1/30
Looks like no tags are added yet.
appropriability
degree to which a firm is able to capture the rents (financial & economic value) from its innovation rather than letting others capture those profits
public domain
an innovation or any intellectual creation is of public domain if anyone can use it at will
when does an intellectual creation become public domain?
published in scientific articles
disclosed at a conference
when the protection regime ends
what causes appropriability to increase?
knowledge tacitness: degree of non-codifiability
knowledge’s social complexity: degree of distribution among ppl within the org
advantages of protection instead of public domain
incentives to invest in innovation
knowledge accumulation
monopoly rents
advantages of public domain instead of protection (6)
incentives for others to invest in innovation
increased learning economies
increased collabs
enhanced competition
faster standard convergence
rapid diffusion & adoption
disadvantages of protection over public domain
slow penetration rates
less collab
disadvantages public domain over protection
coordination
effort redundancy
IP protection mechanisms requiring disclosure (5)
patents
utility models
designs
trademarks
copyrights
IP protection mechanisms requiring non-disclosure
trade secrecy
patents
granted by national or supranational IP bodies
valid for 20 years since application, with 1 year grace period
requirements
new process, product, or machine
improvement or enhancement of existing ones
worldwide novelty
utility models
granted by national or supranational IP bodies
valid for 10 years since application
requirements
inventions with lower level of inventiveness
configuration or structure providing utility or practical advantage
industrial design
granted by national or supranational IP bodies
valid for 5 years, renewable up to 25
requirements: product’s physical appearance & presentation
distinctive signs
granted by national or supranational IP bodies
valid for 10 years, renewable indefinitely
requirements: trademarks & trade names for the class of products specified
patents, utility models, & design patents
useful, novel, not obvious
protect invention while disclosing some info
non-patentable: natural phenomena (gravity, chemical reactions), replacing materials, changing size or shape
several patents in 1 product
how & why (5) patents work
how: prevent others from using their invention
why
temporary monopoly
barriers to entry
enhance exports
attract investors & resources
architectural control of innovation development
costs of patenting
disclosing making & use of invention
temporarily disclosing for other inventors to challenge
takes 2-5 years to be granted
7000 euros fees from filing to granting
yearly maintenance fees
trademarks & copyrights
distinguish the source of a good
help build a brand
valuable assets
words, logos, slogans, sounds
the case of nokia tune
nokia trademarked a sound based on tarrega's public domain composition (died 70+ years earlier)
trademark protects their specific sound use, not ownership of the original composition
others can still perform, record, rearrange, & distribute the og music
same notes can be used elsewhere, as long as Nokia's trademark isn't infringed
trademark protection doesn’t remove a work from the public domain
trade secret or industrial secret
info belonging to 1 company unknown to others
protected by law
requirements
knowledge that offers a diff advantage to a company
knowledge that is only valuable if kept secret
how are trade secrets kept confidential?
NDAs, restricted access, & security measures
if someone else patents a trade secret invention, the patent holder gains exclusive rights → og firm may lose the right to use the invention unless it has prior-use rights or obtains a license
logbook
record of all activities performed to get the invention
dated, preferably indicating time of meetings & participants
advantages of using a logbook
acknowledges inventors & inventions: procedures, steps, findings, discoveries, formulas
establishes priority dates
useful for trade secrecy & patent disputes
where can appropriability come from?
exploiting the patent
selling patent rights
licensing the techs
patent disclosure
revealing the contents of a patent even before it is granted
attracts investors & potensh licensees
publicise tech’s quality & scope to competitors
patent trolls (patent assertion entities)
buy patents to make money through lawsuits
hide patent ownership, making infringement harder to detect
threaten companies with lawsuits to obtain settlements or licensing fees
focus on patent litigation
patent thickets
web of overlapping patents
prevent other firms from competing without risking patent lawsuits
stifles innovation, firms adopt defensive strats & build patent war chests to defer potensh legal attacks from competitors
is IPR effective?
depends on industry & tech
yes in pharmaceutical industry
no in electronics
manufacturing techniques are hard to protect
trade secrets are limited
what do firms do with patents?
exploit internally, license others, or sell rights outright
disclose an application strategically to signal value & attract investors or licensees
build defensive patent portfolios, navigate patent thickets
some earn through assertion or litigation
identify the commercial motive not just the presence of a patent
how firms protect knowledge?
patent: exclusionary right in exchange for disclosure
trade secret: confidential know-how requiring reasonable secrecy measures
design, trademark, copyright: protect diff aspects of products & brands
logbook: dated evidence of invention, contributors, experiments, & decisions
protection or diffusion
appropriability
protection may preserve rents & support investment but can reduce diffusion & collab
openness may accelerate adoption, learning, & standard convergence but weaken exclusive returns
tacit, socially complex knowledge is harder to imitate