Chapter 5: Public Order Law

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/55

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

56 Terms

1
New cards

What is the basic approach of English law to processions and meetings?

They are prima facie lawful unless they amount to crimes or torts.

2
New cards

How were rights historically protected in the UK, and how did the HRA 1998 change this?

Historically by residual (negative) freedom: people may do anything the law does not prohibit. The HRA 1998 gave positive protection of Convention rights.

3
New cards

Which ECHR Articles matter most for public order?

Art 10 (freedom of expression) and Art 11 (freedom of peaceful assembly and association).

4
New cards

When can the state restrict freedom of assembly under Art 11?

If the restriction is prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society for national security or public safety, prevention of disorder or crime, protection of health or morals, or protection of the rights and freedoms of others.

5
New cards

Why might a march that stops to hold a meeting commit an offence?

It may wilfully obstruct the highway (s 137 Highways Act 1980) unless there is lawful excuse. Courts consider reasonableness and Arts 10 and 11.

6
New cards

What prompted the Public Order Act 1986?

The 1981 inner-city riots and the 1984-85 miners' strike: a perceived need to give the police greater powers and clarify the law.

7
New cards

What does s 11 POA 1986 require?

Organisers of a public procession for a s 11(1) purpose must give the police at least six clear days' notice of the date, time and route.

8
New cards

What are the three purposes in s 11(1) POA 1986?

(a) To demonstrate support for or opposition to the views or actions of any person or body; (b) to publicise a cause or campaign; (c) to mark or commemorate an event.

9
New cards

Where must s 11 notice be delivered?

To a police station in the police area where the procession will start (s 11(4)).

10
New cards

How does s 16 POA 1986 define public procession and public place?

A public procession is a procession in a public place. A public place is any highway or other place the public may lawfully access, on payment or otherwise (so theatres and football grounds count).

11
New cards

Give two examples of processions outside the s 11 notice requirement.

Football supporters on their way to a match; schoolchildren led from school to a local library (no s 11(1) purpose).

12
New cards

Which processions are exempt from the notice requirement?

Funeral processions; customary or commonly held processions in the police area (s 11(2)); and where it is not reasonably practicable to give notice (e.g. an impromptu reaction to news).

13
New cards

What was decided in Kay v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2008]?

Critical Mass monthly cycle rides were 'commonly or customarily' held even though the route varied, so they were exempt from notice.

14
New cards

What are the two offences under s 11(7) POA 1986?

(a) Failing to give the required notice; (b) the procession differing from the notice (date, time or route).

15
New cards

What are the defences to the s 11 offences?

First offence: organiser did not know and had no reason to suspect s 11 had not been complied with (s 11(8)). Second: departure was beyond the organiser's control or was agreed or directed by police (s 11(9)). Burden on D, balance of probabilities.

16
New cards

What is the maximum penalty for the s 11 offences?

A fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale (currently £1,000).

17
New cards

If organisers fail to give notice, is the procession unlawful and are participants guilty of an offence?

No. Only the organisers commit an offence. The procession remains lawful and participants commit no offence.

18
New cards

What must a senior police officer reasonably believe before imposing conditions on a procession (s 12(1))?

That it will result in serious public disorder, serious damage to property or serious disruption to the life of the community, or that the organisers' purpose is to intimidate others to compel them not to do something they have a right to do (or to do something they have a right not to do).

19
New cards

What did s 73 PCSCA 2022 add to s 12?

Conditions may be imposed where noise may have a significant impact on those in the vicinity, or may cause serious disruption to the activities of an organisation.

20
New cards

What did Police v Reid decide about intimidation?

Intimidation is more than nuisance or discomfort and needs an intention to compel. The Chief Inspector applied the wrong test (equating intimidation with discomfort), so the condition was ultra vires.

21
New cards

What did R (Liberty) v SSHD [2025] EWCA Civ 571 decide?

The 2023 Regulations were ultra vires: 'more than minor' disruption is not within the ordinary meaning of 'serious'. Police may impose conditions only if they reasonably believe serious disruption could result.

22
New cards

What other changes did the 2023 Regulations make to ss 12 and 14?

Police must consider all relevant disruption (including normal traffic congestion) and the cumulative impact of repeated processions or assemblies; 'community' means any group of persons affected, not only those living or working nearby.

23
New cards

Who can impose s 12 conditions, and in what form?

During the procession: the most senior officer at the scene, verbally if necessary (s 12(2)(a)). In advance: the chief officer of police, in writing with sufficient reasons (s 12(2)(b)).

24
New cards

Why must the chief officer give sufficient reasons for advance conditions (R (Brehony))?

So demonstrators can understand why the conditions were imposed and a court can assess whether the belief in serious disruption etc was reasonable.

25
New cards

What constraint applies to all conditions imposed on protests?

They must be necessary and proportionate, having regard to Art 11 ECHR.

26
New cards

What are the offences and maximum penalties under s 12 POA 1986?

s 12(4) organiser failing to comply (knows or ought to know): 51 weeks or level 4 fine (£2,500) or both. s 12(5) participant failing to comply: level 3 fine (£1,000). s 12(6) inciting a participant to commit the s 12(5) offence: 51 weeks or level 4 fine.

27
New cards

What defences exist to s 12 offences?

Failure to comply was beyond the person's control (e.g. organiser too ill; participant swept along by the crowd), or the condition was invalid (as in Police v Reid). Burden on D on the balance of probabilities.

28
New cards

What did Re Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) (NI) Bill [2022] UKSC 32 say about proportionality and s 12 convictions?

For certain protest offences the ingredients of the offence strike the proportionality balance, so if the condition was lawful the court need not check that conviction is proportionate on the facts (applied by analogy to s 12).

29
New cards

When can a procession be banned under s 13 POA 1986?

When the chief officer of police reasonably believes that, because of particular circumstances in a locality, s 12 powers are insufficient to prevent serious public disorder.

30
New cards

Who makes a s 13 ban outside London, and who inside London?

Outside London: the chief officer applies to the local authority, which makes the order with the Home Secretary's consent. In London: the Commissioner of the Met or City of London Police makes the order, with the Home Secretary's consent (s 13(4)).

31
New cards

What are the limits on a s 13 prohibition order?

Maximum three months; must be in writing; can ban all processions or a class of procession (e.g. political marches) but not a specific individual procession.

32
New cards

What happened in Kent v Metropolitan Police Commissioner (1981)?

CND challenged a 28-day ban on all processions in the metropolitan district. The CA upheld it: courts are reluctant to quash operational decisions, and CND should have applied for a relaxation under s 13(5).

33
New cards

What are the s 13 offences and penalties?

s 13(7) organising a prohibited procession knowingly: up to three months or level 4 fine or both. s 13(8) taking part knowingly: level 3 fine. s 13(9) inciting: up to three months or level 4 fine.

34
New cards

What are the criteria for conditions on assemblies under s 14, and is advance notice required?

The same criteria as s 12 (including the 2022 noise and disruption provisions). No advance notice of an assembly is required.

35
New cards

How does s 16 POA 1986 define a public assembly?

Two or more persons in a public place that is wholly or partly open to the air (reduced from 20 by the Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003). The purpose of the assembly is irrelevant.

36
New cards

Can police ban a public assembly under s 14?

No, but they can impose conditions, including a limit on duration (which must be proportionate), so they can in effect order dispersal.

37
New cards

What does s 14ZA POA 1986 cover?

Directions to one-person protests where the noise may have a significant impact on those nearby or cause serious disruption to the activities of an organisation (PCSCA 2022 s 79).

38
New cards

What are the s 14 offences and penalties?

s 14(4) organiser failing to comply: 51 weeks or level 4 fine or both. s 14(5) participant: level 3 fine. s 14(6) inciting: 51 weeks or level 4 fine. Defences: beyond control, or invalid conditions.

39
New cards

What did R (Brehony) v Chief Constable of Greater Manchester [2005] decide?

A s 14 notice moving a weekly M&S demonstration to the Peace Gardens over the Christmas shopping period was lawful and proportionate: limited and temporary, and no less intrusive means could prevent serious disruption.

40
New cards

When is permission needed to hold a meeting?

Generally none is needed, but byelaws or local Acts may require it (e.g. Trafalgar Square: GLA; Royal Parks: Royal Parks Regulations 1997). A meeting on private land needs the owner's permission.

41
New cards

What is a trespassory assembly under s 14A POA 1986?

An assembly of 20 or more persons in open-air land to which the public has no right of access or only a limited right, held without the occupier's permission or outside its terms.

42
New cards

What must the chief officer reasonably believe to seek a s 14A ban?

That the assembly is intended to be held without permission (or beyond it) and may result in serious disruption to the life of the community or significant damage to land, a building or a monument of historical, archaeological or scientific importance.

43
New cards

What are the limits and procedure for a s 14A prohibition order?

Maximum four days; area no greater than a circle of five miles' radius from a specified centre; local authority applies with Home Secretary's consent (London: Commissioner with Secretary of State's consent).

44
New cards

How does s 14A differ from s 14 on size and land?

s 14: two or more people, land wholly or partly in the open air, any public place. s 14A: 20 or more people, land entirely in the open air, public has no or limited right of access (so not common land with unlimited access).

45
New cards

What are the s 14B offences and penalties?

Organising a prohibited assembly (up to three months or level 4 fine), taking part knowing it is prohibited (level 3 fine), inciting (up to three months or level 4 fine).

46
New cards

What did DPP v Jones [1999] UKHL 5 decide?

By 3-2, the public may use a highway for any reasonable purpose that is not a nuisance or an unreasonable obstruction. A peaceful, non-obstructive demonstration of 21 near Stonehenge was not trespassory, so no s 14B offence.

47
New cards

What power does s 14C POA 1986 give?

A uniformed constable who reasonably believes a person is on the way to a trespassory assembly may stop them and direct them not to proceed. Ignoring the direction is an offence (level 3 fine).

48
New cards

How did R v Howell define breach of the peace?

Whenever harm is actually done or likely to be done to a person or, in their presence, their property, or a person is in fear of being so harmed, through an assault, affray, riot, unlawful assembly or other disturbance.

49
New cards

Is breach of the peace an offence, and what powers does it trigger?

It is not an offence, but it triggers common law powers: arrest (to prevent or after a breach), requiring people to move on, dispersing gatherings, and entry without a warrant (PACE s 17(6)).

50
New cards

What was decided in Duncan v Jones [1936]?

No breach occurred, but the officer reasonably apprehended one from a street meeting, so he was acting in execution of his duty and the speaker's conviction for obstruction was upheld.

51
New cards

What was decided in Moss v McLachlin [1985]?

Police lawfully stopped a convoy of striking miners miles from working collieries because a breach of the peace was real and immediate, not remote, in close proximity in place and time.

52
New cards

What did R (Laporte) v Chief Constable of Gloucestershire [2006] decide?

Police powers to prevent a breach of the peace (including those short of arrest, e.g. dispersal) need an imminent breach. Turning coaches back was premature, indiscriminate and disproportionate.

53
New cards

What did Austin v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2009] decide?

Kettling at Oxford Circus did not breach Art 5: crowd control to prevent a breach of the peace is lawful if in good faith, proportionate and no longer than reasonably necessary. The ECtHR agreed.

54
New cards

Sample scenario: a spontaneous march (no 6 days' notice) responds to a prison announcement made two days earlier. Is a participant guilty?

No. Notice was not reasonably practicable, so no organiser offence; and in any event the procession remains lawful and participants commit no offence.

55
New cards

Sample scenario: 100 peaceful protesters outside a town hall at 5pm; the inspector orders dispersal because workers will be leaving. Is the order lawful?

No. There is no reasonable belief of intimidatory purpose or serious disruption (s 14), and no apprehended breach of the peace (no violence).

56
New cards

Sample scenario: protesters with the farmer's permission to be on land put up tents, contrary to his terms, within a s 14A prohibited area. Guilty?

Yes. Once they exceeded the limits of the permission the assembly became trespassory.