1/103
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why there are disparate results in negotiations
Some parties embrace negotiation; some hate the process
One person may be better prepared
One party may be more experienced, have more resources, have more leverage
Depends on whether negotiation is for opportunity or necessity
One party may have an alternative
Best
Alternative
To a
Negotiated
Arrangement
Different types of negotiations
Interpersonal relationships
Diplomacy
(treaties, political disputes, trade disputes, extradition, cessation of hostilities)
Criminal law enforcement
Plea bargains
Crisis management
Hostages, hijackings, kidnappings, ledge-jumpers, suicide prevention
Employment terms
Job offers, raises, promotions, new assignment, non-compete, and non-solicitation covenants
Commercial transactions
Price
Time for performance
Conditions
Representations and warranties
Remedies (in event of breach)
Different approaches to negotiations
Puppy, owl, chicken, bull
Puppy
Soft
Give them what they want
Cares a lot about the other side's interests, but not their own
The customer is always right
Accommodating
Probably the worst style of a negotiator
Owl
Wise
Concerned about interests of all parties
Mutual gain approach (win/win)
Wants to increase the size of the pie
Detective mindset
Willing to be a creative learner
Good listener
Chicken
Scared
Don’t care about their interests, or the other side's interests
Thinks “this is too hard”
Avoidance
Bull
Hard
No regard for the other
May yell/curse
Only focus on their own needs
Very adversarial
Overarching principal of negotiating
All good transactions should create value/wealth for both parties
A win-win, NOT a zero sum game
Covenant of good faith & fair dealing
There is no legal duty to be kind, helpful, or to educate or volunteer information to the other party in a negotiation
Expression of opinions, posturing, or "puffery" (opinions) is allowed
Buyer must engage in robust "due diligence" examination (caveat employer) and ask many questions - seller must answer truthfully but is not liable for obvious or readily apparent defects
Seller who makes material false statements may be liable for misrepresentation or fraudulent inducement
Add more
Negotiation tactics
Prepare
Understand the why
Agree on process
Make ultimatums only when real
Never give away your BATNA, but try to learn theirs
Listen more and talk less
Understand their constraints
Keep your cool
Add more
Contract definition
A legally binding agreement that represents a set of promises and creates legal rights and duties between the parties
If the legal rights and duties are broken, it is likely a party will sue for damages
Elements of contract
Agreement
Between competent parties
Based on assent (both parties have to have a fundamental understanding of what the contract is about)
Supported by consideration (both parties have something to gain)
For a lawful purpose
Contracts can be for just about anything you can imagine
True
Privity of contract
Typically only the parties to a contract have "standing" (can sue) to enforce it
Formal contracts
Written contracts (signed by parties)
Contract under seal
Contracts of record
Established through court judgement or court record (created by court)
Negotiable instruments
A written promise or order to pay money that can be transferred.
(A check)
Informal contracts
Oral contracts
Handshake deals
Can sue but it is hard to prove
Does a contract have to be in writing to be able to sue?
No!
Valid contract
A formal contract signed by parties that is binding and enforceable
Voidable contract
A contract that would be valid, but because of the unusual circumstance it was entered into, one party will argue that it should be cancelled
Examples: fraud, mistake, incapacity
Void contract
A contract that is never recognized by the law at all, typically because the subject matter of that contract is illegal
Bilateral contracts
A contract between 2 or more parties, where there is one promise given in exchange for another
One party promises to do something in exchange for another party’s promise
Unilateral contracts
One party makes an offer to the public at large.
The way it is accepted is by someone committing a designated act
Example: reward signs
These are atypical
Are unilateral contracts still legally binding?
Yes, UNLESS the offeree performs the act without knowledge of the offer
Ex: someone returns your cat and did not see the sign that they will be awarded $500
Since they already returned the cat, they are not entitled to this money
Multilateral contracts
Contract with more than 2 parties agreeing to terms
Quasi contracts
Fictional contracts that the law creates, in absence of a written contract, in order to prevent unjust benefits/enrichments
What does a claim of unjust enrichment require?
A benefit is conferred
The defendant does not have knowledge of benefit
It is unjust to retain that benefit without having to pay for it
Quantum Meruit
The amount deserved
Sometimes a contract may not exist, but the remedy is the “amount deserved” for the work performed
What may help establish quantum meruit?
Expert testimony
In every quantum merit case, who loses?
Both parties
There is a difference between an invitation to negotiate and an offer
True
First step in the requirements of an offer to form a contract
The offeror must intend to create a legally binding obligation, and it must be determined by a reasonably prudent person
This is not a social invitation
Reasonably prudent person standard
O + A= K
Offer + Acceptance= Kontract
Definiteness
An offer must be definite, with material terms that are clearly spelled out
Vagueness suggests that there is no intent to enter into a legally binding agreement OR that it is merely an invitation to negotiate
Communication of offer to offeree
The offer must be clearly communicated (spelled out in writing)
Revocation of offer
Generally, an offer may be revoked at any time by the offeror prior to the offeree’s acceptance
A clear expression to to revoke the offer (preferably in writing) is required
Can an offeree accept a terminated offer?
No
Who is the “master of the offer”?
The offeror, who may impose conditions
Mailbox Rule
An offer is effected when received by the offeree
A letter revoking an offer is effected when received by the offeree
If the offeree accepts prior to knowledge of the termination of the offer, the contract is formed
Ask yourself what the offeree knows
Rejection of offer by offeree
The offer is terminated if the offeree rejects the offer and clearly communicates this to the offeror
Counteroffer by offeree
If the offeree makes a counteroffer, the first offer is considered rejected and terminated
Lapse of time
The offer will expire automatically during the stated deadline, but if none was stated a reasonably time lapse is implied by law depending on what goods were sold
What goods have a short lapse of time for the offer to expire?
Goods that fluctuate a lot (gold, oil, metal) or goods that go bad (like produce)
What goods have a long lapse of time for the offer to expire?
Goods that are good for a long time
Death or disability of either party
Death/disability of either party generally terminates a contract when it was a personal services contract (a service that was going to be done by the unique skills of an individual)
However, death does not automatically terminate all contracts (loans, real estate)
Subsequent Illegality
A contract was legally valid when it was created, but a change in the law later makes performing the contract illegal, which terminates the contract
Termination of Offer Picture

What Constitutes an Acceptance?
Clear expression in whatever mode, preferably in writing
Who is the master of the acceptance?
The offeree
Due to this privilege, silence can never be construed as acceptance
Effect of acceptance
Creates a binding agreement
Communication of acceptance
Due to the mailbox rule, acceptance by mail takes effect on the date the letter is mailed
This also applies to electronic contracts
How can the offeror avoid the mailbox rule
By requiring the acceptance to be in effect upon receipt and countersigning the offer
This shows how they are the “master of the offer”
Study Maria Cantu Case
Schoolteacher… at the end of the summer, she is having doubts about returning to work
On Friday she sends a letter of resignation
On Monday her letter of resignation is signed and accepting
On Tuesday, Maria Cantu withdraws her resignation without knowing it is coming back to her
Does she have a legal right to teach?
No, because the acceptance by the offeree was accepted on Monday
Always think about the offeree!!!
Auction sales
Asking for bids is an invitation to negotiate
Once the highest bid is accepted by the auctioneer, it gives rise to a contract
When the auction sale is without reserve, the auctioneer must…
Tell the audience and put a reserve price that must be met
If the price is never met, there is no deal
What is contractual capacity?
The ability to understand that a legally binding contract is being made
A party to a contract is presumed to have capacity unless proven otherwise
Simply not understanding the contents of a contract (ignorance) does not mean incapacity
Status incapacity
Minors do not have the legal capacity to contract
Factual Incapacity
Mental incompetence due to medication, intoxication, drugs, illness, senility
Minor’s ability to avoid contracts
Contracts are generally voidable
Except for “necessaries” - health, sustenance, education
The minor may only disaffirm a contract while still a minor, or very shortly after they turn 18
Minor incapacity should only be used as a shield, not a sword
Restitution
Minor must return what had been received from the other party if the minor still has it
If property is sold to third party, trend is to have minors pay other party for reasonable value of property sold
Scenario:
A high school student (a minor) buys 100 records from a shopkeeper, intending to resell them at a higher price.
The parents have him return all 100 records.
Outcome:
The shopkeeper gets all 100 records back.
The shopkeeper must generally refund the money because the minor disaffirmed the contract.
Scenario:
The student buys 100 records but sells 50 of them to third parties.
The student then disaffirms the original contract.
He returns the remaining 50 records.
Outcome:
The shopkeeper must refund the purchase money for the 50 records
The student must provide restitution (pay the shopkeeper) for the 50 records he already sold, based on their reasonable value
The shopkeeper receives the remaining 50 records and compensation for the 50 that were sold
Minors takeaways:
Minors have to return what they receive from the other party if they still have it
Minor can disaffirm a contract but has to return what is left
If property is sold to a third party, they have to pay the reasonable value that has been sold
Was the common law more or less harsh to minors?
Super harsh!
Anyone under the age of 21 could argue that the contract was voidable
Contracts for necessaries usually pertain to
contracts for health, sustenance, education
In contracts for necessaries, who is liable?
The parent/guardian is liable, but then the minor becomes liable when they become an adult
Example case:
A minor received hospital treatment, but her parents failed to pay the hospital bill.
Her parents received money from the insurance company intended to cover the hospital expenses but used it to purchase a car instead.
When the minor turned 18, she became legally responsible for the outstanding hospital bill.
She challenged the payment obligation in court but was still found liable.
What are contracts minors cannot avoid?
Educational loans or contracts made when running a business
Parents are generally not liable for non-necessaries
If a minor independently buys something unnecessary, the parents are generally not responsible for paying for it
EXCEPTIONS:
Parent is a co-signer of a contract
Parent makes the minor their agent (poor credit, ask minor to sign on behalf)
Mental incompetency
Someone who is temporarily/permanently incapacitated
Mental incompetency and contracts
Very similar to minors
Once the incapacity lifts, that person needs to immediately disavow any contracts that have been entered into when they were incapacitated
Or else, the contract will be deemed ratified (once the fog lifts)
Mental incompetency & legal guardians
If a guardian has been appointed, a contract made with the insane or senile person is void (NOT voidable)
It is not recognized as a contract at all from the outside
Intoxicated person
An intoxicated person (drugs and alcohol) lacks contractual capacity to make a contract if the intoxication is such that the person does not understand that a contract is being made
In that case, the contract is voidable
Intoxication & suits
Judges are not as sympathetic to these types of cases as they would be to a minor or mentally insane person
Therefore, it is harder to argue this, but it can be done
The burden of bearing the proof
Unilateral mistake
If a mistake made by one of the parties is unknown to the other party, it does not affect the binding character of the agreement
HOWEVER
If a mistake made by one of the parties is known by both parties, it does affect the binding character of the agreement
Unilateral Mistake Example (read)
New employee at a store accidentally orders 100 computers, the delivery truck arrives, and the manager runs outside and says we do not need them
Is the truck required to bring the computers back?
No, this is because the mistake was unaware by both contracts
The computer did not do anything wrong
What if the person taking the order was someone who was very familiar with the store's ordering habits, and should have known that ordering 100 computers by a new employee had to be a mistake
In this case, they would have to take the computers back
Mutual mistake
When both parties are mistaken about a basic, material fact of the contract, the adversely affected party may avoid the contract
Is a contract voidable when there is a mutual mistake of judgment?
No, only facts (cow).
Cow vs. Colt
Cow: (fact)
Two parties are negotiating the sale of a cow
They both believe the cow is capable of giving birth
The sale is for a lot of money, and it turns out that the cow cannot reproduce
The buyer later discovers the cow is barren
Can he get his money back? Yes!
This is because it a mutual mistake
Colt: (judgment)
A colt running around in Kentucky
The colt's sire was a Kentucky Derby winner, so the buyers believe the colt will be very valuable in the future
They use this judgment to negotiate a high price
As it grows, the horse is very slow
Can the buyer get his money back? No!
This is a mistake of judgment, not fact
Fraudulent Misrepresentation
Someone makes a material misrepresentation of fact with knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth, and the listener relies and is harmed
Can a listener say they were harmed because someone made a statement of opinion, hyperbole, or puffery?
No
Nondisclosure to the seller- general rules
There is no legal duty to educate or volunteer information to the other party in a negotiation. Expression of opinions or "puffery" allowed
Buyer must engage in through "due diligence" examination (cavaet emptor)
Once a buyer asks a question, the seller has to answer truthfully
Seller must disclose unknown defects or latent conditions that reasonably cannot be discovered by the buyer during due diligence
Seller will be liable for active concealment of a problem or defect
Undue Influence
When one party benefitting from a contract is in a position of extreme power over another party unable to exercise free will
Example: wills
Contract may be voidable
But, you have the burden of proving this
Physical duress
Threat of physical force to party or a relative that would cause serious personal injury or damage to property
They enter into the contract to avoid this physical duress
"Sign into this contract or I will smash your car"
Economic duress
Contract induced by a fear or threat of financial loss
Entered against free will
Contract takeaways
Contracts are meant to be durable
The party arguing out of the contract carries the burden of proof
People are presumed to have capacity
Possible grounds for avoiding contract picture

Consideration explained
The price of entry in a contract
Bargained-for-Exchange
What each party gives to the other in the making of the agreement
Can be money, goods, services, property, or forbearance of a legal right (a promise not to do something)
Benefit-Detriment Approach
Alternative view of consideration
You have to incur a detriment to get a benefit
Ex: pay money for a car
Are promises to make a gift enforceable?
No, because they lack consideration
(git receiver contributes no skin in the game)
Exception to Gifts
Charitable subscriptions are binding because the donor reasonably should have known the charity relies on the promise
Charities depend on these donations to fund their programs and services
Some states require the charity to take steps in reliance on the promise
Adequacy of consideration
$1 can be a sufficient consideration
Courts care more that something legal was exchanged, not the financing
The fact that consideration turns out to be disappointing or inadequate in the opinion of one of the parties (seller’s/buyer’s remorse) does not affect the binding nature of the contract (you cannot get out of it)
Special situations to consideration
Things that may look like consideration but are not
Pre-existing legal obligations
Promising (or refraining) to do what one is already required to do is not consideration
Past consideration
Not consideration
The promise has to become before the act
Moral consideration
Not consideration
Just because someone feels they owe another person something doesn't automatically create a legally binding contract
Forbearance
Is consideration
This means you refrain from doing something you have every right to do
Exceptions to consideration
Charitable subscriptions
Promissory estoppel / detrimental reliance
If promisee relies on promisor’s representation and there is a resulting detriment, the promisor is “estopped” from claiming the promise is unenforceable because of lack of consideration
EXAMPLE:
A business owner promises you a job.
You rely on that promise, quit your current job, and move to another town.
The business owner changes their mind.
You are now worse off because you relied on that promise.
The court may prevent the business owner from arguing that the promise is unenforceable
A court will not enforce the following contracts
Contracts requiring the commission of a tort or crime
Contracts that are contrary to the public policy (general health and welfare of society)
Contracts that are unconscionable
Contracts entered into by the unlicensed
When an agreement is illegal or for an illegal purpose, it is ____
void
No contract arises from it
Unconscionable clause
Where one party has an unfair bargaining power and unfair advantage over another party
Are all contracts one-sided?
Yes, but if you make things “too” one-sided it can be deemed unconscionable
Take-it-ot-leave-it contracts
Have extremely one-sided terms and can be voidable
Agreements affecting public welfare
Agreements contrary to public policy (public welfare, health, or
Gambling, wages, and lotteries
Require three elements: prize, chance, and consideration
May be permitted by statutes to raise funds or for