1/3
Looks like no tags are added yet.
A strength is supporting research will be studied 44 juvenile thieves and carried out interviews to try and identify signs of affection psychopathy. He found that 14 out of 44 juveniles what affection psychopaths and that 12 out of 14 were separated from the carer for more than six months. This is a strength as Bobby‘s theory suggests that early separation does increase the risk of affectionate psychopathy and criminal behaviour in increasing the validity of the theory. However, we study used on all male sample so it lets population reality as we cannot be sure that girls would have the same consequences.
A limitation is counter evidence. Lewis replicated Bobby‘s 44 thieves study with 500 children including girls and didn’t find the same link between separation and AP. May indicate the fact that are involved in development of AP e.g. gender socio economic background or exposure to role models. Therefore this is a limitation for maternal deprivation theory as it doesn’t consider all factors leading to AP which equals decrease validity. However, case studies e.g. Genie has demonstrated that early deprivation can have significant consequences on intellectual development
limitation – fail to distinguish between deprivation and probation. Critics such as Rutter state that deprivation the loss of attachment and privation to complete lack of an attachment have different effects on an infant and bold be oversimplifies them by considering them the same. Rotter also stated the quality of attachment was more important than any separation therefore suggest be oversimplified concept of maternal deprivation decreasing validity. Furthermore, any supporting research is or correlation so it does not establish cause and effects as other factors arent included in intellectual and emotional development.
u