1/6
Looks like no tags are added yet.
When can a deal bind before the final paperwork? Supaseal Glass Ltd v Inverclyde Windows Manufacturing Ltd
A deal can bind before the final paperwork is signed if the parties have agreed the essential terms and their words and actions show they intend to be bound straight away.
One distinguishing fact: The parties signed a price list at the meeting where they agreed that Inverclyde would buy all its glass from Supaseal for five years. The glass deal was binding.
When must the parties sign before a contract becomes binding? Name: W S Karoulias SA v The Drambuie Liqueur Co Ltd
Parties can agree on the wording of a deal but intend to become legally bound only when they sign. The court decides this from their words and conduct.
For example, if they always signed previous contracts and are now arranging to send the new contract for signature, that can suggest they meant to become bound only when they signed.
One distinguishing fact Both sides expected copies of the new Greek distribution deal for signature. Neither signed, so Karoulias could not enforce the new deal.
What if the parties describe different jobs? Mathieson Gee (Ayrshire) Ltd v Quigley 1952 SC (HL) 38
Principle: An acceptance must match the offer on what each party is agreeing to do. If the offer and reply describe different jobs, no contract is formed.
One distinguishing fact: The contractor offered to supply machinery for clearing a pond. Quigley replied as though the contractor had offered to clear the pond itself. No contract was formed.