SAM Salah Masail Groups

اختلاف الأئمة في كلمات الأذان

Group 1: 19 (tarjeeh + tarbeeh) - Shafi
Group 2: 17 (tarjeeh, no tarbeeh - Maliki
Group 3: 15 (tarbeeh, no tarjeeh - Hanafis

اختلاف الأئمة في كلمات الإقامة

Maliki - 10

Shafi + Hanbali - 11

Hanafi - 17

 التأذين للفجر أي وقت هو؛ بعد طلوع الفجر أو قبل ذلك

Imam Abu Yousuf + Maliki + Shafi + Hanbali: Can do adhan for fajr before the time enters and no need to repeat

Tarafain + Sufyan at thawri: Need to be in fajr time, repeat in time if did before time

الجمع بين صلاتين كيف هو

Jamhoor: Can do jama haqiqi if there is an excuse

Hanafi: Only do jama suri, except in hajj

رفع اليدين في افتتاح الصلاة إلى أين يبلغ بهما

Iraqioon from Malikis and 1 Hanbali Riwayat: Can lift hands as much as you want

Some Malikis + 1 Shafi and 1 Hanbali Riwayat: Raise to shoulders

Hanafis + Malikis + Shafis preferred: Raise to ears

 ما يقال في الصلاة بعد تكبيرة الافتتاح

Tarafain + Imam Ahmed + Ishaq bin Rahway: Only thana in fard

Imam Abu Yousuf + Ishaq Al Marwazi + Tahawi: Thana and tawjih

Shafi: Only Tawjih

Maliki: Neither

 قراءة بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم في الصلاة

Shaif: Say it outlound

Maliki: Don’t it at all

Hanafi + Hanbali: Say it silently

Side Masala: Iktilaf regarding basmalla - is it part of quran?

Shafi: Its part of each surah except surah tawbah

Maliki: It isn’t an ayah

Hanafis: It is an ayah but only there to separate the surahs

القراءة خلف الإمام

Shafi: Fatiha wajib to recite for follower

Hanafi: Markuh Tahrimi to recite for follower

Maliki: Allowed in jahri salah, mustahab in sirri

Hanbali: Makruh in jahri salah, mustabh in sirri

التطبيق في الركوع

Tatbeeq is sunnah - Abdullah Ibn Masud, Alqama bin Qays, Aswad Bin Yazid, Ibrahim Nakhai

Sunnah is holding knees - Jamhoor

مقدار الركوع والسجود الذي لا يجزئ أقل منه

Duration of 3 tasbeeh - Hanbali (1 opinioin), Ishaq Rahway, Ibrahim Nakhai

Just Itminan is Fard - Jamhoor (Shafis + Malikis + IAY say fard, Tarafain say Wajib in riwaya from karkhi (this practiced in madhab), sunnah in another

 ما ينبغي أن يقال في الركوع والسجو

Group 1: Sunnah is tasbeehs, can do dua after in sujood and ruku - Shafis + hanbalis

Group 2: Tasbeeh 3x, Extra dua in Sujood only - Malikis

Group 3: Tasbees 3x or more in odd numbers only - Hanafis

 الإمام يقول "سمع الله لمن حمده"؛ هل ينبغي له أن يقول بعدها "ربنا ولك الحمد" أم لا

Group 1: Imam does’t say it - Imam Abu Hanifa + Malikis

Group 2: Imam recite both - Sahibain + Shaifs + Hanbalis. Tahawi, Abdul Hay Laknawi, and Shurumbulali Prefer this

Side Masala - Do you do action with or after imam

Sahibain: Do it after the imam

Imam Abu Hanifa: Do it with the imam as long as you dont go before him

القنوت الراتب

Group 1: After ruku in Fajr - Shafis

Group 2: Before ruku in Fajr - Malikis and ibn abi Layla

Group 3: No qunut ratiba - Hanafis + Hanbalis

Side Masala: Qunut Nazila

Hanafiya: Allowed in Fajr. one opinion that in all jahri salahs

Tahawi: Completely Mansukh

Shafi: Allowed in every salah

 صفة الجلوس في الصلاة كيف هو

Group 1: Tawaruk in all - Maliki

Group 2: Last qaida tawaruk, otherwise iftirash - Shafi

Group 3: Iftirash in every Qaida - Hanafi

 التشهد في الصلاة كيف هو

Group 1: Tashahud of Omar (RA) - Malikis

Group 2: Not tashahud of Omar (RA) - Jamhoor (Hanafis say Ibn Masud, Shafis + Hanbalis say Ibn Abbas)