Mary Anne Warren's Personhood and the Moral Community

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/15

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary flashcards covering Mary Anne Warren's criteria of personhood, the distinction between genetic humanity and personhood, and objections regarding physical resemblance, potential personhood, and infanticide.

16 Terms

1
New cards

Person (Moral Sense)

A member of the moral community whose existence warrants some set of moral rights, most fundamentally the right to life.

2
New cards

Moral Community

The collective body of beings who warrant moral consideration and rights, functioning as active and capable participants.

3
New cards

Warren's Five Criteria of Personhood

A set of central attributes proposed by Mary Anne Warren to determine personhood; a being must possess at least one of these to the full extent to warrant full moral rights, though possessing all five is not required.

4
New cards

Fallacy of Equivocation (in Abortion Debates)

The logical error of confusing or conflating the genetic sense of being a human being with the moral sense of being a human being (a person).

5
New cards

Genetic Humanity

The biological status of being a member of the human species, which Warren argues is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for personhood.

6
New cards

Non-Necessity of Genetic Humanity

The principle that an entity does not have to be biologically human to be a person, exemplified by hypothetical conscious self-aware robots or intelligent alien inhabitants.

7
New cards

Non-Sufficiency of Genetic Humanity

The principle that biological humanity alone does not guarantee personhood, exemplified by fetuses or humans whose consciousness has been permanently obliterated.

8
New cards

Resemblance Objection

The anti-abortion objection asserting that fetuses warrant a right to life because they develop physical traits, heartbeats, or brain activity that resemble adult human persons.

9
New cards

Rudimentary Consciousness

A basic, developing state of conscious experience that Warren acknowledges begins to appear in a human fetus at approximately 20 to 24 weeks of gestation.

10
New cards

Potentiality Objection

The argument that even if a fetus does not currently satisfy the criteria for personhood, its potential to develop into an actual person warrants a full right to life.

11
New cards

Actuality Trumps Potentiality

Warren's principle stating that the rights of an actual person (such as a woman's right to liberty and bodily autonomy) always outweigh whatever potential rights are attributed to a potential person.

12
New cards

Space Explorer Thought Experiment

A hypothetical case used by Warren involving an abducted explorer whose cells could be cloned into separate individuals, showing that an actual person's right to liberty outweighs the rights of potential persons.

13
New cards

Infanticide

The killing of a born infant, distinct from the termination of an unborn fetus.

14
New cards

Infanticide Objection

The challenge against Warren's view claiming that because newborn infants do not meet the criteria of personhood any more than late-term fetuses, her view must absurdly permit the killing of infants.

15
New cards

Direct Moral Standing

Moral considerability possessed by an entity in its own right by virtue of satisfying the core criteria of personhood.

16
New cards

Indirect Moral Standing

Moral protection granted to an entity that lacks personhood because other actual persons in society care for it, value it, and desire to protect it without violating anyone's rights.