1/21
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Holds rights
corporations, future generations
Doesn’t hold rights
river, chimpanzee, forest, AI systems
The premise of 1948
all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights (UDHR, Art. 1)
Kymlickas argument
server human rights from human supremacism, a nonsupremacist account may be better for humans
Species hiearchy Jacques Maritain (UDHR)
rights insist on the radical distinction between persons and all other beings, humanity is lifted above animality
Species hiearchy Catherine Dupre
european jurisprudence treats dignity as what seperates humans from animals, which have only relative worth
Species hiearchy Angus Taylor
exceptionalism is as much about whom we exclude from the moral community as whom we include
Intrinsic hiearchy
defended for its own sake, Maritain’s idea that humans alone bear gods image
Strategic hierarchy
as a shield against dehumanizing marginalized groups; vanessa watts idea that indigenous people must fight being animalized while sustaining kinship with animals
The estrellita judgement (ecuador, 2022)
held in captivity for 17 years, was treated as a pet and within a year the monkey died; court found that estrellita should not be forced to assimilate characteristics for the benefit of human beings
UNDRIP self determination
art 3-4 determining political status, development, and autonomy
UNDRIP lands and territories + resources
art 25-29 spiritual relationships, ownership, use, env protection
UNDRIP free, prior, and informed consent
art 10,19,32 consultation and cooperation to obtain FPIC in specified decisions
UNDRIP culture knowlegde and language
art 11-16, 31; traditions, languages, education, heritage, traditional knowledge
UNDRIP equality and collective survival
art 7-9, 21-24 collective security, identity, health, social and economic rights
UNDRIP participations and institutions
art 5, 18, 20, 33-34; institutions, representation, identity, customs
a different relationship with nature (UNDRIP limits on HR)
article 25 recognizes indigenous people distinctive spiritual relationship responsible to futures
A collective conception of justice (UNDRIP limits on HR)
UNDRIP protects peoples, institutions, cultures, and territorial relationships, independent legal rights holders
Welamalsewakan
health is rational, land is not simply a determinant, knowledge and authority matter
From a right to health to a relational ethics of care
conventional rights framework, a lenape centered challenge, implications for institutions
Whanguai river, new zealand (Rights of nature in law)
te awa tupua act 2017 recognizes river as person, i am the river the river is me
Los Cerdos protected forest, ecuador, (Rights of nature in law)
cloud forest, mining concessions violated the forests rights of nature rooted in article 71 of 2018 constitution