1/14
Looks like no tags are added yet.
We have seen how religion can be a conservative force (how?), but sociologists have also shown it to be a force for change.
Arguably, the most famous example of this view is M____ W____ (1905) study The P_____ E_____ and the S_____ of C_____.
In it, Weber argues that the religious beliefs of V
C____ helped bring about major social change how? leading to the emergence of m____ c____ in N____ E____ in the ___th and ___th centuries
We have seen how religion can be a conservative force (by legitimating traditional values and discouraging social change), but sociologists have also shown it to be a force for change.
Calvinism
Arguably, the most famous example of this view is Max Weberās (1905) study The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism.
In it, Weber argues that the religious beliefs of Calvinism helped bring about major social change (by encouraging hard work, self-discipline, and investment), leading to the emergence of modern capitalism in Northern Europe in the 16th and 17th centuries
How does Weber argue capitalism existed in earlier societies?
How is this different in modern capitalism?
Weber calls this m___ the s___ of c___.
He argues that this spirit had an elective affinity with Calvinist beliefs and attitudes - what does this mean?
how did Calvinism/Calvinist beliefs bring social change?
Weber argues that while earlier societies had capitalism in the sense of greed for wealth, this money was usually spent on luxury and consumption.
In contrast, modern capitalism is different because it involves the systematic, efficient, and rational pursuit of profit for its own sake, rather than to spend it. (like a sport - the love of the gameš)
Weber calls this mindset the spirit of capitalism.
He argues that this spirit had an elective affinity (an unconscious similarity) with Calvinist beliefs and attitudes, meaning the two fitted together naturally - capitalism and calvinism has similarities
Calvinism brings social change because Calvinist beliefs changed how people behaved in everyday life, reshaping society.
Calvinism encouraged hard work, discipline, saving, and reinvesting profits rather than spending money on luxury.
what are 4 calvinist beliefs?
predestination
divine transcendence
asceticism
the idea of a vocation/a calling
Calvinist beliefs āpredestination
what is Predestination?
Individuals could do nothing whatsoever to c____ this, whether through their d____, as the C____ believed (e.g. through p____, prayer or g____ to the Church),
G__ d___ is already made and cannot be altered.
what was the problem with predestination?
1. How does this belief have the spirit of capitalism?
how were people living with the belief of pre destination
This led to Calvinists looking for s____ from God that they were indeed among the e___
Predestination led Calvinists to work hard, be disciplined, and reinvest profits _ as evidence of what?
2. How did it bring social change?
These w____ habits spread through society, helping shift economies towards m____, r____, profit-focused capitalism.
Calvinist beliefs āpredestination
Predestination is the idea that it has already been decided who will go to heaven 'the elect' and who will go to hell and there is nothing you can do about this during your time on Earth.
Individuals could do nothing whatsoever to change this, whether through their deeds, as the Catholics believed (e.g. through pilgrimages, prayer or giving to the Church),
God's decision is already made and cannot be altered.
The problem with this belief is that it fails to perform many of the social cohesion functions that sociologists like Parsons suggested religion should perform, because it offers little comfort.
1. How does this belief have the spirit of capitalism?
People were leading pious, joyless lives without knowing if they were to receive any reward in heaven. This contributed to a sense of anxiety - salvation panic.
This led to Calvinists looking for signs from God that they were indeed among the elect (those who would go to heaven).
Predestination led Calvinists to work hard, be disciplined, and reinvest profits as signs they might be among the elect, matching the spirit of capitalism.
T believed that being able to work hard and succeed was a sign that God had already chosen them for heaven.
2. How did it bring social change?
These work habits spread through society, helping shift economies towards modern, rational, profit-focused capitalism.
Calvinist beliefs ā Divine transcendence
what does divine transcendence means/involve)
This left Calvinists to feel 'an u_____ i____ l_5555'. When combined with what belief?, this created what Weber calls a s____ p____
They could not know what?
1. How does this belief have the spirit of capitalism?
2. How did it bring social change?
Calvinist beliefs ā Divine transcendence
God was so far above and beyond this world and so incomparably greater than any mortal, that no human being could possibly claim to know his will (other than what he had chosen to reveal through the Bible).
This left Calvinists to feel 'an unprecedented inner loneliness'. When combined with the doctrine of predestination, this created what Weber calls a salvation panic
They could not know whether they had been chosen to be saved, and they could not do anything to earn their salvation.
1. How does this belief have the spirit of capitalism?
Divine transcendence created anxiety and a salvation panic, so Calvinists worked intensely as a way to seek reassurance of being among the elect.
2. How did it bring social change?
This mindset encouraged disciplined, organised, profit-focused work, which helped spread modern capitalist practices across society.
Calvinist beliefs ā Asceticism
What does asceticism mean?
how would an ascetic person be like?
For example, m____ lead an ascetic existence, refraining from l____, wearing s____ clothes and avoiding e____ in order to d____ themselves to G___ and a life of p___
1. How does asceticism have the spirit of capitalism?
2. How did it bring social change?
Calvinist beliefs ā Asceticism
This refers to abstinence, self-discipline and self-denial (denying yourself of desires of pleasures)
An ascetic person would save money instead of spending it on nice thing, avoid partying or extravagance focus on work, duty, and discipline
For example, monks lead an ascetic existence, refraining from luxury, wearing simple clothes and avoiding excess in order to devote themselves to God and a life of prayer
1. How does asceticism have the spirit of capitalism?
Because self-denial encouraged Calvinists to avoid luxury, save money, and reinvest profits instead of spending them.
2. How did it bring social change?
These disciplined habits spread through society and helped develop modern, profit-driven capitalism.
Calvinist beliefs ā The idea of a vocation or calling
Before Calvinism, the idea of a religious vocation (a c_____ to s__ God) meant r_____ o____ life to focus only on h___ and God and join a c____ or m___.-
Weber calls this other-worldly asceticism- what does this mean?
For example, living s____ from s____, not working in normal jobs and d____ life e___ to prayer
By contrast, Calvinism introduces for the first time this-worldly asceticism.- what ones this mean?
This means being d____ and s___-c____{ while staying in ordinary life.
For Calvinists:
what was your religious calling?
Working hard in e____ life = s___ G___
You stayed in s____ but lived a s___, d____ life
Calvinist beliefs ā The idea of a vocations or calling
Before Calvinism, the idea of a religious vocation (a calling to serve God) meant rejecting ordinary life to focus only on heaven and God and join a convent or monastery.-
Weber calls this other-worldly asceticism.
It is called āother-worldlyā because people left this world behind to be holy.
For example, living separately from society, not working in normal jobs and devoting life entirely to prayer
By contrast, Calvinism introduces for the first time this-worldly asceticism. It is called āthis-worldlyā because Calvinists believed you should serve God in this world, not escape from it.
This means being disciplined and self-controlled while staying in ordinary life.
For Calvinists:
Your job was your religious calling
Working hard in everyday life = serving God
You stayed in society but lived a strict, disciplined life
Calvinist beliefs ā The idea of a vocations or calling
The only thing Calvinists knew of God's plan for humanity came from the B____, which revealed what? .
Thus for Calvinists the idea of a calling or vocation meant c___, m_____ work in an o_____, not in a m____.
However, work could not earn s_____ - it was simply a r____ d____.
For this reason, the Calvinists led an a____ lifestyle shunning all l____, worked l____ h____ and p_____ r____ s____-d____.
āI____ is a s____ ā 'Lose no t_____; be always e____ in something u____' as the Calvinist B____ F____ put it
Calvinist beliefs ā The idea of a vocations or calling
The only thing Calvinists knew of God's plan for humanity came from the Bible, which revealed that we were put on the earth to glorify God's name by our work.
Thus for Calvinists the idea of a calling or vocation meant constant, methodical work in an occupation, not in a monastery.
However, work could not earn salvation - it was simply a religious duty.
For this reason, the Calvinists led an ascetic lifestyle shunning all luxury, worked long hours and practised rigorous self-discipline.
āIdleness is a sin ā 'Lose no time; be always employed in something useful' as the Calvinist Benjamin Franklin put it,
The Calvinists' hard work and asceticism had two consequences:
1.Firstly, their wealth and success performed a psychological function for the Calvinists - how?
As they grew w____, they took this as a sign of God's f________ and their s____ - for why else would we have p____, they asked themselves.
2.Secondly, because of their s___ w___ e_____, Calvinists carefully and rationally built up w____ by working e____ and r____ p____ instead of spending them on l____
By not permitting themselves to waste it on l____, they r____ it in their businesses, which g___ and p____, producing further p___ to reinvest and so on and on.
For Weber, this represents the spirit of modern capitalism, _ how?
Calvinism thus brought capitalism as we now know it into the world.
consequences:
1.Firstly, their wealth and success performed a psychological function for the Calvinists as it allowed them to cope with their salvation panic
As they grew wealthier, they took this as a sign of God's favour and their salvation - for why else would we have prospered, they asked themselves.
2.Secondly, because of their strong work ethic, Calvinists carefully and rationally built up wealth by working efficiently and reinvesting profits instead of spending them on luxury.
By not permitting themselves to waste it on luxuries, they reinvested it in their businesses, which grew and prospered, producing further profit to reinvest and so on and on.
For Weber, this represents the spirit of modern capitalism, in which the goal is the continual acquisition of more and more money, not for enjoyment or consumption, Instead, they make money for the sake of making more money.
Calvinism thus brought capitalism as we now know it into the world.
it is very important to note that Weber was not arguing that what? but simply what instead?
A number of m____ or e____. factors were necessary, such as n____ r____, t___, a m____ economy, t___ and c___, a system of l___ and so on.
it is very important to note that Weber was not arguing that Calvinist beliefs were the cause of modern capitalism, but simply that they were one of its causes.
A number of material or economic factors were necessary, such as natural resources, trade, a money economy, towns and cities, a system of law and so on.
Hinduism and Confucianism
On the other hand, Weber notes that there have been o____ s____ that have had a higher level of e____ d____ than N______ Ee____ (areas where Calvinism spread had) in the ___th and ___th centuries, but that still failed to develop what?
In particular, he argues that countries? were materially more a____ than Europe, but capitalism did not t___ o___ there
He argues that the this was due to the lack of a what? like that of Calvinism that would have spurred its development.
Calvinist beliefs combined what 2 things that supported the rise of modern capitalism?
Hinduism and Confucianism
On the other hand, Weber notes that there have been other societies that have had a higher level of economic development than Northern Europe (areas where Calvinism spread had) in the 16th and 17th centuries, but that still failed to develop modern capitalism.
In particular, he argues that ancient China and India were materially more advanced than Europe, but capitalism did not take off there
He argues that the this was due to the lack of a religious belief system like that of Calvinism that would have spurred its development.
Calvinist beliefs combined with existing economic and social conditions helped create the right mindset ā the Protestant work ethic ā that supported the rise of modern capitalism.
Hinduism and Confucianism
Thus in ancient India, H____ was an ascetic religion, like Calvinism, favouring renunciation of what?
However, its orientation was other-worldly - what does this?
In ancient China, C________ also discouraged the growth of rational capitalism, but for different reasons.
Like Calvinism, Confucianism was a t___-w____ religion that directed its followers towards the m_____ w____ but, unlike Calvinism, it was not a_____.
Both Hinduism and Confucianism thus l____ the d____ to systematically a____ w___ that is necessary for modern capitalism
. In Weber's view, Calvinism was unique - how?
Hinduism and Confucianism
Thus in ancient India, Hinduism was an ascetic religion, like Calvinism, favouring renunciation of the material world
However, its orientation was other-worldly - it directed its followers' concerns away from the material world and towards the spiritual world.
In ancient China, Confucianism also discouraged the growth of rational capitalism, but for different reasons.
Like Calvinism, Confucianism was a this-worldly religion that directed its followers towards the material world but, unlike Calvinism, it was not ascetic.
Both Hinduism and Confucianism thus lacked the drive to systematically accumulate wealth that is necessary for modern capitalism
. In Weber's view, Calvinism was unique in combining asceticism with a this-worldly orientation to enable the spirit of modern capitalism to emerge.
Evaluation - āstrengths
ā- Weber offers a more complex explanation than Marx, how?
Marx saw economic or material factors as the d___ f___ of c______, whereas Weber argues that material factors alone are not e___ to bring about capitalism.
As we have just seen, in Weber's view, it also needed specific c___ f___ - the b_____ and v_______ of Calvinism - to bring it into being.
This makes his theory more n____ and r_____ than a purely e_____ e____.
Evaluation - āstrengths
ā- Weber offers a more complex explanation than Marx, recognising that both economic factors and cultural/religious beliefs were important in the rise of modern capitalism.
Marx saw economic or material factors as the driving force of change, whereas Weber argues that material factors alone are not enough to bring about capitalism.
As we have just seen, in Weber's view, it also needed specific cultural factors - the beliefs and values of Calvinism - to bring it into being.
This makes his theory more nuanced and realistic than a purely economic explanation.
Evaluation - ālimitations
Marxists have responded with their own criticisms of Weber.
ā- For example K____ (1927) argues that Weber overestimates the role of what? and underestimates what?
He argues that in fact capitalism p_____ rather than f____ Calvinism.
ā- Similarly, ___.___. T___ (1926) argues that t____ c____, not r___ ideas, caused the birth of capitalism.
It was only after capitalism was established that the b____ adopted c____ b____ to l_____ their pursuit of economic gain.
Evaluation - ālimitations
Marxists have responded with their own criticisms of Weber.
ā- For example Kautsky (1927) argues that Weber overestimates the role of devotional religion and underestimates economic factors in bringing capitalism into being.
He argues that in fact capitalism preceded rather than followed Calvinism.
ā- Similarly, R.H. Tawney (1926) argues that technological change, not religious ideas, caused the birth of capitalism.
It was only after capitalism was established that the bourgeoisie adopted Calvinist beliefs to legitimate their pursuit of economic gain.
Evaluation - ālimitations
ā- Weber has also been criticised because capitalism did not d___ in every c____ where there were Calvinists.
For example, S_____ had a large C___ population but was slow to do what?
However, Weberians such as M____ (1982) argue that this was because of a lack what? - āsupporting Weber's point that both m____ and c____ factors need to be present for capitalism to emerge.
Evaluation - ālimitations
ā-Weber has also been criticised because capitalism did not develop in every country where there were Calvinists.
For example, Scotland had a large Calvinist population but was slow to develop capitalism.
However, Weberians such as Marshall (1982) argue that this was because of a lack of investment capital and skilled labour - āsupporting Weber's point that both material and cultural factors need to be present for capitalism to emerge.