1/37
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Story of Decline
things were good, then they got worse, now they’re intolerable
Story of Rising
things were bad, but now they’re getting better
Story of Stymied Progress
things were terrible, then they got better; now we’ve stalled out, they are getting bad again, or our progress is being threatened
“Change is Only an Illusion” Story
you thought things were getting better or worse, but you were wrong
Stories of Power
the situation is bad; we always thought we couldn’t do anything about it, but we can (or vice versa)
Conspiracy Story
all along, we’ve been manipulated by a few people for exercising control for their benefit at our own expense.
Blame-the-Victim Story
if people would just change their behavior, the problem could’ve been avoided.
Synechdoche
a part is used to represent the whole
used for “typical cases” or horror stories
can lead to skewed policy
Metaphor
using a word or image that denotes one kind of object/idea to describe another
ex. “war on ___”
Ambiguity
the capacity to have multiple meanings, sometimes all at once.
Numbers in narrative stories
numbers are used to tell stories
Numbers don’t speak for themselves, and people try to control how others will interpret them.
Accidental causes
phenomena that are devoid of purpose, either in their actions or consequences
ex. natural disasters, such as floods and earthquakes; anything our culture understands as “fate” (looks, health, winning the lottery, etc.)
Intentional causes
problems or harms that are understood as direct consequences of willful human action
either someone acted in order to bring about consequences, or someone acted knowing exactly what the consequences would be
Inadvertent causes
unintended consequences of purposeful actions
harmful side effects of well-intentioned policy; “help is harmful”; ignorance
Problem vs. Condition
Problem: government has a responsibility to fix it
Condition: government does not have a responsibility to fix it
Criteria for successful causal stories:
Do storytellers have visibility, reputation, access to media?
Does it fit with dominant cultural values? [Long-term]
Does it capture the national mood? [Short-term]
Do its solutions NOT challenge existing institutional and economic arrangements?
Crisis vs. Disaster vs. Catastrophe
Crisis: defined in terms of threat to core values or life-sustaining systems
Disaster: defined in terms of the outcome/consequences for society (crisis with a ‘bad ending’)
Catastrophe: when a crisis is perceived to have really bad consequences
Focusing events
Rare, harmful, & sudden events that become known to the mass public and policy elites simultaneously
rare; little to no warning; large scope; immediate awareness
Quiescence
a state marked by inactivity or repose; causing no trouble
First face of power
“A has power over B to the extent that he can get B to do something that B would not otherwise do”
Tools: votes, influence, access, experience
Key policymaking stage: policy adoption
Assumptions: grievances are recognized and acted upon; any dissatisfied group will find a spokesperson (pluralist approach)
non-participation/inaction isn’t a political problem
Second face of power
power to exclude
key policymaking stage: agenda setting
tools: rules of the game (institutional procedures, norms), threats
Third face of power
“A exercises power over B when A affects B in a manner contrary to B’s interests”
key policymaking stage: problem recognition
tools: socialization (myths, language, symbols) and info control
Strategies of “agenda denial”:
low cost: non-recognition
medium cost: attack policy proposals and/or proposers; placate
high cost: direct threats
False conciousness
“the most effective and insidious use of power is to prevent such conflcit from arising in the first place”
Policy solutions: Government Management
public provisions of goods and services
Policy solutions: Rules/Regulations
governmental commands and mandates, backed by enforcement
Policy solutions: Inducements/Incentives
rewards and punishments; drawing on human motivation
Policy solutions: Facts/Persuasion
provide information and let the people decide
Policy solutions: Rights
invoke government protection
Policy solutions: Powers
shift power of decision-making to different groups of people; restructure authority
Rational Choice assumptions about rules
A rule should be complete, with all expectations stated explicitly
A rule should be flexible
A rule should be optimally balanced between fairness and allowance for discretion
A rule should be neutral
A rule should be properly enforced
Polis Model assumptions about rules
Policy problems are too complex to allow for perfectly detailed rules
A rule that is flexible enough to accommodate all situations would have to be so vague that it would end up not even being a rule
Discretion and fairness are competing values; balancing them is a political process
All rules benefit some people and harm/exclude others
There are usually more rule violations than enforcers can handle; so they use the rule of thumb to selectively enforce rules
Positive incentives
People are given something in return for cooperation (i.e. states that raised their drinking age to 21 got federal funding for highways)
Negative incentives
People won’t get something/ will have something taken away if they don’t cooperate (i.e. states that didn’t raise the drinking age to 21 didn’t get federal funding)
Perverse incentives
Incentives unwittingly built into a rule that create new problems or make the original problem worse
Incentivizing inputs vs. outputs in educational settings
Incentivizing inputs (i.e. reading) is better than incentivizing outputs (i.e. higher grades) because at least if the student’s grades don’t improve drastically, they are still engaging with material that will teach them things
they’re less worried about the outcome and can focus more on doing the activity that is meant to help them
Intrinsic motivation
Motivation to perform an activity for enjoyment rather than a reward
Extrinsic motivation
Motivation to perform an activity in order to earn a reward/ avoid punishment