1/131
Looks like no tags are added yet.
When are we most likely to conform to informational social influence?
ambigous/uncertain situations
when we need to be accurate
when we percieve other as experts
Sherif’s autokinetic studies (1936)
point on wall, participants asked how much point moved when in actuality it didnt move at all, participtants asked once alone, once in group setting, and then alone again, participants stuck to group answer/norm even alone after group consenous
Rohrer, Baron, Hoffman, & Swander (1954): one year follow-up
about importance of accuracy
pick perp out of lineup, 2 groups, 2 different levels of importance of accuracy- not important and important, split again between being able to study drawing of perp vs shown very quickly - high importance on a difficult task causes high conformity
The “dark side” of informational social influence
pluralistic ignorance
propaganda
Pluralistic ignorance
In ambiguous situations, people look to the reactions of others to gauge how serious an event is. If everyone else remains calm or inactive, individuals wrongly conclude that no help is needed. [1, 2, 3]
Bystander effect
a social psychological phenomenon in which individuals are less likely to offer help to a victim when other people are present caused by diffusion of responsibility, fight/flight, pluralistic ignorance
Propaganda
systematic attempt to advance a cause bu manipulating mass attitudes and behaviors often through misleading or emotionally charged information
Social contagion
rapid transmition of behaviors and emotions through a crowd
Mass psychogenic illness
widespread of subjective symptoms though to be associated with environmental exposure to a toxic substance in the absence of objective evidence
When are we most likely to conform to normative social influence?
to be liked- public compliance only, following implicit or explicit social norms without private acceptance
Social norms
informal/unwritten rules to be followed socially
Injunctive norms
what is the socially approved thing for me to do
descriptive norms
what are people actually doing ? following the injuctive norm?
Boomerang effect
a phenomenon where an attempt to persuade or influence someone results in them adopting the opposite position or behavior of what was intended
Asch’s line studies (1951, 1956) When/why did participants conform?
line judgment study - asked to judge length of line and pick a similar line, first 3 rounds everyone says right answer then actors give wrong answers, and participants have to choose whether or not to conform, a lot of them did conform - normative because other people were wrong but didnt want to draw negative attention to themselves
Normative influence
don’t want to be perceived as different/ fear of rejection
informational influence
think others know something you dont/trust in others
Normative Conformity and fMRI Brain activity when participants conformed vs didn’t conform
when conformed (gave incorrect asnwer) - areas related to visual perception (same as baseline)
when disagreed/did not conform- gave correct asnwer :
amydgala negative emotions
right caudate nucleus regulating social behavior
Factors that affect likeliness to submit to normative social influence
group unaminity
public response
no prior commitment
importance of being accurate
Group unanimity
how unanimous is group consensous
True partner
somone who disagrees with group but agrees with u
Compromise partner
someone who disagrees with you and group
Baron, Vandello, & Brunsman (1996) (perp out of lineup)
Cultural factors
Social impact theory
strength (S): The perceived power, status, authority, or expertise of the person or group exerting the influence.
Immediacy (I): How close the source is in physical space or time (prophylactic or temporal proximity) at the moment of interaction.
Number (N): The quantity or size of the people acting as sources or targets of influence.
Strength
how important is the reference group to us? (more importance
what is the perceived status of the group? (high status more conformity)
how cohesive is the group? (more cohesive more conformity)
Immediacy (time + space)
groups closeness in time and space
Number
3 people is minv
At what number of people is max influence reached?
4-5 reaches max effect, conformity doesn't go up much after that, equal to 30-50 people
Milgram et al, 1969
impact of group size on social influence
Eliciting compliance
Foot-in-the-door technique
getting people to do one small task it is easier to get them to keep agreeing/doing larger tasks
better for eliciting long term compliance
Freedman & Fraser, 1966 (household products survey
2 groups, 1 asked big task letting people into house to go through products, 2: asked about products over phone and then asked to go into house and go through products
Safe driving committee (signs)
Researchers wanted to see if getting people to agree to a small, low-cost request would make them much more likely to comply with a large, intrusive request later on. [1]
The Procedure: Experimenters went to California neighborhoods and asked homeowners to put a large, poorly lettered "DRIVE CAREFULLY" sign on their front lawns.
In the control group (no prior request), only about 17% to 20% agreed to put up the giant sign.
For the experimental group, researchers first asked homeowners to accept a small, unobtrusive precursor—either a small sticker in their car window or a small sign reading "Be a Safe Driver" placed in a window. Weeks later, a different researcher asked the same homeowners to put the large, ugly "DRIVE CAREFULLY" sign in their yard. [1]
76% agreed with small sign and then big sign
Door-in-the-face-techique
getting participants to feel like they are doing a favor
asking larger requests first expecting no and then asking smaller request more likely to get a yet
better at eliciting short term one time compliance
Reciprocity norm
caialdini 1975 - take delinquents to the zoo
two hour trip actual goal 17 % agreed
recruiting unpaid volunteer counselors for 2 hours a week for 2 years 50% of ppl agreed
Cialdini et al, 1975: “take the delinquents to the zoo” Best for eliciting ___ term compliance?
caialdini 1975 - take delinquents to the zoo
two hour trip actual goal 17 % agreed
recruiting unpaid volunteer counselors for 2 hours a week for 2 years 50% of ppl agreed
short term
Resisting social influence
consequences of deviating from group norm "
“Johnny Rocco” studies (e.g., Schacter, 1951)
groups of 10, 3 confederates modal, slider, and deviate
45 min discussion with check ins at 20 and 45
rate group members/assign tasks
Idiosyncrasy credits
describes an individual's earned capacity to acceptably deviate from group expectations or norms without losing status or facing punishment
Psychological reactance
Toys behind high/low barriers (Brehm & Weintraub, 1977)
Support for co-ed dorms (Worchel, Arnold, & Baker, 1975)
Banned” books (Zellinger, Fromkin, Speller, & Kohn, 1974)
showed blurb about books to students and some book blurbs said for adults only 21 and over
students are more interested when it was restricted
“Romeo and Juliet” effect (Driscoll, Davis, & Lipetz, 1972
asked couples about commitment of their relationships
also asked about approval of families members on their partner
less approval from family the more committed they were to the relations
Bathroom graffiti (Pennebaker & Sanders, 1976)
putting signs in bathrooms to say not to graffiti
2 dif signs 1. “do not write on wall under any circumstances” and 2. “please do not write on walls”
more sternly worded sign bathrooms had more graffiti
Obedience
compliance in response to direct request to change your behavior
most likely when requestor is perceived as a legitimate authority figure
Most likely when?
Milgram’s Obedience (film), could it be replicated today
need to be allowed to withdraw at any time
more thourough informed consent, told it could be distressed
offering counseling during debrief
Burger, 2009
important updates to replication of milgram
changed script to stop at 150 volts
found after the first protest at 150 if that if particpants chose to keep shocking the learner after 150 then they would go all the way to the end
Burger vs Milgram results?
40 adults
shock range - 15-140 volts
study one 25/40 participants complied to end 62%
study 2: heart condition 26/40 complience to end 65%
milgrams obidience a group?
65 % obedience
realism came from authoritative figure
situational factords influencing obedience in milgrams studies
What is a group
two or more people who for longer than a few moments interact with and influence one anoyjer and percieve one another as us
their own norms and roles
Social Roles
expected behaviors
How can others influence behavior
social facilitation
social oafing
deindividation
Social Facilitation
strengthening of dominant response when in the presence od others and individual performance can be evaluated
Dominant response
your individual most common response
Zajonc, heingartner, & Herman 1969 (cockroaches)
Why the presence of others leads to arousal
evaluation apprehension
increase alertenss/vigilance
distraction
Evaluation apprehension
alertness/vigilance
Distraction
How groups influence the behavior of individuals
Social Loafing - Exceptions?
less evaluation apprehension nd less individual effort recognition produces poorer performances on simple tasks in most situations
except: when group is especially important , group is highly cohesive, when task important
Shepperd, 2001 (for the troops gum study
worse group was discarded no indivual eval
best groups were individual eval and for the troops
difference between social loafing and social facilitation
Deindividuation
loss of self awareness and evaluation apprehension that leads to loosening of normal constraints on behavior when people are in a crowd or anonymous
What leads to deindividuation
feeling like we cant be seen study (ellison 19950 - feel more self aware with top down in convertable , ppl with top up more likely to honk horn
Diener et al (1976)
In children: Ross, Anderson, & Campbell, 2011: (Don’t look in
the box)
In adults: (e.g., Zimbardo, 1969; Johnson & Downing, 1979
Ellison, Govern, Petri, & Figler, 1995
Process loss
any aspect of group interaction that inhibits good problem solving , occurs bc conforming pressure, may not seek out most competent members input, communication problems
Conformity pressure
Stasser & Titus, 1985: failure to share unique info
Risky Shift (Stoner, 1961; Wa llach, Kogan , & Bem, 1962)
Groupthink- When is it more likely?
type of thinking in maintaining group cohesiveness and solidarity is more important than considering the facts in a realistic manner
Symptoms of groupthink
illusion of invulnerability
belief in moral correctness of group
rationalization/justification of group
stereotyped or simplistic views of out groups
conformity pressure
mind guards
Mindguards
Challenger explosion example
Nasa top decsion makers went ahead with launch despite warnings from engineers
decision making hierarchy
Avoiding groupthink
group leaders should take less directive role/remain impartial
solicit opinions from outside group
division of groups intosubgroups
anonymity
Group Polarization, why, where
tendency for groups to make decisions that are more extreme than individual - social comparison interpretation/persuasive arguments
The ABCs of prejudice
affective, behavior, cognitive
Affective = prejudice
a hostile or negtaive attitdue towards people in a distingguishable group based solely on their membership in that group
difficult to chnage - persuasion chapter
Behavior = discrimination
behavior or actions often negative toward an individual or group based solely on group membership
Cognitive = stereotypes (schemas)
What is the first step in prejudice, stereotyping, and discrimination?
Ingroup vs. Outgroup
people u are with vs people u are not like
Social identity
College prejudice study (Blascovich et al., 1997)
In-group bias
Minimal groups
Group points study (Tafjel et al., 1971)
Jane Elliot classroom studies in 1968 (“Eye of the storm”/”A class divided”
Out-group homogeneity
Princeton vs Rutgers study (Quattrone & Jones, 1980)
Stereotype(s)
Stigma consciousness
Stereotype (social identity) threat
tereotype threat study (Aronson et al., 1995)
Yueng & Von Hippel, 2007