GEO 2104 - Ethics in GIS

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/11

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

12 Terms

1
New cards

Why Ethics in GIS? (3)

  • Data produced can used to invade privacy

  • These data are used to inform policy decisions

  • GIS technology has potential to exacerbate societal inequities


2
New cards

Areas of Application of Ethics in GIS (3)

  1. Collection

  2. Analysis

  3. Visualization


3
New cards

Areas of Application: Collection & Analysis (3)

  • Research or crowdsourced?

  • Clean data of Personally Identifiable Information (PII) before analysis/sharing

  • What of security sensitive data? Keep data secure


4
New cards

Areas of Application: Visualization (4 points, 2 examples)

  • Maps can inform but also deceive

  • Deceptive maps have existed for ages and hide critical information (e.g. propaganda maps, trap maps, etc.)

  • Maps need to show the appropriate information for the reader to make an informed decision

  • Inappropriate maps/graphics lead to misunderstanding


  • What other factors should you consider? (Necessary to standardize data?)

    • Population?

    • Geographic area?

  • Color choice for features impact perception

    • Red = bad/dire/severe

    • Green = good/better/preferred

    • Darker tones = more

    • Lighter tones = less


<ul><li><p>Maps can <em>inform </em>but also <em>deceive</em></p></li><li><p>Deceptive maps have existed for ages and hide critical information (e.g. <u>propaganda </u>maps, <u>trap </u>maps, etc.)</p></li><li><p>Maps need to show the <em>appropriate information </em>for the reader to make an <em>informed decision</em></p></li><li><p>Inappropriate maps/graphics lead to <em>misunderstanding</em></p></li></ul><p></p><ul><li><p>What other factors should you consider? (Necessary to <em>standardize </em>data?)</p><ul><li><p>Population?</p></li><li><p>Geographic area? </p></li></ul></li><li><p><em>Color </em>choice for features impact <em>perception</em></p><ul><li><p>Red = bad/dire/severe </p></li><li><p>Green = good/better/preferred</p></li><li><p>Darker tones = more</p></li><li><p>Lighter tones = less </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
5
New cards

Official Standards?

There is no official standard for the geospatial industry; the ethics need to evolve with the industry

6
New cards

Establishment of Guidelines/Codes (3 overall examples)

1) Professional/Industry Organizations

  • Geospatial Professional Network (GPN)

  • American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing (ASPRS)

  • GIS Certification Institute (GISP)

2) United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)

  • Focuses on how geo tech are used to protect vulnerable populations

3) American Geographical Society (AGS) – EthicalGEO (5 Priorities)

  • Privacy

  • Politics

  • People

  • Planet

  • Property


7
New cards

Code of Ethics: 10 Key Attributes by Spatial Reserves

1. Maps should be evident, not deceptive or confusing

2. Know your audience – facilitates effective communication

3. Do not lie with your data

4. Show all relevant data as completely as possible

5. Do not discard contradictory data, remain neutral in your portrayal of data

6. Portray your data accurately, do not exaggerate or diminish

7. No plagiarism

8. Choose neutral symbols to minimize bias

9. Repeatability of your work – someone else can replicate it

10. Sensitivity to cultural values & beliefs

8
New cards

Joseph Kerski Quote

“…when creating a map, you should strive to provide a truthful, neutral representation of reality targeted specifically for your audiences’ level of knowledge so that your map can effectively convey your intended message.”

9
New cards

Placenames & Propaganda

Gulf of America, West Taiwan, Canada Everywhere, etc.

10
New cards

GIS Professional Ethics Project: Guide to Ethical Decision-Making (Workplace Dilemmas)

1. State the problem

  • Does it make you uncomfortable?

  • Is there a conflict of interest?

2. Check facts — some issues disappear with closer examination, others look very different

3. Identify relevant factors

  • Who’s involved?

  • What laws, professional code of conduct apply?

4. Develop list of options

  • Whom to go to

  • What to say

  • Possible scenarios

5. Review & Test Options

  • Harm — Is one choice > < than another?

  • Publicity — Ok with it being public?

  • Defensibility — In front of peers?

  • Reversibility — What if it impacted me how it would others?

  • Colleague, Professional & Organization tests — Talk to them all

6. Make choice based on 1-5

7. Review steps 1-6 to determine how to avoid this situation in the future


11
New cards

Case Study 1: Ethical Evaluation of Remote Sensing in Conservation

TBD 1

12
New cards

Case Study 2: Practical Application of the GIS Code of Ethics

TBD 2