1/25
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Argersinger v. Hamlin
Background: Charged with carrying concealed weapon-Misdemeanor in Florida and convicted-Sentenced for 90 days
Est: Anyone who committed a crime that has the possibility of incarceration has the right to appointed counsel. (extended Gideon (felonies)) to misdemeanors that cause sentencing.
Atkins v. Virginia (1974)
Background: Convicted for numerous charges such as capital murder. Witness forensic psychologist deemed defendant as mildly mentally disable. Jury sentenced him to death
Est: Violated the 8th and 14th amendment
Can’t give death penalty to someone who is intellectually challenged
Atwater v. City of Lago Vista
Background: She was driving her car and had children not safely secured in the car. This was a violation due to children and driver safety, and she was arrested for the misdemeanor. She sued as it was violation of her 4th amendment
Est. Warrantless arrest for a minor offense can be made if the officer has probable cause. Her arrest was legal.
Ballew v. Georgia
Background: Committed a misdemeanor for showing obscene motion picture film and was put Infront of only 5 jurors
Est: It is a violation of the 6th and 14th amendment that there are less than 6 jurors. (violation of person right to a fair trial)
Betts v. Brady
Est: State is not required to provide attorney, only provides attorney if charges are complex
Coker v. Georgia (1977)
Background: Escaped prison and broke into couple home and raped a woman and stole car. Sentence to death on rape charge
Est: Cannot sentence someone to death for just rape it is a violation of the 8th amendment (cruel and unusual punishment)
Duncan v. Louisiana
Est: Do not have a right to a jury trial if it's a petty offense (6 month or less of imprisonment)
Escobedo v. Illinois
Background: Danny was arrested and forced to confess to murder after police kept denying him to get his lawyer and continued interrogation.
Est: His rights were not upheld at the 6th amendment hence his confession was unconstitutional under the 5th amendment. (self-incrimination) Moved from a 6th amendment violation to a 5th amendment violation.
Person needs to be informed of his right that they have the absolute right to remain silent.
Furman v. Georgia (1972)
Background: Committed burglary and when caught, tried to flee when he “tripped and fell” and shot the resident. Convicted of murder and sentenced to death.
Est: Made death sentence unconstitutional as it was arbitrary (inconsistent) and had a racial biased towards African Americans
Gideon v. Wainwright
Backstory: He committed a Florida felony by breaking into poolroom. He couldn't afford an attorney and asked the court when he was convicted and went to appeal
Established: Right to an attorney if convicted with a felony charge and can’t afford attorney
Graham v. Florida
Background: 16-year-old convicted for armed burglary and attempted armed robbery and after first sentence when released does it again
Second time convicted for life in imprisonment without parole and appealed on basis of 8th amendment (cruel and unusua punishment)
Est. Crime must be murder to be punished with life in imprisonment without parole
Gregg v. Georgia
Background: Convicted for armed robbery and murder and sentenced to death. Argued that he shouldn't be sentenced to death as it goes against his 8th amendment.
Est: Bifurcated Trial (Two Stage Procedural requirement that ended arbitrariness)
Stage 1: Trial (Guilt or innocence)
Stage 2: Sentencing (Which sentence to give)
In re Winship
Background: Age 12, breaking into women locker and stealing $112 from her purse. (larceny-felony if done by adult)
Est: Rather then using the preponderance of the evidence rule “proof of evidence” The reasonable-doubt standard must be applied to both juveniles and adults alike.
Johnson v. Zerbst:
Est: Poor defendants must be appointed by a lawyer at trial in federal court.
Lockhart v. McCree
Background: Shop gets robbed and person gets killed look alike of the getaway car is caught, person claims that person took my rifle from the backseat and shot the shop owner.
During Voir Dire juror that said that they would not convict someone of the death penalty were removed
Est: Excluding people who are unwilling to impose death penalty is not a violation of the defendant's 6th and 14th amendment
State is allowed in their discretion to have juror who can impartially and properly apply the law (fair trial is protected)
Maryland v. Wilson
Background: Wilson was asked to step out the vehicle (he was very nervous) in which he was arrested because cocaine fell out of his pocket. Challenged that if he was not forced to step out of his car the drugs would have not been found.
Est: Ruled that if speeding vehicle is being stopped that it is allowed for a police officer to ask the driver to step out the car for their safety.
Michigan v. Long
Background: Was convicted for possession of pot in his passenger and trunk of his car. (police was searching for his car originally due to a suspicion of weapons)
Est: State of Michigan said that arrest of illegal but then in federal court stating
Road stops can be dangerous, hence for the police safety they can search for the compartment of a car where a weapon can be stored. (They are only allowed to search the passenger side of the car)
New York v. Quarles
Background: Police had description of guy who attacked and raped a women and was frisked after they found him in the supermarket. Found empty gun holster which he confessed he left in the supermarket in the egg carton. Arrested then read Miranda rights.
Question: Is it okay to delay Miranda rights for the public safety?
Est: Allowed to delay Miranda right if its a public safety issue (Public Safety exception) (gun was in the supermarket hence anyone could have grabbed it)
N.C. v. Alford
Background: Accused of first-degree crime and evidence showed guilt. Hence, attorney suggests he plea to a lesser deal hence second-degree murder. He took the stand and said he did not commit the crime and only pleading to a lesser charge because first degree will lead to death penalty.
Est: Alford plea
Allowed to plea guilty while saying you are innocent, defendant intelligently concludes that their interest require a guilty plea
Payne v. Tenn.
Background: Convicted by jury on two counts of first-degree murder and one count of assault with intent to commit murder in first degree.
Mother was given opportunity to testify, and her lawyer emphasizes her emotional speech she gave to the jury
Prosecuted closed argument with “victim impact evidence” (mom sob story) and he was sentence
Est: Victim impact statements can be used as evidence that can be considered in jury decisions.
Powell v. Alabama
Backstory: Scottsboro boys (9 boys) convicted of rape of two white women. Both women had alleged the rape and there was no proof. Boys had no fair representation, hence ate the fault.
Established: Right to counsel in capital cases (death penalty)
Roper v. Simmons
Background: Was sentenced to death at 17
Est: Used international opinion and deemed that execution of minors was unconstitutional in ALL circumstances
Strickland v. Washington
Background: Shooting spree and killed three people. Lawyer presented no character witness nor psychiatrist/medical documents that might prove otherwise. Was sentenced to death
Est: That counsel should be effected!
Two Prong test
1. Threshold Reasonableness (was counsel effective)
2. Would have the results of the trial change.
Welsh v. Wisconsin
Background: Welsh one night swerving car in field and then went home. Police come to his house with no warrant and arrested him for drunk Driving (Did refuse the breathalyzer to the station as police assumed he was drunk driving)
Est: Arrest is unconstitutional and does not fall under exigent-circumstances -exception (allow warrantless arrest for dangerous and emergency circumstances)
He was already home and did not pose a threat to anyone.
Williams v. Florida
Est: Jury only has to have enough jurors to have a fair trial. (don't need 12 jurors, 6 can also work)
Wong Sun v. U.S
Background: Arrested for heroin possession and which he blamed “blackie toy” sold it to him which then he blamed James Wah Toy and then later when toy tried to flee from his laundromat. After which he blamed Johnny who blamed Wong Sun that he was the dealer (all three men were arrested)
Est: All were unlawful arrest and that the time between the illegal arrest (first man) and getting heroin from the second man was too close to find the heroine.
Unlawful arrest led to unlawful evidence
Objected the use of “fruits” of unlawful arrests.
“Under the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine, evidence that is derived from inadmissible evidence is likewise inadmissible”