1/136
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Basic Principle of Managed Care Model for Health Insurance
improve coordination of health care and control health care spending in insurance plans. the focus is more on the supply (health care provider) side, although there also are some patient incentives
Problems with Indemnity Model
lack of coordinated care
high prices
high utilization
patients may not be able to afford to pay provider and wait for reimbursement
Managed Care Model
managed care is found in…
public insurance programs like Medicare and Medicaid
private health insurance (both employer-sponsored and individual)
contract is key. it gives the MCO control over the patient-provider transaction
Provider Networks
a group of providers under contract with the insurer
providers typically accept lower reimbursement rates in exchange for being in the insurer’s provider network
the patient’s choice of providers is restricted or incentivized
provider networks can be broad (cover most providers) or narrow (cover few providers)
narrower provider network = lower costs
key distinction: some plans allow patients to use out of network providers (with higher out of pocket charge higher cost-sharing) while other plans have no coverage for services obtained from out of network providers
Why are narrow network plans cheaper?
plans negotiate with providers to get lower reimbursement rates
plans have fewer high-cost providers in the network
premiums are based on enrollee’s expected health care costs and patients who choose narrow network plans are healthier (adverse selection)
key challenge: there is no standard definition for narrow vs broad network plans and people often don’t know what type of plan they are choosing
Surprise Bills
no coverage: patient pays full provider charges
higher cost-sharing for non-network or non-preferred providers
balance billing: patient is charged difference between insurance allowed amount and provider charges
balance billing is usually prohibited for network providers because the health plan contracts require that the providers “accept assignment”
No Surprises Act: emergency care received from out of network provider
patients pay in network cost-sharing rate
no balance billing
insurer goes through arbitration process with provider to determine payment amount
ground ambulance fees were excluded from the law and are one of the big contributers to surprise bills
No Surprises Act: non-emergency care received from out of network provider at in network facility
protection on applies to some services
patients pay in network cost-sharing rate
balance billing prohibited in some cases and requires signed consent in other cases
insurer goes through arbitration process with provider to determine payment amount
No Surprises Act: non-emergency care received from out of network provider at out of network facility
no protections, so even if service is covered, out of network rates and balance billing apply
this isn’t directly related to provider networks, but starting to see more surprise bills due to “facility fees”
Fee for Service
the more you do, the more you get paid
in some managed care models, providers trade lower FFS rates in exchange for being in the insurer’s provider network
if patients are sicker, the payer bears the risk
physicians are incentivized to increase the volume of care
Capitation
the more you do, the less profit you make
capitation is a prospective per member payment for a specified time period
used in some managed care plans
the amount of the payment may be based on past utilization, health status, age/gender, etc.
more common for primary physicians
payment may include labs and other costs
if patients are sicker, the provider bears the risk
physicians are incentivized to minimize unnecessary clinical services
Primary Case Manger/Gatekeeper
under this arrangement, all health care must be accessed through the gatekeeper physician - usually a primary care physician (PCP). to see a specialist, the patient must be referred by the PCP or the MCO will not pay for the specialist visit
this arrangement used to be common, but now most states have some form of direct access to specialists law. under these laws, patients must be able to access some types of mspecialists without PCP referral
Prospective Utilization Review
review is done prior to obtaining the service (ex. prior authorization)
Retrospective Utilization Review
review is done after the service is used. can be for specific services, specific physicians, or specific provider groups
Case-Management of high-cost patients
patients with complex health care needs or high expected health care costs receive extra services to improve their health and/or lower costs
may involve a nurse or other health care provider employed by the managed care plan working with the patient or the patient’s health care providers to provide more efficient and/or higher quality care
Disease state management
similar to case management, except patients are selected due to having a certain disease
Educational activities
one example is a letter to prescribers who prescribe higher cost drugs more often than peers in their specialty area
Traditional HMO
no coverage for out of network providers
primary care physician as “gatekeeper”
providers financially at risk and payment is often capitation
in some HMOs, the HMO employs the providers (staff model HMO)
POS
patients can see out of network providers
primary care physician as “gatekeeper”
payment can be capitation
EPO
no coverage for out of network providers
can see specialists without referral
PPO
patients can see out of network providers but may pay more
FFS payment, with discounted rate paid to network providers
providers not at risk
emphasize utilization management
can see specialists without referral
Payment System Problems
a capitation payment system rewards providers for giving less care. this system has lower costs but there are concerns about poor quality and patient dissatisfaction
a fee for service payment system rewards providers for providing more care which leads to higher costs. the extra care could lead to better or worse outcomes for patients
dissatisfaction wiith these two payment systems led to value-based health care delivery models
Value-Based Health Care Delivery Models
accountable care organizations (ACOs)
patient-centered medical home (PCMH)
basic principle: work with health care providers “behind the scenes” to incentivize them to control costs AND improve quality
Patient-Centered Medical Home
PCHM is a model of providing primary care, not a type of insurance plan
patients are in a PCMH if their primary care provider has a PCMH designation
PCMH has 5 key components (comprehensive care, coordinated care, patient-centered, accessible services, quality and safety)
Accountable Care Organization
voluntary contractual arrangement between different groups of health care providers who work together to reduce health care spending while improving quality of care
not a type of insurance plan
ACOs contract with private insurers, Medicare, and Medicaid. CMS has been a big driver for ACOs. providers may be in more than one ACO
patients don’t enroll in an ACO. patients are assigned to an ACO if their main providers are in an ACO. they are in both the ACO and their original health insurance plan
if health care spending for patients assigned to an ACO is sufficiently reduced and the ACO meets designated quality measures, some of the savings will be returned to the ACO
Medicare ACO - Shared Savings Program (SSP)
ACOs agree to take responsibility for the quality and cost of Medicare fee for service beneficiaries who are assigned to the ACO
currently there are ~450 Medicare SSP ACOs
beneficiaries assigned to an ACO based on either their selection of a primary care provider or via claims data on provider visits
ACOs earn (or lose) money based on
meeting minimum standards on quality measures AND
having savings (or extra costs) relative to projected costs for assigned beneficiaries
SSP ACOs can choose from different tracks, but most tracks have two-sided risk
ACO decides how to distribute any shared savings to their affiliated providers
Medicare ACO Quality Measures
patient/caregiver experienc
patient’s rating of provider
coordination of care/patient safety
percent of patients screened for future fall risk
preventive health care
percent of patients aged 6 months and older who received an influenza vaccination
health outcomed for at-risk populations
percentage of diabetes patients with poor HbA1c control
Charity Care
helps patients pay for health care services
services offered at reduced fee or no fee
offered by health care providers
ex. hospitals, clinics, community health centers
funded by public and private sources
ACO
falls under the value-based health care delivery model
contractutal arrangement between provider groups
patients can go anywhere to receive care
patients are retrospectively assigned to an ACO based on their main providers
primarily fee for service payment
ACO must meet quality measures to share in savings
HMO
falls under the managed care model
type of insurance plan
patients often required to use in network providers
use of capitation payment is common
use of quality measures is optional
Consumer Directed Health Plans
high-deductible health plans (HDHPs)
health savings accounts (HSAs)
basic principle: control health care spending by controlling patient demand for health care and making patients more price sensitive
consumer directed health plans are often listed as a separate type of plan, but they can be combined with any type of managed care plan or traditional indemnity insurance
High-Deductible Health Plans
for federal tax purposes, the minimum deductible to be considered a HDHP is 1700/3400 single/family for 2026, but deductibles often are much higher
most health plans available through the ACA health exchanges are HDHPs and HDHPs are becoming more common in employer health plans
premiums typically lower than other plan designs
can be tied to a health savings account (HSA) if follow certain rules
ACA preventiv care exempt from the deductible
works best for high income, healthy populations with good health literacy
Health Savings Accounts
allows for tax-free payment of eligible medical expenses
tax deductible contributions
no taxes on earned interest
who benefits most from this tax exemption?
must be tied to a HDHP meeting the federal minimum deductible
owned by an individual, not employer
max annual contributions generally are 4400/8740 single/family for 2026
employers and/or employees can contribute
balances in HSAs can accumulate over time and can be used to save for medical expenses in retirement
this is different from a flexible spending account (FSA) where to money generally must be spent annually
Challenges with HDHPs
people with HDHPs/HSAs may forgo needed care
either can’t afford deductible or trying not to use the money in their HSA
research shows that HDHPs reduce the use of both high value and low value care. even use of free preventative care that is excluded from the deductible is reduced
premise of HDHPs is that people will be more price concious if they are paying the full cost, but it is difficuly to obtain accurate prices
health care costs are highly concentrated (5%/50% problem). HDHPs have a small effect on overall costs
Mechanisms that help patients pay for health care services
charity care
Methods of paying health care providers for health care services delivered
per case
per service
per diem
Amount of money spent on health care
hospital care
physician services
other personal healthcare
prescription drugs
non-medical insurance expenditures
clinical services
Who pays the bill?
private health insurance
medicare
medicaid
out of pocket
other third party payers and programs
Medicare
public health insurance that provides coverage for elderly, disabled, and individuals with end-stage renal disease
is administered and funded by the federal government
medicare spending is 14% of federal spending
Medicare eligibility
>65 years - elderly
<65 years
disabled - waiting period: must get disability benefits from social security for 24 months before eligible for Medicare
individuals with end-stage renal disease - kidney transplant, dialysis
Medicare Part A
inpatient hospital care (room and board, nursing care, medications), skilled nursing facility care, home health care, hospice care
Medicare Part B
physician services, clinical laboratory services, home health care, preventative services, durable medical equipment, some prescription medications
Medicare Part D
outpatient prescription medications (not over-the-counter medications)
Services not covered by Medicare
hearing aids
eye examinations related to prescribing glasses
eyeglasses/contact lenses
dental: cleanings, fillings, tooth extractions, dentures
long-term care
Medicare Part A Funding and Premiums
funding: payroll tax on earnings paid by employers and employees and part a premiums
premiums: most medicare beneficiaries do not have to pay premiums to have part a, “premium-free part a”
Medicare Part B Funding and Premiums
funding: government contributions and part b premiums
premiums: $202.90 to $689.90 per month in 2026
Medicare Part D Funding and Premiums
funding: government contributions and part d premiums
premiums: vary based on plan chosen
Medicare Enrollment Periods
become eligible for Medicare because of age and do not have employer sponsored coverage - initial enrollment period lasting 7 months
if do not enroll during inital enrollment period must wait until…
part b - january 1 - march 31
part d - october 15 - december 7
must be enrolled in part a or part b to enroll in part d
Medicare Part B Late Enrollment Penalties
if not enrolled during initial enrollment period, late enrollment penalty added to premium when decide to enroll
duration of penalty is for as long as you have part b
amount of penalty depends on how long without part b
Medicare Part D Late Enrollment Penalties
if not enrolled during initial enrollment period and without creditable prescription drug coverage for >63 days, late enrollment penalty added to premium when decide to enroll
duration of penalty is for as long as you have part d
amount of penalty depends on how long without part d
Medicare Part A: more characteristics
coverage through federal government
uniform availabilty
uniform covered services, cost-sharing, and providers
uniform premiums
Medicare Part B: more characteristics
overage through federal government
uniform availabilty
uniform covered services, cost-sharing, and providers
uniform premiums
general enrollment period: enroll in part b
Medicare Part B: more characteristics
drug plans offered by private insurance companies, approved by CMS
available plans depend on where beneficiary lives (region)
covered medications, cost-sharing, and network outpatient pharmacies vary by plan
premiums vary by plan
open enrollment period: enroll in part d, disenroll from part d, or switch plans. decision in effect for following calendar year
Medicare Cost-Sharing for Part A
part a deductible applies to some services
coinsurance: some services
copayment: some services
no OOPM
Medicare Cost-Sharing for Part B
part b deductible applies to some services
coinsurance: some services (typical coinsurance for part b services is 20%)
copayment: some services
no OOPM
Medicare Supplement Insurance (Medigap)
there are “gaps” in medicare coverage (ex. cost-sharing)
purpose of medigap: fill “gaps” in medicare coverage
medigap offered by private insurance companies
plans identified by single letter (ex. plan K, plan M)
benefits
all medigap provide basic benefits applying to part a and part b (not part d)
option to choose medigap with additional benefits
eligibility
must be enrolled in part a and part b
Medicare Part D cost-sharing
beneficiaries are responsible for paying a portion of the cost of their medications
drug plans use deductibles, coinsurances, copayments, and out-of-pocket maximums
cost-sharing varies by plan
Outpatient Prescription Vaccines covered by Part B
pneumococcaal vaccine: covered
influenza vaccine: covered
hepatitis B vaccine: covered for beneficiaries at high or medium risk of contracting hepatitis B (beneficiaries with end-stage renal disease, certain beneficiaries with hemophilia, health care professionals in frequent contact with blood or other bodily fluids)
covid-19 vaccine: covered
other vaccines: covered by part b if directly related to treatment of an injury or direct exposure to a disease or condition
Outpatient Prescription Vaccines covered by Part D
pneumococcaal vaccine: not covered
influenza vaccine: not covered
hepatitis B vaccine: covered by part d for beneficiaries at low risk of contraction hepatitis B
covid-19 vaccine: not covered
other vaccines: covered by part d in absence of injury or direct exposure
Downsides of Medicare Part A and Part B
“gaps” in coverage
cost-sharing - deductibles, coinsurance, copayments, no out-of-pocket maximum
noncovered services
Addressing Downsides of Medicare Part A and Part B (Medicare Supplement Insurance)
downsides
not as good at filling the “gap” of noncovered services as it is at filling the “gap” of cost-sharing
premium
must be enrolled in part a and part b to have medicare supplement insurance
medicare supplement insurance is not part of medicare
Addressing Downsides of Medicare Part A and Part B (Medicare advantage)
health plans offered by private insurance companies, approved by CMS
available plans depend on where beneficiary lives
must be enrolled in part a and part b to choose medicare advantage
medicare advantage is a part of medicare
all plans cover services covered by medicare part a and b
all plans have out-of-pocket maximum for part a and b services
cost-sharing (including OOPM), coverage of noncovered services, and premium vary by plan
downsides - provider network varies by plan, may need a referral to see a specialist
Coverage of Outpatient Prescription Medications
medicare supplement insurance does not impact coverage for outpatient prescription medications
beneficiary with traditional/original medicare who wants coverage for outpatient prescription medications selects a separate medicare drug plan (stand-alone prescription drug plan, PDP)
beneficiary who chooses medicare advantage and wants coverage for outpatient prescription medications should select a medicare advantage plan that covers medications (MA-PD)
Medicaid
public health insurance program that provides coverage for low-income individuals
administered by states in accordance with federal guidelines
jointly funded by the federal and state governments
state participation in medicaid is voluntary. states are not required to offer a medicaid program, but all do
medicaid spending is 10% of total federal spending
Traditional Medicaid Eligibility
>65 years old: elderly
<65 years old
children
parents
pregnant women
disabled
blind
financial eligibility
to be eligible for medicaid, a person’s household income cannot be higher than cutoff established by the state
a state cannot drop its cutoff for medicaid eligibility below the lowest cutoff allowed by federal guidelines
Age 65 or older
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - receiving supplemental security income (SSI)
Under age 1
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - 133% FPL
Age 1 to age 5
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - 133% FPL
Age 6-18
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - 133% FPL
Parent
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - state-specific
Pregnant woman
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - 133% FPL
Disabled
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - receiving supplemental security income (SSI)
Blind
lowest cutoff for medicaid eligibility allowed by federal guidelines - receiving supplemental security income (SSI)
Mandatory Services Covered by Traditional Medicaid
inpatient and outpatient hospital services
early and periodic screening, diagnostic, and treatment services
nursing facility services
home health services
physician services
rural health clinic services
federally qualified health center services
laboratory and x-ray services
family planning services
nurse midwife and practitioner services
freestanding birth center services
transportation to medical care
tobacco cessation counseling for pregnant women
Optional Services Covered by Traditional Medicaid (vary by state)
prescription drugs
clinic services
physical therapy
speach, hearing, and language disorder services
other diagnostic, screening, preventive, and rehabilitative services
podiatry services
optometry services
dental services
dentures
eyeglasses
chiropractic services
hospice
Traditional Medicaid Funding
jointly funded by the federal and state governments
health care services for medicaid enrollees in a state being paid for by both the federal and state government
how much the federal government pays is determined by a formula defined by law
minimum of 50%
high percentage for states with lower per capita income (as high as 77% in 2026)
ACA Medicaid Expansion Pathway
affordable care act (ACA) signed into law in 2010
created new pathway for medicaid eligibility that would begin in 2014 → the ACA medicaid expansion pathway
states allowed to choose whether they want to permit this pathway
ACA Medicaid Expansion Eligibility
age 19 to age 6
not eligible via traditional medicaid pathway
required cutoff for ACA medicaid expansion eligibility
138% FPL
ACA Medicaid Expansion Covered Services
ten essential health benefits
ambulatory patient services (outpatient care)
emergency services
hospitalization
pregnancy, maternity, and new born care
mental health and substance use disorder services
prescription drugs
rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices
laboratory services
preventative and wellness services and chronic disease management
pediatric services, including oral and vision care
ACA Medicaid Expansion Funding
jointly funded by the federal and state governments
health care services for medicaid enrollees in a state being paid for by both the federal and state government
the federal government pays 90% (since 2020)
2014-2016 - 100%
2017 - 95%
2018 - 94%
2019 - 93%
Problem created by states choosing not to adopt ACA Medicaid expansion eligibility pathway
limited coverage options for a group of low-income individuals
household income <100% FPL
age 19 to age 64
residing in state thay has not adopted ACA medicaid expansion eligibility pathway
not eligible via traditional medicaid pathway
employer-sponsored insurance
may not be eligible
if eligible, may not be affordable for individual with household income <100% FPL
individual health insurance without financial assistance
may not be affordable for individual with household income <100% FPL
Dual Eligibles
enrolled in medicare part a and/or part b and eligible for some form of medicaid benefit
Medicaid: filling “gaps” in Medicare Part A and Part B
filling “gap” of noncovered services
option for those who are eligible based on income and resources
medicaid pays for long-term care, eyeglasses, etc.
medicaid pays for medicare part a and/or part b premiums
Part D Extra Help
extra help
program to help people pay for part d costs
automatically qualify for extra help
full medicaid
getting help from medicaid with part b premiums
apply for extra help
eligibility based on income and resources
level of extra help
full extra help
partial extra help - since 2024, everyone who qualifies gets full extra help
Insurance Coverage for Outpatient Prescription Drugs
medicare
medicaid
employer-sponsored health insurance
individual health insurance
What happens when insured patient fills prescription at outpatient pharmacy?
patient presents insurance card to pharmacy
pharmacy submits claim for medication to insurer before dispensing medication to see if insurer approves payment
What impact does insurance coverage for prescription drugs have on pharmacies?
need system to submit claims electronically to payer
instead of getting full payment at point of sale, receive only partial or no payment - remaining amount due to pharmacy arrives later
need process in place to verify if payment arrives and is correct amount
need to process prescription claims - verify enrollment and medication coverage, determine payment amount and patient cost-sharing, distribute payment
need to manage prescription drug utilization and spending
What happens if insurer does not manage prescription drug utilization and spending?
may result in extra dollars spent on drugs with out extra progress towards treatment goals
Formulary
a listing of drug products that are covered under an insurance plan
also known as drug list, approved drug list, prescription drug list, formulary drug list, covered drug list
drugs on a formulary often catergorized into “tiers”
if drug not included on formulary, exception may be requested
Patient cost-sharing
under most insurance plans, patients contribute toward the cost of at least some covered prescription drugs
deductible
coinsurance
copayment
Formularies and cost-sharing
tiered formulary used in conjunction with tiered cost-sharing
Prior authorization
criteria must be met before insurer will pay for a drug for a patient
purpose: to provide coverage for a drug for certain individuals
Step Therapy
failure on one or more drugs before insurer will pay for a drug for a patient
purpose: to provide coverage for a drug for certain individuals
Days supply limitations
limit number of days of therapy that can be obtained in one fill and limit when insurer will pay for the drug again
purpose: prevent spending on drugs that may never be used or spending on drugs for a person who may no longer be enrolled with ensurer
Quantity limits
limit amount of medication that will be paid for a given number of days of therapy
purpose: prevent more costly administration of a drug
Insurance coverage for specialty drugs
specialty drugs may be covered under the medical benefit or the drug benefit
if covered under drug benefit, may use same drug utilization management tools used with traditional drugs
may see formulary tier composed solely of specialty drugs, with cost-sharing specific to that tier
How does insurer get pharmacy to agree to accept lower payment?
by offering inclusion in insurer’s pharmacy network
Manufacturer rebates
insurer gets rebates from the manufacturers of drugs dispensed to its enrollees
What is a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM)?
an organization that provides administrative and other services associated with processing prescription drug claims for payment and managing drug utilization and spending
hired by health insurance companies and self-insured employers
PBM services
processing of prescription drug claims
drug utilization management
pharmacy network management
rebate negotiation