1/169
midterm questions, quiz questions, and NEED TO KNOWS FROM NOTES
EE vs IK
WHO HAS CONTROL
1. Behaviors 2. relationship 3. financial needs
Matters because - liability, applicability of laws, taxes, and benefits
TRUE
T/F If union or private employer violate section 7 rights, does the NLRA still apply?
Federal
If the case is the US district court - what law is that
Employment at Will
Fire or leave
At any time with or without reason
as long as not discriminatory or otherwise illegal.
Employees Exempt or Nonexempt for overtime pay
wage level
salary basis
classifications of their job
False
T/F If an employer's negligence causes an employee to be injured at work, the employee can bring a tort action for damages against the employer.
false - limited for ees in non work areas and non work time but non employees can be bammed completely
T/F work rules can prohibit ees from union solicitation
What is the employer's legitimate need to intrude on your privacy? And, what is the Employee's legitimate expectation of privacy?
what considerations must an employer balance in order to avoid (or prevail on) a violation of privacy complaint?
Judicial, where they handle, settle, and interpret case law. (SCT)
Legislative, where they "make" laws but they handle statutory laws. (US CONGRESS)
Executive, public and administrative law where they make executive decisions and orders as well as admin rules and regulations. (PRESIDENT)
Identify the three branches of government in the United States and the types of law each creates.
statutory law
law in books written by congress
judicial law
case by case sceneio basis law
A plaintiff is the person or group of people who start a civil lawsuit by filing a claim or complaint in court against another party.
The defendant is the person or group who is being accused of the claim the plaintiff is making.
A prima facie case is where a case is presented to the couurt with enough initial evidence to support all of their legal claims.
A motion is a request from one of the legal parties about an issue.
A appellant is the person who loses in trial court, either the plaintiff or defendant, and they take the case to court of appeals.
Explain briefly the following in the context of a legal proceeding: (1) Plaintiff (2) Defendant (3) Prima Facie Case (4) Motion (5) Appellant
Prima facie case: The plaintiff must present enough evidence to the court to support their claim.
Failure to meet the burden: If the plaintiff doesn’t, it isn’t considered a prima facie case. Even if the accusations are taken as true, they haven’t stated a recognized, lawful cause of action.
Motion to dismiss: This is a request to dismiss the case because the plaintiff failed to state a legal claim.
Court’s response: When a claim fails to state a legal cause of action, the court must grant the motion to dismiss.
If the plaintiff in a lawsuit fails to articulate the elements necessary to establish a prima facie case and the defendant files a motion to dismiss the case, what will the court do?
Is there a law? Does it apply, and to who? What does it require (or prohibit)?
Identify the three questions to ask when drafting a new policy or making a human resources decision.
public employers - constitutional prhiitions apply
private employers - does not have constituional prohibitions (exept private employer working on behalf of public agency)
EEO (equal employment opprotunity) / Titile VII Discrimination Applies to:
1964 - enacted
1965 - into practice
when was title VII enacted and into practice
section 1983
“if someone made decision as governing authority; no discrimination intent based on race”
section 1985
2 or more people conspiring together
section 1981
requires intentional discrimination based on race (ethnicity + ancestory)
extra facts about section 1981
Section 1981
1860
after reconstuction era
prhibits. discrimination of blacks and contracts (expanded to laws)
difference between ss 1981 and Title VII
1981 Title VII
all private EEs - 15 or more employees
4 years - 180 days or 300 with state workshare agreement
no cap on damages $ - cap on damages $
can go straight to court - have to go through gatekeeper (EEOC) first
only based on race (ethnicity and ancestory) - Race, color, religion, sex, national origin
only reason - A reason
civil rights act of 1964
- addresses discrimination in
housing, public accomodation (hotels, resturaunts, etc), education, employment (title 7)
rights under title 7 starting in 1965
employment goal
hire best qualified candidate
create good place to work (trust and communication)
definition of MGT (perfomance = abilitiy x motivation x E(?)
titile seven
foundation for modern EEO law
effective july 2 1965
ammendments: 1968, 1972, 1991, 2009
IS THERE A LAW (VII)
Yes - Title seven (equal employment opportunity)
What has to apply to title 7 for it to apply to the law
15 or more employees FOR PRIVATE (20+ calendar weeks???)
fed, state, and local goverments ~ foreign corporations?
^ each has different procedure enforcement
what does title seven prohibit after identifying it is a law and applies
discrimination, retaliation, harassment
refusal/failure to hire
termination of employment
terms and condiitions of employment
(all of these: discrimination of hiring/firing and other terms and conditions of employment based on protected classes)
What are the protected classes under title 7
race, color, sex, national origin, religion
michigan law prohibits what 3 additonal protected classes
height, weight, marital status
Gender identity laws
gender expressiona and sexual orientation; protection under title 7 is based on CASE LAW not statutory (aka not covered initially or legislatively, but case by case) SEX IS covered under 7
michigan gender identity laws
gender expression and sexual orientation is STATUTORILY protected
both state and federal law protect, but federally (legislative) is sex M/F and instead by case law
under title 7
terms and conditions of employment: cannot discriminate in promotions, job transfers, performance evaluations, trainings, etc (dont need to knwo legal difference between sex and gender)
When must an individual file a complaint with the EEOC in order for it to be timely?
An individual must file within 180 days with the EEOC in order for it to be timely, unless their state has a shared agency, then they may file within 300 days of the last occurence.
Identify and briefly explain the two primary classifications of discrimination claims.
1) Disparate Treatment - intentional discrimination in terms and conditions of employment, where the EER intentionally treats EEs or applicants differently due to their race, color, sex, religion, or national origin
2) Disparate Impact - the discriminatory effect of apparently neutral employment criteria/selection devices, which does not require intention to discriminate on behald of the EER
Identify three additional protected classes highlighted in class and related to employment pursuant to Michigan law.
height, weight, marital status
What are three primary goals of the EEOC?
1) administrative and judicial enforcement
2) education
3) technical assistance
Sexual orientation and gender identity discrimination are prohibited under both federal and state laws.
false
What is the significance of the Supreme Court's decision in McDonnell Douglas Corp v Green, 411 US 792 (1973)?
this decision set the president for how to establish a case of disparate treatment discrimination based on circumstantial evidence.
By articulating a prima facie case of disparate treatment discrimination, the plaintiff will win the lawsuit.
False
Identify the five identified protected classes when Title VII was enacted.
race, color, religion, sex, national origin
Identify the three primary prohibitions under Title VII.
discrimination in the hiring, firing, or terms and conditionws of employment, retaliation, and harassment
What is a BFOQ? When can it be used? When is it not permitted?
BFOQ - Bona Fide Occupational Qualification
Can be used - if it is necessary for safe and efficient business operations, and if it is based on sex, religion, or national origin
Cannot be used - if it is based on race or color, and cannot be for customer preference, coworker preference, or employer convenience.
what does EEOC stand for
Equal Employment opprotunity commission
The EEOC is the what?
the gatekeeper for a lawsuit; you cannot get to court without them.
they are not a lawsuit; instead they are a charge of discrimination to try and facilatate voluntary early solutions (resolution)
EEOC
administrative and judicial enforcement
education
technical assistance
file a suit with the EEOC within 90 days of the incident
eeoc will decide if they thing it COULD BE discrimination and issue a right to sue letter
they will try to get parties to engage in conciliation (voluntary)
ADR?
Alternative dispute resolution (alternative to a lawsuit)
idependant 3rd parties will try to resolve disputes without the court
Alternative Dispute Resolution
1) (EEOC) conciliation
2) mediation
3) arbitration
MDCR
Michigan department of civil rights
MDCR does what?
investigates and resolves discrimination complaints and works to prevent discrimination through educational programs that promote voluntary compliance with Civil Rights laws
enforce
prevent
serve
EEO Enforcement Procedure under Title 7:
filing a complaint
individual must file first with state or local agency authorized to deal with this issue (if such agency exists)
state agency role
employment opprotunity agencies “fair employment” or “human rights” commissions some state agencies have powers and jurisdiction beyond those given to the EEOC
Filing with Federal Title 7 Law Requires:
File within 180 days unless state has a work-share agreement, then file within 300
days begin counting after the last occurence of discrimination
Work Share Agreements
agency intitially recieves complaint and processes it
if EEO recieves it first,, it refers the complaint to the appropriate state agency
state agency can waive its right to process the complain and refer it back to the eeoc
(mostly sbout who has the administrative time to deal with it”
Once filed with local/state agency, complaintent must wait _____ days before filing complaint with the EEOC
60 days
when does a discrimination violation occur?
continuing violation
file within 180 (300) days of the latest incident of alleged continious violation
hostile environment harassment
file withing 180 (300) of the most recent discrete incident of harassment
Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act (2009)
file within 180 days (300) when pay policy adapted; Ee is subject to pay policy; ee affected by pay policy; each paycheck is a NEW violation
3 Q’s
is there a law ? - Title 7 (VII)
apply ? 15 or more EEs
Prohibit ? discrimination, retaliation, harassment on R, Rel, Col, Sex, N.O.
90 days
file your right to sue letter or it gets dismissed
EEOC Complaint procedure
1st - call a lawyer!
eeoc recieves (charge of discrimination (1 page)) properly filed complaint (from complainant)
eeoc has 10 days to serve notice of the complaint to the employer, union, or agency alleged to have discriminated (respondent)
1st thing call a lawyer to get a position statement, witnesses, documents, etc
eeoc conducts investicagtion to determine whether reasonable cause exists to believe it is true
(their opinion/answer is not final say it is just their thoguhts on the case, they are just gatekeeper)
if NO reasonable cause of discrimination is found:
complaint dismiesed
eeoc issues “notice of right to sue” file within 90 day period
IF REASONABLE CAUSE is found
eeoc tries to settle complaint throught voluntary conciliation/negotiation
1st - conciliation (voluntary, but usually choose not to)
2nd - right to sue
3rd - federal district court
complaint is settles
if voluntary procedures are unsuccessful
eeoc may file suit in a federal district court
eeoc issues “notice of right to sue”
(have to have PF case to make legal claim)
Two types of discrimination
Disparate Treatment
Disparate Impact
D. Treatment
intentional discrimination in terms and conditions of employmennt
employer is intentially treating employees or applicants differently because of their R, C, S, Rel, No
D. Impact
more often than not is unintentional
discriminatory effect of apparently neutral employment critera / selection devices ; does not require intention to discriminate on behalf of the EER
employment critera or selection device disproportionately disqualifies employees based on R C S Rel No
such as: test, screening device, that on its face looks not disciminatory but when applied excludes people in a protected class more than a non protected class
could be used to discriminate
How to prove D Treatement?
direct evidence = illegal discrimination (less illegal, more just discrimination) (motive)
circumstantial evidence (Q of F based on T of C) (direct evidence is “ilegal discrimination”)
How to prove D Imact
Proven based on stats of the 4/5th rule
“you’re excluding more poeple ina protected class by using this”
current eeoc was told ‘not to entertain disperate impact cases"‘
get the stats by EEOC persuing for class action
can you at times male decisions on protected classes?
yes, it is a BFOQ
BFOQ
Bona Fide Occupational Qualification
What is a BFOQ
has to be necessary for reasonable, safe, and efficient, business operations
based on sex, religion, national origin
NEVER based on race or color
cannot be for Customer preference, Coworker preference, or Convenience of the eer
what are the rules for a prima facie case of discrimination (framework)
1) protected class
2) qualified or satisfactory performance
3) adverse employment action
4) position open or granted to another or circumstances suggest unlawfully discriminatory motivations
Identify specific employment practices
statistical evidence impacts a protected class
McDonnel Douglas v Green case did what?
Set the precident for how to establish if a case of disparate treatment is discirimination based on on circumstantial evidence
After the PLaintiff (ee) presents PF case:
defendents rebuttal : articulate a LEGITIMATE NONDISCRIMINATORY REASON (LNDR) for its employment decision
JOB RELATED AND CONSISTENT WITH A BUSINESS NECESSITY
OR no evidence of disparate imapct
has to be stated and believable
what comes after the defendants rebuttal
plaintiffs burden: (PRETEXT)
(cover up on why LNDR is not believable)
discriminatory reason on why this action was motivated or rebuttal was not believable
section 1981 or title vii
section 1981 |. title VII
private employees | 15 or more employees
file within 4 years | 180/300 days
no cap on damages $ | cap on damages $
can go straight to court | have to go through gaekeeper of EEOC
ONLY RACE (ethnicity/ancestry) | R, C, Rel, NO, Sex
WHY and WHEN do disc cases usually get settled?
after PF case is presented, there is motion to dismiss (called the discovery) where employers will settle if it looks bad or actually is discirimination
if not, its a Q of F and goes to trial where they usually settle after m/SJ and the EER usually wins because if they think theyll lose theyll settle to not look bad
EEOC v DIAL case
the test to see how long they could carry heavy things for 7 minutes but the job only requires 10-30 seconds of carrying so it wiped out women and they hired mostly men.
Ttitlve VII discrimination needs:
uniform guidlines on EE selection
validating job requirements
and the 4/5th rule
retaliation
engaged in an activty protected or opposed a practice prohibited
suffered adverse action
causal link
gender discrimination 3Q’s
is there a law? : EPA and title 7 (state: elliot larsons)
does it apply?: 15 or more employees (1 or more employee)
what does it require/prohibit? : discrimination, harassment, retaliation based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin
can you have different standards for men and women’s dress codes
yes, but they have to be substantially similar (but not equal)
based on:
community acceptable social norms
related to legitimate business needs
and equally enforced S
Stereotyping case
price waterhouse v ann B hopkins
sr manager (accountant) went up for partnership
didnt get it even though very qualified
people said she was aggressive and “too mocho” and needed to walk and talk and look more feminine
ann brought case of title 7 against employer and she won and moved up to partner
does title 7 include sexual orientation, preference, identity, and expression ?
because of the bostoc v clayton county case, it concluded that OPIE sex are covered under federal and state law (sct cases; case law)
state law (elliot larsons, so statutorily MI sex discrimination includes OPIE)
Gender Discrimination in pay (EPA 1963)
can bring case under EPA or title 7 or usually both
EPA - equal pay for equal work, effort, skill, responisbility, and working conditions
defences: seniority systems, merit pay systems, productivity based increases, factors other than sex
EPA V title 7
| EPA | title VII
enforced by: EEOC | EEOC
initiating claim: EEOC or Court | EEOC
statitute of limitation: 2/3 years | 180/300 days
requirements of law: equal pay for equal work | prohibits sex discrimination in terms and conditions of employment
pregnancy is a BFOQ?
NO, PREGNANCY IS NOT A BFOQ
PREGNANCY DATES
1976 - sct decided title 7 didnt protect pregnant women
pregnant discrimination act of 1978 - you cant discrimination against a pregnant woman
young vs UPS case of 2015
basicaly if you have restrictions with your pregrnancy, if your eer has viable accomodations for the job you could still work or if they tell you of the risks and you choose to ignore you could still work
pregrant workers fairness act of 2023
PREGNANT WORKERS FAIRNESS ACT (PWFA) 2023
15 or more employees
covers temporary physical and mental limitiations due to pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition (morning sickness, back pain, PPD)
requires reasonable accomodations unless undue hardship
effective june of 2023 (EEOC rules june 2024)
Issues with PWFA: meijer vs burger king (sunrise)
slipped, which caused a pre-term birth
moms injury? is it workers comp? yes
is the babysitter injury (birth early and complications) workers comp? no baby isnt an employee
now BK is legally neglegant for babys death
Eer needs to outline job duties and risks and Ee has tp agre to them and then you dont breach your duty of safe work environemnt
sexual harassment 3
what is the workplace culture
policu and procedures that are enforced
awareness and trainign for ees
sexual harassment defined:
unewelcome sexualy-oriented conduct which has the purpose or effect of substantially interffering with an individuals emplpyment
what does unwelcome mean in terms of SH
not merely whether the individual participated but
unsolicited
uninvited
undesirable
offensive
Sexual Harassment 3 terms
unwanted, coercive, abusive
what is sexually- oriented conduct in terms of SH
unwelcome sexual advances
unwelcome requests for secual favors
any other communication or conduct of a secual or suggestive nature
verbal SH
off-color language, jokes, nicknames
suggestive comments
insults
sexual propositions
threats
repeated social invitiations
nonverbal SH
suggestive or insulting sounds (whistle, hum, wink)
whistling
obscene or crude gestures
photos, postcards “pin-ups”
pysical SH
touching (hugging?)
pinching
brushing of the body in any way
coerced sexual intercourse
assault
what is sustainable interference with SH
DO YOU HAVE ACTIONABLE LEGAL PROBLEM/CASE
inteferes with productivity
undermines employee morale
creates atmosphere of suspicion, hostillity, mistrust
can damage a persons reputation
TWO TYPE OF HARASSMENT
quid pro quo
hostile work environment
tqo types of quid pro quo
expressed : ill give you this in return for that
inplied : time for promotion and you dont get it even though you should because you said no to me 3 times
Can one instance of harassment be enough (HWE)
yes
if significantly aggregious and outragious
RADTKE v EVERETT set precident for standard of SH cases!!!!!!!!!!!
1) protected class
2) communication/cnduct based on sex
3) unwelcome
4) substantially interfered with employment and work environemnts
5) respondent superior
HWE prima facie case (5 elements)
protected class?
commincation / conduct based on sex
unwelcome
substantially interferred with employment or HWE (emotional /mental distress or termination of employment)
respondeat superior (there is a reason to hold the Eer responsible)