1/17
November 2, 2026 reading: pp. 51–64 and notes on pp. 119–120 (John T. Scott edition). Follows Professor Dempsey’s October 31 updated schedule and study questions, superseding the original syllabus. Concise paraphrases; cards on natural life and Hobbes provide the comparison requested in the study guide. Sources: Canvas announcement https://utexas.instructure.com/courses/1458104/discussion_topics/5879175 ; Rousseau, Preface and opening of the Discourse (public-domain Cole translation): https://www.gutenberg.org/files/46333/46333-h/46333-h.htm ; Rousseau’s Notes I–II in the Scott edition.
What question does Rousseau’s Discourse on Inequality investigate?
Where human inequality comes from, what supports it, and whether natural law justifies it.
Why must Rousseau study human nature before judging inequality?
We must distinguish natural differences from social inventions before deciding whether existing hierarchies are justified.
Why is knowledge of human nature so difficult?
Society, education, passions, and acquired habits transform us, obscuring what humans were originally like.
What does the statue of Glaucus illustrate?
Just as weathering disguises the statue’s original form, social changes disguise original human nature.
What two principles does Rousseau identify before reason?
Self-preservation: concern for our own well-being. Pity: reluctance to see another sentient being suffer or die.
How do self-preservation and pity work together?
Pity restrains unnecessary harm to others; urgent self-preservation can take priority. Neither requires philosophical reasoning.
Why does Rousseau reject natural sociability as his starting point?
He can explain basic conduct through self-preservation and pity without assuming an original need for society. Social dependence must be explained.
Why does Rousseau include animals in our basic obligations?
Their capacity to suffer, rather than their capacity to reason, gives us a reason not to mistreat them.
What is natural or physical inequality?
Differences established by nature, such as age, health, strength, and qualities of mind.
What is moral or political inequality?
Conventional privileges in wealth, honor, power, or authority, established or accepted by human beings.
Does Rousseau deny that any inequality is natural?
No. Natural differences exist, but they do not automatically justify social rank, wealth, or obedience.
What mistake do earlier state-of-nature thinkers make?
They project socially acquired ideas and passions—such as property, pride, and domination—onto original humans.
Is Rousseau’s state of nature a proven historical period?
No. It is a hypothetical reconstruction used to distinguish original human traits from acquired ones and evaluate society.
How does Rousseau handle the Bible in the opening?
He formally acknowledges Scripture, then brackets revealed history to ask what humans might become through natural causes alone. His deeper religious stance requires interpretation.
What is natural human life like in Rousseau’s account?
Largely solitary and independent, with simple needs and little lasting dependence on others; society’s competitive ambitions are absent.
How does Rousseau’s state of nature differ from Hobbes’s?
Hobbes emphasizes insecurity and conflict without common power. Rousseau argues that simple needs, independence, and pity limit conflict; Hobbes imports social passions into nature.
What does the Otanes story in Note I illustrate?
Otanes gives up a claim to rule in exchange for independence. His wish neither to command nor obey separates freedom from domination.
What does Buffon’s passage in Note II add to the Preface?
We attend to external objects more than ourselves. Passions and sensory distractions obstruct the inward attention needed for self-knowledge.