essential cases formation of contract (CONTRACT LAW)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/6

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

7 Terms

1
New cards

When can a deal bind before the final paperwork? Supaseal Glass Ltd v Inverclyde Windows Manufacturing Ltd



A deal can bind before the final paperwork is signed if the parties have agreed the essential terms and their words and actions show they intend to be bound straight away.


One distinguishing fact: The parties signed a price list at the meeting where they agreed that Inverclyde would buy all its glass from Supaseal for five years. The glass deal was binding.

2
New cards

When must the parties sign before a contract becomes binding? Name: W S Karoulias SA v The Drambuie Liqueur Co Ltd



Parties can agree on the wording of a deal but intend to become legally bound only when they sign. The court decides this from their words and conduct.

For example, if they always signed previous contracts and are now arranging to send the new contract for signature, that can suggest they meant to become bound only when they signed.

One distinguishing fact Both sides expected copies of the new Greek distribution deal for signature. Neither signed, so Karoulias could not enforce the new deal.

3
New cards

What if the parties describe different jobs? Mathieson Gee (Ayrshire) Ltd v Quigley 1952 SC (HL) 38



Principle: An acceptance must match the offer on what each party is agreeing to do. If the offer and reply describe different jobs, no contract is formed.


One distinguishing fact: The contractor offered to supply machinery for clearing a pond. Quigley replied as though the contractor had offered to clear the pond itself. No contract was formed.

4
New cards
Can an agreement between friends bind them?
Name: Robertson v Anderson 2003 SLT 235 at [13]
Principle: An agreement between friends can bind them if the circumstances show they intended it to have legal effect.
One distinguishing fact: Two friends agreed to split their bingo winnings. When Anderson won £108,000, Robertson was entitled to half.
5
New cards
Can a buyer change the terms and then accept the original offer?
Name: Wolf and Wolf v Forfar Potato Co 1984 SLT 100
Principle: A reply that makes acceptance conditional on extra terms is a counter-offer. It ends the original offer. Simply asking whether the seller would consider a change can leave the offer open.
One distinguishing fact: The potato buyer made its first acceptance conditional on extra terms. Its later attempt to accept the original offer failed, even though the deadline had yet to pass.
6
New cards
Does delivering goods mean the supplier accepted the buyer’s terms?
Name: Specialist Insulation Ltd v Pro-Duct (Fife) Ltd 2012 SCLR 641
Principle: Delivery can show acceptance of a buyer’s terms if the supplier’s actions, viewed in context, show agreement to those terms.
One distinguishing fact: Specialist delivered the ductwork without signing Pro-Duct’s form. Specialist’s terms required written agreement to changes, so delivery alone did not bring Pro-Duct’s adjudication clause into the contract.
7
New cards
Is an ordinary advert listing goods and a price an offer?
Name: Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 2 All ER 421
Principle: An ordinary advert listing goods and a price is usually an invitation to treat. The customer makes an offer to buy and the seller decides whether to accept it.
One distinguishing fact: Partridge’s magazine advert listed bramblefinches at 25 shillings each. It invited orders, so his conviction for offering a protected bird for sale was quashed