1/18
Law CBE
UK legal jurisdictions
The UK is a unitary state, meaning it is a single sovereign entity with a central government. However, it consists of four countries – England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland – each with its own distinct legal system and varying degrees of legislative power devolved to their respective governments. These are known as legal jurisdictions.
Legal jurisdictions refer to specific geographic or functional areas where particular legal systems and authorities have the power to create, interpret and enforce laws.
England and Wales
England and Wales share a unified legal system known as the ‘English legal system’. This system is characterised by common law principles and statutory law. It is the most widely recognised legal system within the UK.
Scotland
Scotland has its own distinct legal system known as the "Scots law." It is a hybrid system that incorporates elements of both civil law and common law traditions. Scots law is known for its unique approach to certain legal principles and procedures such as succession law and land laws.
Northern Ireland
Northern Ireland possesses its own legal system, which is similar to the English legal system but has some differences in terms of legislation and legal processes. Northern Irish law has been influenced by both English law and Irish legal traditions.
Law areas
The law of territory refers to the set of rules and regulations that a specific geographic area, such as a country or region, expects its citizens to follow.
These laws are created by recognised legal authorities within the territory and are enforced by various institutions, such as courts and law enforcement agencies. The purpose of these laws is to maintain order, protect rights, and provide a framework for resolving disputes.
Public law
Governs relationship between individuals and the state. Includes constitutional, administrative, and criminal law. Public law is concerned with issues that affect society as a whole, such as the enforcement of laws, the operation of government agencies, and the protection of public rights.
Private law
Governs relationships between individuals and entities in a more personal or commercial context. Includes contract, tort, property, and family law. Private law deals with disputes and legal issues that arise in private interactions, such as business transactions, property ownership, and personal relationships.
Revenue law
Aka tax law, is a branch of public law that deals with the rules and regulations governing the taxation of individuals and businesses. It includes the laws related to the assessment, collection, and enforcement of taxes.
Differences between the legal jurisdictions in the UK and Crown Dependencies
The legal systems in England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland are common law systems, unlike the civil law systems in countries like France and Germany. This means that, besides laws made by Parliament, UK courts also establish important legal principles, whereas civil law countries rely more on written codes.
The Isle of Man and the Channel Islands (Jersey and Guernsey) are not part of the UK. They have their own legal systems and governments and make their own legal and tax policies. However, as Crown Dependencies, the UK handles their foreign policy and defence.
Common law and equity
English law mainly relies on "common law," which is a type of law created by judges through their decisions and past rulings. However, common law can be strict and sometimes unfair. This led to the creation of another system called "equity," which aimed to be fair and just. Equity offered solutions that common law didn't, like court orders to stop someone from doing something (injunctions), forcing someone to fulfil a promise (specific performance), and managing property on behalf of others (trusts). Unlike common law, equity is applied only at the discretion of the court.
Scots law
Scots law is the legal system of Scotland, distinct from English law. It is a hybrid system, incorporating elements of both civil law and common law traditions, with significant influence from Roman law. This unique legal framework has evolved over centuries, reflecting Scotland's own historical, cultural, and social contexts, and the principles of Roman law have contributed to its development, particularly in areas such as property, obligations, and family law.
Scotland's devolution, initiated by the Scotland Act 1998, transferred certain legislative powers from the UK Parliament to the Scottish Parliament, enabling self-governance in areas like education, health, and justice.
However, not all aspects of the law are fully devolved, as areas like immigration, defence, and some tax matters remain under the jurisdiction of the UK Parliament. This partial devolution allows for the development of laws tailored specifically to Scotland's needs while maintaining coherence with the broader UK legal framework.
Division of law in the UK
Law divided into substantive and adjective law.
Adjective law:
Also known as procedural law, outlines the methods and procedures for enforcing the rights and duties established by substantive law. This area of law focuses on evidence, process and arbitration. The divisions of adjective law include:
law of evidence
civil procedure
criminal procedure
arbitration.
Substantive law:
defines the rights, duties, and legal relationships of individuals and collective bodies. The divisions of substantive law are:
public
private.
Private law:
Regulates the relationships between individuals and organisations, focusing on matters that do not involve the state. Examples include:
law of property
law of obligation
law of personas (e.g family law)
insolvency
international law
commercial law
company law.
Public law:
Governs the relationship between individuals and the state, as well as the structure and operation of the government. Areas of public law include:
criminal law
administrative law
international law
constitutional law
revenue law
National Insurance and Social Security
taxation.
Sources of law
Legislation:
Legislation, as a source of law in the UK, refers to laws enacted by Parliament, including primary legislation (Acts of Parliament) and secondary legislation (Statutory Instruments).
These laws provide a structured framework for governance and societal conduct, offering clear, codified rules that must be followed. Legislation is a fundamental source of law, ensuring consistency, clarity, and authority in the legal system.
i.e is the written law made by the government.
Case law:
Case law, also known as common law, is a source of law in the UK that arises from judicial decisions made in courts. It involves judges interpreting and applying statutes and legal principles to specific cases, with their rulings setting precedents for future cases.
This system ensures that the law evolves through judicial interpretation, providing flexibility and adaptability in the legal framework.
i.e is law created by judges through their decisions in court cases.
Assimilated law: came from the European Union, from when the UK was a member.
Legal persons definitions
Are entities, such as individuals or organisations, that have legal rights and obligations.
Persons
In tax legislation, the term "person" follows the definition from the Interpretation Act 1978. According to this Act, a "person" includes both individuals and groups of people, whether they are legally incorporated (like companies) or not (like clubs or associations).
This means that in tax laws, "person" can refer to:
an individual (a single human being)
a corporate body or company (a group of people legally recognised as a single entity)
an unincorporated group (a group of people not legally recognised as a single entity).
So, "person" in tax terms can mean an individual, a company, or any other organised group of people, whether they are legally incorporated or not.
Individuals
An individual is classified as a ‘natural person’ or human being. Individuals are said to have legal personality which means they possess legal rights and obligations, such as the ability to enter into contracts, own property, and be subject to legal actions. These rights and responsibilities distinguish individuals from other legal entities for example the obligation to pay income tax.
Juristic persons or corporations
Juristic persons describes entities that are not human beings but are given legal status by the law. They don't have a physical form, but in the eyes of the law, they have rights and responsibilities just like a human being. We refer to juristic persons as corporations.
Corporations include companies or partnerships, that are recognised by law as having their own legal rights and obligations, separate from those of their individual members or owners.
When it comes to tax laws, the term "company" can have different definitions. But what they all have in common is that a company is considered a body corporate. This means it’s a legal entity, that is recognised by law as having its own separate existence.This separation is fundamental in structuring how legal entities interact within the legal system.
Non-juristic persons or unincorporated associations
According to the Interpretation Act 1978, an unincorporated group of people is considered a "person" for tax purposes. However, these groups, known as unincorporated associations, don't have their own separate legal identity. This means they are seen as "transparent" because they don't exist independently of the people who make them up. Instead, you look at the individual members who form the group.
Examples include:
trustees who manage a trust
personal representatives who manage the estate of someone who has passed away
clubs or groups, like sports or social clubs, that are not legally incorporated.
Creation of companies
Charter
Companies created by charter are established through a formal document that outlines the company's rights, privileges, and obligations, issued by a sovereign authority or government. Historically, many of these charters were granted by the Crown, particularly for entities that served public or significant societal roles, such as universities, professional bodies, and certain corporations.
Examples include the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), the Royal College of Surgeons, and the University of Cambridge, which were all established by royal charter, signifying their special status and often involving a formal and ceremonial process.
Statute
Companies created by statute are established through specific legislation passed by a governmental body, which defines their structure, purpose, and regulatory framework. These companies are typically formed to fulfil public functions or provide essential services, and their creation is directly authorised by an Act of Parliament or similar legislative authority.
Examples include public bodies like Transport for London (TfL).
Companies Act 2006
Companies created under the Companies Act 2006 are established by registering with Companies House, the UK's official registrar of companies. The process involves submitting specific documents, including the Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association, along with details about the company's directors, shareholders, and registered office. Once registered, the company is legally recognised as a separate entity and must comply with the regulatory and reporting requirements set forth in the Companies Act 2006.
Types of corporation
Corporation sole:
A corporation sole is a legal entity consisting of a single individual who holds a specific office or position, allowing for the continuity of office through successive holders.
This structure, often used for certain public offices such as bishops in the Church of England or government officials, enables seamless transfer of rights and responsibilities to successors.
The individual acts in a double capacity: as a natural person and as the holder of the office, ensuring that the legal entity persists regardless of changes in officeholders.
Corporation aggregate:
A corporation aggregate is a legal entity formed by a group of individuals who collectively act as a single entity, such as companies or partnerships.
This structure allows the entity to own property, enter into contracts, and be liable for obligations independently of its members, who act in a single capacity as part of the collective entity.
The corporation aggregate ensures continuity and legal recognition beyond the involvement of any single individual, facilitating organised and sustained business operations.
Particular attributes of corporations
Both types of corporations—corporation sole and corporation aggregate—have something called perpetual succession. This means that even if their members change, the corporation itself continues to exist. For example, if a shareholder in a company sells their shares or passes away, the company still remains.
For a corporation sole, like the position of a Member of Parliament (MP), the role always exists even if it's temporarily empty. For instance, the MP's seat is always there, but it might be vacant during an election until someone new is elected.
Another important feature of corporations is continuous identity. This means that the corporation is seen as the same entity over time, regardless of changes in its members. So, any obligations or debts the corporation takes on stay with it, even if the people involved change.
Lastly, just because you are a member of a corporation doesn't mean you can freely take its income or property. Members can't automatically take profits out of the corporation without following specific rules.
Assessing foreign entities on UK principles
The process of classifying a foreign entity involves evaluating its characteristics against specific legal criteria, such as its legal existence, share capital issuance, operational independence, profit distribution, debt responsibility, and asset ownership, to determine if it meets the requirements to be recognised as a corporation under UK law.
The foreign entity in question doesn’t have to meet the full criteria as outlined in the following steps. However, the decision whether it can be classified as a corporate entity is decided when all of the factors have been examined.
Steps:
Does it have a legal existence separate from members?
Does it issue share capital or similar?
Is the business carried on by the entity separate from members?
Are profits automatically paid to members or does it require separate decision?
Who is responsible for debts?
Who owns the assets?
Questions of fact
Questions of fact involve determining the specific details of a situation, such as verifying financial records or the nature of a transaction, and are used to establish the factual basis needed for applying the law.
The answers to questions of fact are typically determined by examining evidence, such as witness testimony, documents, and physical items.
Purpose of the questions of fact:
Authenticity of documents
Meanings of words in context
Business and accounting matters
Impression and degree
Expert opinion
Overseas and non tax law
Questions of fact in tax law
Questions of fact in tax law involve determining the specifics of a legal persons situation, such as income, expenses, and the nature of transactions. These questions help establish the factual basis needed to apply the relevant tax laws accurately.
Understanding the facts ensures that tax assessments and compliance measures are based on accurate and complete information.
Questions of Law
Questions of law involve interpreting and applying legal principles and statutes to decide how the law should be enforced in a given scenario.
These questions focus on what the law means and how it should be applied to the facts of a case, typically decided by judges rather than juries.
Purpose of the questions of law:
Proper understanding and application of the law
Failure to ask the proper question
Interpretation of words and meaning
Application of the meaning of a word
Questions of law in tax law
Questions of law in tax law involve interpreting and applying tax statutes and legal principles to determine how the law should be enforced in a given situation.
These questions help clarify the legal rules and guidelines that govern tax-related matters. By resolving questions of law, tax authorities and courts ensure consistent and fair application of tax regulations.
Primary facts and inferences of fact
For instance, if a witness testifies that they saw a person at a specific location at a particular time (a primary fact), a court might infer that this person was involved in an event that occurred there (an inference of fact).
Primary facts:
Primary facts are the basic, foundational pieces of evidence or data that are directly observed or recorded. These facts are objective and verifiable, such as financial records, receipts, and documented transactions.
Inferences of facts:
Inferences of fact involve drawing logical conclusions from primary facts to establish elements that are not explicitly documented. Tax authorities and courts use these inferences to fill in gaps where direct evidence may be lacking.
For instance, if a taxpayer's lifestyle significantly exceeds their reported income, an inference might be made that there is unreported income. These inferences are pivotal in tax investigations and disputes, helping to ensure that tax obligations are accurately assessed and enforced.
Features of the UK constitution
The constitution of the UK is unique in that it is not codified into a single written document. Instead, it is derived from various sources, including statutes, common law, and historical documents.
Monarch
Uncodified - not contained in a single written document. Instead composed of various statutes, judicial decisions (case law), and long-standing conventions.
Flexible - Parliament has sovereign authority to amend or create laws, allowing the constitution to evolve and adapt to changing circumstances.
Unitary - UK has centralised govt control (unitary state), but due to devolution, regional govts in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have certain powers.
Dualist - dualist approach to international law means can enter into treaties such as Double Taxation Relief (DTR) agreements, but these treaties require domestic legislation to be implemented and have legal effect within the country.
Fundamental doctrines
Fundamental doctrines in constitutional law form the core principles that underpin the legal framework of a nation. These are:
Rule of law
In the UK, everyone (except generally the Crown in its executive capacity and the King in his private capacity as Monarch) is subject to the law and the courts' jurisdiction. No one can be punished without a clear breach of the law. The rule of law means that every person has the freedom to do anything unless explicitly restricted by law. The fundamental doctrines of the UK's constitutional law include the rule of law, which guarantees personal liberties:
freedom of association
assembly, demonstration
expression
protection of property.
These freedoms are further supported by the Human Rights Act 1998. The law must be transparent, non-arbitrary, and not applied retrospectively, ensuring lawful tax planning is permissible. However, such tax planning is limited by regulations like the General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) and the Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Schemes (DOTAS).
Separation of powers
The separation of powers in the UK ensures that the executive, legislative, and judicial branches operate as distinct entities. These bodies provide checks and balances for one another.
Parliament holds the Crown accountable, and the Judiciary operates independently of the Crown, overseeing government actions. Parliament does not perform judicial functions, and civil servants and armed forces members cannot be MPs.
However, the separation of powers isn't absolute; overlaps exist. For example, only MPs can hold executive positions, the Crown appoints judges, and the Judiciary creates rules of common law and Equity.
Parliamentary supremacy
One of the defining features of the UK constitution is the supremacy of Parliament. As the supreme law-making body, Parliament can legislate on any subject, including its own processes, devolved areas, and even succession to the throne. It can also give its laws retrospective effect in exceptional circumstances.
Parliament is not bound by previous Parliaments and can amend or abolish any law, including common law or Equity rules. Similarly, it cannot bind future Parliaments. The validity of parliamentary laws cannot be challenged in court.
Parliament can choose to limit its own supremacy. For instance, the European Communities Act 1972 subjected the UK to European law, but Parliament later reversed this, demonstrating its ultimate authority. Another example is the Human Rights Act 1998, which aligns UK law with the European Convention on Human Rights. Public bodies must act in accordance with this Act, and individuals can bring human rights cases in UK courts, with appeals going to the European Court of Human Rights. UK laws must be interpreted to be compatible with the Human Rights Act, and if they are not, courts can issue a declaration of incompatibility, though they cannot invalidate the law.
What is judicial review ?
What is it?
Administrative law governs the actions and decisions of governmental agencies, ensuring they comply with legal standards and principles. In the context of tax this would be ensuring a balance of power between the HMRC and the taxpayer.
A judicial review is used when an individual or organisation believes that a public body has made a decision or taken an action that is illegal, irrational, or procedurally unfair, and seeks to challenge it in court.
Judicial reviews are conducted by judges in the High Court or equivalent higher courts, who assess the legality and procedural fairness of the decisions or actions under challenge.
Grounds for applying for a judicial review
Since HMRC, part of the executive branch, manages taxation and determines taxpayer rights and duties, it can be subject to judicial review to ensure it does not exceed or abuse its legal powers. Judicial review focuses on the process behind HMRC's decisions, not the merits of the decisions themselves, differentiating it from an appeal. Its purpose is to ensure fair treatment by HMRC, not to replace HMRC's judgment with that of the Judiciary.
Applications for judicial review are made to the Administrative Court or the Upper Tribunal, which must grant permission based on an arguable case and sufficient interest by the applicant. These applications must be made promptly, typically within three months, or one year in cases involving the Human Rights Act 1998. Only applicants with sufficient interest (locus standi) can apply for judicial review.
Categories for the grounds for applying for judicial review:
Illegality
If the HMRC issues a tax assessment based on incorrect legal grounds or ignores relevant evidence presented by the taxpayer, these actions could be challenged as illegal in a judicial review.
Other examples of illegality in the context of a judicial review appeal against HMRC include:
HMRC exceeding its statutory powers, such as imposing a tax penalty not authorised by law
failing to consider relevant information when making a decision
misinterpreting tax legislation or error of fact
HMRC failing to act when required to do so
Irrationality
If HMRC imposes a disproportionate penalty without reasonable justification or fails to follow its own guidelines in a way that leads to an absurd outcome, these actions could be grounds for a judicial review based on irrationality.
Irrationality refers to a decision made that is so unreasonable that no reputable authority would have made it, often described as "Wednesbury unreasonableness."Examples include:
HMRC making a tax assessment based on arbitrary or capricious criteria
ignoring clear evidence that contradicts its decision
applying inconsistent standards to similar cases.
Procedurally wrong
If HMRC conducts a tax audit without informing the taxpayer of their rights or makes a decision based on undisclosed evidence, these actions could be grounds for a judicial review based on procedural wrongness.
Procedural wrongness refers to situations where HMRC has not followed the required legal procedures or has breached principles of natural justice in making a decision. Examples include:
failing to provide adequate notice of a tax investigation
not giving the taxpayer an opportunity to present their case
not following statutory procedures for issuing a tax penalty
not treating the individual with impartiality.
Judicial review remedies
If a taxpayer's judicial review is successful, there are various remedies available at the discretion of the court depending on the outcome of the appeal.
These remedies are known as prerogative orders and include:
Quashing order
A quashing order would nullify an unlawful decision, effectively removing it from legal effect and requiring the agency to reconsider the matter.
This ensures that the decision is re-evaluated in compliance with legal standards and proper procedures, rectifying any identified errors.
Mandatory order
A mandatory order compels the agency to perform a specific legal duty it has failed to fulfil.
This ensures that the agency takes the necessary action required by law, correcting any previous omissions or failures to act.
Prohibition order
A prohibition order prevents the agency from taking or continuing an action that is unlawful.
This ensures that agency refrains from acting beyond its legal powers or in a manner that contravenes legal procedures, safeguarding against potential future errors.