance is their primary function rather than law enforcement
Use the law as a means of maintaining order rather than regulating conduct through arrests
Ignore many minor violations and victimless crimes
Using the law to give people what they “deserve”
Legalistic style
“soldier” → enforcing law formally
Harsher view of law violations
Officers issue large numbers of traffic citations, detain a high volume of juvenile offenders, and act vigorously against illicit activities
Assumes the purpose of the law is to punish
Service style
“teacher” → help residents solve community problems
Falls between watchman and legalistic style
Take in seriously all requests for either law enforcement or order maintenance but are less likely to respond by making an arrest or imposing formal sanctions
See their primary responsibility as protecting public order against the minor and occasional threats
Will use informal sanctions instead of making arrests
Kansas City Preventive Patrol Experiment
examined whether changing the amount of routine patrol affected the amount of crime and public perception
Did not make a significant difference
Newark Foot Patrol Experiment
studied effects of police officers on foot patrolling areas
People felt more safe and liked police more
Broken Windows Theory
Visible disorder can contribute to further disorder
Addressing the disorder may help maintain neighborhood stability
Use of force: Graham v. Connor (1989)
police use of force during an arrest, investigatory stop, or seizure → how to know if police brutality is occurring
Questioned whether the officer’s actions were objectively reasonable given the facts and circumstances
Courts must consider the severity of the crime, immediate threat, and active resistance/flight
Problem-oriented policing and SARA
Scanning → identify the recurring problem
Analysis → find out why it’s happening
Response → design a response/solution
Assessment → check if the solution has worked
Constitutional policing
exercising police authority consistently with the constitution
Requires officers to respect individuals rights → 4th, 5th, 6th amendment
fourth amendment
No reasonable search and seizure
Officers must have a warrant
Probable cause or suspicion is necessary
due process
Allows for fair treatment
Lawful investigation and prosecution
Protection against wrongful conviction
Constitutional rights
constitutional policing
forms the foundation of community policing
Police cannot form positive and productive relationships with the people they serve if those communities do not trust the police or believe the police only see themselves protecting civil rights as public safety
Authority with limits
police legitimacy
the extent to which the community believes that police actions are appropriate, proper, just, and willingness to recognize police authority
If they have a higher level, community members are more willing to cooperate accept the outcomes of their interaction with authorities → the willingness of residents to lean into the law and to police authority
Involved the belief that police actions are morally justified and appropriate to the circumstances
constitutional policing vs police legitimacy

civil liability
legal responsibility for harm that may require compensation or another remedy
happens from negligence
basic elements of negligence
1. Duty → person has a legal responsibility to act with care
2. Breach of duty → person failed to meet their responsibility
3. Causation → failure to do that cause the person’s injury/harm
4. Damages → the person suffered actual loss or injury
police brutality
severe abuse or unjustified use of force → both speech and physical → broader
Excessive force: unreasonable force given the circumstances
police accountability
Administrative discipline → investigate under department policies and employment rules
Civil lawsuits → injured person can sue the agency or government responsible for damages
State criminal prosecution → can bring criminal charges against an officer
Federal civil rights prosecution → can bring charges can be brought → officer didn’t read 5th amendment rights