Chapter 9: Equitable and other remedies

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/42

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

43 Terms

1
New cards

What is an action for an agreed sum?

Suing for a fixed amount of money that is owed (an action in debt or for the price), usually the price of goods or services supplied

2
New cards

What must be shown before a claimant can bring an action for an agreed sum?

Money is owed and the date for payment has fallen due

3
New cards

Can interest be claimed in an action for an agreed sum?

Yes, accrued interest for late payment can be claimed on top of the sum owed

4
New cards

Why is an action for an agreed sum more direct than a claim for damages?

There is no need to prove loss, and remoteness and mitigation drop out of the picture

5
New cards

What is specific performance?

An equitable court order requiring D to actually perform what they agreed to do, normally something other than merely paying money

6
New cards

When is specific performance generally available?

Only where damages are not an adequate remedy, e.g. sale of land

7
New cards

Why is specific performance available for contracts for the sale of land?

Land is unique: Claire wants 21 Acacia Avenue itself, not a house like it, so damages would be inadequate

8
New cards

Why is specific performance not generally available for sales of goods?

The buyer can claim damages and use them to buy identical goods elsewhere

9
New cards

Why will specific performance not usually be granted for employment or service contracts?

They depend on trust and confidence, and it would be inappropriate to force parties to work together once the relationship has broken down

10
New cards

Is specific performance available as of right?

No, it is discretionary and only awarded where it is just and equitable

11
New cards

What two things will the court consider when deciding whether to order specific performance?

Whether the claimant has acted equitably, and whether the order would cause disproportionate hardship to the defendant

12
New cards

What is an injunction?

An equitable, discretionary remedy only available where damages would be inadequate

13
New cards

How do injunctions differ from specific performance in how they are commonly used?

Specific performance makes D do what they agreed to do, whereas injunctions more commonly restrain D from doing what they agreed not to do

14
New cards

Give an example of when an injunction would be used to enforce a contract.

Reya agreed with the buyer of her hairdressing business not to set up another hairdresser's in the same village, so the buyer could seek an injunction to restrain her

15
New cards

When will an injunction not be granted?

If its effect would be to compel D to do acts they could not be ordered to do by specific performance (e.g. forcing an employee to work for a particular employer)

16
New cards

What were the facts and outcome of Page One Records v Britton?

The Troggs dismissed their manager, who had a clause preventing them from appointing anyone else. The injunction was refused because it would in practice force them to keep a manager they had lost confidence in

17
New cards

What is the general aim of restitution?

To prevent one party being unjustly enriched at the expense of the other

18
New cards

Does restitution require a breach of contract or a formed contract?

No, it can arise where there is no contract at all, but it is not available in every case of unjust enrichment

19
New cards

When can a payer recover money paid under a contract in restitution?

If the payee is in breach and there has been a total failure of consideration

20
New cards

What is a total failure of consideration?

Where the payee has not done any part of what they were supposed to do under the contract

21
New cards

Shakira pays £500 in advance and the seller refuses to deliver the goods. What can she do?

Claim restitution of the £500 for total failure of consideration, plus damages if replacement goods cost more

22
New cards

Bill pays £800 in advance and the painter never turns up. What are his remedies?

Restitution of the £800 for total failure of consideration, plus damages if a replacement painter costs more than £800

23
New cards

If a painter starts the job and then abandons it, is there a total failure of consideration?

No, so restitution is not available and the customer's only remedy is damages (the cost of getting someone else to finish the work)

24
New cards

When can restitution of a reasonable sum be claimed where the contract has been broken?

Where one party has supplied goods or done work and the other then breaches, the supplier can claim a reasonable sum as an alternative to damages

25
New cards

What choice does a supplier have where the other party breaches after work has been done?

Claim a reasonable sum (quantum meruit) in restitution, or claim damages (net loss of profit on the project)

26
New cards

What is a quantum meruit?

A reasonable sum for the work done (e.g. Gavin's partly built garage after Ray cancels)

27
New cards

When can a reasonable sum be claimed where no contract was ever formed?

Where work was done before a contract was finalised and negotiations then broke down

28
New cards

What were the facts and outcome of British Steel Corp v Cleveland Bridge and Engineering Co Ltd?

Steel nodes were made and delivered at the defendant's request while terms were still being negotiated. No contract was formed, but the claimants recovered a reasonable sum for the work done

29
New cards

What is the traditional purpose of damages in contract, and how do restitutionary damages differ?

Traditional damages are compensatory (based on C's loss), whereas restitutionary damages are based on the gains made by D, which need not reflect C's loss

30
New cards

What were the facts and outcome of Attorney-General v Blake?

Blake, a spy, was paid £150,000 in advances for his autobiography in breach of his undertaking. The Crown suffered no financial loss but received an account of Blake's profits as a just response to the breach

31
New cards

When will a claimant be awarded an account of profits for breach of contract?

Only in exceptional circumstances, where it is a just response to the breach (AG v Blake)

32
New cards

What are negotiating damages?

Damages for the notional loss of the opportunity to bargain (a reasonable release fee) where that is C's only loss

33
New cards

What were the facts and outcome of Wrotham Park Estate v Parkside Homes?

Parkside built on land in breach of a restrictive covenant and made a large profit. There was no diminution in value, but damages of 5% of the developer's profit were awarded in place of a mandatory injunction, for the lost chance to negotiate a release fee

34
New cards

When will negotiating damages not be awarded?

Where C has suffered clear financial loss, even if hard to calculate, and they are not an alternative to conventional damages

35
New cards

What is a contract of guarantee?

A contract where a guarantor promises to pay the debtor's debt if the debtor defaults (e.g. a parent guaranteeing a child's overdraft)

36
New cards

Is a guarantee a primary or secondary obligation?

Secondary: the guarantor pays if, and only if, the debtor does not pay

37
New cards

What formality does a guarantee require?

It must be evidenced in writing, otherwise it is void and completely ineffective

38
New cards

What does "evidenced in writing" mean for a guarantee?

The contract need not be written, but there must be written evidence that existed before the creditor seeks to enforce it and is signed by the guarantor. It can be a series of documents linked by reference

39
New cards

What is an indemnity?

A primary obligation where one party promises to reimburse pound-for-pound the other for a particular loss arising under the contract

40
New cards

Does an indemnity need to be evidenced in writing?

No, because it is a primary obligation

41
New cards

When are indemnities commonly used?

In business acquisitions and land purchases where there is a known specific liability or loss (e.g. £100,000 contamination clean-up costs)

42
New cards

What is the difference between warranties and indemnities in sale and purchase agreements?

Warranties allocate unknown risks to the seller (e.g. third party litigation), whereas indemnities allocate known liabilities or losses to the seller

43
New cards

In a shop, which statement is a guarantee and which is an indemnity: "If he does not pay you, I will" or "I'll ensure you're paid"?

"If he does not pay you, I will" is a guarantee (void if not in writing), and "I'll ensure you're paid" is a personal undertaking to pay, i.e. an indemnity