1/50
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Central argument
-Intangible cultural heritage is not simply a collection of old traditions that should be preserved unchanged
-It consists of living cultural practices that communities repeatedly perform, reinterpret, and transmit to new generations
-These practices include festivals, rituals, dances, oral traditions, craft skills, knowledge about nature, music, and other emodied forms of cultural activity
-Because they shape people's values, identities, relationships, and ways of interacting with nature, they can contribute to the social and ecological transformations required in the Anthropocene
Culture as a global public good
-Culture affects almost every dimension of human life
-It is defined broadly: it includes not only art, literature, theater, and music, but also ways of life, traditions, beliefs, value systems, emotions, knowledge, and everyday behavior
-This matters because the transformations required in the Anthropocene cannot be achieved solely through new laws or technologies
-Social transformation requires cultural transformation --> intangible cultural practices affect behavior at an embodied and emotional level
Anthropocene
-Anthropocene is an era in which human activity has become a major force affecting the planet
-At the same time, humans remain dependent on the ecological systems they are damaging
-For Wulf, this creates a need for fundamental change --> people must learn to interact less violently with nature, with other people and with themselves
Intangible cultural heritage (UNESCO's 2003 Convention)
Intangible cultural heritage includes practices, expressions, knowledge, skills, objects, instruments, and cultural spaces that communities recognize as part of their heritage
5 main domains of intangible cultural heritage
-Oral traditions and expressions, including language
-Performing arts
-Social practices, rituals, and festive events
-Knowledge and practices concerning nature and the universe
-Traditional craftsmanship
Heritage is living
-Intangible cultural heritage is constantly recreated, a practice survives because people continue to perform it
-Every new performance combines elements inherited from the past, the needs of the present, changes in the community, new technologies, encounters with other cultures, and individual creativity
-Safeguarding does not mean freezing a tradition in one supposedly authentic form --> if a practice cannot change, it may lose its relevance and disappear
Preservation
-Maintains historical continuity
-Protects knowledge and skills
-Strengthens cultural identity
-Can resist homogenization
Transformation
-Keeps the practice socially relevant
-Allows new interpretations
-Responds to changing communities
-Prevents heritage from becoming a museum object
Tangible heritage
-Buildings
-Archaeological sites
-Landscapes
-Documents
-Historical objects
-Monuments
Intangible heritage
-Human bodies
-Performances
-Practical knowledge
-Social relationships
-Memory
-Participation
-Transmission
Diffferent types of UNESCO heritage
-World heritage
-Documentary heritage
-Geoparks
-Biosphere reserves
World heritage
-The World Heritage Programme protects cultural sites and natural landscapes considered to have outstanding universal value
-Its strategic objectives are summarized through five Cs: Credibility, conservation, capacity-building, communication, communities
Documentary heritage
UNESCO's Memory of the World Programme safeguards important historical documents such as the Gutenberg Bible, Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, and colonial archives
Geoparks
Geoparks use important geological sites to promote understanding of the Earth, finite natural resources, climate change, and sustainable regional development
Biosphere reserves
Biosphere reserves are model regions in which conservation, economic activity, and sustainable development are combined
Heritage selection is political
-Not every tradition becomes officially recognized heritage
-Selection is a complex social and political process
-A heritage list does not neutrally record everything a society possesses, it actively helps define which practices represent the society and which groups receive recognition
What shapes decisions
-Government institutions
-Civil-society organizations
-Expert committees
-Local communities
-National identity
-Historical conflicts
-Cultural policy
-International relations
Different selection systems
-Top-down selection
-Bottom-up selection
-Hybrid systems
National selection approaches
-Japan: Intangible heritage was important to rebuilding Japanese identity, so legislation created a strong legal framework for identifying and safeguarding practices
-South Korea: Connected to the reconstruction of Korean identity, where it recognizes selected holders and trainees and gives government institutions an important role
-Germany: Adopted a bottom-up system, where communities can submit applications through the federal states after which expert committees review them
Selection criteria in Germany
-Whether the practice remains active
-Whether knowledge and skills are transmitted
-Whether performance is central
-Whether there are active tradition-bearers
-Whether a credible safeguarding plan exists
Controversial things cultural traditions have been used to do
-Legitimize colonial domination
-Destroy Indigenous identities
-Exclude minorities
-Reproduce antisemitism
-Reinforce racism
-Maintain unequal gender relations
-Support nationalist ideologies
The way people's bodies preserve heritage
-Moving
-Speaking
-Singing
-Dancing
-Making objects
-Performing rituals
-Using tools
-Reproducing gestures
-Interacting with others
3 dimensions of performativity
-Cultural performance
-Language as action
-Aesthetic bodily performance
Cultural performance
-Festivals, rituals, dances, weddings, musical events, and similar occasions represent a culture to its members and to outsiders
-They are observable cultural events with a particular time, place, beginning and end, group of participants, and social purpose
Language as action
-Some statements do not merely describe reality, they help create it
-Statements made in weddings, contracts, ceremonies, and official appointments can produce new social relationships
Aesthetic bodily performance
-Bodies, gestures, movements, spaces, images, music, and objects create experiences that cannot be reduced to words
-A performance is shaped by its physical location, the performers' bodies, material objects, media and technology, audience participation, spontaneous actions, and emotional and easthetic qualities
-These dimensions explain why intangible heritage cannot be adequately understood by reading its symbols as if they were a written text
Forms of knowledge
-Practical knowledge is needed to perform an action
-Hermeneutic knowledge is used afterward to interpret the action
-Someone can competently participate in a ritual without being able to provide an academic explanation of its symbolism
-Conversely, a researcher may interpret a performance without possessing the skills required to perform it
Mimetic learning
-Intangible cultural heritage is primarily transmitted through mimesis
-Mimesis is not copying, it is a creative process through which people observe, imitate, adapt, and make practices their own
-The learner becomes similar to others while also introducing differences
-Every act of transmission therefore preserves and changes the practice simultaneously
Mimesis vs. Mimicry
-Mimicry means adapting passively to existing conditions
-Mimesis is productive --> The learner interprets what is observed and incorporates it into their own experience
7 characteristics of mimesis
-Mimesis is central to cultural performance
-It is creative rather than merely reproductive
-It depends on embodied performance
-It is important in art but extends far beyond aesthetics
-It creates collective and individual cultural imaginaries
-It transmits silent, embodied, and practical knowledge
-It can have both positive and negative consequences
Cultural imaginary
-Through mimetic learning, communities develop a cultural imaginary: a shared field of images, emotions, memories, expectations, and possible futures
-The cultural imaginary connects past traditions, present performances, and future aspirations
-It gives people a sense of continuity while also making cultural innovation possible
3 forms of mimetic interaction in a cultural event
-Performers draw on inherited forms
-Performers coordinate mimetically with one another
-Spectators respond to and participate in the performance
--> when these interactions succeed, participants may experience belonging, emotional intensity, and collective meaning
Flow experiences
-Joint cultural activity can create a flow: an intense experience in which people become absorbed in meaningful collective action
-Flow may emerge through music, rhythm, coordinated movement, singing, ritual, collaborative craftsmanship, and shared preparation
-These experiences reduce the felt distance between people and can create temporary communities even among strangers
Intergenerational learning
-Intangible heritage brings generations together
-Young people aquire practical skills, social knowledge, emotional competence, cultural memory, a sense of responsibility, and experience cooperating with adults
-Adults also learn through interaction with younger participants --> young people may question familiar methods, introduce new interpretations, or combine traditions with contemporary cultural forms
Gender
-Cultural heritage practices can reproduce traditional gender roles, but they can also create opportunities to challenge them
-Festivals and carnivals may contain clearly gendered roles, but at the same time their exceptional or playful atmosphere can permit behaviors that would normally be restricted
-Wulf acknowledges that it is unclear whether temporary changes during festivals lead to lasting changes in everyday gender relations
Inclusivity
-UNESCO-recognized practices are expected to encourage participation rather than discrimination
-An inclusive heritage practice should allow people with different identities, emotions, beliefs, social positions, cultural backgrounds, and gender identities
-Strong community identity can produce belonging internally while excluding outsiders
-Heritage policy must therefore examine both community-building and boundary-making
5 interconnected Ps of sustainable development
-Planet: Protect ecosystems, biodiversity, animals, and plants
-People: Reduce poverty and hunger and enable dignified lives
-Peace: Reduce violence and promote justice
-Prosperity: Improve well-being through economic and technological development
-Participation: Build cooperation at local, national, and global levels
Heritage and the SDGs
-Many practices on the UNESCO's Representative list can be connected to one or more sustainable development goals (SDG)
-The argument is not that heritage automatically creates sustainability, practices may need to be modified, reinterpreted, or connected to new educational programs
Global responsibility
-Because climate change and environmental destruction cross national borders, sustainability requires cooperation on a planetary scale
-Global citizenship means recognizing that people belong to overlapping local and global communities and have responsibilities beyond their own nation
-It involves responsibility toward: Other societies, future generations, ecosystems, nonhuman life, and humanity as a whole
--> Wulf argues for pluriversality
Pluriversality
-Creating a shared world that allows multiple cultural worlds to coexist
-A pluriversal global community recognizes different histories, colonial inequalities, cultural variation, different relationships with nature, conflicting political systems
-Human rights provide a common reference point, but their interpretation and implementation remain culturally and politically contested
Different types of education
-Education for sustainable development
-Critical and research-oriented learning
-Global citizenship education
-Human rights education
-Peace education
How do intangible cultural practices educate people
-Participation
-Observation
-Embodied learning
-Cooperation
-Emotional experience
-Intergenerational relationships
-Encounters with different cultures
How can intangible cultural practices contribute
-Food security
-Healthcare
-Access to water
-Gender equality
-Biodiversity protection
-Disaster resilience
-Sustainable livelihoods
-Decent work
-Peace and security
Critical and research-oriented learning
-Education for sustainability should not simply transmit predetermined information, it should encourage people to question existing conditions
-Wulf emphasizes the importance of amazement: Why is the world organized this way? Why do people behave as they do? Could things be different? Which institutions should be transformed?
-Curiosity and research-oriented learning can expose social arrangements that have come to appear normal or inevitable
-Intangible practices are valuable because they offer concrete experiences through which abstract questions about sustainability, identity, and justice can be explored
3 dimensions of global citizenship education
-Cognitive: People develop knowledge of local, national, regional, and global problems and understand how societies are interconnected
-Socio-emotional: People develop empathy, solidarity, respect for difference, and a sense of belonging to a common humanity
-Behavioral: People acquire the capacity and motivation to act responsibly for a more peaceful and sustainable world
Human rights education
-Knowledge of rights
-Recognition of injustice
-Critical reflection on inequality
-The capacity to exercise one's own rights
-Willingness to defend the rights of others
Peace education
-Human dignity
-Nonviolent conflict resolution
-Solidarity
-Dialogue
-Civil courage
-Sustainable development
-Democratic participation
Opportunities of digital technologies
-Record threatened practices
-Create archives
-Make traditions visible internationally
-Help communities analyze performances
-Support intergenerational transmission
-Give elderly, ill, or geographically distant people access
-Provide educational resources
-Support intercultural exchange
-Create new cultural forms
Problem of embodiment
-Digitalization creates a major tension because intangible heritage is fundamentally bodily, sensory, and performative
-Watching a ritual online is not identical to being physically present, feeling sound and movement, participating with others, experiencing the atmosphere and respondings through one's own body
Ethical risks of digitalization and AI
-Manipulation
-Fake news
-Cultural distortion
-Racism
-Discrimination
-Privacy violations
-Commercial exploitation
-Loss of community control
-Decontextualization
-Misleading representations
UNESCO's ethical principles for AI
-Human dignity
-Human rights
-Peaceful and just societies
-Diversity and inclusion
-Environmental flourishing
-Privacy and data protection
-Transparency
-Accountability
-Human oversight
-Fairness
-Safety
-Sustainability