1/52
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is Nagel's overall philosophical project?
To understand how the subjective, first-person perspective can be reconciled with the objective, third-person perspective.
What are the two fundamentally different points of view Nagel focuses on?
The subjective first-person perspective and the objective third-person perspective.
What is Nagel's main claim about consciousness?
Conscious experience has a subjective character that current physicalist and reductionist theories fail to fully explain.
What does Nagel mean by the "subjective character of experience"?
The fact that there is something it is like for an organism to have an experience.
(Nagel) What does it mean to ask "What is it like to be a bat?"
It asks what the bat's own conscious experience is like from the bat's point of view.
(Nagel) Why does Nagel use a bat as his example?
Bats are conscious but experience the world through echolocation, a sensory system very different from ours.
(Nagel) Why can't we fully imagine what it is like to be a bat?
Our imagination is limited to our own human experiences and cannot reproduce the bat's subjective point of view.
(Nagel) What is echolocation?
A bat's way of perceiving its surroundings by producing sounds and detecting their echoes.
(Nagel) What does the bat example show about subjective experience?
Knowing an organism's physical structure and behavior does not necessarily tell us what its experience feels like.
(Nagel) What is the difference between knowing how a bat behaves and knowing what it is like to be a bat?
Behavior describes what the bat does objectively; experience concerns what the bat feels subjectively.
(Nagel) What is reductionism in the mind-body problem?
The attempt to explain mental phenomena completely in terms of physical or non-mental phenomena.
Why does Nagel think the usual examples of scientific reduction do not solve the mind-body problem?
Conscious experience has a subjective point of view that ordinary physical reductions leave out.
(Nagel) What is physicalism?
The view that mental states and events are ultimately physical states and events.
Does Nagel argue that physicalism is definitely false?
No. He says physicalism may be true, but we currently do not understand how it could be true.
Why does Nagel think current physicalist theories are incomplete?
They explain physical processes, behavior, or functions but fail to explain the subjective character of conscious experience.
(Nagel) What is the problem with explaining consciousness only through behavior or functional states?
Something could behave like a conscious person without actually having conscious experience.
(Nagel) What is the difference between subjective and objective facts?
Subjective facts depend on a particular point of view, while objective facts can be understood from multiple points of view.
(Nagel) Why is consciousness different from something like lightning?
Lightning can be described objectively without including how it appears to a particular observer, but conscious experience is tied directly to the experiencer's point of view.
What does Nagel mean by an "objective phenomenology"?
A possible new method for describing subjective experiences objectively without relying entirely on imagination or empathy.
(Nagel) What is the main takeaway from "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?"
Conscious experience has a subjective character that cannot currently be fully captured by an objective physical description.
(Haji) What is incompatibilism?
The view that determinism is incompatible with free will and moral responsibility.
(Haji) What is determinism?
The view that events, including human actions, are determined by the past and the laws of nature.
(Haji) What is libertarianism in the free will debate?
The view that determinism is incompatible with free will, but humans sometimes act freely and are morally responsible.
Who is Ishtiyaque Haji?
A professor of philosophy at the University of Calgary who studies free will and moral responsibility.
(Haji) Why does Robert Harris's case raise questions about moral responsibility?
Harris committed terrible crimes, but his history of severe childhood abuse raises questions about how responsible he was for becoming the person he became.
(Haji) What does the Ann/Beth case demonstrate?
It shows how manipulating someone's desires and values may undermine their freedom and moral responsibility.
(Haji) How are Beth's desires changed in the Ann/Beth case?
Scientists implant Ann's values into Beth, making Beth more dedicated to her work.
(Haji) Why might Beth not be morally responsible for actions caused by her implanted desires?
Because she did not choose those desires, and they were forced upon her through manipulation.
(Haji) What is the Principle of Alternative Possibilities (PAP)?
The idea that a person is morally responsible for an action only if they could have done otherwise.
(Haji) What is the Lack of Freedom Argument?
The argument that if a person's actions are caused by irresistible desires and they cannot do otherwise, they are not acting freely or morally responsible.
(Haji) What is the Consequence Argument?
If determinism is true, our actions follow from the distant past and the laws of nature, which are beyond our control. Therefore, our actions are not ultimately up to us.
(Haji) What is the Direct Argument?
The argument that because we are not responsible for the distant past or the laws of nature, we are not responsible for the actions those things determine.
(Haji) What does the Deontic Argument claim?
If determinism means we cannot avoid our actions, then we cannot be morally blameworthy for them because we could not have done otherwise.
(Haji) What is the Manipulation Argument?
The argument that if manipulation can remove moral responsibility, then actions determined by the past and the laws of nature may also remove moral responsibility.
(Haji) What is the Impossibility Argument?
The argument that we cannot be responsible for our actions because being responsible would require being responsible for an infinite chain of earlier choices that shaped us.
(Haji) What is the difference between compatibilism and incompatibilism?
Compatibilism says free will and moral responsibility can exist even if determinism is true. Incompatibilism says they cannot both be true.
(Haji) Why does Haji discuss manipulation and childhood abuse?
To show how a person's background and experiences may influence their actions and raise questions about whether they are fully responsible for them.
(Haji) Suppose someone commits an action because a scientist implanted an irresistible desire in them. According to the Manipulation Argument, should they be held morally responsible?
No. The argument suggests that manipulation can undermine moral responsibility because the person is not the ultimate source of their action.
(Haji) According to the libertarian view described in the reading, why must people have the ability to do otherwise?
Because genuine free will requires having alternative choices available, even when the past and the laws of nature remain the same.
(Haji) What position does Haji ultimately favor?
Semicompatibilism, the view that determinism may prevent us from having the freedom to do otherwise but does not necessarily eliminate moral responsibility.
What would it take to explain consciousness?
Explaining what an organism experiences from its own point of view.
According to Nagel, what makes an organism conscious?
An organism is conscious if there is something it is like to be that organism.
What can we know about a bat's echolocation, and what does Nagel say this still does not tell us?
We know bats use sound waves and echoes to detect objects, but this does not tell us what it feels like to be a bat.
Why doesn't imagining yourself behaving like a bat answer Nagel's question?
Because imagining yourself acting like a bat does not tell you what a bat experiences from its own point of view.
What does the caterpillar/butterfly example show about evidence and understanding?
It shows that we can have evidence that something is true without understanding how it happens.
How does Nagel think physicalism might put us in a similar position?
We might have reason to believe consciousness is physical without understanding how physical processes produce conscious experiences.
What would a satisfactory physical explanation of consciousness still need to explain?
It would need to explain how physical processes in the brain produce subjective experiences, or what it feels like to be an organism.
Why might determinism threaten moral responsibility?
Determinism might threaten moral responsibility because our actions are determined by the past and the laws of nature, which are beyond our control.
Explain the Lack of Freedom Argument in your own words. What role does Beth's inability to do otherwise play in the argument?
The Lack of Freedom Argument says that if someone cannot do otherwise, they are not acting freely or morally responsible. Beth cannot resist her implanted desires, so she cannot do otherwise, meaning she is not morally responsible for her actions.
According to Haji, what does determinism make ordinary agents share with Beth? Explain.
Both have actions caused by things they cannot control. Beth's desires are implanted, while our actions may be determined by the past and the laws of nature.
Explain the Manipulation Argument in your own words. What similarity between manipulated Beth and a person in a deterministic world does Haji think matters for responsibility?
Both Beth and people in a deterministic world may not be the ultimate source of their actions because their actions are caused by factors beyond their control.
What important difference between deliberate manipulation and an ordinary causal history in a deterministic world could someone point to? Why might that difference matter for responsibility?
Beth's desires are deliberately implanted by scientists, while ordinary people develop their desires through life experiences. This difference might matter because ordinary people can reflect on their desires and make choices based on them.
How do the two arguments give different reasons for thinking determinism threatens moral responsibility? What questions could someone raise about each argument?
The Lack of Freedom Argument says we are not responsible if we cannot do otherwise. The Manipulation Argument says we are not responsible if our actions are caused by things beyond our control. Someone could question whether we must be able to do otherwise to be responsible or whether caused actions can still be our responsibility.