1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why is friendship important to Aristotle?
Friendship is both ānecessary and noble.ā Without friends, there is no point to life; there is no point to prosperity without having the opportunity to produce good, which comes especially from friendships. We need help when weāre struggling, and at all ages - when weāre young, they keep us from error, in middle age, they stimulate noble actions and make us more able to think and act, and when weāre old, they help us with the things that weāre struggling to do (and we help them in return).
What is the key characteristic of friendship for Aristotle?
Goodwill - friends need to mutually bear goodwill and wish well on one another.
What are the three kinds of friendship?
1) Utility - accidental, serve a function; not about who the other person really is; based on each friend appreciating or loving the other because they get some good from each other.
2) Pleasure - accidental; personalities mesh/click; not enough to make it a deep friendship, and similarly easily dissolved
3) Virtue/goodness-based - both friends are virtuous; providing each other mutual feedback on how to flourish and live a good life; based on mutual respect and a recognition of the otherās character; the superior form of friendship; encompasses the other two; rare, can be permanent
What is the good life for the Stoics/Marcus Aurelius?
Shaping a calm, healthy, rational mental state that allows you to accept external events outside of your control. Figuring out what you can control, letting go of the things you canāt, using reason. Turning obstacles into opportunities, getting over with/moving on from emotions, a resignation to oneās fate but not in a powerless way. Based on following routines and creating a structure for oneās life.
What language did Marcus Aurelius write the meditations in?
Koine Greek
What are four themes of Stoicism?
1) Living with purpose
2) Living virtuously and without excuses
3) Achieving calmness and the power of adapting to circumstances
4) Debate about whether Stoicism is pessimistic or hopeful
What does Marcus Aurelius say about society and nature?
We live in societies, together. We should be vocal and active about the things that harm ourselves and others, but not too vocal about the things that harm only ourselves and not others. Thereās a kinship among all rational and creative beings, who can see what truly is harm and try to be better together. We all share reason and have a place in the Whole; we all have a role to play in society, and there is a natural order. This creates a kind of harmony. Part of this involves accepting our fates, or that there are elements of our lives that are not free; thereās a thread of destiny spun for each of us. What happens for each individual determines the welfare, perfection, and coherence of the whole. Our experiences may be negative, but we shouldnāt resent it, because we need people of all experiences for everything to be coherent; your contingent circumstances are part of what makes the whole work. We still have power and can control many things in our lives, but at the same time, weāre extremely small; in the whole of existence, each individual is a brief, fleeting part.
What does Marcus Aurelius say about death?
Death is just another transition and another function of the body. He says as an added bonus that when youāre dead, you donāt need to deal with people that you dislike anymore. Thereās nothing superficial or disdainful about death, itās just one of the natural things in life. There are little deaths everywhere, all the time - the end of a particular stage of life; but none of these need to make us afraid, because with every transition in life, there comes something else.
How does one live a good life according to Marcus Aurelius?
Focus on mental strength and direction as a source of self restraint; stop impulses, quench desires, make the directing mind its own master.
Make your actions contribute to the greater whole; good or ill lies not in feeling, but action.
Acknowledge that the source of all anxiety is within yourself, and you can change your judgements to be less anxious.
Accept that all things are transient and in a process of change; therefore, you can turn your view of loss into an acceptance of change, and delight in it - āall that flows from nature happens for the good.ā
Learn to accept that there are ignorant, shameful people in the world, and not expect good from them, but instead respond with the appropriate virtuous action.
Look back at ourselves when we are annoyed or disappointed with others, because the fault lies with us.
True or false - according to Marcus Aurelius, living in accordance with nature means acting for the benefit of others, not just ourselves.
True - weāre social beings.
True or false - according to Marcus Aurelius, something that negatively affects us as individuals is only truly harmful if it also harms society.
True. Our wellbeing is tied to the Whole, and the Whole needs to do well for us to do well. The key is to separate harm from suffering; this doesnāt mean nobody suffers individually, but he says that harm impacts our ability to act rationally and virtuously.
True or false - Marcus Aurelius argues that we should fear death because, unlike other natural changes, it marks a fundamental disruption of the natural order.
False.
True or false - According to Marcus Aurelius, our mental wellbeing depends primarily on controlling external circumstances so that we can avoid stressful experiences.
False
What is the good life according to St. Augustine?
The good life is worshipping and delighting in God, taking instructions from scripture. He thinks that the love of God and devotion to the kingdom of heaven should bring us a higher happiness than anything that we can get from sex or carnal pursuits.
Why did Augustine pursue sin?
For its own sake, but also to gain the respect and admiration of his peers. This included pretending that he had done things that he didnāt actually do, to avoid scorn for lacking courage.
What is the eighth commandment, which Augustine broke?
You shall not steal.
Why did Augustine view the theft of the pears as so bad?
Because he didnāt steal the pears due to hunger, or for their beauty; he stole them just to enjoy the excitement of thieving and of doing something wrong. It was purely for thrill, to feast on wickedness.
What was the role of others in Augustineās theft of the pears?
He claims he wouldnāt have done this alone. His desire to sin was encouraged by the excitement generated by sharing in the guilt with others. Friendship can be beneficial, but it can also be dangerous and a āseduction of the mindā by leading you to do wrong if you associate with people who sin.
How did Augustine use sin to explain his immoral actions?
He said that sin is a rebellion against God; itās even an attempt to be more powerful than God by being the one who sets up whatās right and wrong, and breaking Godās laws. Weāre egoistic creatures who crave pride and social status, and by nature, weāre misdirected towards the flesh and earthly objects. We abandon higher goods and delight in that which is not God.
What is oneās mindset immediately before a big life change, according to Augustine.
Being in a disturbed condition and a state of uncertainty. Weāre not settled; pulled between two opposing poles of our desires, who we want to be.
What were the two wills that Augustine felt conflicted between?
The carnal and the spiritual will.
What were the two events, outside of Augustineās control, that influenced his conversion?
He wanted to convert, but his habits and temptations were present. āLady Continenceā came to embrace him; she represents faithfulness to God, and symbolizes the virtue of chastity or self-control. He felt this embrace and the misery he felt came up and led him to weep. As he cried, he heard a childās voice repeating āpick up and read, pick up and read.ā He did, and read a line from St. Paulās letters, which dispelled his doubt and anxiety. These events led him to convert.
How do we know what God is, and what happiness through God is?
Augustine says we have some prior knowledge of God, including a memory of a unity with God, in some unconscious part of ourselves. We have some sort of collective memory of the divine, and we need to recognize the ideas that we already have. We all seek joy, and that joy rests in God, even if we donāt know that weāre seeking God. The happy life is joy in the truth itself, which is joy in God; we must remember the essence of truth itself, which is in our collective memory. The desire for joy and the desire for truth are linked and universal.
What is the good life, according to Kant?
The good life as exercising the categorical imperative, which requires a high level of self-discipline and self-control.
True or false - Kant grew up rich
False
What did Kant think about human nature?
It always has the potential to be corrupt. He secularizes Christian morality - weāre sinful, but he doesnāt use that language; he refers to corruption, the influence of the passions, etc., and thinks this is in our nature, but we can overcome these things to become rational.
What did Kant think should replace religious authority?
The authority of reason.
What does it mean to be free for Kant? How does he describe free will?
True freedom comes when we bind ourselves to the moral law, by limiting ourselves in view of maxims or laws that can be universalized. This law doesnāt come from any text, God, or source of authority - it comes from us. We have the capacity to be reasonable and rational, and we should follow that to be our highest selves.
What is beauty a reminder of, for Kant?