Unit 5: Case Management, Pre-Trial Hearings and Trial Procedure in Magistrates’ and Crown Courts.

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/126

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

127 Terms

1
New cards

When are case management directions usually given in the magistrates' court?

Usually at the same hearing where D enters a not guilty plea (for either-way offences, after plea before venue/allocation), or sometimes at a later hearing. Some courts call it a pre-trial review.

2
New cards

How long do the standard magistrates' court directions allow to prepare for trial?

8 weeks (14 weeks if expert evidence is required).

3
New cards

What form records the magistrates' court case management directions?

The Magistrates' Court Trial Preparation Form. Parts 1-4 are completed by the parties and Part 5 records the court's directions.

4
New cards

When will a court issue a witness summons (s 97 MCA 1980)?

If it is satisfied that the witness can give material evidence and it is in the interests of justice. Procedure is in CrimPR Part 17.

5
New cards

What should a defence solicitor do before applying for a witness summons?

Ask the potential witness to confirm in writing that they will attend. If the answer is no (or there is no reply), write to the court asking it to issue a witness summons.

6
New cards

What must D serve on the CPS under s 6C CPIA 1996?

A notice of the names, addresses and dates of birth of any witnesses D intends to call, so the CPS can check for previous convictions.

7
New cards

Can the CPS interview defence witnesses?

Yes, via the police, as there is no property in a witness. A code of practice governs the interview (s 21A CPIA 1996).

8
New cards

Does D have to serve defence witness statements on the CPS?

No. The only exception is expert witness reports, which must be served before trial.

9
New cards

What must a defence solicitor do before instructing an expert on a legally aided case?

Obtain prior authority from the LAA.

10
New cards

What are the four conditions for a s 9 CJA 1967 witness statement to be admissible without the witness attending?

(1) Signed and dated. (2) Contains the prescribed declaration (true to best of knowledge and belief, liable to prosecution if wilfully false). (3) Copy served on the other parties before the hearing. (4) No objection from the other parties within 7 days.

11
New cards

When should s 9 statements be used, and by whom?

Only for evidence not in dispute. Either party can use the procedure, although the CPS routinely serves all its witness statements this way.

12
New cards

How should plans or photographs be verified at trial?

By a witness statement from the person who prepared the plan or took the photographs.

13
New cards

What is the difference between the IDPC and unused material?

IDPC is the evidence the CPS will rely on at trial and is served on D's solicitor. Unused material is everything else the CPS holds that it does not propose to rely on (e.g. a witness statement that does not help the prosecution).

14
New cards

When should the IDPC be published on Common Platform under the Transforming Summary Justice characteristics (2023 update)?

At least 5 days before the first hearing.

15
New cards

What do the TSJ characteristics say about plea credit for either-way offences that will go to the Crown Court?

To obtain maximum credit, a guilty plea must be entered at the magistrates' court.

16
New cards

When must a magistrates' court send an adult to the Crown Court under s 51(1) CDA 1998?

When charged with an offence triable only on indictment.

17
New cards

When will a related either-way offence be sent to the Crown Court alongside an indictable-only offence?

When it appears to the court to be related to the offence triable only on indictment (the 'requisite conditions').

18
New cards

What extra requirement applies before a related summary-only offence is sent alongside an indictable-only offence?

It must be related AND be punishable with imprisonment or involve obligatory or discretionary disqualification from driving (s 51(11) CDA 1998).

19
New cards

What is the purpose of the s 51 sending hearing and what does the magistrates' court do at it?

To decide whether an indictable-only offence is charged and whether there are related offences to be sent. The court sets a PTPH date (or preliminary hearing date), remands D on bail or in custody, gives standard directions (unless a preliminary hearing is to be held) and gives D a s 51D notice of the offences and the Crown Court.

20
New cards

When is an either-way offence sent to the Crown Court?

When D pleads not guilty at plea before venue and either the magistrates decline jurisdiction or D elects Crown Court trial. D is sent forthwith (s 51(1) CDA 1998).

21
New cards

Which summary-only offences can be tried at the Crown Court under s 40 CJA 1988, and when?

Common assault, taking a conveyance without consent, driving whilst disqualified and criminal damage, if founded on the same facts as the either-way offence or part of a series of offences of the same or similar character.

22
New cards

D is sent for trial on an either-way offence and also faces a related imprisonable summary-only offence. What happens if D is convicted of the either-way offence and pleads guilty to the summary offence?

The Crown Court can sentence for the summary offence, but only with the sentencing powers of the magistrates.

23
New cards

What happens to the summary-only offence if D is acquitted of the either-way offence or pleads not guilty to the summary offence?

It must be remitted to the magistrates' court for trial.

24
New cards

When will a Crown Court preliminary hearing take place for an indictable-only offence?

If: case management issues need resolving; trial likely to exceed 4 weeks; early trial date desirable; D is under 18; or a guilty plea is likely and D could be sentenced at the hearing.

25
New cards

What is the time limit for a preliminary hearing?

Within 10 business days of the magistrates sending the case to the Crown Court.

26
New cards

What is the PTPH and when should it take place?

The first Crown Court hearing where no preliminary hearing is held. D enters their plea and, if not guilty, the judge gives further case management directions. It should take place within 20 business days of sending.

27
New cards

What happens at arraignment?

The counts on the indictment are put to D, who pleads guilty or not guilty. If D pleads guilty to some counts only, the jury is not told about the counts already pleaded to.

28
New cards

When will the CPS offer no evidence at arraignment, and what is the result?

When D agrees to plead guilty to some counts on the basis that other counts are dropped, or when new evidence means there is no longer a reasonable prospect of conviction. The judge orders a not guilty verdict.

29
New cards

What does it mean for a count to 'lie on the court file'?

The count is left on the file instead of the CPS offering no evidence. No not guilty verdict is entered and, with the court's leave, the CPS may be allowed to reopen the case later.

30
New cards

What can the judge do if D pleads guilty at the PTPH?

Sentence immediately, or adjourn for pre-sentence reports (e.g. medical or Probation Service reports). D is bailed or remanded meanwhile.

31
New cards

What is a Newton hearing?

A separate hearing held where D pleads guilty but disputes the prosecution's factual allegations, to decide the factual basis on which D will be sentenced.

32
New cards

What is a Goodyear indication?

An advance indication by the judge at the PTPH of the likely sentence if D pleads guilty at that stage. D must specifically ask for it, and it is binding if D then pleads guilty (R v Goodyear [2005]).

33
New cards

What information must the advocates be able to give the judge at the PTPH after a not guilty plea?

Summary of the issues; number of oral witnesses and trial length; whether interview transcripts need editing; whether a defence statement has been served and is adequate; further prosecution evidence; disputes over unused material disclosure; expert evidence; hearsay and bad character directions; special measures; facts to be admitted; points of law and admissibility; availability dates of witnesses and advocates.

34
New cards

What are the two ways the judge can list a case for trial at the PTPH?

Fix a trial date, or place the case in the 'warned list' (cases awaiting trial without a fixed date). The Crown Court tells D's solicitor shortly before trial is due to start.

35
New cards

When can a defendant change a not guilty plea to guilty?

At any time before the jury returns its verdict, at the judge's discretion. Common examples are after a failed submission of no case to answer, or after a ruling that removes D's intended defence.

36
New cards

Which Act contains the disclosure obligations for both CPS and defence?

The Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act (CPIA) 1996.

37
New cards

What is the s 3 CPIA 1996 test for prosecution disclosure of unused material?

Material must be disclosed if it might reasonably be considered capable of undermining the case for the prosecution or of assisting the case for the accused.

38
New cards

Give examples of unused material that must be disclosed under s 3.

The first description of a suspect that differs from D; information from D indicating an innocent explanation; material casting doubt on a witness's reliability (e.g. previous convictions); material casting doubt on a confession's reliability; witness statements supporting D's account.

39
New cards

Mahmood is charged with assault and claims Selim threw the first punch. The CPS holds a statement from a witness saying Selim threw it but will not call that witness. Must it disclose the statement?

Yes. It undermines the prosecution case and assists D's self-defence claim, so it meets the s 3 test.

40
New cards

What does the CPS usually send to D's solicitor for unused material?

A schedule of all non-sensitive unused material, with copies of any items on the schedule that satisfy the s 3 test.

41
New cards

Is the CPS's duty of disclosure ongoing?

Yes (s 7A CPIA 1996). It must apply the test to any further material it receives, and consider further disclosure in light of the defence case.

42
New cards

What are examples of sensitive unused material?

National security or intelligence material; identity of informants or undercover officers; police techniques and methods (e.g. covert surveillance); material relating to a child witness (e.g. local authority social services material).

43
New cards

How can the CPS withhold sensitive material that meets the s 3 test?

Only by applying to the court for a finding of public interest immunity (R v Ward). The application is under CrimPR Part 15 and is often made ex parte (without notice to the defence).

44
New cards

Is a defence statement compulsory in the magistrates' court?

No. It is voluntary and extremely rare in practice, as the risk of giving away the defence outweighs the possible gain of extra disclosure. It is worth considering only if it would prompt the CPS to disclose further helpful unused material.

45
New cards

Is a defence statement compulsory in the Crown Court?

Yes, under s 5 CPIA 1996 ('compulsory disclosure'). It is enforced by the court being able to draw an adverse inference if none is provided.

46
New cards

What are the time limits for serving a defence statement?

The chapter text says 14 days (magistrates') and 28 days (Crown Court) from the CPS's initial disclosure. The flowchart and standard time limits say 10 business days (magistrates') and 20 business days (Crown Court). Check which version your course uses.

47
New cards

What does s 5A CPIA 1996 allow in a case with co-accused?

The court can order that each defendant's defence statement be served on the other defendants.

48
New cards

What must a defence statement contain (s 6A CPIA 1996)?

The nature of the defence (e.g. alibi, self-defence); the matters of fact on which D takes issue with the prosecution and why; particulars of facts D relies on; points of law (including admissibility) and authority; and for alibi, the name, address and date of birth of any alibi witness (or as much as is known).

49
New cards

Is there a duty to update a defence statement?

Yes, a continuing duty if the details change before trial, e.g. a new alibi witness comes forward (s 6B(3) CPIA 1996).

50
New cards

Why must D approve the defence statement before it is served (s 6E)?

It is deemed to be given with D's authority unless the contrary is proved. Usually the solicitor signs the served original and D signs a copy for the solicitor's file.

51
New cards

When can an adverse inference be drawn under s 11 CPIA 1996?

If D fails to provide a defence statement, serves it late, serves an incomplete one, serves one inconsistent with the defence at trial, or fails to update it.

52
New cards

Who can comment on a defence disclosure fault and what can happen?

The court or, with leave, another party (the prosecution or a co-accused) may comment, and the court or jury may draw such inferences as appear proper.

53
New cards

Amanda does not serve a defence statement but raises an alibi at trial. What is the consequence?

The judge or, with leave, the prosecution may comment, and the jury may draw an adverse inference.

54
New cards

Javed's defence statement says alibi, but at trial he raises self-defence. What is the consequence?

The disparity between the statement and trial defence allows comment and a likely adverse inference (s 11).

55
New cards

What is the only 'reward' for D serving a defence statement?

The CPS must review its unused material in light of it and disclose anything now capable of undermining the prosecution case or assisting D (s 7A CPIA 1996).

56
New cards

In the Sergio example, why did the CPS have to disclose the car-cleaning receipts after the defence statement?

Before, there was no indication of the defence so the receipts met neither limb of s 3. The defence statement said Sergio only valeted cars, so the receipts now assisted his innocent explanation.

57
New cards

What is a s 8(2) CPIA 1996 application?

An application by D for an order that the CPS disclose material, if the CPS has failed to comply with its continuing duty. D must have served a defence statement, have reasonable cause to believe material exists that should have been disclosed, and have set out in detail the material he thinks the CPS holds. Procedure is in CrimPR Part 15.

58
New cards

What are the five parts of the Magistrates' Court Trial Preparation Form?

Part 1: both parties (contact details and representation). Part 2: prosecutor. Part 3: defendant. Part 4: witnesses (all parties and court). Part 5: court's decisions and directions.

59
New cards

What must parties do if information on the trial preparation form changes after directions are given?

Tell the court at once (CrimPR rules 1.2(1) and 3.12).

60
New cards

What do the standard trial preparation time limits total?

6 weeks (9 weeks if expert evidence directions apply). The court can vary them.

61
New cards

What are the key standard time limits for written admissions, expert reports and certifying trial readiness?

Written admissions: 10 business days. Expert report: 20 business days. Certify trial readiness: at least 10 business days before trial.

62
New cards

What are the standard time limits for defence witness statements to be read at trial and objections to them?

Defence witness statements: served at least 10 business days before trial. Objection to a statement being read: within 5 business days of service.

63
New cards

What are the standard time limits for prosecution hearsay and bad character notices, and for skeleton arguments?

Prosecution hearsay and bad character notices: 20 business days. Skeleton argument: at least 10 business days before trial.

64
New cards

On the disclosure flowchart, what happens for an either-way offence that will be tried in the Crown Court?

CPS must serve all evidence it will rely on before the sending hearing. Unused material is served at or before the PTPH (or as soon as reasonably possible after) in line with Crown Court directions.

65
New cards

On the disclosure flowchart, what happens for an indictable-only offence?

Case is sent at the s 51 sending hearing, and the magistrates give directions for disclosure of all evidence to be relied on. The CPS serves that evidence and unused material, then D serves a defence statement, then after the PTPH the prosecution reviews disclosure in light of it and keeps reviewing.

66
New cards
Who bears the burden of proof in a criminal trial and what is the standard?
The prosecution, throughout (subject to a few statutory defences and insanity). The standard is beyond reasonable doubt (the court must be sure of guilt).
67
New cards
Why does the defendant usually testify even though they do not have to prove anything?
To discharge an evidential burden for defences such as alibi or self-defence.
68
New cards
What is the order of events at a magistrates' court trial?
Prosecution opening speech; prosecution witnesses; possible submission of no case to answer; defence witnesses (defendant first); optional prosecution closing; defence closing; magistrates retire; verdict; sentence or adjourn for reports.
69
New cards
What does the prosecution opening speech in the magistrates' court cover, and is it evidence?
It is not evidence. It sets the scene: facts of the charge, relevant law, what must be proved, burden and standard of proof, the witnesses to be called and any anticipated points of law (e.g. Turnbull, ss 76 and 78 PACE).
70
New cards
Who is usually the first prosecution witness, and when is evidence unsworn?
The complainant. Evidence is sworn (oath or affirmation) unless the witness is under 14, in which case it is unsworn (s 55 YJCEA 1999).
71
New cards
How is the evidence of a prosecution witness who does not attend court dealt with?
The prosecutor reads out their statement (s 9 CJA 1967 statement the defence has not objected to, or hearsay evidence).
72
New cards
How is a police station interview put before the magistrates?
A summary or transcript is read out unless the defence objects (e.g. the summary omits points helpful to the defence), in which case the audio recording is played.
73
New cards
What is a voir dire?
A "trial within a trial" to decide the admissibility of disputed evidence, e.g. a confession (s 76 PACE), identification (s 78 PACE) or bad character.
74
New cards
What is the difficulty with a voir dire in the magistrates' court?
The magistrates decide both law and fact, so they still know about evidence they rule inadmissible. This is one reason a defendant may elect Crown Court trial for an either-way offence.
75
New cards
How do magistrates' courts try to avoid the voir dire problem?
Hear the disputed evidence in the trial and rule on it at the no case to answer stage or in closing speeches, or hold a pre-trial admissibility hearing before a different bench.
76
New cards
How does a voir dire work in the Crown Court?
The judge holds it in the absence of the jury, so the jury never hears evidence ruled inadmissible. If admitted, the defence can still attack its reliability or cogency in cross-examination.
77
New cards
What is a submission of no case to answer and when is it made?
A request by the defendant's solicitor that the court dismiss the case, made at the close of the prosecution case because the prosecution has failed to discharge its evidential burden. The test is from R v Galbraith.
78
New cards
What are the two grounds for a submission of no case to answer (Galbraith)?
(1) The prosecution has failed to put forward evidence to prove an essential element of the offence; or (2) the prosecution evidence is so discredited in cross-examination or so manifestly unreliable that no reasonable tribunal could safely convict.
79
New cards
Give an example of a no case to answer submission based on a missing element.
Harvinder is charged with theft of a bicycle but the prosecution produces no evidence that it belonged to another person. That is an essential element of theft, so the defence should submit no case to answer.
80
New cards
What principle did R v Sardar apply to no case to answer submissions?
Where there is direct evidence capable of proving the charge, there is always a case to answer, however weak. With circumstantial evidence, there is no case only if it is not capable in law of supporting a conviction.
81
New cards
Why is a no case to answer submission usually hard to win?
Not much prosecution evidence is needed to get past the halfway stage.
82
New cards
What happens if a no case to answer submission succeeds or fails?
Succeeds: the magistrates dismiss the case (in the Crown Court the judge directs the jury to acquit). Fails: the defence case follows, which does not mean the prosecution is entitled to a conviction.
83
New cards
Is the defendant a competent and compellable witness for their own defence?
Competent but not compellable (s 1(1) Criminal Evidence Act 1898). The solicitor should always discuss with the client whether to testify.
84
New cards
What is the effect of s 35 CJPOA 1994 if the defendant does not testify?
If the prosecution has raised issues calling for an explanation, the court may infer that D has no explanation, or none that would stand up to cross-examination.
85
New cards
What are the advantages of the defendant giving evidence?
Avoids s 35 adverse inferences; allows D to dispute prosecution evidence and explain their conduct (e.g. why they falsely confessed); enhances credibility if D repeats their police interview account.
86
New cards
What are the disadvantages of the defendant giving evidence?
D could incriminate themselves, and their account may not stand up to cross-examination.
87
New cards
In what order are defence witnesses called, and why?
The defendant, if testifying, must be called first (s 79 PACE, unless the court directs otherwise) because D is in court throughout and could otherwise tailor their evidence to other witnesses. Other witnesses stay out of court until they have testified.
88
New cards
Can the prosecution make a closing speech in the magistrates' court?
Yes (r 24.3), but it is usually only exercised in more complex cases. If it does, the defence always speaks last.
89
New cards
Why does the defence nearly always make a closing speech in the magistrates' court, and is it evidence?
For the tactical importance of having the last word. It is not evidence.
90
New cards
What points should a defence closing speech include?
Keep it short; remind the court of the burden and standard of proof and that D need not prove innocence; refer back to the opening speech and where the case "came up short"; cover evidential issues (Turnbull warning, undermine disputed confession, downplay bad character); end by inviting a not guilty verdict.
91
New cards
How are verdicts reached in the magistrates' court, and where does an appeal go?
Usually a bench of three, deciding by majority (not unanimous). If found guilty, sentence immediately or adjourn for reports. Appeal against conviction and/or sentence goes to the Crown Court (Chapter 12).
92
New cards
How are functions split in a Crown Court trial?
Judge: decides points of law, directs the jury on the law, sums up and sentences. Jury (12): decides disputed facts and guilt or innocence.
93
New cards
Who can sit on a jury?
12 randomly selected people aged 18-75, on the electoral roll and resident in the UK for at least five years. Some are ineligible (e.g. mental disorder) or disqualified (e.g. on bail, many with custodial sentences) under Juries Act 1974 s 1.
94
New cards
Why is arraignment usually done before the jury is empanelled?
So the jury is not prejudiced by hearing D plead guilty to some counts and not guilty to others. The clerk only tells the jury the counts pleaded not guilty. Usually it has already happened at the PTPH.
95
New cards
What does the prosecution opening speech in the Crown Court usually contain?
The legal elements of the offence(s), an outline of the evidence to be called, and an explanation of the burden and standard of proof. It may also flag anticipated points of law and possible defences.
96
New cards
When can the defence make an opening speech in the Crown Court?
Only if the defence will call witnesses in addition to the defendant. Not if only D will give evidence.
97
New cards
What can a defendant do after an unsuccessful no case to answer submission in the Crown Court?
The judge may allow them to change their plea to guilty (e.g. they admitted guilt to their solicitor, or a ruling removed a defence they relied on).
98
New cards
How does a defendant change a plea from guilty to not guilty?
Apply in writing as soon as practicable after becoming aware of grounds for the change (r 25.5 CrimPR in the Crown Court; r 24.10 in the magistrates' court).
99
New cards
Order of closing speeches and summing up in the Crown Court?
Prosecution closing speech, then defence closing speech, then the judge's summing up.
100
New cards
What are the two parts of the judge's summing up?
Directions on the law (burden and standard of proof, legal requirements of the offence, other issues such as Turnbull or ss 34-37 CJPOA inferences) and a summary of the evidence. Misdirection is a common ground of appeal.