1/84
Looks like no tags are added yet.
lucid thinking
-know precise definition of all concepts
-practice complete thoughts by logically organizing your writing, speaking, and thinking
-three fundamental questions of active listening
3 fundamental questions of active listening
-how can i use this information?
-why is it important to me?
-does it agree with my existing knowledge?
forensic science
-the use of science or technology in the investigation and establishment of facts or evidence in a court of law
-forensic chemistry, biology, physics, accounting, nursing, digital, environmental, etc.
L U S T acronym
-Leaky Underground Storage Tanks
-gas tanks held underground, when empty, water condenses in tank and corrodes metal, now fuel is leaking into drinking water
-can investigate by taking water samples, use GCMS and see if chemicals match certain gas tanks
Analytical chemistry
-qualitative analysis
-quantitative analysis
-classification
-individualization
-applies to environmental samples, biological samples, chemical samples
Forum
-the word forensics originated from
-where the Romans conducted business and legal proceedings
prosecutorial data
-used in court to prosecute a crime
research in forensic chemistry and the law
-analytical chemistry
-electrophoresis
-rapid communications in mass spectrometry science
application of forensic chemistry and the law
-analytical and bioanalytical chemistry
-applied spectroscopy
-journal of analytical toxicology
-journal of chromatography A and B
Forensic aspect of forensic chemistry and the law
-Forensic science international
-Journal of Forensic Sciences
-Science and Justice
Judicial use for forensic chemistry
-is the information relevant?
-is it reliable?
-is it admissible?
goal of science
understanding the natural world
Merit decided by
scientific method
goal of the legal system
settling disputes
merit decided by
-adversarial system
-2 parties disagreeing and debating the truth
Daubert/Frye criteria
-Daubert used more commonly now
-decision on admissibility
Culture Table- police
-Truth: mutable; binary, may evolve but will be final
-Dialog: Hierarchical, ordered, coded, Q&A
-Viewpoint: Experienced-based, first-person, intuitive
-Advocacy: Government
-Structure: Authoritarian
Culture Table- Scientists
-Truth: Mutable; scalable, may evolve slowly
-Dialog: Peer-to-peer, open, free, exchange
-viewpoint: Truth is not fully known, query-oriented, rational, discipline-based; statistically oriented
-Advocacy: Neutral, offered by plaintiff or defendant
-Structure: Collaborative
Culture Table: Lawyers
-Truth: Fixed; Binary; must become fixed quickly
-Dialog: Cross-examination, directed, Q&A, filtered
-Viewpoint: Truth based on precedent, decision-based, rule-oriented, advocate-based
-Advocacy: plaintiff or defendant
-Structure: Adversarial
How to testify
-Answer the question asked and only those questions
-be polite, patient and professional
-tell the truth
-be prepared
-speak clearly, slowly and loudly
-take your time
Cross-examination tactics
-admit-deny: cut you off before you can clarify
-historic-hysteric: try to undermine the field of study (ask something not relevant)
-learned treatise: others in your field surely disagree (getting you to say you accept someone as an expert and then the lawyer says their work contradicts yours)
-fishing expeditions
-push-pull: when lawyer pushes, the expert pulls in the same direction
Code of ethics
-the forensic scientist serves the court to present the truth
-forensic chemists can only answer questions that are directed by the lawyers
-lawyers are frequently interested in only disclosing advantageous pieces of the truth
-lawyers often know very little about science
-pre-trial conferences with lawyers are important
-contingency fees are forbidden by the American board of criminalistics code of ethics
Mathieu Orfila
-father of forensic toxicology
-published the first treatise on the detection of poisons
Alphonse Bertillon
-father of personal identification
-first system of personal identification
-anthropometry was considered the most accurate system for personal identification for 2 decades
Francis Galton
-father of fingerprint identification
-first statistical proof supporting uniqueness of fingerprints
gave key developments to fields of statistics including the normal distribution
Leone Lattes
-devised a system for determining the blood group proteins A, B and O (first discovered by Dr. Karl Landsteiner
Calvin Goddard
-developed the use of the comparison microscope for the comparison of bullets and casings test fired from a suspect’s weapon
Albert S. Osborne
-father of modern document examination
-responsible for the acceptance of documents as scientific evidence
Walter C. McCrone
-father of modern microscopy and world’s most foremost microscopist
-developed techniques for identifying numerous materials including paints, soils, hairs and fibers, and drugs
Hans Gross
-wrote the first treatise describing the application of scientific disciplines to the field of criminal investigations
Edmond Locard
-father of the modern crime laboratory
-described how the principles of scientific investigation could be practically incorporated into a workable crime lab
August Vollmer
-father of modern law enforcement
Paul L. Kirk
-first school of criminalistics at UC Berkeley in 1948
Paradigm Shift
-federal agencies providing more funding for statistical analysis, database construction, and scientific validation of techniques
-assisted by 911, war on terror, DHS, etc.
Who does the CSI-effect affect?
-cops: over-collect; higher expectations
-prosecutors: demand unnecessary tests to cover all eventualities
-Defense attorneys: flawed/perfect science dooms their client
-Juries: require excessive and unneeded tests to shake ‘unreasonable’ doubt
-forensic scientists: receive the brunt of excessive expectations
-public: want to be like the people on tv
-criminals: becoming wiser?
CSI TV-show myths
-most forensic chemists do not visit the crime scene because of the costs, liability, contamination, time, and expertise
-most crime scene investigators do not analyze samples because of costs, time, contamination, and expertise
-analyses on TV are oversimplified
-need lab certification
-cases are solved very quickly
Roles of evidence
-infer: conclude based on evidence and reasoning
-deduce: conclude about something specific, follows from a general premise
-induce: conclude something general like a pattern from specific observations
-abduction: make a probable conclusion from a specific piece of evidence
precedents
-law, as science, follows that which has gone before
-a guide for future decisions
-a forensic chemist uses the scientific method to determine the truth about evidence
-courts use a trier of fact to determine the truth
types of precedents
-binding precedent
-persuasive precedent
binding precedent
-the reason for a decision of a higher court that must be followed by a lower court in the same court hierarchy
persuasive precedent
-the reason for a decision of another court that is not binding but is relevant to the case and is an important statement of law
key federal cases for use of experts
-criminal and civil cases
The Frye rule
-1923, Frye v. United States
-the US challenged evidence by the defense that “systolic blood pressure deception test” (lie detector test) was valid
-appeals realized that they had no legal doctrine to replace the views of scientists
-evidence is admissible if the techniques are accepted as valid by the relevant scientific community
-gives a list of criteria for admissibility (peer review process is proof of prior acceptance/validation
-need to prove general acceptance
Coppolino v. state
-medical examiner devised new test (LC-MS) to determine death by succinylcholine poisoning
-the defendant’s lawyer claimed lack of corroborating support by other scientists and lack of peer review
-Evidence held up because of principles of the analysis
The Daubert Decision
-Daubert v. Merrel Dow Pharmaceuticals
-birth defects due to morning sickness drug Bendectin
-US supreme court ordered new standards for admissibility of forensic evidence in (federal) court: gave judges “gatekeeper roles”
-Requires scientific rigor more than expertise or historical use
Problem with Daubert: non-science loophole
-US v. Starzecpyzel (1995) found that handwriting analysis had no scientific foundation
-however, evidence was not rejected because it was not considered scientific
General electric v. Joiner (civil case)
-Joiner claimed that (contaminant) PCBs in dielectric fluids caused his lung cancer
-offered 4 expert witnesses and epidemiological studies negating link between PCBs and cancer
-however, Joiner claimed that dioxin and furan decomposition products from PCBs caused his lung cancer
-court expanded roles of gatekeepers to reject experts’ opinion, with just cause
Kumho extension (plugged Daubert non-science loophole)
-Kumho Tire Co., Ltd v. Carmichael (1999)
-Plaintiff expert Carlson claimed tire explosion on a minivan was caused by defect
-he was an engineer and did not use routine scientific methods
-court extended Daubert to all expert testimony, not just scientific
-requires different standards for different disciplines
Voir Dire
-means to say what is true, what is objectively accurate, or subjectively honest, or both
-refers to the questioning of the jurors’ backgrounds by the lawyers before they sit on a jury
-it is also used to question an expert witness about their credentials, education, and experience
The sixth amendment
-in all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witness against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense.
Bullcoming v. New Mexico
-ruled that only the analyst who did the work, rather than a colleague or supervisor, would do. DWI case. Decided 2011.
Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts
-submitting reports without testimony was unconstitutional
-cocaine case
-decided 2009
Crawford v. Washington
-rules that all witness testimony, the defense has a right to cross-examine even if the witness is unavailable
-Rape case
-decided 2004
Brady v. Maryland
-supreme court case which ruled that the prosecution must release evidence to the defense
-withholding evidence violates the 14th amendment’s due process clause
-involved 2 people tried for murder, the prosecution withheld a confession to the murder over the other assailant named Boblit
-case is thrown out if evidence is withheld
A defendant’s request for “Brady disclosure”
-the holding of the Brady case and the numerous state and federal cases that interpret its requirement that the prosecution disclose material exculpatory evidence to the defense
Exculpatory evidence
-evidence they did not commit the crime
-”there is a reasonable probability that his conviction or sentence would have been different had these materials been disclosed”
Frye Standard
-scientific theory is accepted
-scientific method is accepted
-method was applied correctly
-science is the gatekeeper
Daubert Standard
-used in Federal Courts and other states
-theory or techniques have been tested
-subject to peer-review and publication
-error rate of the technique or theory is known
-standards and controls exist and maintained
-theory has been accepted by the relevant scientific community
-judge is the gatekeeper (ensures expert testimony and evidence is reliable)
Direct evidence
-establishes fast
-eyewitness accounts, confessions. etc.
-usually not very reliable
Circumstantial evidence
-evidence that can lead to inferences about fact
-forensic evidence
-can put suspect at a scene, but might not prove guilt
-usually most reliable evidence
-objective
-statistics is an objective measure
Chain of custody
-A paper form that traces the handling of evidence
-ensures integrity of evidence and protects against tampering, loss, and mislabeling
-important for validation and certification
-digital cameras provide a facile method for documenting a laboratory procedure
Steps in Forensic analysis
1.Identification
2.Classification
3.Individualization
Identification
-Qualitative: What compounds are present?
-Quantitative: how much of each compound is present?
Classification
-more details about the history/properties of the sample
-where did the sample come from? did it decompose?
-small class size makes better evidence
Individualization
-establishing a unique or common source
-history/properties completely match with a known source
-can’t always be achieved
Scientific working groups (SWG)
-since 1990’s have been used to improve discipline practices and create mutual agreements between federal, state, and local forensic community partners
-each SWG is made up of members from within the focus field. The SWGs have a common working framework that is based on the scientific working groups bylaws
-the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors (ASCLD) publishes the ASCLD NEWS newsletter three times a year in April, August, and December. This news letter contains updates from the individual SWGs
SWG groups
-SWGDNA: DNA analysis
-SWGDE: digital evidence
-SWGDOC: questioned documents
-SWGDRUG: analysis of seized drugs
-SWGFAST: latent fingerprints
-SWGGUN: firearms and toolmarks
-SWGIT: imaging technologies
-SWGMAT: materials
-SWGSTAIN: bloodstain pattern analysis
-SWGFEX: firearms and explosives
SWGFEX classification of analytical methodologies: four categories
1- those that provide significant structural and/or elemental information (confirmatory)
2- those that provide limited structural or elemental information (intermediate)
3- those that provide a high degree of selectivity (intermediate)
4- those that are useful but do not fall in either of the other categories (presumptive)
Categories 1 and 2 (confirmatory)
-IR spectroscopy
-GCMS
-LCMS
-NMR spectroscopy
-Raman spectroscopy
-X-ray diffraction (XRD)
-Energy dispersive X-ray analysis (EDX)
Category 3 (presumptive)
-thermal energy analyzer (TEA)
-GC
-Ion mobility spectrometry
-LC
-Ion chromatography
-Capillary electrophoresis
-TLC
-polarized light microscopy
-stereo light microscopy
category 4 (selective)
-burn test
-flame test
-spot test
-melting point
a technique identified with a numeral 1
-is sufficient for identification
a technique identified with a numeral 2
-requires one more supporting technique for identification
a technique identified with a numeral 3
-requires two more supporting techniques for identification
a technique identified with a numeral 4
-requires 3 more supporting techniques for identification
when identifying ions
-two techniques per ion are required
chromatographic techniques
-may be counted as two distinct category 3 methodologies when different stationary and/or mobile phases are employed
PLM
-may be counted as 2 distinct category 3 methodologies when 2 different identification tests are done, such as examination of the physical/optical properties plus a microcrystalline test
for an analytical technique to be considered of value
-the test must be considered “positive”
-”negative” tests provide useful information for ruling out the presence of a particular family of explosives, these results have limited value toward establishing the identification of an explosive substance
forensic chemistry
-combines analytical chemistry qualitative and quantitative measurements for classification leading to individualization
individualization
-can be achieved by combining measurements
set protocals and certification
-helps prevent forensic testing errors
accrediting bodies
-help establish uniform performance between labs and between analysts
scientific evidence
-usually circumstantial but very strong
expert witnesses
-should only comment on topics within their areas of expertise
-not required or expected to know everything