1/5
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What happens in Lindsey’s Brain Bomb Scene?
During what is assumed to be a getaway, Tom Cruise’s character (Ethan Hunt) discovers a “brain-bomb” that was implanted in Lindsey’s head by their enemies, which would instantly kill her if it went off. Ethan gets a defibrillator and plans to use it to prevent the brain bomb from going off, which would also kill Lindsey, but he plans to shock her again afterward to bring her back to life.
The problem is that the defibrillator needed 30 seconds to charge, and before he was able to use it to save Lindsey, the brain bomb went off.
What happens in Ethan’s Brain Bomb /Julia’s Rescue Scene?
While Ethan saves his wife, Julia, from being held hostage, he realizes he’s been implanted with a brain bomb that’s going to go off and looks to find a defibrillator for Julia to do what he planned to do for Lindsey, but can’t find one. He asks Julia to administer a shock wave to him that will kill him, then tells her to bring him back to life (she’s a doctor). She administers the shock wave by pulling a switch, then gives him CPR, which does bring him back to life.
What is the Natural Law Theory?
Do good, avoid evil
What would a natural law theorist say about both scenes, given that they pass the first 2 conditions of the Double Effect Theory?
This assumes that both scenes are otherwise good, and the bads brought about are unintended.
What would Thompson, Costa, & Fischer say in response to Lindsey’s brain bomb scene?
Thompson:
she would rely on intuitions: which argue that Ethan was attempting a rescue
However, she would also argue that Ethan introduced a new threat. The threat to Lindsey was her brain bomb, and Ethan introduced stopping her heart rather than stopping the brain bomb itself
Innocence/Guilt: Also would argue that Ethan assumes guilt here of introducing a new threat to an innocent person.
Costa:
would say it is impermissible: Lindsey would have died, then been revived, which shows temporal priority, but also shows that her death is in causal sequence of her life (impermissible)
Fischer:
Would argue that if you find that Ethan’s scene is permissible, then Lindsey’s is. If you find Ethan’s scene impermissible, then Lindsey’s is impermissible.
What would Thompson, Costa, & Fischer say in response to Ethan’s brain bomb scene?
Thompson:
Innocence/Guilt: Ethan is the one bearing the risk since he instructs Julia to do it. The person harmed is the person responsible for the new threat, so it would be permissible.
Costa:
Ethan would have died, then been revived, which shows temporal priority, but also shows that his death is in the causal sequence of her life (impermissible)
Fischer:
Would argue that if you find that Lindsey’s scene is permissible, then Ethan’s is too.