1/71
Looks like no tags are added yet.
The schooled society |
Describes the society we currently have where schooling is formal and takes centre stage. It is also standardized and relatively the same all over the world, age segregated, stratified, and mandatory. Schooling has become increasingly diversified, important to our identity, tied to the labour market, and to our futures.
Social mobility |
School has become the main pathway to social mobility, also known as the great equalizer. The best way to have more success than your parents is to educate yourself
Ex. i’m poor, go to school become a doctor get rich
Link between education and life chances
Absolute social mobility
Making more than your parents did at your age ex. I make 30 an hour, my dad at my age only made 20 so i have absolute mobility
Relative social mobility
Making more money relative to what my parents made, meaning being in a higher income percentage than they were. Higher in a fluid society, not many people experience this
Ex. i’m top 10% of income, my dad was top 50 i have experienced relative mobility
Socialization in school
Socialization in schools is meant to teach values of society and impart know-how onto students, such as human capital (skills, abilities, knowledge). School reflects how members see themselves and their role in society, and how they learn expectations of the world such as norms and identity.
Ex. demonstrating kindness so students are kind
Selection in school
Select by sorting and differentiating students based on ability and skill. Kids are graded and given badges of ability for being good at certain things, and selected for certain roles in the economy. Schools shape who ends up in what jobs
Ex. smart kid encouraged to pursue AP classes and become a lawyer
Organization and legitimation
Schools legitimate knowledge by acting like an organized bureaucracy. There are procedures, a hierarchy, rules to keep schools standardized and operating efficiently. Schools legitimize knowledge by making it credible
Ex. once you graduate, the knowledge you have is legitimized through accreditation
Cognitive skills
Skills that are cognitive abilities such as reading, writing, literacy, problem solving. These skills are a form of human capital
ex. Problem solving, reading, writing
Non cognitive skills/soft skills
Skills that are not cognitive or academic but are important for existing in society such as perseverance and grit.
ex.perseverance, hard word, personality traits, grit, social trust
General skills |
Transferable and will come in handy at many jobs, not specific to one. ex. Collaboration, familiarity with computers,
Specific skills
Specific to one particular job, form of human capital. Valuable but not necessarily transferable
ex.
Fine hands for operating a a surgeon, mechanic ability
Social transformations leading to formalized schooling
Social transformations that led to formalized schooling include the industrial revolution, needing an educated society to help economy, less nuclear families, importance of instilling moral values into youth, financialized economy, aging population, immigration, diversity.
Polarization of labour
Growth of high pay high skill jobs and low pay low skill jobs, decline of middle skill opportunities
Macro theory
Links schooling to broader forces such as modernization, capitalism, culture
Ex. industrialization leads to mass schooling, applies across societies
Middle range theory
More tied to a specific place and time ex. Post secondary expansion post WW2
Micro theory
Face to face interaction among people, smaller scale Ex. teacher interacts with students
Emile Durkheim
Durkheim was a functionalist that focused on social change and the rise of individualism. Thought about shift away from traditional society to modern values, collective norms and beliefs and how schools socialized the next generation with morals. Thought school was for recreating social order and stability and develop talent
Karl Marx
Marx was very focused on class struggle and thought about how education reproduces capitalist systems and creates inequality, it reflects ruling class ideologies and benefits the economically advantaged Ex. schools want you to be passive and obedient
Max Webber
Concerned with how schools organize and legitimate knowledge, thought rationalization was the key aspect of modern society. Explored how knowledge becomes standardized, specialized and measureable
individualism
Greater emphasis on personal goals, autonomy, self-expression over obligation to others. Weak shared moral framework – declining social cohesion
rationalization
Process of society basing its systems around logic and science
Structural functionalism
Modern socialization, what is the function or role of modern education? Explores how schools socialize kids into modern values, universalism and meritocracy
meritocracy
System that operates on the belief that everyone must earn power and success based on abilities and effort and not family connections or social class
Ex. i get into uni because i have good grades
Hidden curriculum
The mechanism of socialization, schools socialize implicitly, Obedience, rule following, punctuality
stratification
Educational stratification refers to the systematic ranking and division of students into different hierarchical layers of educational access, quality, and opportunity. It shapes how schools sort individuals—influencing their future jobs, income, and social mobility
Ex. kids in AP classes more likely to succeed
Selecting for Merit
electing who will end up in what jobs based on merit, positions need to be filled in order to keep social stability. Functionally important positions get high incentives like money and prestige
Ex. doctor makes bank because we need them
Schools scout and train the ones with potential and skills to be a doctor
neo-marxism
Contemporary ideas around marx and class struggle, schools reproduce equality and push capitalist values, Correspondence principle
Correspondence principle
School reflects capitalist workplace Ex do what you're told, shut up and listen, hierarchical order
Cultural capital
Familiarity with high status culture that allows someone to blend in with the powerful elite by speaking, behaving and having tastes similar to them. Signals that you are one of them. Poor people can learn but not as good as the ones born into it Ex. opera
Social capital
Who you know, your network of connections and how you get resources from them. Higher SES students have better connections Ex. i know a guy so i get hired
Human capital theory
Education is viewed as an investment in your personal worth and skills. Workplaces want high output per input, if you are worth it they will hire you
views workers not as simple labor costs, but as economic assets whose skills, knowledge, health, and education can be developed to increase productivity
Lack of skills matching new technology reduces HC
Opportunity costs
People accept opportunity costs because it’ll pay off later, investment in future
Ex. sitting in class because it's a better use of our time
credentialism
Schools act as credentialing institutions, more emphasis on credentials than your real skills since workplaces cant test your skills. School more like an entry ticket for workforce
Credential inflation
Post WW2, credentials don't mean as much as they used to because so many people have them. More graduates than available jobs
Leads to education requirements for jobs rising
Vertical mismatched
Schools produce more graduates than jobs available so graduates work lower jobs
Weak education-job link
School content doesn't apply or relate directly to jobs, employers don't test skills Occupational groups (medicine, law) limit competition to increase status and income vs. human capital Ex. want less lawyers
New institutionalism
Schools and world culture, schools viewed more as a national project concerning human rights and focuses on common values Ex. UN having requirements for schools
signalling theory
Since employers have limited info about applicants, skills and productivity are not directly observable. Credentials signal ability, Oh she graduated so clearly she can handle this
Labour queue theory
Employers rank applicants in the labour queue, credentials used to sort and screen applicants. More education = higher in queue
Early Modern Schooling
School started out as being church based, and only for the few. Education wasn't centralized or mandatory. Classrooms used to be organized based on knowledge level not age
By mid 19th century it becomes centralized, standardized, state regulated, compulsory attendance and teachers must be certified
Four hypotheses of why modern schooling emerged
Economics: need skilled and competent workforce
Technical complexity: need for basic literacies and technical skills
Socialization: ensures children adopt a common value system
Nation Building: build national unity, language, civic norms
Enrollment and attendance
Schools used to just be one room with a teacher and focus on core subjects, most kids didn't even go because of farm work. Now that school is centralized and standardized, regular attendance is the norm, it's deviant if you don't attend. Longer schooling for more people
Reasons for Increased public spending on school
-industry, science, and skill demands means jobs require more cognitive skills
- credential inflation
School as a public good, everyone must be able to attend
Opportunity consciousness
an individual's or group's level of subjective awareness regarding the structural pathways, resources, and systemic limitations available to them to achieve success
Expanding curricula
Higher education used to only be for law or medicine, now there are so many pathways. Universities are the main pathway to most careers ex. baking major
Expanding functions
School becomes more than just about academic education, teaches kids about social issues, sex ed, gym. Schools have nurses and drivers ed, therapists, meal programs
Expanding alternatives
schools give more choices for form like french immersion, online school, private school, homeschooling
Exporting the school model
School model being used in other settings like prisons, parenting classes, leisure classes
streaming/tracking
Streaming is sorting students into different educational pathways based on perceived abilities. Each path you take narrows future options
How schools function as stratification
Kids are sometimes streamed based on social class
Higher ses kids academic path. Students benefit differently from some curriculum
Streaming also shapes learning opportunities
Ex. writing assignment, more difference between students and streams more important than between schools
Other countries do streaming younger
Stratification in post secondary
Mainly institutional prestige and field of study. Ex. harvard and engineering vs uwindsor and art history
Canada less institutional prestige than US, more focus on field |
sponsored mobility
early selection by elites, ascribed credentials, traditional european systems
contest mobility
delayed, open competition, individual merit and achievement, America
Canadian post secondary
Very little difference in worth between uni, we have more public and less private. Your major matters more
American post secondary
Different leagues and types of uni, common to travel across country for uni, field matters less
accommodation
Schools like shopping malls try to accommodate everyone, everyone needs to pass and student failures are blamed on teachers. Even bad students encouraged to do post secondary
Schools accommodate with multiple intelligences considered, gifted programs, ESL, AP
Educational expansion paradox
The paradox that even though education expands it does not necessarily lead to lesser inequalities
Maximally maintained inequality
Also known as vertical stratification, advantaged groups seek higher levels of education, Ex. secondary school saturated, distinguish themselves by doing post secondary
Effectively maintained inequality
Horizontal stratification
Advantaged groups become more selective within the same level
ex. Both going to western but one is doing ivey
Direct inheritance
Things you directly inherit Ex. land, title, status
Indirect inheritance
Things one cannot inherit directly ex. an MBA degree
SES gradient
Shows how SES differences are visible before school even starts. This trend persists even when controlling for ethnicity, region, family structure. Also reproduced across time and nations
4 important characteristics of SES
Occur at all levels of schooling
They persist even if other demographics are considered → gradients show causal link between SES & educational attainment
Gradient is robust across different measures of education & SES (pattern shows regardless of measure you use)
SES gradient has persisted over time & space
Coleman report
Shows that student achievement is influenced by parents education income and status
Causes of inequality
Schools reduce inequality but not fully, rich still do better
In summer rich stay smart but poor aren't exposed to education so they get dumber
Family bg matters more in wealthier countries because in poorer countries school effects are smaller. In rich countries rich families learn how to play the game and work the system for their benefit
Primary mechanisms
Primary mechanisms directly affect a child’s ability to learn ex. Skills, readiness, Inherited intelligence, flynn effect, family based learning opportunities, better books and cultural access, tutoring, neighbourhood
secondary mechanisms
Secondary mechanisms Affect outcomes of education via choices, expectations, and sorting. This is independent of raw learning capacity
Ex. me and julia are both smart and have exactly the same skills. Why do i go to uni and she doesnt
How does family background shape expectations and choices?
Rational choice/risk benefit framework
Education isn't just based on ability but also choice. Not everyone can afford to go to school some ppl have to drop out in 4th grade to run drugs and support their nana
Students and families assess risk vs benefit and make the best choice
Relative risk aversion
All families want to avoid downward mobility, but class position shapes what risks are worth taking
Ex. rich kid will take advanced courses, high risk high reward
Poor kid takes safer less demanding routes and avoids failure
Time discounting
Higher SES families can wait longer for a return on investment because they have money to fall back on
Lower SES families face immediate financial pressure and need quicker payoffs
Ex. i can go to school instead of finding a full time job right away because i have my mom and dad’s money to rely on, so i’m not starving and struggling to pay tuition
collective effervescence
Collective effervescence is a sociological concept coined by Émile Durkheim in 1912 that describes the intense energy, unity, and shared emotional awakening people feel when gathering for a common purpose