1/134
Ethics CBE
Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation (PCRT)
Guides tax professionals in particular on ethical behaviour, emphasising legal compliance, integrity and responsible tax advice. It helps manage situations where client requests may challenge ethical or legal standards.
By prioritising ethics over personal or client interests, PCRT maintains public trust and supports professionals in navigating complex situations, reinforcing the profession’s credibility.
Member
Anyone affiliated with the Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) or the Association of Taxation Technicians (ATT). This category includes full members, students pursuing professional qualifications and ADIT affiliates (specialists in international tax).
PRPG applies to all members equally. This ensures a unified approach to ethical conduct, with every member held to the same high standards. Members are expected to act in a way that upholds the reputation of the profession and supports public confidence in tax services.
Member in practice
Refers to a member who provides taxation services as an individual practitioner or as part of a firm. This includes sole proprietors, partners in a partnership, members of limited liability partnerships, and company directors offering tax services.
Everyone offering professional tax services – whether on a full-time or a part-time basis – is subject to PRPG’s rules. This clarity avoids gaps in accountability and reinforces the responsibility of practitioners to act ethically and competently.
Tax advice
All services related to taxation, such as preparing and submitting tax returns, advising on tax planning, representing clients in disputes with tax authorities, and offering guidance on compliance with tax laws.
Tax advice often involves complex and sensitive matters, ranging from personal income tax to corporate compliance. PRPG ensures that professionals offering tax advice do so with care, competence and ethical responsibility, providing clients with accurate and lawful solutions tailored to their circumstances.
Client
Anyone who engages a tax professional or firm for advice, guidance or services. This can include individuals, organisations, companies and nonprofit organisations.
Clients place their trust in tax professionals to guide them through complex and often high-stakes matters. PRPG ensures that clients, regardless of their size or circumstances, receive equitable and ethical treatment, building trust in the profession.
Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB)
An independent body, both legally and operationally separate from the CIOT and ATT.
It’s responsible for overseeing the Taxation Disciplinary Scheme, which serves as the practical framework for managing complaints lodged against members of these organisations. The TDB ensures that any grievances are addressed fairly and professionally, maintaining the integrity and standards of the tax profession.
Who does PRPG apply to?
full members of CIOT and ATT
students registered with either body
international tax affiliates (ADIT affiliates)
PRPG’s jurisdiction is not limited to members directly engaged in tax practice. Members employed by organisations that are not CIOT or ATT members are still required to uphold PRPG standards.
This ensures that members remain accountable for their actions, regardless of the nature of their employment. For example, an employed tax professional cannot claim that their employer’s policies exempt them from adhering to PRPG principles.
What are the fundamental principals of PRPG?
integrity
objectivity
professional competence and due care
confidentiality
professional behaviour.
Integrity
Importance of honesty and legality:
act honestly in professional work - cannot purposefully provide false or misleading info.
not take part in illegal activity
separately maintain different client’s money and assets
seek work in a professional manner
Objectivity
Remain unbiased and avoid any conflicts of interests that could compromise their judgement.
Ensure decisions are based on factual info and free from any undue influence or personal bias. This principle helps maintain the credibility and reliability of professional advice and services.
Professional competence and due care
Carry out work with proper regard for the technical and professional standards expected in their field.
Emphasises that professionals shouldn’t undertake work they are not competent to perform, ensuring that clients receive services that meet the highest standards of quality and expertise.
This principle ensures continuous development and adherence to best practices.
Confidentiality
Sensitive info is kept private unless the member is authorised to disclose it, or when overridden by a legal or professional duty.
This obligation applies to all employees and subcontractors and remains in effect indefinitely. It necessitates compliance with all data protection laws. Adghering to this principle ensures the protection of client information and upholds trust.
Professional behaviour
Individuals uphold all professional standards and avoid actions that could discredit themselves, CIOT/ATT, or the profession as a whole.
This expectation extends beyond business relationships, encompassing all conduct that may impact the professional community. Adhering to this principle ensures the maintenance of a respected and trustworthy profession.
Professional indemnity insurance
The Professional Rules and Practice Guidelines (PRPG) list a series of professional obligations that all members must meet. One of these obligations is to have and maintain their professional indemnity insurance.
Professional indemnity insurance (PII) is a type of insurance designed to protect professionals and businesses against claims made by clients or third parties relating to negligence, errors or omissions. It is essential that a member’s PII is up to date at all times and that the level of cover meets the minimum requirements set out by the CIOT and ATT.
Benefits of professional indemnity insurance (PII)
Protection against claims:
provides coverage for legal costs and any claims for damages arising from professional negligence, errors or omissions.
Financial security:
PII safeguards the financial stability of a business by covering compensation costs that could otherwise be substantial.
Reputation management:
PII helps protect the reputation of a business or professional by addressing claims promptly and effectively.
Compliance:
ensures members are compliant with the professional obligations to always have coverage.
Annual returns
Annual returns for members of the CIOT and ATT is a professional obligation that involves self submitting a yearly report detailing their professional activities and compliance with the institutes’ standards. The time limit to submit these is provided to members by CIOT/ATT.
This process ensures that members maintain their professional qualifications, adhere to continuing professional development (CPD) requirements, and comply with ethical and regulatory standards set by CIOT and ATT, thus upholding the integrity and professionalism of the tax profession.
What encompasses ‘compliance with professional obligations’?
Complying with standards such as Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation (PCRT) for ethical tax practices and adhering to anti-money laundering legislation to prevent financial crimes. Proper registration with relevant bodies is required to uphold accountability, and engaging in continuing professional development (CPD) helps maintain and enhance your professional knowledge and skills.
Compliance with professional obligations : PRCT
The PCRT sets out the fundamental principles and standards of behaviour that members of the CIOT and ATT must adhere to in their tax work.
Compliance with professional obligations : Anti-money laundering legislation and registration
Anti-money laundering (AML) encompasses a set of laws, regulations and procedures that aim to prevent the laundering of illegally obtained funds, whether by individuals or companies, into legitimate income.
Members of the CIOT and ATT must comply with these measures to help safeguard the financial system, acting in line with the standards set by the Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies (CCAB).
They have also agreed to be supervised to ensure compliance and are required to report any suspicious transactions to the appropriate authorities. Proper registration with relevant professional bodies and regulatory authorities ensures accountability and adherence to professional standards.
Compliance with professional obligations : continuing professional development
Continuing professional development (CPD) is the process by which professionals maintain and enhance their knowledge, skills, and competencies through ongoing education and training.
All members must stay fully informed about statute, case law, and practice in their areas of expertise. CPD is compulsory for all members, however there are some exceptions which are outlined by the institute. Compulsory CPD rules do not apply to students of the CIOT or ATT who are not yet members.
What constitutes a report to the TDB?
A member may be reported to the Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB) for a range of professional misconduct by clients, colleagues or regulatory bodies, including:
Breach of ethical standards: engaging in dishonesty, fraud or any behaviour that undermines the integrity of the profession.
Negligence: providing substandard or incorrect tax advice or services that result in harm or loss to a client.
Conflict of interest: failing to disclose or properly manage conflicts of interest that affect professional judgement.
Incompetence: demonstrating a lack of necessary skills or knowledge to perform professional duties effectively.
What to do if contacted by TBD to provide evidence and testimony for a report on another member?
All members must adhere to the board’s requests and reply promptly. The time limits to reply to requests are set by the board. Any delays or failure to reply can result in further disciplinary action being taken.
Also:
Acknowledge and cooperate:
Acknowledge receipt of any communication from the TDB.
Provide all requested documentation and information accurately and promptly.
Attend interviews and hearings as required.
Adhere to decisions and orders:
Respect and accept the decisions made by the Disciplinary Tribunal.
Implement any imposed sanctions, such as paying fines, undergoing additional training or observing suspensions.
Engage with the appeals process of necessary:
If appealing, follow the prescribed procedures for lodging an appeal.
Comply with any interim measures during the appeal process.
Valid reasons for someone to be referred to the TBD?
Providing false or misleading information to a client or tax authority.
Attending fewer than the required CPD hours but reporting full compliance
When and how to notify the CIOT and ATT of any significant issues that may affect their professional standing?
It is a professional obligation for all members to notify the CIOT or ATT if they have had a change of circumstances in regards to convictions, receiving disciplinary action for misconduct or being declared bankrupt.
Members notify the professional body by submitting a formal written notification, including all relevant details and supporting documentation, to the head of professional standards. This must be submitted within 2 months of the change of circumstances as to avoid any further disciplinary action.
What constitutes as a change of circumstances in regards to illegality and gross misconduct? (reporting to CIOT and ATT)
Illegality:
Members must contact the CIOT or ATT if they are:
convicted of a criminal offence
arrested on suspicion of committing a criminal offence.
Members must provide detail of the conviction and / or allegation and comply with any requests for further information.
However, it’s not necessary to report a speeding offence if the member goes on a driving awareness course or accepts a fixed penalty for speeding.
Gross misconduct:
Members must contact the CIOT or ATT if they any of the following occur.
Their employment is terminated due to misconduct/gross misconduct.
They receive notification of disciplinary and / or regulatory action upheld against them, either by another professional body they belong to or by a regulator.
They receive a dishonest tax agent conduct notice.
They receive a monitoring notice from HMRC under the Promoters of Tax Avoidance Schemes (POTAS) legislation.
Members must provide further information if requested by the CIOT or ATT.
Reporting own bankruptcy
Bankruptcy is a legal process where an individual is declared unable to repay their outstanding debts, leading to the liquidation of their assets to satisfy creditors.
Declaration of personal bankruptcy: members must inform CIOT or ATT if they have been declared bankrupt by a court of law. This includes providing details of the bankruptcy order and the date it was issued.
Discharge from bankruptcy: members must also notify CIOT or ATT when they are discharged from bankruptcy, including the date of discharge and any conditions attached to it.
The CIOT or ATT will ordinarily not refer a member to the Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB) until the outcome of the financial proceedings is known.
Reporting Individual Voluntary Arrangements (IVA)
An IVA is a formal agreement between a debtor and their creditors to repay a portion of their debts over a specified period, and is typically managed by an insolvency practitioner.
Entering into an IVA: members must notify CIOT or ATT if they enter into an Individual Voluntary Arrangement. This includes providing information on the terms of the IVA, the date it was agreed, and the name of the insolvency practitioner handling the arrangement.
Completion or termination of an IVA: members must inform CIOT or ATT when an IVA is completed or terminated, including the date and any relevant details of the completion or termination process.
The CIOT or ATT will ordinarily not refer a member to the Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB) until the outcome of the financial proceedings is known.
What is honorary work, with examples?
Honorary work typically involves taking on roles or responsibilities without compensation, often in recognition of one’s expertise or standing in the profession. It usually relates to official positions or titles that carry a certain level of prestige and responsibility.
Taking part in honorary work allows members to use their expertise to benefit those in need, contributing to the wider community and addressing social inequalities.
Examples:
Serving on charity boards: a tax professional might be appointed as a trustee or board member of a charity, providing governance and strategic direction.
Advisory roles: acting as a voluntary advisor to community groups or local government bodies on financial and tax-related matters.
Professional committees: being member of a committee within a professional body, such as ATT or CIOT, to help develop industry standards and policies.
Honorary treasurer: serving as the honorary treasurer for a non-profit organisation, overseeing financial affairs without renumeration.
What is pro bono work, with examples?
Pro bono work refers to providing professional services voluntarily and without payment to benefit individuals, groups or organisations that are underserved or unable to afford such services. It’s often associated with direct service delivery to those in need.
Examples:
Tax clinics: offering free consultations and advice sessions to individuals and small businesses who cannot afford professional tax services.
Charity support: assisting non-profit organisations with their tax compliance and financial management on a voluntary basis.
Educational workshops: conducting workshops and seminars to educate the public on tax matters, helping them understand their tax obligations and rights.
Community projects: participating in community initiatives that require tax expertise, such as advising on the tax implications of community development projects.
What is practice governance?
Clear operational guidelines and contingency plans. Ensure business runs smoothly in the face of unexpected events.
Has a ‘memorandum of understanding’ - how business operates, name complies with business regulations.
For sole practitioners a robust contingency plan is crucial to prepare for unexpected events like illness to ensure continued support for clients.
Business continuity plan - steps to take in case of major disruptions like natural disasters and cyber attacks.
Engaging new clients effectively - before taking on a new client, receive professional clearance from previous adviser with their consent. Ensures smooth transition and protects both parties.
Issue an engagement letter - outlines scope and nature of services. Protects you and client, but also prevents misunderstandings.
Act with reasonable skill and care, and seek a second opinion from a trusted colleague if need assurance.
Confirm advice in writing.
Maintaining organised records and monitoring tax deadlines.
Inform clients of deadlines and any tax due, unless said otherwise in engagement.
Key considerations of practice governance
Key considerations include organising the business effectively and presenting it professionally to the world. Including:
Governing documents and agreements : establish a ‘memorandum of understanding’ - a formal agreement that clearly explains how the business will function, specifying the roles and responsibilities of each partner or principal. This clarity not only helps prevent disputes but also ensures smooth operations.
Practice name : When choosing a practice name, it is crucial to ensure compliance with relevant partnership and company laws. The name should project a professional image that accurately reflects the nature of the practice.
Typically, a name derived from current or former members of the firm, or from a firm with which it has merged or succeeded, is considered clear and not misleading.
Practice brand: A practice's brand encompasses all materials used for external communications, such as stationery, advertisements, websites, and other digital platforms. It's essential that these branding materials adhere to the following guidelines:
They must meet legal standards regarding the names of partners, principals, and other involved parties.
They should align with guidelines for practising designations.
Specialist services should only be advertised if the firm possesses the necessary expertise to offer them.
The overall presentation should maintain a high level of professionalism.
Additionally, the PRPG offers guidance on how to handle changes like merging with another firm or dissolving a practice. It also clarifies that being a member of the CIOT or ATT does not automatically qualify tax practitioners to offer investment services, which require specific authorisation.
Practice governance for a sole practitioner
For a sole practitioner, governance is inherently streamlined, as the individual is responsible for all strategic and operational decisions, allowing for a more agile and personalised approach to practice management.
A particular consideration for sole practitioners, as guided by the PRPG, is ensuring the continuity of their practice in the event of illness or even death.
Sole practitioner : business continuity plan if temporary incapacity?
The PRPG strongly recommends that sole practitioners establish a plan to ensure business continuity in cases of illness or temporary incapacity. Without such a plan, there is a risk of significant challenges arising, which could impact client interests.
According to the PRPG, practitioners should evaluate whether their practice has sufficient resources to fulfil its obligations in their absence. If resources are insufficient, it is advised to arrange for another firm or a temporary replacement (locum) to handle their responsibilities.
The PRPG emphasises the importance of ensuring that anyone taking over is experienced, competent, and adequately insured to carry out the necessary tasks.
Sole practitioner : business continuity plan if permanent incapacity?
According to the guidance outlined in the PRPG, it’s crucial for sole practitioners to prepare for scenarios involving death or permanent incapacity by having a plan for the continued operation of their practice.
This plan should be detailed in a formal agreement to avoid any potential confusion or disputes. The document should outline the duties and timeframe for the person managing the practice and define the legal connection with the sole practitioner or their representatives. Consulting with a lawyer skilled in creating such agreements is recommended. Granting a power of attorney might also be appropriate.
The individual responsible for managing the practice must maintain the same level of care and responsibility towards the sole practitioner or their representatives as they would towards any client. They should not exploit their position for personal gain beyond what was agreed upon.
PRPG guidance on the dissolution or merger of practices?
When practices merge or a practice is dissolved, it is generally expected that clients will be informed and, when appropriate, given the choice to continue with the newly formed practice.
The PRPG stresses the importance of maintaining adequate professional indemnity insurance coverage throughout this process. Practitioners are also encouraged to seek specialist legal advice to handle matters such as the transfer of engagements and other contractual issues effectively.
Additionally, the PRPG advises that when a practice ceases operations, the responsibility for services rendered continues. It is essential to arrange ongoing professional indemnity coverage in line with the CIOT and ATT PII Regulations.
Retiring partners should also consider securing an indemnity from those who continue in the practice to protect against future claims.
PRPG guidance on regulated investment business activities?
Holding a membership with the CIOT or ATT does not, by itself, grant the authority to offer regulated services (providing financial advice, e.g. on investments or pensions). To engage in activities covered by these regulations, a member must be part of a firm authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) or associated with a Designated Professional Body (DPB).
Recognised DPBs include:
The Law Society (England and Wales)
The Law Society of Scotland
The Law Society of Northern Ireland
The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW)
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS)
Chartered Accountants Ireland
The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA)
The Institute and Faculty of Actuaries (IFoA)
The Council for Licensed Conveyancers (CLC)
The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS).
Providing regulated investment business services
When a member is employed at a firm associated with a Designated Professional Body (DPB), they are allowed to offer a limited range of investment services, referred to as 'exempt regulated activities.' For more detailed information, they should seek guidance from the relevant DPB.
Determining what qualifies as regulated or exempt regulated activities can be quite complex. If a member is uncertain whether their activities fall into these categories, it is advisable for them to seek independent legal advice or consult with a DPB.
Examples:
A member working for a firm that is neither authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) nor part of a DPB can discuss the general benefits of setting up a pension but must avoid mentioning any specific pension product providers.
A member employed at a firm authorised by the FCA, and who is registered with them as an Approved Person in this area, can provide comprehensive advice on pensions and recommend specific products.
However, they require additional FCA authorisation before advising on pension transfers or opt-outs.
If a member is with a firm registered under a DPB, they can discuss the benefits of setting up a pension and provide feedback on advice from an authorised financial adviser regarding pensions and selecting pension products.
However, they cannot recommend alternative products.
Guiding new clients in choosing the right professional adviser
When a potential client approaches a member for professional services, the member is not required to accept the work. In fact, they should refuse if they feel they cannot meet the necessary duty of care for that client. For instance, if a tax advisor is approached by a business owner seeking complex international tax planning, and the advisor lacks expertise in that area, they should decline the engagement to uphold professional standards.
Additionally, clients have the freedom to select or switch their professional advisers, seek a second opinion, or hire different advisers for various issues. For example, a client might choose to consult one tax expert for personal tax matters while engaging another for business tax advice, ensuring they receive the most specialised expertise for each aspect.
Essential considerations for client acceptance
When taking on a new client, a member must carefully evaluate several key factors to ensure a successful and compliant engagement.
This process involves thorough identification, risk assessment, and ensuring that the necessary skills and competencies are in place. Additionally, professionals must consider potential conflicts of interest and adhere to relevant regulations, such as the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013.
Keeping a thorough record of the decision-making process, especially for complex client acceptances, is recommended to ensure transparency and accountability.
Follow AML guidelines when taking on a new client (available on CIOT and ATT websites).
Evaluate client risk:
Evaluate client’s personal and business circumstances
Financial standing
Source of funds
Integrity
Commitment to tax law compliance
Ensure any identifies risks can be managed effectively with the available resources.
Determine whether the practice has the necessary skills and expertise to meet the client’s requirements throughout the engagement.
Any conflicts of interest? and if they can be managed without compromising professional integrity.
Gain full disclosure of the client’s tax affairs - do not get involved in illegal activity whether intentionally or unintentionally.
Consider the application of the Consumer Contracts Regulations when dealing with clients classified as consumers - these regulations require a cancellation notice to be provided if the contract isn’t finalised at the business premises, ensuring enforceability of contract terms, including fees.
Failure to follow these rules can lead to legal penalties.
Guidelines for fees and rewards for referrals?
Building a client base often involves networking and referrals. Sometimes, professionals may choose to reward those who introduce them to new clients or generate more work from existing ones.
When permitted by law, this can involve paying a fee, commission, or other reward. However, it’s essential to adhere to specific guidelines to ensure ethical practice and maintain trust.
Avoiding undue pressure: Ensure that the person referring the client hasn't used any undue pressure or influence.
For example, if someone suggests your services, make sure they haven't forced or unduly persuaded the client to choose you.
Transparency with clients: Before accepting new business, communicate clearly with the prospective client. Provide written details of any fee, commission, or reward you plan to offer for their introduction, and identify who will receive it.
For instance, if a colleague refers a client, disclose the referral fee and name the colleague as the recipient to keep everything transparent.
Professional enquiry guidance?
When taking on a new client, the PRPG on professional enquiry (also known as professional clearance) recommend that a professional generally reach out to the client's previous adviser before agreeing to the new role. However, this step requires the client's permission. Once permission is granted, the professional should write to the previous adviser to ask if there is any professional reason not to accept the client, while avoiding inquiries about any Anti-Money Laundering (AML) suspicious activity reports.
According to the PRPG, it can also be helpful to request any relevant information that will assist in managing the client's affairs smoothly. This ensures that important tasks, such as filing deadlines or submitting claims, are not overlooked during the transition. The request for information should be reasonable and consider any costs involved for either the client or the previous adviser.
If the new adviser doesn't receive a positive response—whether because the client doesn't allow communication, the previous adviser doesn't reply, or the response is negative—the new adviser should carefully evaluate all the facts and available evidence before deciding to take on the client. The PRPG advises documenting the reasons and considerations behind the decision, especially if choosing to proceed with the appointment.
Guidance on Services Directive for new clients
Under the Services Directive, professionals, whether self-employed or leading a legal entity, are required to share specific details with clients and potential clients. This information must be provided before finalising a contract for services, or if no contract exists, before the service begins. For more detailed guidance, resources are available on the CIOT and ATT websites.
Consider a consultant preparing to offer advisory services, before signing any agreement, they must inform the client about their qualifications, service scope, and any applicable terms.
This transparency ensures clients understand what to expect and fosters trust.
Obligations in respect of advice given by a predecessor
According to the PRPG's guidance on Obligations in Respect of Advice Given by a Predecessor, professionals generally aren't required to examine the advice provided by a previous adviser, unless the client specifically requests it. However, if a professional discovers any errors in that advice, they must inform the client.
For instance, if a new tax advisor takes over a client's accounts and notices a mistake in the past tax filings, it's their responsibility to notify the client about this issue. The client can then decide how to proceed, potentially correcting the error to avoid future complications.
Professionals should also refer to the guidelines in the Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation (PCRT), which are available on the CIOT and ATT websites. These guidelines can provide further clarity on handling such situations and ensuring that all actions align with best practices.
General principles of engagement letters
Guidance is based on the Law of England and Wales and on practice and procedures in the UK. The CIOT and ATT strongly recommend that their members issue engagement letters to their clients.
The general principles of an engagement letter are to safeguard both the practitioner and the client by defining the scope and nature of the work to be performed, mitigate the potential for misunderstandings, disputes and professional negligence claims.
Typically an engagement letter will include:
Covering letter with a Privacy Notice and possibly a separate fee schedule.
Schedules of Services.
Standard Terms and Conditions of Business.
No engagement letter is high risk and can lead to higher insurance premiums.
Issued at start of engagement and if change to scope of services.
Reflect legal requirements of Payment Services Regulations 2017 and Data Protection Act 2018 / General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
Firms can customise engagement letters (suit needs of practice and ensure compliance with all relevant regulations.
When to issue an engagement letter?
Engagement letters should be issued at the beginning of an engagement.
Also:
New service provided: A standard engagement letter typically includes a covering letter, Schedules of Services, and the Standard Terms and Conditions of Business. When introducing a new service, practitioners should issue a new Schedule of Services along with a tailored covering letter, an updated fee schedule if applicable, and any necessary updates to the Privacy Notice, while also referencing the standard business terms.
In accordance with GDPR, it’s mandatory for practitioners to inform clients if there is a change in the purpose or lawful basis for processing their data.
Separate engagement letters : should be issued for each individual client, unless there is a mutual agreement otherwise. For instance, distinct letters are recommended when providing tax services to both:
An individual and their spouse or civil partner.
An individual and the personal representatives managing their estate posthumously.
A partnership and its individual partners.
A company and its shareholders, directors, or employees, especially in cases of bulk tax return services.
The trustees of a settlement and its beneficiaries.
Status of a practitioner changes : If there is a change in the practitioner's status, such as transitioning from a sole practitioner to a partnership or limited liability partnership, new engagement letters should be distributed to all affected clients.
Client incorporates, merges or demerges: If a client undergoes incorporation, merger, demerger, or converts to a limited liability partnership, a new engagement letter is necessary to redefine the terms of the business relationship with the new entity.
Acting for a group of companies: When representing a group of companies, it might be more efficient to send a single engagement letter to the parent company, clearly stating that the services extend to all member companies within the group.
Advising clients of changes to standard terms
It's important to inform clients when there are changes to terms and conditions or fees, but you don't need to send all the related documents every time something changes. When you do send engagement documents, make sure they are customised for each client's specific situation.
Any changes to the terms of engagement must be agreed upon by both parties; simply posting an update on a website isn't sufficient. If there's a disagreement, you can't prove that a client accepted the new terms without some clear action from them that shows they agreed. For the changes to be considered accepted, you must ensure the client is aware of them.
Minor changes might be updated on a website if the original engagement letter allows for this. For significant changes, don't rely solely on the website. As a minimum, email clients about the new terms, direct them to the website, and seek their confirmation. If confirmation is impractical, state that any future work will adhere to the new terms, though this is less secure.
Scope of covering letter
The covering letter should be printed on the practice's letterhead.
The guidance to members recommends that the covering letter include seven particular sections:
who they act for
For clients who are organisations, clearly identify who has the authority to give instructions and who is authorised to sign documents.
Direct the letter to the appropriate party, such as company directors, partnership partners, trust trustees, or limited liability partnership members.
period of engagement
The letter should specify the start date of the engagement. It should also mention the period, like a tax year or accounting period, for which the initial work will be done. Additionally, outline when any advisory services will begin.
If a previous practitioner is finishing work for prior periods, clearly define each party's responsibilities to prevent disputes.
scope
If additional work is agreed upon after the initial engagement letter is sent, issue a new or updated letter unless the new tasks are already covered under the original agreement's ad hoc and advisory section.
Consider including a section about other services available to clients.
Automatic Exchange of Information (AEOI)
For work involving the Automatic Exchange of Information (AEOI), such as the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA), use the relevant schedule and adjust the covering letter accordingly. Not all clients or entities are subject to FATCA, but those affected must be identified.
The letter should clarify that the client is responsible for notifying the practitioner of any changes in their FATCA status or US connections. Clearly outline any FATCA-related work and specify who will handle it.
Note that non-UK resident subsidiaries and branches are not covered by the UK agreement, whereas UK permanent establishments of non-UK entities are.
fees
Details about fees should be included in the practice's terms and conditions, but they should also be referenced in the covering letter. Clients need enough information to make informed decisions about fees, as contract law may not enforce payment if a client is unaware of the charges.
For complex fee arrangements, consider detailing them in a separate schedule. Include hourly rates for each team member unless a fixed fee is agreed upon. Explain how and when clients will be informed of rate changes. If a fixed fee or other payment basis is agreed, adjust the covering letter accordingly.
Mention any fee protection insurance that may cover the work to inform the client. If additional fees arise due to late information, notify the client to avoid disputes.
liability cap
Practitioners can limit or exclude liability for negligence, but any such limitation must pass the reasonableness test under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.
The Consumer Rights Act 2015 also affects the effectiveness of liability limitation clauses in consumer contracts. Consider these laws when drafting liability clauses to understand their potential effectiveness as a liability cap included in an engagement letter may be found to unenforceable.
client agreement.
Clients should be asked to agree to the terms and scope of the engagement in writing, typically by signing and returning a copy of the engagement letter. Having documented evidence of agreement helps reduce the risk of future disagreements about the terms of the work.
Any verbal changes to the agreement should be followed up with written confirmation. If the engagement involves multiple companies within a group, a representative from the parent company can sign the letter, provided that all companies are listed and the signatory is authorised.
Client acknowledgment of engagement letters
An engagement letter, when signed or acknowledged by the client, serves as a legally binding document. It outlines the scope and nature of the work, minimising the potential for misunderstandings and dispute. According to guidelines on Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation, it's important to have proof of the client’s approval, which can be in electronic or paper form. For instance, a client can confirm their agreement via email and this should be kept on file.
Unsigned letters:
While getting a signed acknowledgment is ideal, sometimes clients may not return a signed letter despite your best efforts. In such cases, the contract may be evidenced by actions, such as the client providing the necessary documents to start the work. If services are performed without a signed agreement, you'll need to show that the client received the letter and acted in a way that indicates acceptance.
This can be demonstrated through an email from the client acknowledging receipt, a recorded delivery of a reminder letter, or notes from a phone call where the client referenced receiving the letter. If the client expressed dissatisfaction with the terms, it would generally mean the terms weren't accepted by their actions.
Urgent work:
If there's an urgent need to start work before the engagement letter is signed, ensure that the work is covered by the terms in the engagement letter.
Make the client aware of the terms under which the work is being done, and it's a good idea to make a file note of any discussions about these terms. Confirm in writing to the client that any work done before the letter is signed is subject to the engagement letter's terms to prevent future disputes about coverage.
Engagement letter ‘Schedules of Services’
To avoid misunderstandings about the scope of work, the schedule of services attached to the engagement letter should clearly outline the services to be performed.
If a client requests multiple types of services, it's advisable to create separate schedules for each one. This helps clarify both the practitioner’s duties and the client’s responsibilities.
Scope of work
Misunderstandings can occur over whether a service is part of a "standard package" or annual fee. To prevent this, the schedule should differentiate between recurring tasks and "one-off" services.
While the schedules aim to cover the most common services a practitioner offers and remain flexible, they might need to be tailored to meet the specific needs of a firm.
Specific considerations
The service schedules cover the most typical tasks a practitioner handles and are designed to be adaptable. However, they aren't all-inclusive, so practitioners might need to adjust them to fit their specific firm’s needs.
Practitioners should think about how they handle certain issues, such as:
Enquiries from HMRC.
Tax credit and universal credit claims.
Tagging.
Probate.
Submission of returns:
For services involving the submission of returns, the schedule should state that submissions will occur after the client approves the return. This allows for situations where verbal approval is necessary.
The schedule should also include a disclaimer for changes in law, practice, or public policy, as a practitioner's responsibilities vary with the nature of the engagement. Once a retainer ends, there is typically no obligation to update the client unless the engagement is ongoing.
Use of specialists
When drafting wording about the involvement of other specialists, practitioners should be careful to ensure clarity and accuracy.
Engagement letter Standard Terms and Conditions of Business
When establishing a professional relationship through an engagement letter, it's crucial to include the Standard Terms and Conditions of Business.
These terms serve as the foundation for the agreement between a practitioner and their client, outlining the rights and responsibilities of both parties.
They cover a range of essential topics, from legal jurisdiction and client verification to confidentiality and fee arrangements. By clearly defining these aspects, the Standard Terms and Conditions help prevent misunderstandings and ensure both parties are aligned in their expectations.
This framework not only safeguards the practitioner but also provides clarity and assurance to the client, fostering a transparent and professional partnership.
Engagement letter - Privacy notice and client data protection
The privacy notice explains how the practitioner collects, uses, stores, and shares the client's personal data. It should comply with the Data Protection Act 2018 and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Practitioners need to comply with the Data Protection Act 2018 and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) when handling personal data. These regulations ensure personal data is processed legally and securely.
The source of personal data collected needs to be included in the privacy notice. Examples of sources include:
spouse/partner
HMRC
your employer/partnership/limited liability partnership (LLP)/company
electronic ID verification providers
other third parties (eg banks, investment managers etc).
Privacy notices and personal data:
While not mandatory, it's practical to include a privacy notice with the engagement letter.
Clients have the right to be informed about how their personal data is being used. Clear and comprehensive privacy notices should be provided to clients. These notices should explain the purposes of data processing, the types of data collected, how data is stored and protected, and with whom it might be shared. It's also important to inform clients about their rights, including the right to access their data, rectify inaccuracies, and object to processing.
Documenting personal data:
Before creating a privacy notice, practitioners should document the personal data they hold, its sources, and how it is shared. This ensures transparency and compliance. Practitioners should inform clients of any changes in how or why their data is processed.
Protection of client data: data controller and processor
Data controller:
In many instances, practitioners act as data controllers, meaning they decide the purposes and methods for processing clients' personal data. For example, when preparing tax returns, practitioners determine what information is needed, how it will be used, and how long it will be stored.
Data controllers are required to give individuals specific information at the time their data is collected, or if obtained from another source, within a reasonable timeframe, usually within a month.
Data processor:
In certain scenarios, practitioners might function as data processors, processing data on behalf of a data controller. Payroll processing is a typical example, where the client (the data controller) dictates the data processing instructions. When practitioners act as data processors, written contracts with data controllers are essential.
The distinction between these roles is vital because it impacts the responsibilities and obligations under GDPR.
GDPR lawful bases on which client data can be processed:
Consent, legal obligation, and vital interests.
Data protection: data retention policies
Data should not be kept indefinitely.
Tax practitioners must establish clear data retention policies that comply with GDPR, ensuring personal data is kept only as long as needed for the intended purpose.
A common practice is to retain tax-related documents for seven years, but the specific duration should be tailored to individual client needs and the practice's nature.
Regular review of these policies is essential, and any data no longer required should be securely disposed of. For detailed guidance, practitioners should refer to resources provided by the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO). It's also prudent to align data retention periods outlined in the privacy notice with those stipulated in the Standard Terms and Conditions of Business.
Data protection: individual’s rights concerning their personal data under GDPR
Individuals have specific rights concerning their personal data under GDPR. Practitioners must be prepared to facilitate these rights.
Some of the rights include:
Right of access: Individuals have the right to request access to their data and confirmation of how it's being processed.
Right to rectification: Individuals can request the correction of inaccurate or incomplete data.
Right to erasure ("Right to be Forgotten"): In certain circumstances, individuals can request the deletion of their data.
Right to restriction of processing: Individuals can request limitations on the processing of their data under specific conditions.
Right to object to processing: Individuals can object to the processing of their data based on legitimate interests or for direct marketing purposes.
Data protection: protecting client data
Practitioners must implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to safeguard personal data against unauthorised access, use, disclosure, alteration, or destruction.
Examples of such measures include:
Encryption: encoding data to make it unreadable without a decryption key.
Secure storage: using secure physical and digital storage systems with access controls.
Access controls: limiting access to personal data based on roles and need-to-know principles.
Staff training: educating employees on data protection best practices and the importance of confidentiality.
Data protection: Transfer of personal data outside of the EEA
GDPR applies to all member states in the EEA and restricts the transfer of personal data outside of the EEA unless there are appropriate safeguards in place.
A practitioner will need to carefully consider where their data is stored, including use of cloud based software, and take specialist advice in relation to their privacy statement and other requirements where data is to be transferred outside the EEA or to an international organisation.
For example, if a tax practitioner uses a cloud storage provider based in the US, they need to ensure that the provider offers adequate data protection safeguards compliant with EEA regulations.
Responding to data security breaches
Tax practitioners must implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to safeguard client data. These measures should consider the sensitivity of the information and the potential risks of unauthorised access, use, disclosure, alteration, or destruction. This might include using strong passwords, encryption, secure storage, and regular security updates. It's also crucial to have procedures to detect, report, and investigate data breaches.
GDPR mandates specific actions in the event of a data security breach. A breach occurs when there is unauthorised access, disclosure, alteration, or destruction of personal data.
Practitioners are obligated to:
Inform the relevant data protection authority about the breach without undue delay.
In cases where the breach is likely to result in a high risk to individuals' rights and freedoms, they must be informed as well.
Recommendations to ensure GDPR compliance
Data retention policies:
Tax practitioners need to implement data retention policies. This policy should outline how long specific types of data are kept and ensure the secure disposal of data no longer needed. The policy helps avoid keeping unnecessary information, minimising risks associated with data breaches.
Secure communication methods, such as encrypted emails, should also be used when exchanging sensitive information with clients, safeguarding their data during transmission.
Address data transfers outside the EEA:
If client data is transferred outside of the UK or the EEA, practitioners must ensure appropriate safeguards are in place. This is especially important when using cloud-based services or working with international clients. Safeguards might include standard contractual clauses, binding corporate rules, or adequacy decisions by relevant data protection authorities.
Seek expert advice when data is stored or transferred outside the EEA.
Regularly review data retention policies:
Regularly review data retention policies and destroy data that is no longer needed.
Tax practitioners should consistently stay updated on best practices and guidelines. Regularly reviewing and updating data protection practices ensures they remain current and aligned with regulatory changes. This involves consulting relevant authorities and resources to stay informed about new interpretations or updates to data protection regulations, allowing practitioners to adapt their practices accordingly.
Marketing consent:
Obtain explicit consent from clients before marketing additional services to them. Ensure clients actively agree to receive marketing communications by ticking a box or providing a signature.
Keep records of client consent, whether in the form of signed documents or electronic records.
Provide clients with a simple and easy method to opt-out of marketing communications, such as an unsubscribe link in emails or a designated contact email address.
Ensure that clients who have not consented to marketing communications do not receive such materials.
Client service : duty of care
Recognised by law, this duty ensures that professionals are diligent and competent in their work.
According to the PRPG, a member's duty of care involves exercising reasonable skill and care in all client interactions. It's about meeting client needs effectively while adhering to legal and ethical standards.
An engagement letter or related communication can help define or limit this duty, outlining the specific responsibilities and expectations agreed upon. This not only clarifies the scope of work but also protects both parties by setting clear boundaries and ensuring mutual understanding.
Client service: managing client expectations
Involves setting clear timelines, maintaining open communication, and ensuring that the engagement terms are consistently met.
By implementing these practices, professionals can effectively manage client expectations, fostering trust and ensuring successful outcomes.
Agree on a realistic timetable
Establish a practical timeline for delivering services.
For example, when preparing a client's annual tax return, discuss and agree on a completion date that considers all necessary steps and potential delays.
Maintain regular communication
Keep clients informed throughout the process.
Avoid long periods without updates, and if delays occur, notify the client promptly to maintain trust and manage expectations.
Review engagement terms regularly
Periodically assess the scope of work to ensure it aligns with the client's needs and expectations.
If the terms need adjustment, discuss these changes with the client to ensure continued alignment and satisfaction.
Client service: supervision and training of delegated people
When a member delegates work to an employee, sub-contractor, or consultant, they still hold primary responsibility for the outcomes. This process requires careful supervision to ensure the work performed meets the expected standards.
It's essential that these individuals—whether they are employees within the organisation or external consultants—are properly trained and equipped with the necessary skills to carry out their responsibilities effectively.
Client service : use of subcontractors
The PRPG highlights the critical role of client confidentiality when using subcontractors. Before delegating tasks to a subcontractor, a member must obtain the client’s consent to ensure their sensitive information remains protected. This transparency helps maintain client trust by making them aware of who will access their information.
Including a clause in the engagement letter that authorises the use of subcontractors, subject to client approval, can streamline this process by removing the need to seek consent for each instance. This proactive measure ensures that client service remains seamless and trustworthy, upholding both legal and ethical standards while reinforcing the client-professional relationship through transparency and confidence.
Client service: consultation and second opinions
The PRPG emphasises importance of consultation and seeking second opinions, particularly when navigating complex or high-stakes situations. The guidance is based on a risk-based approach, taking into account a member's expertise, the financial implications, and the clarity of the proposed actions.
For example, when substantial tax amounts are at stake or the client's interests are critically impacted, members are encouraged to consult with fellow professionals. This collaboration ensures that the advice provided is comprehensive and informed by diverse expertise.
Include asking a peer e.g. colleague or fellow tax professional. Keep paper trail of advice/consultation to keep a record and rationale.
Get client consent before sharing their data to external consultants to ensure confidentiality.
Client service : form of advice provided to a client
When offering advice to clients, it's crucial to tailor the communication to fit their specific needs and circumstances.
Significance and financial impact of the transaction:
Consider how important the transaction is to the client and the potential financial consequences. Larger or more complex transactions may require more detailed advice/
Whether the client's question is specific or general:
Tailor the advice based on whether the client seeks a specific answer to a particular issue or more general guidance on a broader topic.
The time available to prepare and submit the advice:
The urgency of the client’s needs can impact the format and depth of the advice. More time allows for comprehensive analysis, while urgent requests might necessitate concise, prioritised advice. E.g. and impending tax deadline might require quick, verbal advice, followed by a more detailed written report once more time is available.
Any technical challenges involved:
Complex tax issues involving technical details may necessitate a more thorough and written explanation to ensure clarity and accuracy.
Existing legal authorities and precedents:
Consider how established laws and previous cases influence the advice. If precedents are clear, advice can be more straightforward; if not, it might need a more cautious approach.
The client’s understanding of tax matters:
Tailor the complexity of the advice to the client’s level of tax knowledge. More sophisticated clients might benefit from simplifies explanations.
Whether other professional advice is needed:
Sometimes, the situation may require input from other professionals, such as lawyers or financial advisors, to provide comprehensive advice.
Format for presenting advice to clients
When providing advice to clients, there is no set format required, so it's up to the member to decide what's best for the client in each situation. Generally, advice should be written down. If advice is given verbally during meetings or phone calls, it's wise to follow up with a written confirmation. This gives the client a chance to correct any misunderstandings and provides a record of the advice.
The advice and related documentation should align with the Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation (PCRT), especially the Tax Planning Standards. When preparing advice, members should refer to the relevant tax laws, HMRC practices, and case law.
It's important to clarify that the advice is based on current laws, which could change. To avoid misunderstandings, it might be helpful to state in the engagement letter that the member is not automatically responsible for informing the client of legal changes affecting past advice, but they are open to being asked to review it.
Typically, the advice should include the following details unless they are covered in other documents like terms and conditions or an engagement letter:
The reason for the advice and the client's goals.
The background information and assumptions, and whether these have been checked.
The options available to the client and any risks involved.
Any relevant warnings or limitations.
Client record keeping
Proper records allow for effective communication and ensure that all interactions with clients and relevant bodies, like HMRC, are well-documented. These records provide a comprehensive client history that can aid future service, help resolve misunderstandings or disputes, and defend against any claims of negligence.
Ensuring that records are well-organised and easily accessible, whether in physical or electronic form, is essential. For electronic records, regular backups are necessary to prevent data loss.
Professionals should develop a policy for retaining working documents, considering both legal requirements and the potential need to defend against legal actions in the future.
According to the PRPG guidance on client service, it's important for members to keep comprehensive records to ensure they meet professional standards.
Key elements of professional records include all written communications such as letters and emails, as well as notes from meetings and phone calls, which should be made at the time and dated. It’s also important to document how advice was formulated, including any technical research, consultations, or second opinions obtained.
Client record keeping : system to track deadlines
When dealing with client record-keeping, it's essential for professionals to have a robust system in place to track important deadlines and take timely action. This ensures that all relevant time limits are observed and managed effectively, providing clarity on responsibilities and avoiding unnecessary complications.
To achieve this, several key aspects need attention, including how deadlines are monitored, understanding tax compliance responsibilities, clarifying roles, and addressing non-compliance situations.
Monitoring deadlines
Professionals should establish a system to keep track of all key dates and deadlines related to the services they provide. This system should help ensure that timely actions are taken to meet these deadlines.
It's also crucial to clearly define who is responsible for meeting these deadlines to prevent any misunderstandings.
Tax compliance responsibilities
For those handling tax compliance for clients, it typically involves informing clients about their tax obligations, including the amount due, the payment deadline, and the fact that interest will start to accrue after this date.
However, it is not the professional’s responsibility to ensure the client actually pays the taxes owed.
Clarifying responsibilities
If a professional has explicitly communicated to a client that they are not responsible for monitoring compliance dates, this should be clearly stated in the engagement letter or in another written form. This helps manage expectations and provides a formal record of the agreed responsibilities.
Non-compliance roles
For professionals not involved in compliance work for a client, there is generally no expectation to track deadlines or tax payments unless specifically asked to do so.
In cases where responsibilities are unclear, it's advisable to discuss the matter with the client and document the agreed terms in writing, such as in the engagement letter.
Objectivity : ceasing to act
If managing conflicts of interest becomes impossible or acting would compromise your professional integrity, the best course of action may be to cease acting entirely. This ensures that you maintain ethical standards and avoid any perception of impropriety.
Key considerations when ceasing to act:
Inform clients promptly of your decision.
Ensure a smooth transition if alternative representation is needed.
Maintain confidentiality regarding all client information.
Collaboration risks : disclosing info to 3rd parties
Sharing advice, reports, or documents with third parties can introduce risks such as breaches of confidentiality, unintended consequences for the client, or third-party claims against the adviser.
Professionals must safeguard client confidentiality, only releasing information with explicit consent or when legally required. To mitigate risks:
Include disclaimers in advice to limit liability to third parties.
Obtain written confirmation from the client to release information and indemnities where necessary.
Decline requests that are excessive, inappropriate, or impractical.
For instance, a firm providing tax advice to a client may find that their advice has been shared with third parties, exposing them to potential liability. Managing these risks proactively is crucial.
Managing client needs : what to do if referring a client
When client needs exceed a professional’s expertise or resources, potential risks arise. Solutions include engaging a subcontractor, referring the client to another adviser, or declining to act.
If referring a client:
Ensure the client has a choice of advisers.
Clarify that the decision to engage another adviser is the client’s alone.
Avoid assuming responsibility for the referred adviser’s work.
Managing client needs : working alongside other professional advisers
Collaboration with other advisers requires clearly defined roles to avoid misunderstandings and ensure efficiency. Key considerations include:
Defining responsibilities in the engagement letter.
Maintaining confidentiality by obtaining client permissions for sharing information.
Advising clients on the benefits of communication between advisers while keeping them informed of key decisions.
For example, when working alongside a solicitor or barrister, a tax adviser must respect professional boundaries and client instructions to ensure effective collaboration.
Managing client needs : working in a subcontractor relationship with another adviser
Subcontractor relationships involve a professional performing specific services under the supervision of a lead adviser. Clarity in roles ensures accountability while maintaining professional standards.
Manage risks by:
Establish clear terms in a written agreement between the subcontractor and the lead adviser.
Define how the subcontractor will interact with the client—whether directly or through the lead adviser.
Address professional indemnity insurance (PII) and anti-money laundering (AML) requirements.
What is clients’ money?
Client money refers to funds received from or held on behalf of a client that are not immediately payable to the professional. These funds must always be kept separate from the firm’s own money and managed with stringent controls to avoid misuse and ensure transparency.
For example, if you were to receive a cheque covering future work that has been explicitly identified as a prepayment, you would not need to treat it as client money. Transparency about the use of funds and proper record-keeping ensures compliance.
Key requirements involved with managing client money?
Separate client accounts
Proper use
Interest management
Records and reconciliation
Keep money from clients in a separate account for that client - not part of own businesses account. Only use that money for what the client asks e.g. for project costs.
Long term money - keep in interest bearing account.
Transparent and keep audit trail
Track transactions and update records every 6 months
Example scenario: what to do if handling a cheque containing both client and non-client money? Ans: deposit the cheque into the client account and withdraw non-client money once cleared.
Tribunals and advocacy
Representing a client in tax tribunals, such as the First-Tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) or Upper Tribunal (UT), involves significant ethical and professional responsibilities. Professionals must only take on work they are competent to perform and consider involving legal counsel for complex cases or those involving allegations of tax evasion.
Compile relevant and accurate facts and arguments.
Charging for services : basis of charge
Setting clear expectations about fees before starting any work is essential for maintaining trust and preventing disputes. Professionals should ensure clients understand how fees will be calculated and how expenses will be handled. These details are best outlined in the engagement letter, which serves as the foundation of the financial relationship.
To prevent misunderstandings, professionals should regularly update clients about fees and issue fee notes promptly. Even if a detailed breakdown isn’t automatically provided, records should allow one to be created if requested. This ensures transparency and builds trust.
Time and expenses
Fees are based on the time spent and the expertise required, with provisions for additional charges if urgent deadlines require extra resources.
Fixed fees
A set fee for defined work, with clear terms for additional charges if the scope changes or the agreement extends beyond a year.
Contingent fees
Fees tied to specific outcomes, which require transparency and careful documentation to avoid risks.
Charging for services : contingent fees
Contingent fees, linked to the achievement of specific outcomes, can present challenges. For instance, they may raise questions about a professional’s objectivity or compliance with legal and regulatory standards.
To manage these risks, it is crucial to:
Clearly outline the terms of contingent fees in the engagement letter, including what happens if the expected outcome changes.
Ensure transparency, particularly if third parties or public documents may rely on the advice.
Review potential regulatory concerns, such as whether the fees could be classified as "premium fees" under tax disclosure rules like DOTAS.
Ethical walls
Separate teams within the same firm of tax advisers deal with two or more clients. Strict confidentiality of information is maintained.
Only an option is the firm has the resources to do this. Will not be possible if the adviser is a sole trader.
Charging for services : commission
Receiving commission from third parties introduces risks of perceived bias. When such arrangements arise, professionals must prioritise the client’s best interests and ensure the advice is not unduly influenced by financial incentives.
Transparency is critical:
Disclose the nature of the relationship with the third party and the commission amount.
Justify the recommendation as being solely in the client’s best interest, independent of any financial benefit to the adviser.
Document all terms in writing, ideally in the engagement letter, to avoid misunderstandings.
For example, if a client is referred to a financial adviser, and the professional receives a commission, the client must be informed about the arrangement. This ensures the client understands the recommendation and reinforces trust.
Charging for services: retainer arrangements
Retainer arrangements allow clients to secure a professional’s availability, often in exchange for a regular fee, regardless of whether specific work is performed. While these agreements can provide stability, they must be carefully managed to ensure fairness and clarity.
A written agreement should define:
The scope of the arrangement and any limitations.
Conditions under which additional fees may be charged.
Termination terms to prevent disputes.
Professionals should also consider their capacity to meet obligations under retainer arrangements without compromising service quality for other clients.
Charging for services : payments on account and payments in advance
Payments on account or in advance help manage cash flow but must be handled responsibly to avoid misunderstandings. Terms for these payments should be clearly outlined in the engagement letter, including:
The conditions under which refunds may apply, such as if work is not completed.
The allocation of funds to specific tasks.
Compliance with VAT requirements, ensuring transparency in financial records.
Large advance payments should be treated with caution to ensure the professional can refund the client if necessary. Maintaining adequate funds for this purpose is essential to uphold trust.
Charging for services : clients who are slow to pay
When clients fail to pay on time, professionals should address the issue promptly and professionally. Open communication is key to understanding the reasons for non-payment and finding a resolution.
Steps include:
Reminding the client of the payment terms, as agreed in the engagement letter.
Seeking an explanation for the delay and working with the client to resolve any genuine issues.
Taking legal action if necessary or notifying the client of a potential cessation of services.
It is crucial to avoid using client funds to settle unpaid fees without prior written approval. Professionals should also be mindful of regulations, such as the Consumer Credit Act, if offering instalment plans.

Correct answer is C
Charging for services : fee disputes
Disputes over fees can arise, even with clear agreements in place. Addressing concerns proactively helps to maintain trust and resolve issues efficiently.
Steps to manage disputes include:
Discussing the issue with the client to understand their dissatisfaction and attempting to reach an amicable resolution.
Reviewing professional indemnity insurance (PII) coverage and, if necessary, notifying insurers to comply with policy requirements.
Seeking legal advice before exercising a lien on a client’s property, which should only be a last resort after addressing any grievances.
Complaints procedure
It's recommended that all members have a structured complaints procedure in place to effectively manage any client complaints that may arise. This ensures that all complaints are handled consistently and professionally, providing a clear path for resolution and maintaining client trust and satisfaction.
The PRPG has a series of recommendations to be included as part of the complaints procedure:
Informing new clients about complaint contacts and TDB options
Inform new clients about the designated contacts for lodging complaints, as well as their option to contact the Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB) if needed. This transparency fosters trust and ensures clients are aware of their rights and the avenues available for addressing concerns
Prompt written acknowledgement of complaints
Acknowledging complaints in writing promptly, demonstrates to clients that their issues are being taken seriously and establishes a professional tone from the outset, as outlined in engagement letters. This timely acknowledgement, as reinforced by the terms in engagement letters, helps reassure clients that their concerns will be addressed efficiently.
Timely and impartial investigation by experienced staff
Conducting a timely investigation by an experienced staff member who is not directly involved in the complaint, ensures an impartial and thorough review. This approach maintains objectivity and helps build credibility in the resolution process.
Taking action on justified complaints
When a complaint deemed justified, taking appropriate action is essential to resolve the issue effectively and prevent future occurrences. This proactive response not only addresses the client’s concerns but also demonstrates the organisation’s commitment to maintaining high standards.
Considering professional indemnity insurance (PII)
When handling complaints =, it is crucial to consider PII to understand potential liabilities and ensure coverage is in place. This consideration helps protect the organisation and supports informed decision-making throughout the complaints process.
Handling a complaint
Acknowledgement
Timely acknowledgment of a complaint is a key aspect of best practice as it shows professionalism and a commitment to resolving issues, helping to maintain trust between the professional and the client. By responding promptly and taking the complaint seriously, professionals aim to defuse potential problems with the client, demonstrating a willingness to address their concerns effectively. Prompt investigation and action on the complaint ensures that any potential issues are addressed efficiently, minimising disruption and potential harm to both parties. Following best practice in handling complaints not only upholds ethical standards but also reinforces the integrity and reputation of the tax profession.
Response
Getting back to the client once a complaint has been investigated, especially if deemed justified even if only partly, is essential as it demonstrates accountability and a commitment to client satisfaction. A quick response and an apology can help to defuse tensions and restore trust, showing the client that their concerns are taken seriously. The member must also evaluate whether the issue has left them liable and if further escalation is necessary, ensuring that all aspects of the complaint are addressed appropriately and professionally.
Escalation
If a client refers a complaint to the TDB, the member must demonstrate how they have managed the complaint, which underscores the importance of following best practices and having an effective complaints procedure. The TDB may ask the client to confirm that they have initially raised the complaint with the member; if not, the client will be directed back to the member. This process highlights the necessity for members to address complaints thoroughly and professionally before they escalate.
If a resolution cannot be reached, the complaint may need to be escalated to the Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB) for further action.
Complaints to the TDB
The Taxation Disciplinary Board (TDB) plays a vital role in managing complaints against members of the Association of Taxation Technicians (ATT) and the Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT). When a complaint is lodged, the TDB assesses whether there is a case to answer, handling the complaint impartially and following established procedures. They conduct thorough investigations to determine if the member has breached professional standards, requiring members to comply and provide necessary information upon request.
The TDB aims to uphold the integrity and reputation of the tax profession by ensuring that members adhere to high standards. By maintaining a fair and transparent process, the TDB helps reinforce professional conduct, safeguarding public trust and confidence in tax professionals.
Why members may cease to act
Typically, a member would not cease to act for a client until a contract has been fulfilled or the work is completed. The end dates of service are agreed upon by both the client and the member at the outset of their engagement, establishing clear expectations for the completion of work. If the agreement is indefinite, the work would continue uninterrupted, but the member would ensure to notify the client in good time if they plan to stop working for them.
However, there are specific situations where a member might consider ceasing to act prematurely. The PRPG outlines the following reasons:
Legal/ethical obligation to cease for working for a client if the work is deemed to be at risk of breaking the law
The client requires the member to cease acting
A member gives reasonable notice to the client of their intention to cease to act. However, a member will need or have due regard to the terms of their engagement letter.
Ceasing to act : notifying the client
The PRPG recommend that members clearly communicate their intention to cease services with a client to ensure transparency and understanding.
A disengagement letter serves as this formal communication, officially terminating the professional relationship, summarising the services provided up to that point, and detailing any remaining responsibilities or actions required by either party to facilitate a smooth transition.
What to include in a letter of disengagement:
Services provided up to date of ceasing to act
This outlines all the tasks and responsibilities that were carried out by the member for the client until the termination of their services.
Note of further action to be taken by member
This details any additional steps or tasks the member needs to complete even after ceasing to act for the client, ensuring a smooth transition.
Outstanding matters
This lists any unresolved issues or tasks that the client or their new adviser must attend to following the member's departure.
Details of any impending deadlines
This provides information on upcoming due dates and the necessary actions required to meet these deadlines, ensuring compliance and continuity.
Member’s willingness to assist new advisers
This indicates whether the member is prepared to cooperate with the new advisers by helping to address any unresolved issues with HMRC and by sharing relevant documents.
Outstanding fee details
This outlines any unpaid fees that remain due from the client for services rendered up until the cessation date.
Details as to who is to advise HMRC of the change
This specifies the person or party responsible for notifying HMRC about the change in advisers, ensuring that the transition is officially recorded.
Ceasing to act : guidance on communicating wit the successor
When a tax professional decides to cease acting for a client, effective communication with the successor is essential. According to PRPG 10.1, if you have the client's authority to communicate with the successor, you should clearly state either that you know of no professional reasons why the successor should not accept the appointment, or that you resigned due to professional reasons because continuing the relationship was inconsistent with your professional obligations.
It's important to note that "professional reasons" relate to ethics and integrity, not issues like fee disputes. Additionally, take care to avoid the offence of "tipping off," which involves inadvertently alerting the client or others to any potential investigations or suspicions of illegal activity. By adhering to these guidelines, you ensure a smooth and professional transition for both the client and successor.
Ceasing to act : handover of documentation
When ceasing activities, the PRPG advises members to ensure a comprehensive handover of all relevant client records, files, and correspondence to the successor for a seamless transition. Obtaining the client's consent before transferring any documents is necessary to respect confidentiality and comply with data protection regulations.
Client’s consent
Before communicating with a successor, the member must obtain the client’s consent. It is essential to respect client confidentiality and ensure that any transfer of information is authorised by the client.
Consult with professional indemnity insurers
If there is a potential risk of a client using information to support a claim against the member, consulting with professional indemnity insurers or seeking legal advice is advisable to manage liability and protect interests.
Ownership documents
Understanding document ownership is crucial, and if considering excercising a lien over client documents, legal advice should be sought to ensure compliance with legal obligations.
Relevant information
The information provided to the successor should be pertinent to the client’s affairs and necessary for the successor to carry out their suties effectively. This typically includes details about ongoing matters, deadlines, and any issues that need attention.
Legal matters associated with client data : document retention
Members are required to retain client data and documents to comply with legal and professional obligations. The PRPG provides comprehensive guidance on managing and retaining these documents efficiently, detailing specific time periods for retention to ensure transparency and accountability in professional practices:
Document retention policy
A member should implement a document retention policy to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, such as data protection and statutory retention periods, thereby mitigating the risk of legal issues
This policy should be included in the member’s letter of engagement or contract, facilitating efficient record management and supporting transparency, accountability, and effective use of documents in business operations and client engagements.
Considerations for retention periods
When specific terms are not outlined in a member’s engagement letter or contract, the retention period for records should consider data protection laws, statutory requirements, and potential legal actions.
Additionally, members should assess the duration needed for compiling tax returns and supporting their work, ensuring records are retained only as long as necessary and with sufficient justification if kept beyond statutory periods.
Securing client confidential information
Members must ensure that records and working papers are securely maintained to protect client confidentiality, as all documents related to a client’s financial affairs and personal data are considered confidential information.
Evidence of record deletion
Members should request a certificate or similar documentation as evidence when outsourcing the deletion of records to ensure it has been properly executed.
Legal matters associated with client data : retention by document type
Retention periods for documents are determined by statutory requirements from various acts and statutes, ensuring legal compliance, and they vary by document type. These periods are established to protect sensitive information, support organisational needs, and enable efficient record management.
Accounting records for companies
The Companies Act 2006 mandates the following retention periods:
Private companies accounting records; three years from date of creation
Public companies accounting records, six years from date of creation
Payroll records
The Taxes Management Act 1970 mandates that payroll records, including those related to overtime, bonuses, and expenses, be retained for six years plus the current year in which the records were created.
Income tax for ex-employees
The Taxes Management Act 1970 mandates that income tax records for former employees be retained for six years after the employee has left.
VAT records
The Value Added Tax 1994 mandates that VAT records be retained for six years (10 years if using VAT MOSS service).
Tax records for an individual
According to the Taxes Management Act 1970, tax records for an individual carrying on a trade, profession, or business alone, in partnership, or as a company must be retained for five years from 31 January following the tax year to which the tax return relates.
Guidance for members
The previous tabs outlined statutory retention periods for compliance, but the PRPG advises retaining records for a longer period.
Members should keep records and working papers for at least seven years from the end of the relevant tax year or accounting period, extendable if required by self-assessment rules, and must return or obtain permission to destroy any documents legally owned by the client or former client.
Legal matters associated with client data : request from other third parties
The PRPG advises that when members receive requests from third parties to disclose documents, they must determine whether client permission is needed or if there is a legal obligation that supersedes the fundamental principle of confidentiality.
Practitioners should not provide information unless the client permits it or there is a legal requirement to do so. In cases of uncertainty, seeking specialist advice may be necessary to ensure that any legal or regulatory rights claimed by third parties are being exercised correctly. For example, a government tax authority may request information during a tax investigation, necessitating careful scrutiny of the request's legitimacy.
Additionally, the PRPG highlights that certain documents, such as those protected by legal professional privilege, may not be subject to such requests. It is crucial for practitioners to thoroughly evaluate the nature and extent of the request, ensuring compliance with legal and ethical standards while safeguarding client interests and respecting both the client's rights and legal obligations.
Legal matters associated with client data : Lien
For tax practitioners, a lien, as outlined in the PRPG, represents a legal right to retain possession of a client's property until a financial obligation is fulfilled. It is a significant tool that must be exercised judiciously, ensuring compliance with PRPG standards while considering the potential impact on client relationships and professional reputation.
Examples of client’s property: prepared financial reports and strategic documents.
Before taking a lien : the PRPG advises that members must thoroughly explore all avenues and ensure that all possible steps have been taken to resolve the situation amicably. Includes addressing any grievances a client may have to prevent further escalation.
It’s essential to carefully weigh the potential loss of goodwill against the financial benefits of retaining the documents.
Seeking legal advice may be crucial if a third party has a legal right to access the documents in question.
PRPG: a lien cannot be applied to company documents that must be publicly available or retained at the company’s registered office, such as accounting records or VAT returns.
A lien :
Is not enforceable against liquidators or administrators
Is enforceable against an administrative receiver or a supervisor of an IVA or CVA
Verify the documents belong to the client, not self and seek legal advice if any dispute over ownership.
Legal matters associated with client data : drafting legal documents
Under the Legal Services Act 2007, certain legal documents may only be drafted by qualified individuals as they are considered "reserved legal activities." These activities include the transfer of real property and the drafting of documents related to real or personal property, such as contracts, conveyances, and mortgages in land transactions. Additionally, preparing instruments relating to legal proceedings and drafting a trust deed for a fee, gain, or reward are also reserved activities requiring qualified professionals.
Non-qualified individuals who engage in drafting reserved legal documents could face fines or imprisonment for their actions. While members can suggest amendments to a legal document, they must ensure they do not overstep their expertise. It's important for members to seek specialist legal advice when necessary and only undertake work they are competent to perform to maintain professional integrity and compliance.
Legal matters associated with client data : data protection and GDPR
Members must comply with relevant GDPR legislation to ensure the protection and lawful processing of data.
Document instructions
Members should obtain documented instructions from any data controller on whose behalf they process data to ensure clarity and compliance with data protection responsibilities.
Record keeping
Members must maintain comprehensive records of all processing activities to effectively monitor and demonstrate compliance with data protection regulations.
Breach reporting
Members should consider the reporting requirements if there is a data breach, including notifying relevant authorities and affected data subjects, to adhere to regulatory obligations.
Individual rights
Members must ensure they have procedures in place to address and fulfil the individual rights that clients can excerise, such as access and rectification requests.
Data security
Members are responsible for storing data confidentially and securely, implementing robust cybersecurity measures to protect against unauthorised access and data breaches.
Key principles of promotional materials
Are outlined in CIOT/ATT’s Professional Rules and Practice Guidelines (PRPG).
The main principle to remember is that members of the CIOT and ATT must not obtain or seek professional work for themselves – or for anyone else – in a manner that is unprofessional.
In general, they can promote themselves, their achievements and their services in any way they think fit – newspaper adverts, direct marketing leaflets, even huge hot-air balloons with their details plastered on its side – so long as the principles we’re about to explore aren’t breached.
Important point: these principles for tax professionals apply in addition to the UK’s legal restrictions and guidelines on advertising. These restrictions and guidelines apply to all companies, not just tax professionals, regardless of which sector they operate in.