1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Define postcolonialism
Academic discipline that comprises methods of intellectual discourse that present analyses of, and responses to, the cultural legacies of colonialism and imperialism.
What are the characteristics of postcolonialism?
Cultural displacement, how displaced defend themselves, employment of a non-Eurocentric perspective, questioning the values that supported imperialism.
What is the discourse of postcolonialism?
About the colonized other rather than the former colonizer; non-West placed at the centre of the dominant discourse of the Western academe.
What was Ella Shohat’s question about postcolonialism?
When does the post-colonial begin?
What was Arif Dirlik’s answer to the postcolonialism question?
When Third World intellectuals arrived in First World academe.
What was the book written by Edward Said?
Orientalism
Define orientalism
A critique of how Western texts such as literature, political tracts, travel books, and religious and philosophical studies have represented the East or the Orient.
How does Said criticize realism?
Disputes the supposedly objective assumptions by showing how the concept of national interest is historically and culturally constructed rather than an inherent aspect of the international system.
What realist figure does Said critique?
Henry Kissinger who, in his geopolitical analysis, divided the world into the binary opposites of the “rational” West and the “irrational” East.
What did Said argue about realism’s explanation of divisions?
Divisions are not natural but constructed through orientalist discourse; the ideas of the West and East serve to justify interventionist policies under the guise of maintaining international order.
How does orientalist discourse relate with realism?
Aligns with focus on power politics but exposes how its assumptions are rooted in imperialist and racialized understandings of global affairs.
How does orientalist conflict with realism?
Realism’s emphasis on power struggles downplays the role of colonialism and imperialism in shaping international relations; Said argues that European powers justified their dominance over the East by claiming civilizational superiority.
How does Said criticize liberalism?
Exposes how assumed universal liberal concepts have historically been used to justify domination rather than equality; Western states selectively promote democracy and use it to justify colonialism while denying self-determination to non-Western peoples.
What are the flaws of liberal thinking in relation to orientalism?
Ideas that the West represents freedom and progress while the East represents tyranny is embedded into historical narratives, policy decisions, and academic discourse to shape IR in a way that maintains Western dominance.
How does Said counteract liberalism’s ideas of international organizations?
Concepts of organizations and global governance being able to lift up underdeveloped nations are deeply intertwined with the history of orientalism which portrays non-Western societies as passive subjects in need of Western guidance.
What is a real world example of the orientalist mindset?
Middle East treated in international politics with continuous Western interventions that see its societies as incapable of self-rule.
How does the Western treatment of the Middle East reflect on liberalism?
Contradicts claim to uphold self-determination while revealing the selective application based on power interests.
How does Said’s Orientalism align with constructivism?
Shows how Western perceptions of the East have been socially constructed overtime; East was not simply discovered as irrational but produced as such through a network of institutional discourses.
What does Said’s work reveal about international politics?
IR is not a game of power but a field deeply influenced by cultural representations and knowledge production.
How does Said examine the “Clash of Civilizations”?
Not an objective reality but a constructed discourse that portrays non-Western societies as inherently hostile to the West; narrative that has shaped foreign policies, media rep, and public perception of the Muslim world and reinforcing a cycle of misunderstanding and conflict.
What does Said say about the use of language?
Language used to describe IR matters as much as material power; words such as terrorism, civilization, and barbarism have been historically used to justify interventions and military campaigns.
How does Said and Wendt’s work relate?
Constructivism says anarchy is what the states make of it and IR is shaped by shared ideas rather than fixed structures while orientalism shows how the West’s perception of the East has been shaped by centuries of discourse rather than objective reality.
What did Amitav Acharya say about IR?
Emphasizes the need to recognize diverse perspectives and experiences from the Global South, aiming to create a more balanced and comprehensive understanding of international dynamics.
What are the arguments by Amitav Acharya?
Norm localization and subsidiarity; local actors adapt and reinterpret global norms to align with Indigenous beliefs and practices, thereby asserting agency in the normative structures of global governance.
What does Acharya’s perspective highlight?
The dynamic interplay between global standards and local traditions, emphasizing the role of non-Western societies in shaping international norms.
What concept did Spivak introduce?
Examined the silencing of marginalized groups within dominant discourses and labelled them as “subalterns” to represent those excluded from hegemonic power structures.
Define subaltern
Populations marginalized and excluded form power structures whose voices are often silenced in dominant narratives.
What does Spivak argue about subalterns?
Even when subaltern groups attempt to express themselves, their voices are filtered, interpreted, or ignored by elites.
What does Spivak say about Western intellectuals and colonial rulers?
Impose their own narratives on subaltern groups, denying them the ability to define their own identity (i.e. the West speaks for what is best for the Global South).
What does Spivak say about international institutions such as the UN, IMF, and World Bank?
Often make decisions affecting the Global South without meaningful participation from those affected (i.e. Structural Adjustment Programs imposed on developing countries prioritize Western economic models).