1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What situation does Singer start from? What is overall claim?
Singer starts from the 1971 Bengal refugee crisis, where people were dying of hunger, shelter loss, and lack of medical care even though richer nations could prevent it. Governments and individuals gave little. For example, Britain’s share of the Concorde project cost far more than its aid to Bengal. He claims this response can’t be justified and that our moral conceptual scheme and way of life need to change drastically.
What is Assumption 1?
Suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care are bad.
State Singer’s principle. What does “comparable moral importance” mean?
The principle is: “If it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought, morally, to do it.”
“Comparable moral importance” means not causing something else comparably bad, not doing something wrong in itself, and not failing to promote a moral good of comparable significance.
What is the drowning child case, and how does it support the principle?
If you walk past a shallow pond and see a child drowning, you ought to wade in and pull the child out, even if it ruins your clothes. Your muddy clothes are insignificant next to the child’s death.
This supports the principle because the cost is trivial compared with the bad outcome we prevent.
Why does Singer think the principle would fundamentally change our lives and society?
It looks uncontroversial, but it takes no account of distance or of how many others could help. So it would require affluent people to give much of their money to prevent suffering, which would fundamentally change our lives, society, and world.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - Proximity and distance
Objection: we owe more to people near us.
Reply: distance doesn’t matter morally, since impartiality means we can’t discriminate against someone just for being far away. Nearness only matters if it helps us help more effectively, and with modern communication and transport we can direct aid well from afar.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - Others could help too. What is the difference between a situation where everyone gives $5 and our actual situation?
Objection: if everyone gave $5, that would be enough, so I need only give $5.
Reply: that argument only holds if everyone actually gives $5, which they don’t, so giving more prevents more suffering. Also, if I see others doing nothing, that doesn’t excuse me from pulling the drowning child out.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - The over-giving challenge
Objection: if everyone gives all they ought, they’ll over-give and some sacrifice will be wasted.
Reply: this only happens if people give at the same time and unexpectedly. Otherwise we can calibrate our giving, since others’ giving is a relevant circumstance.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - The conclusion is too drastic a revision of our moral scheme.
Objection: this changes our moral scheme too much.
Reply: how people actually judge doesn’t decide whether the conclusion is valid. Unless the principle is rejected or the argument shown unsound, the conclusion stands however strange it seems.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - Isn't this an empirical question about what most effectively secures good outcomes? (Sidgwick-Urmson)
Objection: if we demand too much, people may follow no moral rules, so maybe it’s better to call giving optional.
Reply: moral standards shape what people do, since people are influenced by what others expect. Given the stakes, the risk is worth taking, and the point only concerns what we demand of others, not what we ourselves ought to do.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - We would have to be working full time
Objection: we’d have to work full time to prevent suffering.
Reply: Singer accepts that we ought to be working full time to relieve great suffering. He asks why this counts against his view rather than against our ordinary standards of behavior.
Objection & Singer’s Reply - Isn't it the government’s job?
Objection: aid should come from governments, not private giving.
Reply: unless refusing to give would likely lead to government aid, those who refuse are failing to prevent suffering without any tangible benefit. The burden is on them to show their refusal would lead to government action.
What happens to the traditional distinction between duty and charity?
The traditional distinction can’t be drawn where we normally draw it. Giving to famine relief isn’t a generous extra (“supererogatory”), it is something we ought to do, and not giving is wrong. Singer says the line might be redrawn elsewhere, but not where it puts giving money to save lives on the charity side.
What does Singer say about longer-term solutions?
Singer says longer-term solutions may be more effective, such as population control, since relieving famine now may just postpone starvation. He concludes that we should pursue the long-term solutions that work best, and support organizations that work on them. We should also campaign for new standards of public and private giving. Your slide links this to Effective Altruism.