1/185
Looks like no tags are added yet.
2 types of contracts
Express Contracts: legally binding agreement, the terms of which are all clearly stated
Implied: An implied-in-fact contract is a form of an implied contract formed by non-verbal conduct, rather than by explicit word. One party may dispute that a contract even existed in the first place.
True/False: Parties can enter into a contract only if they both intend to do so.
False.
How is assent judged?
Objective test: Whether a reasonable person in the position of the recipient of the offer/acceptance would understand the manifestations to constitute an offer/acceptance
Does unexpressed intentions such as jesting count towards assent?
No, see Lucy. v. Zehmer.
What is an implied in fact contract?
An implied-in-fact contract is a form of an implied contract formed by non-verbal conduct, rather than by explicit words (Taco Bell). One party may dispute that a contract even existed in the first place.
What determines if you have an offer?
Southworth test; objective test from the position of the offeree/recipient
Are ads/form letters offers?
No. Advertisements (commercial and newspapers etc.) and form letters (pre-written letter that goes out to many people) are considered just an invitation to deal or negotiate and not offers to sell.
What if a person does not hear an offer?
If person doesn't hear an offer, not objectively an offer
What is the Southworth test?
Its an objective test to determine if an offer has been made. “Any conduct of one party, from which the other may reasonably draw the inference of a promise, is effective in law as such.”
What are the elements of the Southworth Test?
COD#
1) Context of offer (ex. golf course or board room)
2) Offertory Lang : “selling this” ( this is ad language)
3) # of recipients; likely offer if names definitive parties
4) Details ( defensiveness of proposal)
Modes of Acceptance - Who decides what counts as an offer?
Offeror, then offeree accepts ( moment of conception)
How to determine mode of acceptance?
Offer itself; what a reasonable person in the position of the offeror would take as an acceptance!
What is the exception to naming a certain mode of acceptance?
Daily Activities Exception: an offeror cannot name modes of acceptance that would require an offeror to accept by doing something they would normally do.
Unilateral Mode of Acceptance
promise is given in exchange for a completed act (acceptance by performance)
*Good way to think about it: no more promises to happen
What is the completed act unilateral offer?
Moment of conception is completed act in control of the offeree (recipient)
Requirements for Unilateral Acceptance
Must be aware of offer to accept by performance
Conditions must be met to receive contract benefits ( outside of offerees control), but K can still be accepted/ formed without them
Notice of completion required within a reasonable amount of time.… if not contract expires ( no notice to form contract tho)
Bilateral Contract
Promise for a Promise
A contract where a promise is given in exchange for a promise.
Types of Bilateral Contracts
TYPE 1: Exclusive method (Type I): Only this constitutes an acceptance (“shall”)
TYPE 2: Suggested method (Type II): may or something equally as fast/effective constitutes acceptance (“may”)
TYPE 3: No method stated (Type III): any reasonable method just make sure to notify
Requirements for Suggested Method
When a suggested method of acceptance is stated, an offeree can use the suggest method or a method that is just as good to provide notice of acceptance.
Requirements for no method stated
Objective test used to determine acceptance – what reasonable person in the position of the offeror would believe is an acceptance
Need notice of acceptance in a reasonable amount of time
Can you accept by conduct?
Can you accept by conduct?
Can accept by your conduct, continued use counts
Cannot name modes of acceptance that would force offerees to deviate from their normal life activities ( too ambiguous)
Can you accept by conduct if they didn’t recieve the offer?
No
Can you accept by silence?
General rule: Silence alone does not constitute acceptance
Exceptions
Silence + When Offeree accepts the benefit without saying anything
Taco Bell (had chance to reject the benefit, knowing compensation was expected)
Silence + the parties agree to use silence as a means of acceptance
Beneficial ( credit card agreement, bilateral, bank changed terms to arbitration, said you accept if you don’t notify within 30 days ): accepted when he used the card and agreed to silence as a mode of acceptance, offeree stayed silent
Silence + “previous dealings” – Prior course of dealings, Course of performance or Trade Practice
Ammons (buyer bought shortening from seller in past, placed an order and then didn’t hear any acceptance from seller, price of shortening went up, no method stated): need to notify if not accepting offer if prior course of dealing indicates it, silence constituted acceptance here
Do you need notice of acceptance to for a bilateral contract?
Need to communicate notice of acceptance to offeror to form bilateral contract
What is the default rule for acceptance?
( Dispatch Rule): Acceptance(Notice) is effective as soon as the acceptance is dispatched by reasonable means (when offeree no longer has control over their acceptance)
If the offeror wants the dispatch rule to not apply, it is on her to expressly state that acceptance will only be acknowledged on receipt.
Exceptions to the Dispatch Rule ( Effective upon Reciept)
Exceptions (effective upon receipt)
[Type 1] Offer explicitly states a different mode of acceptance ( ex. Acceptance upon the actual communicator to the offeror)
Electronic communication ( effective upon receipt)
Terminations of Offers ( effective when received )
Rejections, counteroffers and revocations ( make offer then take it back)
2 types of Revocation
(1) Direct revocation
Being told about pulling an offer (Hendricks).
(2) Indirect revocation
Secondhand notice, like being told by someone else that offeror made a contract with someone else (Dickinson).
Requires “reliable information.”
An act that is totally inconsistent with selling to the original offeree.
ii.Dispatch rule exception: if dispatched before heard notice, acceptance effective
What is a counter offer/Rejection?
Counter offer terminates/rejects original offer upon receipt
Default Rule for Acceptance (when it becomes a counter offer)
Default Rule (Mirror image): acceptances must perfectly match the offer (unconditional assent/total congruence). Any slight change (adding qualifications or requiring performance of conditions) to the original offer is a counteroffer
What is not a counteroffer?
counter offer when you inquire: “ would you accept an offer for X?”
When does a counter offer not terminate power of acceptance?
Irrevocable Offers
Two ways to make an offer irrevocable
Paying for it (Humble Oil)
Reliance on an offer
Partial performance of the invited act for a unilateral contract (Marchiondo).
Begin the invited act.
First Restatement § 45.
Reasonably foreseeable reliance on either a bilateral or unilateral offer (Drennan and Ever-Tite).
Second Restatement § 87(2)
Exception to reasonably forseeable reliance
When you bid-shop ( contractor uses other prices and does not rely on the bid)
When does power of acceptance die?
Rejection (or counteroffer)
Lapse of time ( once time/event stipulated expires or if no stipulation, after a reasonable time)
Revocation of offer
Death of a party
Non-occurrence of a condition of acceptance
Notice Requirement
I) Offeror must provide notice of terms for an acceptance
Three Types of Notice
1. Actual: The offer has real notice of the offer
2. Inquiry: A reasonable person would have inquired more details regarding the offer and could have found the terms
3. Constructive: Offeree has notice but did not read (should have known)
a) Think about credit cards in terms of acceptance/ service.
b) Think don’t want to award ignorance
Can agents/bots be put on notice?
Bots are agents that can be notified and can accept on behalf of their principle
What is a theory of defective formulation in general?
Theories of Defective Formulation: (flaw in formation of K that affects enforceability)
What are the theories of defective formulation
Ambiguity
Misunderstanding/Equal Ambiguity
Vagueness
Agreement to Agree (Vagueness)
Lack of Mutual Assent ( disagreement on material terms)
Missing Term
Ambigious Term ( Definition & Resolution)
Definition: A term with a limited number of meanings (usually two)
Resolution of Ambiguous Terms
Objective Test: choose most reasonable interpretation
If no reasonable interpretation → unenforceable
If reasonable interpretation found → enforceable
Equal Ambiguity (Misunderstanding)
Definition: limited meanings where neither meaning is more reasonable
Resolution of Terms: strikes down K/K unenforceable
Agreement to Agree ( type of vagueness)
Definition: Agreement to decide on key terms in the future
Resolution: (Majority Approach) Strike K Down/unenforceable unless fillers exist (4 fillers) [ WI Follows this]
1. The four corners of the contract—if the contract contains a mechanism to fill the document. (Oglebay v. Armco, before that mechanism failed)
2. Trade Practice (Scheider v MGM)
3. Prior Course of performance (Same Contract) (Oglebay v Armco.)
4. Prior Course of Dealings (Other Contracts)
Lack of Mutual Assent ( on COD#) - disagreement on material terms
Definition: When you fail to agree to all of these material terms
Resolution:
Objective Standard
Would a reasonable person believe that there was a disagreement on the terms – if yes – unenforceable
Missing Term
Definition: Term not in K that is necessary to the K formation
Resolution
General Rule: K unenforceable unless filler exists
Fillers
1. The four corners of the contract—if the contract contains a mechanism to fill the document. (Oglebay v. Armco, before that mechanism failed)
Trade Practice (Scheider v MGM)
Prior Course of performance (Same Contract) (Oglebay v Armco.)
Prior Course of Dealings (Other Contracts)
What equitable theory always comes first?
Contract
How to recovery on contract?
I.Use: When consideration is bargained for
II.Damages: benefit of bargain in contract itself
III.Elements
Offer
Acceptance
Consideration
IV. If valid K → cannot use equitable theories unless on different grounds
Quantum Meruit
Use: Conferred benefit by request and then refuse to pay
Remedy: REASONABLE MARKET VALUE OF SERVICES THAT YOU RENDER UNDER THIS
Ex. Reasonable value of work done
Elements(Varney)
Failed contract
Services Rendered (benefit conferred by the services requested by recipient)
Without compensation
Promissory Estoppel
I.Use: When benefit given gratuitously (then someone suffered detriment)
II. Remedy: Reliance damages, damages necessary to avoid injustice resulting from reliance.
i)if still in precontractual liability phase, can’t enforce injunction for specific performance of promise, but can issue reliance damages
ii) Promise is irrelevant; damages is based on what you give up
iii) No person would rely on mere puffery
III.Elements
Promise (ex. Engagement ring)
Reliance was foreseeable.
Was it reasonably foreseeable that the party would rely on the promise being made?
Reliance was of a substantial and definite nature.
Did they commit acts because of the promise?
4. Relief is needed to prevent injustice
What does Restatement 90 say?
(Restatement § 90) provides a theory of recovery for people who incurred an injustice by relying on a promise, so long as the reliance was foreseeable (most people would have relied on the promise) and substantial ( silence was alot)
Factors to consider before invoking promissory estoppel
i. Nature of promise ( more conditions = less reasonable to rely)
ii. Level of reliance
iii. Type of parties (big guy vs. little guy?)
Moral Obligation General Definition
Promise for a past benefit received ( paying for past consideration)
General Rule: A promise made in recognition of a benefit previously received by the promisor from the promise is binding to the extent necessary to prevent justice.
When will the court not enforce a moral obligation?
(1) if the promise conferred the benefit as a gift
(2) for other reasons the promisor has not been unjustly enriched (officiousness)
(3) to the extent that its value is disproportionate to the benefit
Components of a gift
2 components to gift
Intent to make a gift (notice of intent)
Reflex action (not gift)
Deliver the gift
Steps of analysis for Section 86 Moral Obligation
Steps of analysis: (1) promise for past benefit, (2) not a gift (gift = donative intent + delivery), (3) benefit was not officious, and (4) the promise was proportionate to the benefit
What is the difference between Unjust Enrichment and §86 Moral Obligation?
§86 Moral Obligation requires a subsequent promise.
Can you plead promissory estoppel with Moral Obligation?

Difference between moral obligation, promissory estoppel and unjust enrichment?
Accord and Satsifaction
Definition
Method to satisfy dispute over existence of debt or amount
Eligibility to Use
When can you use it: good faith disagreement over either (1) the amount of a debt, or (2) the breakdown of liability ( whos at fault)
Elements
If you are eligible to use it, then accord and satisfaction can satisfy the debt by sending a check/ payment and if party cashes it/accepts it, this satisfies the debt
Quasi Contract/Unjust Enrichment Damages & Use
Use: No recovery if unrequested benefit voluntarily conferred and there was an opportunity to ask consent of receiving party before conferring
Damages:
Reasonable value of the benefit conferred or return of the benefit.
Elements of Unjust Enrichment
(1) Benefit Conferred (ex. Services, real estate etc.) without request of recipient
(2) Benefit Accepted/ appreciated by the recipient
(3) Unfair (not officious) for recipient to retain the benefit without providing compensation for it
Definition of Officious: conferred (a) without asking if the recipient of the benefit wants it and (b) there was an opportunity to ask.
Not Officious = unfair to retain without compensation
Officious = fair to retain without compensation, cannot claim quasi K
What happens if the benefit was conferred officiously?
Quasi-contract cannot be claimed if the benefit is conferred officiously.
Exceptions to officious conduct? (i.e. when is it acceptable to confer a benefit without asking)
(1) Emergency Intervention (ex. unconscious)
(2) Conferred by mistake (ex.wrong address)
(3) Reasonable reason for not asking
What if a person declines a benefit in advance because they want to speed up process and then wants money back?
If a person declines in advance a benefit to be conferred by another, then the person conferring the benefit may not recover for unjust enrichment ( considered officious) ( Green tree)
What are the restituional theories?
Quantum Meruit & Quasai Contract
restitution focuses on restoring the parties to the position they were in before the benefit was conferred or stripping the defendant of their ill-gotten gain
Major differnce between quantum meruit and quasi contract?
In quantum meruit there is a promise while in quasi contract there is not. Also, recall that quantum meruit will be for services and quasi contract for services or property.
Biggest difference between all the other equitable theories and unjust enrichment?
In unjust enrichment, there is no previous agreement
Theories in Defense of an Agreement/K
Equitable Estoppel: an affirmative defense to prevent a wrong by making someone keep their promise (shield)
It can only be used defensively when a party who voluntarily waived a right tries to go back on that waiver.
Used by D
Elements of equitable estoppel
Elements (same as PE)
i. Promise
ii. Foreseeable reliance
iii. Substantial reliance
iv. injustice
What is promissory estoppel
Sword; creates a new cause of action (used by P)
Elements of Consideration
Seeking (Both parties are seeking something (sought for)
Performance or Return Promise
Cannot be a gift
Exchange (Given in exchange for (quid pro quo . . . this for that))
Benefit (Mutual benefit conferred (benefit to both parties)(not detriment; detriment = PE)
Does consideration have to be met by both sides?
Yes, sex has to be met by both parties.
What is the main difference between promissory estoppel & consideration?
PE: person relies on promise to their DETRIMENT
Consideration: there is benefit confered to both parties which induces the promise
What theory do you always back up breach of contract with?
Promissory estoppel
What is the difference between adequacy and sufficiency of consideration?
Adequacy is whether there was a fair deal. Courts do not care about adequacy.
Sufficiency is whether there was enough consideration to be legally “enough.” Courts will address this.
Sufficient Consideration Definition
Enough consideration to be deemed legally enough?
What is not sufficient consideration
Motive is not consideration
Ask about thomas case: no quid pro quo if dead?, but because it was an agreement with the executors it worked? Does not matter if something is bargained for , can still be consideration (ex. Person dies and before dies tells person what they want) (Thomas)
Adequacy (whether there was a good/fair deal) never considered by court
Two Theories of Sufficient Consideraiton
Peppercorn [WI] (Second Restatement 71): Bargained for and at least worth a peppercorn; You bargained for it, you assessed value to it, you got it”
Greater than Nominal (NY + others): More than pretense(false recitation of consideration) or merely nominal → $1 was pretense
What is one example of sufficient consideration?
Release of a Valid or Doubtful Claim (“if claimant in good faith makes a mountain out of a molehill”)
Person giving up claim must have an honest belief they have a claim (intent to be legally bound to a commitment/intent to contract; can’t only just have an intent to agree) is even if it is unreasonable/not actually one → then there is a doubtful claim
What are 3 examples of insufficient consideration?
Past Consideration → violates exchange
Case of the Proud Grandfather: gave painting to name baby august after he was named august
Ex. “Other good and valuable considerations” in In Re Greene
No Gratuitous Promises → commitment given as gratuity rather than in return of something
i. Promises absent consideration = gratuitous (recover with PE)
1. If consideration, recover with contract theory
Given For Free
Sex (Illegal)
Even when all elements of a contract theory of recovery are present (O+A+C), what may a court consider to achieve certain social outcomes?
Public Policy. A court may strike down a contract if the enforcement of that contract would be against public policy.
Note: The courts in In re Greene and Thomas avoided discussing this issue, but they also are cases that illustrate the idea of public policy.
Examples of when a contract goes against public policy?
Leaker
Wife having affair
Promise not to remarry
Is a reporters confidentiality promise enforceable?
Yes, but in the leaker case, the reporters confidentiality promise was related to information concerning criminal activity which was unenforceable on grounds of public policy.
What is the definition of unconsionability and how much of each type is needed?
I) Definition: on its face unfair; renders contract unenforceable
( The two elements need not both be present in the same degree. But some of each is required.)
Procedural and Substantive Unconsionability Definitions
Procedural Unconscionability:
Were there negotiations/context/bargaining power?
Bargaining capacity (look at party A and party B and look at their education level, language skills, health or intelligence)... is it unequal bargaining power/1 party taken advantage of?
Substantive unconscionability: not so high as to shock the conscience of the court, looks at contract langauge( so shocking/one sided that this is outrageous )
What is an analogy for unconscionability for consideration?
IV) Scale of Consideration
a. If sufficiency (peppercorn) is bottom, unconscionability is whatever is just
past top of allowable amount of consideration ( seller wants this)
How to remedy unconsionability
III)Remedying Unconsionability ( 3 ways)
a. Refuse to enforce whole contract
b. Excise unenforceable clause
c. Limit application
Preexisting duty Rule ( K Modification)
Definition: performance or the promise to perform a preexisting legal duty does not constitute consideration.
Traditional Rule to Modify a K
i. Offer
ii. Acceptance
iii. Consideration (new peppercorns)
iv.( + must be voluntary not coerced)
Modern Approach to K Modification (89D) ( if any one of these weak, no modification)
Voluntary ( alaska)
Executory contract ( not complete/ongoing) -->one that has not yet been completed
Unanticipated ( something popped up that was not foreseeable)
Modification is fair and equitable
What does 89D tell us about the pre-exsiting duty rule
Restatement § 89(d) reflects the modern trend of courts enforcing agreements that modify contracts when unexpected or unanticipated difficulties arise during the course of the performance of a contract. (Wisconsin Rule)
What rule does WI follow for K modification?
WI Approach to K Modification ( follows 89D; only 2 elements required for K modification tho)
Voluntary ( no coercion)
K executory (not complete) at the time the modification occurred.
No new consideration needed!
What do half a peppercorn, past consideration, and a preexisting legal duty (under the traditional approach) all have in common?
All three are insufficient consideration.
What happens if something is missing consideration?
Courts read in good faith (based on good and honest effort) duty to perform based on:
i. trade practices
ii. Prior course of dealing
iii. Prior course of performance
What is an illusory promise
Free way out
Is this valid consideration?
No, there is no consideration in an illusory promise and a a valid contract requires mutual consideration, an agreement built solely on illusory promises is unenforceable
Is a personal satisfaction clause illusory?
No, unless no check. Personal satisfaction clauses are not illusory because courts will read in a good faith duty to take reasonable efforts based on trade practice, prior course of performance, and prior course of dealings. Once there is a check on a party’s discretion, such as good faith, there is no longer a free way out.
What does the existence of a valid contract do to equitable theories such as promissory estoppel that are based on the same facts?
Precludes them. BUT, if the equitable theory is based on different adjacent grounds, it may still be viable. See Alpine Valley.
What does the statue of frauds do?
A contract that will not be enforced by a court even though it is valid if an Oral K Needed in Writing in order to enforce K
Who raises the defense?
D- wanting the contract to be unenforceable