1/195
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Modes of Creation
First possession, conquest/discovery, creation, finding and converting, accession, adverse possession
Devise/Bequest
Inheritance by will
Ways to Possess Something
Mere possession, equitable title/interest, legal title
Our Causes of Action
Nuisance, tortious interference, unfair competition, trespass
Nuisance
intentional non-trespassory interference that is substantial and unreasonable
Tortious interference
Intentionally and wrongfully interfering with a contract or economic opportunity
Unfair competition
usurping another’s business opportunity through customer confusion or wongful conduct
Bundle of property rights
Exclusion, use, alienation, possession
Lost Property
the owner accidentally and casually lost— goes to finder, rather than owner of the premise (exceptions — if finder is a trespasser, employee, or a finder is on the premise for a limited purpose)
Mislaid property
property intentionally placed somewhere, then forgotten — goes to owner of the premise
Abandoned property
Property intentionally abandoned by the TO, who shows an objective manifestion to no longer claim right to it — finder gets both possession and title
Accession rules
if you take something in good faith and ulitmately convert it to a new identity through mistaken improvement, you get it (but may still be liable for the value of the raw materials)
Fixtures
Personal property that is so integrated with real property that it becomes a part of it — if you need a tradesperson to install it, it’s a fixture
The Rule of Increase
contested property belongs to the party with the greatest connection (ex: baby animals belong to the owner of the mother)
Adverse possession elements
actual, hostile, open/notorious, exclusive, continues/uninterrupted (sometimes peacefull + under a claim of ownership)
NOTE — can’t adversely possess against the state
Quiet title
a suit brought about to determine who has the title of a certain piece of property
General warranty deed
The grantor warrants title against all defects, including those that arose before the grantor owned the property —
grantor promises the title is good and will defend against ligitimate title claims; protects the grantee against defects caused by both prior owners and the grantor; provides the greatest protection to the buyer
Special warranty deed
The grantor warrants title only against defects that arose during the grantor’s period of ownership —
grantor does not promise that previous owners had good title; protects the grantee only against title defects attributable to the grantor; provides less protection than a general warranty deed
Quitclaim deed
The grantor transfers whatever interest they have in the property, without making any warranties about title—
grantor does not promise they actually own the property; grantor does not warrant that the property is free from liens or other defects; if the grantor has no ownership interest, the grantee receives nothing
Privity
successive relationship to the same rights of property — to protect against trespassers/wrongdoers; used to be more rules but now abolished; legal relationship (buyers/seller, by will, etc) and must be voluntary)
Jus tertii
can’t claim that you’re acting as a third party’s agent unless they are brought in
What parts of your personhood can be property?
no property in parts of the physical body to which one has no right of possession (Moore)— but you can have property rights in attributes fo the self, created through labor (Midler)
Fiduciary duty
a heightened obligation of candor and care — usually created by status where there is a power/knowledge imbalance between the two parties and the weaker party relies on the stronger party and/or pays for their expertise (doctor/patient, lawyer/client) — creates the economic equivalent of insurance, shifts risk to the stronger party
Navigable waterways
These are one of the only fully public things — Commerce Clause allows federal government to protect the ability of the public to use the water ways; so if navigable waterways run through your property, you canot restrict the use of it
Elements to custom
Ancient, uninterrupted, peaceful, reasonable, visible boundaries, obligatory, not repugnant/inconsistent with other laws and customs
Servitudes
a legal right/obligation involvign land that allows someone to use another person’s land or restricts how that land can be use (includes easements, real covenants, equitable servitudes)
License
permission to enter/use another person’s land (generaly revocable) on its own (not a servitude)
Profit a prendre
allows someone to enter someone else’s land and remove natural resources
Purpresture
an unauthorized encroachment/obstruction on property belonging to the public
Three theories of public rights to land
Prescriptive easement, custom, public trust
Public trust
certain resources (ex: navigable waterways) are held by government for public interest
Tresspass to chattel
intentional interference with your personal property, causing actual harm or deprivation of use
Self-help
sometimes permitted, but generally cannot involve unreasonable force, a breach of the peace, or unlawful conduct
A landlord generally cannot use self-help to evict a tenant who is wrongfully holding over)
Can be used to recapture chattels (reasonably, no breach of peace) when there is a security interest
Legal remedies
Damages
ejectment
replevin
restitution
quiet title
Damages
A monetary award intended to compensate a plaintiff for a legally recognized injury or loss caused by the def.
Ejectment
Restores possession of real property to someone entitled to possess it
Replevin
Recovers specific personal property wrongfully held by someone else
Restitution
Restores a benefit the def. wrongfully obtained from the plaintiff (sometimes called a remedy for unjust enrichment) — Requires:
an enrichment of the def
at the expense of the pl
under circumstances that are “unjust”
Equitable remedies
specific performance
accounting/disgorgement
constructive trust, injunction
equitable lien
partition (in kind/in sale)
quiet title*
Party wall
a wall shared by two adjoining property owners neither can make changes that interfere with the other owner’s rights (also can’t put windows in without agreement)
Types of damages
Compensatory (actual damages, diminution in value, cost of restution, loss-of-use damages)
Nominal
Punitive
Full market value (like conversion)
Encroachment rules
baseline — court will grant an injunction requiring the removal
but, because injunctions are equitable, pl.s must quickly file suit when they notice an encroachment
pl.s who fail to mitigate the harm by filing quickly may only be eligible for damages on the trespass
Mistaken improvements rule on real estate
Creates a fixture on real property that belongs to the lot owner, even if the lot owner was not the intended recipient of the improvement
If the improvement is in good faith, the court may award the mistaken improver an injunction for the value of the improvement
However, because owners have a right to manage property as they see fit, and because even underdeveloped parcels are not fungible, courts will often grant diligent pls. the option for an injunction to remove the improvement at the def’s expense
Language to evoke in equity, tortious interference, and accession/bona fide purchaser for value
equity — unclean hands
tortious interference — intent
accession and bona fide purchaser for value — good faith
Incorporeal hereditament
a non-physical property interest in land (holder can enforce the interest against owner, owner can’t exclude them from exercising right)
(ex: easement, profit a prendre, right-of-way, certain other land-use rights)
different from corporal hereditament (a tangible interest; like owning a house or parcel of land)
In rem
Property right enforceable against the world
(fee simple, easement, profit a prendre)
In personam
right against a particular person
(license, personal contractual promise, real covenant, equitable servitude — but can bind successors if requirements are met)
Bailment for hire
temporary possession of real property for payment (you retain ownership but the bailee temporarily has possession) — turns on expectation of security when dealing with injury
Mandatory limitations on exclusion
necessity, custom, public accomodation/common carriage, public policy, antidiscrimmination laws (these can’t be abrogated by contract)
Rules of waste in a will
“Although a person may deal capriciously with his own property, his self-interest ordinarily will restrain him from doing so. Where an attempt is made to confer such a power upon a person who is given no other interest in the property, there is no such restraint, and it is against public policy to allow him to exercise the power if the purpose is merely capricious”
Rule of abandonment in fee
You cannot abandon real property (should make an LLC, grant to the LLC, then abandon the LLC)
Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP)
no future interest is good unless it must vest (if at all) no later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest
(doesn’t apply to chartiies, or reversion, possibility of reverter, right of entry, or indefeasibly vested remainder)
Remedies for RAP problems
1. Invalidation (strict rule)
2. Reinterpretation (more common)
Cy pres
*A good lawyer will always include a savings clause
Are option contrcats subject to RAP? right of first refusal?
option contracts are subject to RAP but right of first refusal are not
(also lease with option to buy (option appurtenant) does not trigger RAP)
Ouster
when one co-tenant wrongfully excludes another co-tenant from their right to possess and use the jointly owned property
Rule: when a cotenant out of possession makes a clear, unequivocal demand to use land that is in the exclusive possession of another cotenant, and that cotenant refuses to accommodate the other tenant’s right to use the land, the tenant out of possession has established a claim for relief
remedies for ouster
1. Out-of-possession tenant needs to attempt self-help
2. Creates a right to contribution, which is a remedy that looks like rent
Remedies with co-ownership
accounting/contribution
partition (in kind/by sale)
owelty
severance
Preemptive rights
also called right of first refusal
does function or form determine how a court interprets an interest?
function
debt financing (mortgage l
sales-leaseback
the owner sells the property to a buyer and then leases it back so they can continue using it
1. The buyer becomes the owner
2. The seller receives the purchase price
3. The seller becomes a tenant and pays rent
4. Failure to pay rent may lead to eviction or lease termination under applicable law
leases vs. loans
Leases:
1. Possessory
2. TT makes periodic payments to LL in exchange to possession
3. LL carries property risk
4. Remedy for nonpayment: eviction
5. LL entitled to protect premises from TT damage with contract terms, inspection
6. TT intents to return property to LL
Loans:
1. Often possessory
2. B’or makes periodic payments to B’ee to avoid loss of possession
3. Contract terms distribute property risk
4. Remedy for nonpayment: repossession, foreclosure
5. B’ee entitled to protect premises from B’or damage with contract terms, inspection
6. B’or intends to retain the property
Tenancy in common
1. To create: presumed whenever conveyance is made to two people (who are not husband + wife)
2. Survivorship: no right of survivorship (when one TIC dies, her interest passes to her heirs or devisees)
3. Alienation: can buy/sell/devise/dispose of undivided share as if sole owner (each has a separate and undivided interest in the whole; each co-tenant is the owner of separate and distinct share of the property)
4. Possession: each has right to possess and enjoy entire property
5. Termination: may be terminated by partition
6. Example of language creating: “To A and B”
Joint tenancy
1. To create: created by express words need four utilities (time, title, interest, and possession); not by inheritance (heirs always take as TIC, default)
(Can be created by deed, will, or joint adverse possession; Must be taken at same time; Must be taken by same instrument (same deed, will, or by joint adverse possession); Must be taken by same interest (interest must be equal in an estate of one duration); Must have equal possession (equal right to possess the whole)
2. Survivorship: right of survivorship (survivor takes all)
3. Alienation: no right to devise; can be alienable but it destroys the JT
4. Possession: each has undivided interest in the whole estate
5. Termination: can be severed and converted to tenancy in common
6. Example of language creating: “To A and B with right of survivorship”
7. Notes: one created, can modify agreement; created with express words only; husband and wife rules vary by state
Tenancy by the entirety
1. To create: most states presume TBTE in any joint conveyance to husband and wife
2. Survivorship: right of survivorship (survivor takes all)
3. Alienation: one H/W can’t alienate all
4. Possession: each has undivided interest in the whole estate
5. Termination: severed by both H + W only (or divorce)
6. Example of language creating: “to H and W” — *Generally, treated as ownership of the whole together; Some jurisdictions recognize TBE and some recognize community property; Uses the same four utilities as JT but also a 5th (marriage)
8. Notes: only applicable for certain states
Community property
1. To create: property acquired during marriage
2. Survivorship: generally, not automatic
3. Alienation: one H/W can’t alienate all
4. Possession: each has undivided interest in the whole estate
5. Termination: severed by both H + W only (or divorce)
6. Example of language creating: “to H and W as community property”
7. Notes: only applicable for certain states
voluntary transfers
sales (contracts)
bequests (trusts, wills)
gifts (contracts, trusts, family law) *not complete until you deliver it
Good faith purchaser for value requirements
good faith (subjective —> did purchaser actually believe it was in good faith? doesn’t depend on reasonableness; burden of proof is on party alleging lack of good faith
purchase (gifts don’t count, includes swindlers)
for value (valuable consideration)
requirements for conveyance
statute of frads (for real estate)
delivery (for deeds and gifts)
recording (real estate; personal property secured financing)
void vs. voidable title
void title: involuntary (theft)
voidable title: voluntary (fraud)
Race state
the first person to record wins (it doesn’t matter whether that person know about the earlier sale)
Ex: Homer gives Lisa a deed. Lisa records before Bart, so Lisa wins, even if she knew Homer had already sold to Bart
Notice state
a later bona fide purchaser wins if they had no notice of the earlier conveyance when they purchased
Ex: Lisa buys without notice that Homer already sold to Bart. Lisa wins, even if Bart records first.
Race-notice state
the later GFP must have no notice of the earlier conveyance and record before the earlier buyer (both requirements must be met)
Ex: Lisa buys without notice and records before Bart. Lisa wins
types of notice for recording systems
actual (purchaser actually knows it)
constructive (prior deed properly recorded)
inquiry (circumstances would prompt reasonable investigation)
what is entity property
you own in fee simple plus something else;
a form of ownership that separates management rights and gives them to a third party
ex: leases; condos; co-ops; trust; corporation; security interests)
two models of property management
exclusion (property is managed by giving an owner the authority to decide who may enter, access, or use the property)
governance (property is managed by establishing rules that determine what people can do, how they must behave, and how competing interests are resolved)
condominium
A condominium is a form of property ownership in which an individual owns their specific unit in fee simple, while sharing ownership of the common areas with the other unit owners (tenants in common)
a condominium association manages the common areas and enforces the condominium’s governing documents
co-op
A cooperative is a form of property ownership in which a corporation owns the entire building, and individual residents own shares in that corporation that entitle them to occupy a particular unit through a proprietary lease.
the corporation is governed by a board of directors, often made up of resident shareholders
Business judgment rule
courts presume that directors make business decisions on an informed basis, and that they know the business needs better than a court does
kinds of leases
terms of years
periodic tenancy
tenancy at will
tenancy at sufferance
term of years lease
1. A tenancy for a fixed period of time
2. Automatically ends when the specified term expires
3. Fixed end date
4. Ex: A leases an apartment to B for 12 months
periodic tenancy
1. A tenancy that continues for successive periods until properly terminated
2. Ends when either party gives the required notice
3. Keeps renewing until terminated
4. Ex: A rents to B month-to-month
tenancy at will
1. A tenancy with no fixed duration that continues at the will of the landlord and tenant
2. Generally, either party can terminate it, subject to applicable law
3. Ex: A lets B live in a spare house with no specified end date or rental period
tenancy at sufferance
1. Tenant didn’t leave when they were supposed to
2. Landlord may have reasons for this; but may pursue eviction or treat the tenant as having created a new tenancy
3. Ex: B’s one-year lease expires, but B refuses to leave
assignment
1. Occurs when A transfers their entire remaining leasehold interest to B (so, both entire space and entire duration) — O and A are in privity of contract, but not estate; O and B are in privity of estate, but not contract; A and B are generally not in either (unless they have a contract between them)
2. B owes rent to O because B now holds the leasehold estate and has privity of estate with O
3. A may still owe rent to O because A signed the original lease and has privity of contract with O
4. If B stops paying rent, O can generally sue A, B, or both (but only recover once)
sublease
1. Occurs when A transfers less than the entire remaining leasehold interest, retaining some portion of the term— O and A are in privity of contract and privity of estate; O and B are not in either; A and B are in privity of contract and privity of estate
2. Here, landlord looks to A for rent and A looks to B under the sublease
3. Each person is responsible for who you allow below you
assignment and assumption
assignee agrees to be in privity of contract with landlord
Assumption — the new tenant expressly agrees to take on original tenant’s obligations under the lease
novation
granted by landlord to release first tenant after assignment
Generally landlords won’t grant because they want more people to sue, but with certain circumstances they might (ex: terrible tenant you don’t want to deal with)
what does a landlord deliver to a tenant
Landlord delivers right to possess, not actual possession (some states have passed statutes though)
our default — risk on tenant for previous tenant (can contract out of this though)
price vs. quantity
1. All quality standards require investment (initial compliance) and maintenance (ongoing compliance)
2. Investment and maintenance requires liquid capital
3. Landlord won’t invest capital beyond what they can recover
4. Landlord won’t invest capital unless they face competition
5. So, without competition and rent that covers these investments, deterioration occurs
management theory of property
shift towards management theory of property — cost of maintenance is better fit to landlord
the warranty of quiet enjoyment
Baseline rule — landlords are responsible for disturbances that are reasonably foreseeable
Warranty of habitability
1. Residential tenants are entitled to withhold rent if the conditions of the apartment do not meet minimum standards, sometimes defined as compliance with the building code
2. This warranty is akin to the warranties that torts implies onto consumer products
3. Modern procedures often require tenants to deposit the withheld rent with the housing court
retaliatory eviction
Landlords may not:
1. Evict tenants;
2. Refuse to renew;
3. Unreasonably raise the rent; or
4. Pull a unit off the market
With the intent to retaliate against a tenant who raised their rights
(Landlords may take these actions if their intent is not retaliatory — need to show that retaliation was not their primary motivation)
business judgmnet rule exceptions
The business judgment is a common-law doctrine by which courts defer to good faith decisions made by boards of directors in business settings
To trigger substantive review, tenants must show either that the board acted:
1. Outside its authority (ultra vires)
2. In a way that did not legitimately further the corporate purpose; or
3. In bad faith (almost always corruption)
three things to determine if a CC&R (covenants, conditions, and restrictions) is unreasonable
a. It violates public policy
b. Costs outweigh benefit
c. Arbitrary
d. *NOTE Cal. Civ. Code says “CC&Rs in a CIC are enforceable unless unreasonable”
trusts summary
Settlor grants legal title, management & control and possibly possession to the trustee
The trustee is a fiduciary for the beneficiary (who gets right to distributions)
The settlor grants for the benefit of the beneficiary
*trustee is bound by fiduciary duty to do what the settlor wants and what helps beneficiary accomplish settlor’s goals
secured lenders’ property right
lender has rights against the property itself (not just a right to sue debtor for money)
secured lenders’ priority right
if multiple people have claims against the same property, who gets paid first?
1. Senior secured lender must be paid in full, before waterfall and next layer gets filled
2. Usually — taxes, child support, then others
3. Unsecured debt (like your phone bill) is at the bottom
foreclosure
the legal process through which a mortgage holder enforces its security interest against the property after default
If surplus (bought for more), then borrow gets