1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What I learned by studying militrized policing (Mummolo 2018)
it doesn’t make the police or public any safer and finding that out exposed the lack fo dtaa on law enforcement practices
militarization can hurt police reputation, many police agencies delete records after 5-10 years or don’t have records in the first place. also they are often poorly tracked, redacted heavily, or have a big fee
data used was from MD which had a law requiring reportin that expired after 10 years but had at least some consistent info
found that though SWAT is for violent emergencies, 90% of deployment fr search warrants and it is much more likely to be used in black areas - also found seeing more SWAT led to lower public support for presence of police & increased preception of crime
police citizen community fulled with mistrust, “All the good intentions in the world won’t do a thing to fix that unless governments first commit to bringing police behavior into the light.”
Militarization fails to enhance police safety or reduce crime but may harm police reputation (Mummolo 2018)
Advocates claim militarized policing protects officers and deters violent crime but data from SWAT deployments in maryland show that militarized police units are more often deployed in communities with large shares of African American residents, even after controlling for local crime rates. Also militarized policing fails to enhance officer safety or reduce local crime and seeing militarized police in news reports may diminish police reputation in the mass public.
so the often cited trade-off between public safety and civil liberties is false
long history of police as an occupying force especially fr black people liek w/ stop and frisk, the war on drugs etc which have been used to maintain racially based hierarchies - so militarization may make disconnect between marginalized groups and the state bigger
so SWAT may have a role as a useful tool fr violent emergencies, it should be restricted to that
the 3rd amendment
“No soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house without the consent of the Owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.”
US permitted a standing army, but 3rd amendment places limits on it.
Understood to mean military troops would not be used for routine law enforcement
Posse Comitatus 1878
Limits use of federal government forces to enforce domestic policies.
Was reaction of former confederate states to military occupation.
Eisenhower uses exceptions to Posse Comitatus act to send in the national guard to enforce desegregation.
Blurring lines between military and police under Reagan with production of a lot of armored vehicles(MRAPS) for the gulf war
1033 program for military equipment (extra military equipment and all those MRAPS went to domestic law enforcement
Police Militarization
Kraska (2007) “The process whereby civilian police increasingly draw from, and pattern themselves around, the tenets of militarization and the military model.”
• Material dimension: weapons, tech, equipment
• Cultural dimension: language, beliefs, values
• Organizational dimension: command and control centers, elite squads, etc…
Kraska and Mummolo
Kraska spent two years conducting ethnographic research with SWAT teams
Kraska fielded two national level surveys of SWAT teams to document explosion of SWAT teams across the US (see Radley Balko “Warrior Cop”) as well.
Mummolo leverages data from 2009 Maryland law (following a botched raid on the home of a mayor in the suburbs) requiring uniform reporting on all SWAT deployments
SWAT 1975 (TV show)
was the first tv show that popularized the SWAT team model a lot fo future tv shows would use
Pilot episode involves a cop getting ambushed and shot at, then SWAT team shows up to save them. The cops are targeted for attempted assassination because they are cops “cus we’re blue” not based on race or religion. One cop dies and they show his pregnant wife weeping and the determination of the cop whose partner died. the criminals are shown doing various drugs
The cops are immediately shown as victims - they even say biggest cause of police death is ambush on call, they’re being targeted by criminals and SWAT is there to protect people and the public. Use language of nasty “bloodsuckers” who have declared war on cops. its a war and will be fought that way
Real SWAT debut
made their debut in a sort of raid on the black panther party headquarters in 1968
came after the polcie were surprised by the Watts riots in 65 when the national guard were called in and had not strategy + uysed excessive force leading to deaths - also fires and raids
SWAT growth with war on drugs
LAPD promotion of their success in catching some radicals without hurting civilians using SWAT and training people around the country
war on drugs ramping up and giving cops more authority to go into people’s homes for drugs without warrants,
went from totally focused on saving lives to to prosecuting and enforcing the war on drugs.
SWAT got discounted of military weapons and lots even if small team - side note 9/11’s threat of terrorism rly spurred growth
questions of SWAT
role of SWAt teams came into question/discussion more after issue in fergusson missourri 2013 - made people feel like there was an occupying force on them not protection
tho SWAT teams and the existance of them in all cities and towns continues to expand
Cop shows
lots of cop shows in the 60s and 70s were detective/PI shows
there was also the “cool” cop shows of the 1970s like mob squad with groups of people
but the of the biggest straight up cop shows in the 80s and 90s (respectively) were Hill Street Blues(HSB) and NYPD Blue
Hill Street Blues
1981-87 its the biggest more famous and significant cop show of the 80s
tagline: lets be safe/careful out there
“Hill Street police are figures of Sisyphus rolling their rocks up the hill and the next morning rolling them down again, and again. Human effort and intelligence, action, risk, sudden eruptions of violence, sudden death– yet very little changes.”
Set in fictional city in Midwest/Northeast. has bad Gender politics but there are female officers with major roles + group is multiethnic and multiracial
Actually showed the struggles of cops making them sympathetic not as vistims or perpetrators but as regular people
It felt critical looking at the collapse of the american dream too. was cheered by liberals as social commentary. also cus militarization is problemitized, MC is a vietnam vet and wants to use SWAT fr everything this is framed as silly
Hill Street Blues as Propaganda
The protagonists are all flawed (not Gmen)
Militarization of the police was interpreted within the context of the Vietnam war
Endings were not formulaic, police did not always succeed
Racism not denied but integral to the dynamics of HSB
Really anti-conservative and viewed crime as social problem
Still, audiences saw police working in declining urban areas and viewed crime as central problem
NYPD Blue
1993-2005 so before law and order
The main character Andy Sipowicz is very flawed (recovering alcoholic, bigoted,Vietnam vet, weight/health struggles). he apologises at some points but isn’t meant to be a perfect or progressive and sympathetic character
has unique camera work gives impression of embattled detectives ina. dangerous urbn environment
each case is resolved within one episode, few cases are left open, and very rarely is a suspect wrongly brought in for questioning.”
“Functions more as an apology for the police rather than interrogating the social causes of crime.”
Importance of these shows
both NYPD blue and HSB are before cable or streaming so TV would have been incredibly important and central to the portrayal of cops and law enforcement
Mass Incarceration in Pop Culture
Law & Order plus Orange is the New Black
may seem progresive but they really are products of their time
super touch on crime narrative and the view of mainly polcie and judges ideas as central
The Economic Origins of Mass Incarceration (Clegg and Usmani 2019)
the say that mass incarceration is often seen as a system of race based social control but this misunderstands disparities in punishment and ignores the rise in violence in the 60s. it also misunderstands the constraints that led state officials to respond with penal not social policy
Unfair by Design: The war on drugs, race, and the legitimacy of the criminal justice system (Bobo and Thompson 2006)
paper maintains that over the past 3 decades~ US has enacted a series of policies that have reforged a historically troubled link between race, crime & the functionings of the legal system - includes a crisis of legitimacy for the legal system in the eyes black americans & threat to the promise of equality before the law and the profoundly punitive crime response
class notes on mass incarcertion
the idea that there are big actors with vested interest in mass incarceration
bi partisan anture of crime policy in the 80s
people are primarily in state, rather than federal, prisons, each with their own unique policies so its not jsut one issue single issue but instead has a lot of variation across different states
Unfair by design was one of the first to point out the huge difference in black adn white opinion of judicial things plus trust in the judicial system and the view of it as unbiased is very racialized
however the standard story of mass incarceration as centered on race ignores class
economic origins piece claims it is more about class than rce (tho theres a lot of african americans in poverty) - they say the rise in incarceration was related to rise in actual crime (like to an extent ig)