1/192
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Intersectionality
Being at the instersection of gender and race
Example: WOC, trans individuals
Recurring themes in study of racially minoritized groups: similarities & differences
Similarities: objetification and sexism, true for all women regardless of race
Differences: different media representations and stereotypes, black women represented as poor and latina women represented as “exotic”
Recurring themes in study of racially minoritized groups: simultaneous oppression and strength
Intersectionality focused on power
Members of these groups should not be seen as victims, neglects their resilience/strength
Race
Biological concept
Group with common physical features (skin color, hair color/texture)
African American women with black skin color can have 50% of European ancestors
Ethnic Group
Group sharing common culture and language
Example: Hispanics are an ethnic group not a race
Hispanic or Latino (ethnicity)
A person of Cuban, Mexican, Puerto Rican, South/Central American or other Spanish culture/origin regardless of race
White (race)
A person having origins in any of the original peoples of Europe, Middle East, or North Africa
Black/African American (race)
A person having origins in any of the Black racial groups of Africa
American indian/Alaska Native (race)
A person having origins in any of the original peoples of North/South America (including Central Americai) and who maintains tribal affiliation or community attachment
Asian (race)
A person having origins in any of the original peoples of the Far East, Southeast Asia, or Indian subcontinent
Example: Cambodia, China, India, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Pakistan, Philippine Islands, Thailand, Vietnam
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander (race)
A person having origins in any of the original peoples of Hawaii, Guam, Samoa, or other Pacific Islands
Hispanic
Pan-ethnic term that refers to ALL people with ties to Spain, regardless of race (Puetro Rico, Cuba, Mexico, Central America, South America)
Centers colonizers and erases indigeneous heritage
Introduced by US government in 1970s as a question separate from race
Latino/a: specific to Latin America (including Brazil, not hispanic)
African American
1960s: Black Power movement used "black” to show pride in qualities causing discrimination
Late 1980s: pride in African heritage motivated “African American” and ignores residents who have Caribbean roots (Jamaica, Trinidad, Haiti)
Native American or American Indian
Refers to Indigeneous Peoples of the US
Census: American Indian/Alaska Native, Native Hawaiians and other Pacific Islanders
Most Indigenous people prefer to be described using their specific tribal affiliation/nation
Asian American
Americans of Asian origin
Replaces older terms that are now considered disrepsectful (e.g orientals)
Asia is enormous/diverse continent: South Asia, Southeast Asia, East Asia
European American
Terms white/caucasian are problematic because meanings have changed overtime to preserve privilege of certain groups
People of origins in Middle East and North Africa (MENA) are categorized as white but don’t identify as white and aren’t perceived as others as white
MENA slated to be separate category in 2030 census
Subcultural variations
Within each category there’s different groups/experiences
Asian: Chinese, Japanese, South Asian
Latine: born and raised here vs 1st gen immigrants (true for all groups)
Specific experiences (e.g wars)
What are some criticisms of psychological research with respect to inclusivtiy?
White samples as acceptable methodology: causes overgeneralization to gender, racial/ethinic, age groups
Bias in observation: observers show in-group favortisim when observing mother-child interactions
Guilty of: androcentrism, ethnocentrism, eurocentrism
Ethnocentrism
Believing that your own ethnic background is the norm
Eurocentrism
Evaluating the world from a Euro-American POV
Guidelines for Research
Be mindful of diversity and inclusive in collaboration: insiders persepective necessary
Conduct research that’s culturally informed: use valid/reliable measures designed for unique experiences
Be mindful of intersectionality/subcultural variations
Avoid deficit interpretations, take strength-based approaches
Keep social/historical context in mind: differences don’t automatically stem from ehtnicity
Racial Microaggressions
Subtle conscious or nonscious insults directed at people of color
Micro refers to level at which it occurs, not magnitude
Related to poorer psychological well-being and worse ohysical health
Addressing microaggresions is challenging: easy to be accused of exaggerating or misreading situations
Acculturation
Process of psychological/behavioral change one undergoes as result of long-term contact with another culture
Largest ethnic minority in the US: Hispanics
Latina culture based on Mexican/Latin American/etc heritage is modified through acculturation to incorporate Euro-American components
Bilingualism (latina: cultural heritage)
Speaking 2 languages
Spanglish common
Familismo (Latina: Cultural Heritage)
A sense of obligation to and connectedness with both one’s immediate and extended family
Evidence shows that familismo protects adolescents psychological well-being
Latina: Stereotypes
Fiery latina
Virgin/madonna
African American: Cultural Heritage
Subcultural variations: brought involuntarily as slaves, voluntary immigrants from Caribbean/Africa
Historical trauma: cumulative psychological wounding over generations resulting from massive group trama (e.g experience of slavery/oppression)
Emphasizes the collective over the individual and harmonious relationships with others
African American: Stereotypes
Mammy: nuturing, self-sacrificing, asexual. During civil rights, it was promoted that woc prefer to do this that’s why they work as help
Jezebel: seductive, promiscuous. Justifies rape of black women, less likely to say assailitant of rape should be prosecuted
Asian American: Cultural Heritage
Arrived in US at various timepoints for various reasons
Chinese (men): to work on railroads and then later Japanese, korean, and Filipino (men) later
Refugees from Southeast Asia during 1960s-1970s
Today, migrants from India are fastest growing Asian ethnic group
Asian American: Examples of Racial Discrimination throughout History
Japanese during WW2
Stereotypes leading to lynchings (e.g Chinese Massacre)
Exclusionary immigration policy
Discrimination during Covid
Discrimination by employment status (H1B)
Asian American: 5 Core Values
Collectivism: others needs should be considered first before own
Conformity to norms: individual should conform to expectations of family/society
Emotional control: emotions should not be openly expressed
Family recognition through achievement: educational failure brings shame to family and educational success brings honor
Humility: be humble and never boastful
Asian American: Stereotypes
China doll: subservient, eager to please, innocent
Sexless worker bee: working as domestics or garment workers
Dragon lady: seductive, powerful, evil
Native American: Cultural Heritage
Historical trauma: forced acculturation, christianization, economic changes
Colonization, killing, and reservations
20th century sterilization of women and abduction of children
Spirit World: women are seen as extension of Spirit Mother, harmonious relationship with the Earth
Native American: Stereotypes
Princess: beautiful, proud, brave
Squaw: meek, powerless
Stereotypes of WOC
Good women: china doll, virgin/madonna, mammy, princess
Bad women: dragon lady, fiery latina, jezebel, squaw
Reflect sexy vs submissive women
Latine Gender Roles: Machismo
The ideal of manliness
Male is the provider, responsible for family
Treated with authority
Latine Gender Roles: Marianismo
The ideal of womanliness
Women are humble, obedient, spiritually superior
Older women highly regarded
Healing role assigned to women, power and status
African American Gender Roles
Multiple gender roles: mother, worker, head of household, wife
Strong black woman schema
More employed black women than black men
Older women have purposeful and respected role
Importance of extended family
Asian American Gender Roles
Seen as model minority: majority graduated from college, have high paying jobs
Gender role conflict: more traditional roles where women are expected to be subservient to compete with Euro-American emphasis on equality in relationships
Native American Gender Roles
Anthropologists introduced their biases to understanding of gender roles
White male researchers had limited access to women
Represented women as princess/squaw
Limited access to interactions in family.home
Did not account matrilineal system
Women menstruating isolated: shunned as powerless vs too powerful
Tribes show egalitarian roles
Women’s status increases with age
What are the stereotypes about migrants?
Threat to public safety
Competition for employment
Reality: migrants less likely to commit crimes/be incarcerated, skill and expertise improves producivity and economic growth
How does migration affect females in particular?
Fleeing gender-based violence in home countries
Losing loved one
Adapting to these experiences is form of resilience: collectivism can help
Preferential Looking
infants are shown two stimuli at the same time and are measured on which object they look at longer (female/male face)
How is preferential looking used to investigate infants’ understanding of gender categories?
By 6 months, infants can distinguish between male and female faces but when cultural cues are removed (facial hair, accessories, hair) they cannot distinguish between males and females
Habituation
infants noticing if the stimuli has changed
male face is shown until children are “habituated”
changed from male face to female face to see if infants look longer
Sequential Touching
demonstrates an infants categorization skills of objects and faces
How is sequential touching used to investigate infants’ understanding of gender categories?
Until 22 months: categorization skills limited to different levels (animals vs vehicles) but not same level (horses, cows, male/female dolls)
What are the ages at which children develop an understanding of gender categories?
by 2-3 years old, children are able to categorize self and others into gender categories (boy and girl)
Essentialism
The belief that members of a category share an inherent, non-obvious property (essence) that confers identity and causes other category-typical properties to emerge
Gender essentialism: all women (or men) share underlying features (psychological) that are innate
Switched-at-birth task
Study done where child of one sex raised by individuals of the other sex (ages 4-10) are asked about
Stereotyped qualities
Biological qualities
control questions (does the girl go to school with girls on the island?)
What do the results from the studies with switched-at-birth task show about essentialism?
All children matched biological qualities to biological sex
Before age 9: children attributed stereotyped qualities to biological sex
Children have strong essentialist beliefs until age 8
Gender constancy
Understanding that gender is a stable, unchanging characteristic
Kohlberg’s Phases
Self-labeling: children’s abilities to identity themselves as boys or girls (previously known as gender identity), develops at 2-3 years old
Gender stability: understanding the lasting nature of gender, develops at 4-5 years old
Gender consistency (constancy): gender is unchanged even with changes in appearance, develops at 6-7 years old
What is Sandra Bem’s criticism of Kohlberg’s methods for his three-stage theory and when it develops?
Argued that the tasks used were unnecessarily difficult
Bem’s method shows thaat children start showing gender consistency (constancy) by age 3
Information Processing
How we attend to, encode, and remember environmental stimuli such as events, pictures, or stories
Bottom-up processing
Data-driven, perception directs cognition
Top-down processing
Perception is constructed by cognition
Gender-differentiated attention
By age 2, only boys are more likely to imitate culturally masculine actions (i.e building a house) than a feminine action (i.e cracking an egg and cooking it)
By preschool (4-5 years) children show greater interest in novel objects described as for their gender than objects labeled for the other gender
How do errors of encoding relate to gender-atypical behavior?
When identifying the sex of actors in pictures, 84% of errors occur on pictures depicting a person in a gender-atypical activity
How do people tend to remember gender-role-consistent vs gender-role-inconsistent information?
Children are better at remembering own-sex info than other-sex info
Children are more likely to remember gender-typical info than gender-atypical info and to distort gender-atypical info
Exception: strong violation of male gender norms
Cognitive errors
Errors in our thought processes
Categorizing people into social groups by race, gender, socioeconomic status
What are some of the cognitive errors that people commit with respect to gender and categories and roles?
Categorization by gender leads to
Exaggerating contrast between men and women: attributing individual differences to gender
Overusing the normative male
Making biased judgements: judging competence based on gender
Remembering gender-consistent information: makes changing stereotypes harder
Applying stereotypes to ourselves: self-fulfilling prophecy, stereotype threat
How parents contribute to children’s gendered world: subtle preferences
Choice of clothing
Choice of room decoration
Choice of toys
How parents contribute to children’s gendered world: gendered names
Boys names are more traditional
Trends more common in girls name
Boys are more likely to be named after a parent or relative
Boys names that are adopted for girls end up being girls name
Parents see boys in a more traditional way and are uncomfortable with unusual names for boys especially feminine sounding ones
How parents contribute to children’s gendered world: choice of activities
Parents choose gendered activities for boys and girls
Emphasis on sports involvement for boys more than girls and believe that boys have more athletic ability: parents views of athletic ability affect children’s performance
Gendered behavior/interests and avoidance of feminine activities encouraged
How parents contribute to children’s gendered world: academics
Parents often hold stereotypes about children’s competence
Expectations of child’s ability tend to follow from their own gender stereotypes
Effects children’s perceptions of their own ability even more than actual grades
How does parents anxiety about math relate to their kids anxiety and performance?
1st and 2nd graders completed math/reading tests and parents completed measure of math anxiety/extent of homework help
Results: children’s performance is affected by parents’ math anxiety when parents help a lot with homework
How parents contribute to children’s gendered world: chores
Parents assign gendered chores to boys and girls
Girls are assigned more chores than boys
Gendered chore assignment depends on sibling composition in family, parents own gender-role attitudes (whether father does chores), and if mother is employed
How parents treat their children differently: judging newborns
New parents asked to rate their babies on 18 adjective pairs (strong-weak, big-little)
Babies physical characteristics measured and were not found different (weight, length, health)
Daughters rated by mom/dad as softer, finer-featured, little, more inattentive
Sons rated by mom/dad firm, larger featured, better coordinated, more alert, stronger, hardier
Similar trends persist today
How parents treat their children differently: crawling ability
Parents are asked to judge their 11 month old ability to crawl down an inclined ramp
Mothers estimated boys would be able to crawl steeper ramps than girls
There was no actual crawling difference between boys/girls
Parents have gendered expectations from the start, initially these don’t have any effect on children but later on they do
How parents treat their children differently: play patterns
When present in a playroom with toys, parents (especially fathers) are more likely to choose gendered toys for boys and girls
Parents respond positively when children choose gender-typical toys
How parents treat their children differently: socialization of emotions
Parents enforce emotion control more in young boys except for anger
Anger more acceptable from boys which causes parents give in to demands of boys more than girls
Parents more tolerant of vulnerable emotions (fear, sadness) from girls
Parents discuss emotions more with girls than boys (except anger) and focus on relationships with others
Parents talk to girls more than boys and are more supportive
Parents more likely to discuss academics with boys and friends/relationships with girls
How parents treat their children differently: reactions to behaviors
When children engage in risky behavior, parents more likely to intervene to prevent harm if it’s a girl
Risky behavior is inevitable for boys and permit more autonomy/independence
Parents more likely to engage in physical play with sons, quieter pretend play with daughters
How parents treat their children differently: spending patterns
Family spending patterns differ slightly in families with daughters only or sons only
Daughter only: more money spent on clothing (short-term spending)
Son only: more money spent on housing (long-term investment, better school choices)
Choices reflect parents expectations of their children: importance on appearance for girls and academic success for boys
How parents treat their children differently: spending time
Gauthier et al studied time spent by parents with their children in 16 industrialized countries
Time spent with children increased over time for mothers and fathers
Mothers spent significantly more time than fathers even when they were employed
Homemaker mothers: 3.4 hours per day
Working mothers: 2.2 hours
Fathers: 1.2 hours
Why do fathers spend less time with children than mothers do?
Men earn more on average which makes sense for fathers to work more to provide for family
Men socialized to care less about children and nuturing
Gatekeeping: mothers see themselves are predominantly responsible for children and they keep fathers less involved
Aka pygmies in Africa
Fathers spend lots of time with children, interacting with them and caring for them almost as much as mothers
Men are not innately inclined to avoid children
Providing food is a collaborative activity for men and women
When men are not main breadwinners they can spend more time with children
How parents model gendered behavior: interactions with children
Young children: mothers more likely to be caretakers and fathers are playmates
Mothers tend to be more involved in children’s lives and know more details
Interaction style: mothers tend to be more responsive/comforting, fathers more authoritarian/less flexible
Nontraditional families
Parents who are commited to equality of parenting and feminism
Children learn gender labels and toy stereotypes later than average
Children have less stereotyped interests and more flexible attitudes about roles in the family and workplace
Girls don’t show decline in math performance in middle/high school
Nontraditional families: single-parent families
Parent is observed doing variety of tasks that don’t follow gender norms
Children are less stereotypical and more flexible
Other studies (especially of single-mother families) show average stereotyping levels
Nontraditional families: gay & lesbian parents
Gay parents less likely to have custody of children from previous heterosexual relationship and gay couples less likely to form families
Lesbian mothers have parenting behaviors similar to heterosexual mothers
Having 2 mothers means more involvement and knowledge
How does the sibling composition relate to children’s intersts?
Girls with (older) brothers have more masculine interests
Boys with olders sisters have more feminine interests initially but then have more masculine interests than boys w/o sisters as they get older
How does the sibling composition affect math performance and verbal performance?
Having a brother improves math performance of boys/girls
Having a sister improves verbal performance of boys
Firstborns achieve at a higher level than later-born children
Younger sisters of older brothers are notably disadvantaged
Gender Segregation
Playing in same-sex peer groups
2-3 years old: children start choosing more same-sex peers as play partners/friends
Girls show same-sex peer preference first then boys follow and have stronger preference
Parallel play
Before age 2, children show no interest in playing with other children and prefer playing by themselves
How does gender segregation progress in childhood?
Same-sex preference increases between 2 and 6 years
4 y/o spends 3x as much time with same-sex peers as other-sex peers and by age 6 it’s more than 10x as much
Gender segregation persists throughout childhood but lessens into adolescence
Gender segregation more visible when adults are not present: adults will try to get boys/girls to interact with everyone
Two-cultures theory: girls peer group
Smaller groups: dyads (2 people) or triads
More likely to play boys games than boys are to play girls games
Play style: cooperative, taking turns, pretend play focuses on relationships
More egalitarian, concerned with who is whose friend
Conflict: tendency for double-voice discourse, resolving conflict by “saying it with a smile”
Two-cultures theory: boys peer group
Larger, more age-heterogeneous groups
More likey to play outdoors, competitive/formal games and sports
Play style: more active and physical
Dominance hierarchy more prevalent, forms quicker, more stable, use more direct commands
Conflict: more likely to argue/fight, physical aggression, profanity
Is the two-cultures theory universal?
These patterns are not universal
Study in China looked at peer groups: Chinese boys are less assertive and more mitigating whereas girls are more direct and assertive
Assertiveness is more valued for girls and less valued for boys in China
Peer relationships follow gender expectations in Chinese culture
Why does gender segregation happen in childhood?
Compatible play styles: children choose peers who have similar play styles, boys prefer girls with masculine play styles more than boys with feminine play styles
Knowledge of gender: toddlers who develop self-labeling earlier are more likely to choose same-sex peers
In-group favoritism: people tend to prefer/value individuals of their own group
How does gender segregation affect children’s gender development?
Children imitate, reinforce, and punish other children’s gender related behavior
8-20 months: positive feedback when playing with same-sex peers, girls cross-gender play more acceptable
18-24 months: boys behavior more masculine and less feminine due to peer reactions, girls masculine behaviors usually ignored so tomboyish behavior remained stable
Children feel pressured to adopt gender norms
Dosage-dependent effects
More time spent in same-sex groups the higher stereotyped behavior
3-5 year olds who play in same-sex groups in the fall have higher stereotype levels in the spring
Children in mixed-sex groups adapt to play styles of others
Jane Elliot “brown eyes - blue eyes” experiment
Humans have tendency to prefer in-groups even groups formed on trivial dimensions
Higer in-group bias, out-group hostility
Borderwork
Teasing/chasing that takes place between boy and girl groups
Cooties
Long-term effects of gender segregation
Continues in adulthood
Communication/relationship problems arise
Effects on romatic/marital relationships
Workplace segregation
Formal Curriculum
Academic subject matter that school intends to teach
Boys/girls mostly receive the same education
Informal Curriculum
After-school activities like athletics, drama, student clubs, etc
More interest based
Hidden Curriculum
Subtle gender-related practices that may take place in the classroom
Lining up boys and girls separately
Assigning different tasks to boys and girls
Proportion of students taking math AP classes
Null Curriculum
Material missing from formal curriculum
Lack of focus on females in history, sciences, or contemporary life
How do male and female academic performance differ?
Modern industrial countries: girls get better grades, only exception is standardized testing where boys do better at math/science, girls better at writing
Girls more anxious about academic performance and more focused on pleasing teachers
Boys are 2x more likely to be placed in special education programs, high rates of ADHD, autism, dyslexia
Boys are 4x more likely to be placed in programs for emotional and behavioral disturbance
Girls are more likely to escape diagnosis of learning disabilities