1/35
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the types of change in teams and organisation (the focus of a change effort)
Attitude/Role Approach
Technology Approach
Strategy Approach
Economics or People Approach
Attitude and Role Centered Approach
Attitude: Trying to change attitudes and values so that behaviour also changed
Goal is for resistors to become change agents who will transmit the vision to others
Role: involves changing work roles, hoping that these new roles will lead to new behaviours and therefore attitude changes (to be consistent with behaviour)
Different activities, responsibilities, authority relationships
Technology Changes
Trying to change/improve performance by implementing new information and decision support systems (human resource information system)
Often fail, because without a change in attitude and roles, new technology will not be accepted
Strategy Changes
Changes in competitive strategy to achieve major objectives (new products)
to be successful it requires consistent changes in peoples, roles and tech
Economics/People Approach
The first approach (econ) seeks to improve financial performance (eg. downsizing)
The second approach seeks to improve human capability, creativity and commitment (eg. through empowering people to initiate improvements)
Change Processes Definition:
describes a typical pattern of events that occur from beginning of a change to the end, and include how earlier changes affect subsequent changes
Stages in the Change Process: Lewins Change Management Model
Unfreezing: recognition of old ways of doing things are no longer accurate and costly
Change: search for new ways of doing things and selection of promising approach
Refreezing: implementation of that approach
Lewins Force Field Analysis (Unfreezing):
Framework for looking at forces that influence the situation:
Increasing driving forces towards change (increase incentives)
Decreasing restraining forces that create resistance (reduce fear)
Steps in Lewins Force-Field Analysis
Steps:
Analyse the situation and map all the forces
Asses the forces (are they driving or constraining, and which value should we attack to each of them)
Take steps to increase the driving forces and decrease constraining ones
Stages in Reaction to Change:
Denial (that change is happening), Anger (blame), Mourning (acknowledge what is lost) and Adaptation (accept the need for change)
Reactions to Change is Dependant on :
Reactions (amount of resistance/commitment) to change is dependant on contextual and individual factors
How do individual factors and contextual factors affect reactions to change:
Individual: persons general confidence to coping with a change (self-efficacy)
Contextual: stress caused by prior experiences
Reasons for Accepting Change:
Due to leader power and the types of influence processes that leaders use: legitimate, coercive and expert power
What is Legitimate, Coercive and Expert/Strong Referent Power
Legitimate: people comply with change if thy believe that it is a legitimate exercise of leader authority
Coercive: People comply due to fear of punishment
Expert: People comply because they trust their leader and believe that change is necessary and effective
Reasons for Rejecting Change:
Not Necessary(no evidence), Not Feasible (not possible), Not Cost Effective, Cause Potential Losses (shift in power), Inconsistent with Values (unethical beneficial), Leader isn’t Trusted (personal ambitions and no legitimate authority)
Active Resistance
presence of strong values and emotions rejecting change that could serve as a source of commitment if opponents are converted to supporters
Implementing Change: Outcome of a Change Depends on:
Who participates
How and when the change is implemented
What is Changed
How much influence each participant has
Outcome of a Change can be judged by:
The commitment of people to the change
Successful implementation of the change
Extent to which change provides desired benefits and avoids consequence
Four Major Concepts to think about when implementing change
Determining what to change; diagnosis of the problems confronting the organisation
Understand system dynamics: cause of the problem, and effect of change
Responsibility for major change: encourage, support and resources
The pace and sequence of changes: gradual movement, timelines
How Visions Influence Change:
clear vision helps to guide and coordinate the decisions and actions of many people in widely dispersed places
Desirable Characteristics for Vision
Be simple and idealistic, Appeal to values, hopes and ideals, be challenging but realistic, be focused but general enough, communicated clearly in 5 minutes
Why Do Transformation efforts Fail (2 reasons):
Change processes go through a series of stages that take time, satisfying result
Critical mistakes in any stages, slow momentum and negate hard-won gains
Cynicism:
involves a loss of faith in the leaders of change
Caused by history of change attempts that were not entirely successful
Caused by predisposition of people to see things from a cynical perspective
Skepticism
doubt about the likelihood of of success, but is still hopeful that positive change will occur
Reasons for Cynicism:
make sense of puzzling events in their environment
rationalise failure and fill in the gaps
Defense mechanism to protect themselves from personal responsibility and unpleasant thought
Causes of Cynicism about Organisation Change:
feeling uninformed
Lack of communication and respect from union representative and supervisor
Lack of opportunity to be involved in decision making
Negative Disposition
Effects of Cynicism in Organisational Change:
Lower organisational commitment and motivation to work hard
Lower job satisfaction
Lower willingness to engage in organisational change efforts
Lower credibility for organisational leader
Strategies to Minimise Cynicism
Keep people involved in decision making that effect them, and informed of changes
Keep surprising changes to a minimum
Acknowledge mistake (apologise and make amends) and publicise successful changes
Use two-way communication to see employees perspectives and give them opportunities to express feelings, receive validation and reassurance
Chaotic Change:
Chaotic change occurs when internal and external complexity becomes so high that managers can no longer confidently predict what will happen next. Since its unpredictable leaders need a flexible approach
Change Management vs Change Leadership
Change management provides the structured tools and processes to execute a transition smoothly
Change leadership focuses on the vision and inspiration needed to make people want to embrace it
Why move from change management to change leadership?
Traditional change management approaches were often developed in the private sector and then applied to public organisations.
The problem is that these approaches often assume that change can be:
Planned in advance, Controlled by managers and Implemented in a predictable sequence
In public organisations, this often does not work well because change takes place in much more complex and uncertain environments.
So the alternative is change leadership
Why must change leadership be flexible?
People aren’t rational agents, and are constantly changing the nature of our relationships therefore future actions are at most times unpredictable and constantly reshaping
Why do people resist change in organisations in relation to identity?
People develop an organisational identity around things such as their role, their responsibilities and their relationship with others
Change can threaten this identity and they will resist anything that doesn’t benefit their economic and social survival
How does change actually happen?
Organisational change occurs through conversations relationships and identities
shifting of identities and relationships through communication
People create interpretations of the change (communication) and share it with others (relationships). This then affects the individuals view of their identity and leads to changes in behaviour
What should leaders do when change is occuring
Since they cannot predict how people will react, they should loosen control and focusing on creating relationships within the organisation
this ‘loosening’ will lead to chaos, confusion and uncertainty all needed for change to occur
Leader have to find their own way to lead chaos, since there is no set tool
How should leaders lead chaotic change
Pay attention to identity formation: role model and communicate core values and purpose of organisation
Pay attention to relationships: Memes, Involvement and Sybols/forms