1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Muller
Sought to define conservatism
Argued that conservatism is defined by historical utilitarianism (institutions that have survived to today are inherently beneficial by nature of their continued existence)
Conservatives have no inherent positional ideology
But some key features are the belief that existing institutions are good and must be preserved and that humans are impefect and cannot know themselves (and thus cannot rationalize new traditions out of the air); also often skeptical of written constitutions, utility of religion,
Orthodox (divinity: Antigone) v. Conservative (history/tradition: Strauss)
Radical conservatives: hate existing order, must revive the past via revolution (de Maistre, Strauss, Schmitt)
Robin
Sought to define conservatism
Conservatives seek to uphold hierarchy, even when they are oppressed/do not benefit
Freedom for the elites, control for the commonfolk
Conservatives nowadays often gravitate towards private power over public
All conservatism is reactionary
Some conservatives are counterrevolutionary (ie. de Maistre, Schmitt), who are opposed to all changes in order
Plato
Already know this
Burke
English, writing Reflections after French Rev.
Bit horrified
Argues rights are inherited, and institutions all have latent functions & benefits
When the revolutionaries destroyed everything, they had no idea what they were destroying – Bad things may (and will) happen because those institutions may have served a hidden purpose we took for granted/didn’t even realize
Slow, gradual reform (English common law) > Revolution
Common people should not really be involved with reform; reform should be initiated by government, church, aristocrats
Inequality/hierarchy is good and necessary, folk religion is ok
Contract thinker: Society = contract between living & dead
De Bonald
French, writing after revolution
Also horrified
Specifically re: divorce being a thing now
Marriage as foundation of society, invisible glue (similar to Schlafly, Hayek)
Family as building blocks of society; Marriage > Family > Society
Domino effect if marriage falls; it must be unbreakable for society to be unbreakable
Expresses concern about women; writes that women leave marriage with no dignity, youth, or fertility – If their husband leaves, they are screwed
Marriage tames humans (particularly men)
Individual happiness sometimes must be sacrificed for good of society (ie. staying in an unhappy marriage to preserve social order)
De Maistre
“To conserve all, consecrate all” – All institutions/traditions/norms we need to preserve should be made sacred
Could be read as argument for theocracy
Origin of institutions doesn’t matter; the lowlier the origin of a surviving institution, the better it is
Constitutions should be written on the heart; writing them down on paper takes their power away and makes them human (less divine)
De Tocqueville
French, came to America to observe burgeoning democracy
Not too shabby; appreciated liberty
Fascinated by equality of conditions, though believed the best would no longer be the best because of it
Cautioned against tyranny of the majority
Cited incident of Black voters being intimidated, juries siding with clear criminals
Believed civil society, lawyers, judges, and juries (to an extent, teaches commonfolk responsibility & about legal process) could put a check on tyranny
Accepted democracy as inevitable, though not necessarily thrilled about it; emphasis on preserving aspects of old order into democracy (ie. lawyers as aristocracy)
Also, federalist – skeptical of centralized democratic government left unchecked, as it could do virtually anything
Strauss
Natural law guy
Loved Ancient Greece, believed philosophers hide secret messages in writings because of what happened to Socrates (people can’t handle realness)
Critical of modern political theory (Machiavelli introduced ideas of historicism and it all went downhill from there)
Historicism > Relativism > Nihilism
Bleak outlook re: relativism/nihilism; if I can’t definitively say something is ALWAYS bad, how am I to know not to do it?
Nature law is real and it must be gleaned through reason and rationality, as opposed to through religion
Key to having political advantage is to have power at the moment of creation
Schmitt
Writing during Weimar Republic
Annoyed af by the parties/legislature
Believed they couldn’t get their shit together for a few key reasons:
Too many parties/special interests/groups involved in politics – govt. is trying to do too much and is involving itself with too many facets of society/economy/church
Clientelism – corruption/favors from politicians
Tolerance – liberal democracy encourages compromise (as opposed to friend vs. enemy distinction) (and they aren’t even compromising/making decisions, they’re just arguing)
Solution: Get a Dad. He can assume control of govt’, and even operate unchecked, to make decisions when necessary
Also, we need to start viewing the opposition as existential enemies who cannot be compromised with; even if they are good, beautiful, etc.
Treat politics as war; victory will propel society & politics forward (agonism)
Oakeshott
Presentism
Burden of proof lies on the innovator
Institutions have latent effects in our lives; they make us happy and secure, even if we don’t realize – to get rid of them or to change them jeopardizes our happiness, and may lead us someplace worse
Conservatism is a political attitude and life philosophy; to prefer the familiar and to find the good/make the most out of the moment
Government shouldn’t be trying to reshape society; it should work as a neutral umpire that oversees society
Defends present, not the past
Buckley
Founder of nat’l review, initiated Fusionist movement
Marriage between traditional family values & libertarians
In response to communism (godless & anticapitalist, so it concerns both groups)
More focused on capitalism than old right wing
Friedman & Hayek
Economic freedom & political freedom are intertwined
Less radical than Nosick, though believe govt. should not really regulate economy at all
Early neoliberals
Friedman:
Chicago New School
Against Keynesian
Involved with promotion of charter schools/vouchers (“school choice” movement)
Freedom should be limited by our effects on others (ie. you can’t physically harm someone else)
Children are an investment for families, and the govt. should protect them (including unborn babies, potentially) as such
Role of the government is to protect children & enforce the law (which should primarily be concerned with prohibiting interpersonal violence)
Conservative habits:
Hayek:
Austrian
Critiqued conservatives for liking authority too much, not understanding economy
Described self as old whig, classical liberal
Believed democracy is least evil form of government (people have most say/liberty)
But govt. should still be very limited & stay out of economy
Moral beliefs shouldn’t be legislated
Conservative habits: Cautious of rapid change, uses historic language (“classical liberal”, callbacks to French revolution-era free market thinking/liberalism)
Nosick
Minimal state
Hate this guy
People own their labor and their money, to take their money away is tantamount to thievery or slavery (ahistorical but ok)
State should protect principles of historical justice:
Acquisition (ie. getting things honestly)
Transfer (ie. not fencing stolen shit)
Rectificiation (ie. do not coerce or decieve people into deals)
Nothing else!
Anti-time slice (how distribution is right now) and end goal (how distribution is at the end)
Wilt Chamberlain example 🤾
Schlafly
Anti-ERA
Believed would erode women’s privileges, like-
Separate bathrooms
Alimony
Getting the kids after divorce
Not getting drafted
Being valued, just as like, a social vibe
Supported women having jobs “outside the home” (ie. provided they are still in the home in some capacity)
Children as unique form of social security for women (similar to Hayek)
Not entirely opposed to progress; believes capitalism & tech innovations (promotes two as sort of hand-in-hand) have made women’s lives easier
Gives example of sewing machine, washing machine, etc.
Imo doesn’t really pay attention to how more is expected out of women as a result; before a whole afternoon may have been devoted to laundry, now a whole afternoon is devoted to laundry, then vacuuming, then cooking an elaborate dinner, then mending the kids’ clothes, then…
Schlafly doesn’t think husbands should be involved in household chores at all; assumes all women prefer to do all chores themselves
Present happiness > Potential future bliss (Muller, Oakshott)
Argues potential dangers of ERA far outweigh benefits