1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Elements of culture
-Ideational element
-Material element
-Practiced element
Categories of intangible cultural heritage
-Oral traditions and expressions
-Performing arts
-Social practices, rituals, and festive events
-Knowledge and practices concerning nature and the universe
-Traditional craftsmanship
Analysis of intangible cultural heritage
-Material and visual dimensions: How is it documented, beyond just the tekst
-Context: Where does it take place, at what level: region, towns, communities, countries, etc.
-Community involvement: Who practices it, which communities are involved in maintaining or transmitting it?
-Use and function: What is it used for, is it recreational, ritual, folkloric, commercial, social, etc?
-Dynamic nature: How is it maintained and reproduced over time, is it passed down and if so how and who transmits to whom? How has it changed?
Practices
-Manifestations of ways of doing things
-That are context specific
-That involve communities
-That require the presence of human actors to carry them out
-But also, oftentimes, of non human actors
-And the knowledge of how to use them
-They require training, effort, and dedication
-They are connected with processes of transmission
Practices as a lens to look at culture
-Looking at practices allow to account for embodied, know how, processual, ideational, and material all-in one
-It allow to observe culture in context, it makes us in see the multidimensionality of culture --> it makes the complexity observable
-To study and manage culture entails observation, description, and contextualised interpretation
-Cultural practices: elements of culture (phenomena)
-Practice dimensions: way of looking at culture (method)
What is the appearl of the practice-based approach
-The appeal lies in its capacity to describe important features of the world we inhabit as something that is routinely made and re-made in practice, using tools, discourse, and our bodies
-Its capacity to resonate with the contemporary experience that our world is increasingly in flux and interconnected, a world where social entitites appear as the result of ongoing work and complex machinations, and in which boundaries are increasingly difficult to draw
Definition of practice-based approach (Nicolini, 2012)
-Regimes of a mediated object-oriented performance of organised set of sayings and doings
-We call these performances practices when they have a history, social constituency, and hence a perceivable normative dimension
-Historically situated performance and the resources that go into producing and accounting for them is the basic building block of a practice-based approach
Why are practices performances (Nicolini, 2012)
-Practices only exist to the extent that they are reproduced
-The interest is in performances connected in space and time, not mysterious entities called practices
-Mediated means that all practices are carried out through and are made possible by material or discursive resources we bring from somewhere else
-Mediation also means including both material tools and discursive resources
The boundary of practice
-To say that saying and doing must have a history to become a practice means that practices last in time by virtue of being re-performed
-Practices have a social constituency: practices are always such for a social group that legitimates them and performs them on a regular basis so the practice is kept in existence
-The boundary of the practice is a place that is always contestable and contested and where very often new practices emerge
-Practices are always oriented and organised around a telic dimension
Key elements of the practice based approach
-Processual: Focus on activity, agency, and creativity in the creation and perpetuation of all aspects of social life
-Materiality/embodiment: Underline the critical role of bodies and material things in all social affairs
-Knowledge: Knowledge is conceived as a form of mastery
-Context/political: Understandable in context and situated in historical and material conditions
Using practice to study culture
-A methodologyical approach
-Focused on processes
-Accounting at once for discursive and material aspects
-Embodied in individuals
-That are carriers of embedded kowledge
-And whose agency is central to reproduce social phenomena
Evidence based, bottom up, processual method of engaging with practices
-Give prominence to the "in practice" and not to the "in principle" dimension, and only after come up with generalisations
-More than just describe what people do --> practices are meaning-making, identity-forming, and order-producing activities
-Understand contextually, historically, and untangle relationships
-Sense-making and knowing are located in the material and discursive activity, body, artefacts, habits, and preoccupations that populate the life of organizational members
-Allow to capture the at once social, discursive, and material dimension
3 movements in engaging with practices
-Zoom in
-Zoom out
-Write it up
Focuses of the zoom in phase
-Sayings and doings
-Interactional order (what sort of interactional order is performed by this specific practice and how does it differ to similar practices)
-Timing and tempo (how are sayings and actions temporarily organised)
-Bodily choreography (material and symbolic landscape in which the practice is carried out)
-Tools, artefacts, and mediation work
-Practical concerns (what practical concerns orient daily work of the practitioners)
-Tension between creativity and normativity
-Process of legitimation and stabilisation
Zoom out
-Follow the practice in time and space and the connection between practices
-Understand how they are kept in place
-What are the effects of the practice
-Study the emergence and the evolution of the practice
Write it up
-Observation
-Contextual interpretation
-Thick description
-Making worlds with words
-Variegated speech
4 strategies to engage with practices
-Situational orientation: scenes of action
-Genealogic orientation: history, development, change
-Configurational orientation: how are practices related
-Conflict sensitive orientation: internal tensions, conflicts, competitions